Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Have you read the Silmarillion  

39 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted

Just wondering. I am totally addicted to Tolkien. I've read the Silmarillion 4 or 5 times now.











Ardillacid who would kill a chipmunk for a taco

Posted

excellent read :)

it *SO* totally mirrors the way God works. :)

Posted

Yessssssss! What is your favorite part. (as if one could pick :) )




Ardillacid who would kill a chipmunk for a taco

Posted

My brother is addicted to The Silmarillion



and everything else Tolkien for that matter

Posted

I bought it for my dad and have yet to read it.

Posted

Read it twice and love it.

I like the Book of Lost Tales better though.

Posted

Possibly his best work. Oh yeah.

Posted

I'm totally in LOVE with the Silmarillion. And everything Tolkien. I was rereading The Two Towers for the first time in like five years (high school stinks, I'm too busy for fun) and I was like 'Oh my gosh I forgot how much this book ROCKED!' Anyway...yeah.

BTW, Dudette, your sig rocks my socks.

Posted

Now you've hit on my favorite subject.

Silmarillion was like a 3D thinking adventure.

FutureSoror
Posted

I said yes, but in truth finishing it is on my to do list. I started it over a year ago.

Posted

I said yes too, even though I still ahve to finish it-- definitely by summer when things are less hectic.

Posted (edited)

The Silmarillion really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really really rocks my socks so much.

I love it... and Tolkien. Yes, I confess to you, my brothers and sisters... But it's soooo awesome. I mean... 3D thinking adventure.. They could never make it into a movie, but if they could, it would be so awesome.

If you read Silm, then you also have to read in The Book of Lost Tales 2, the fall of Gondolin. Possibly my favorite of Tolkien's writings. How he tells of the destruction of Gondolin and the noble defense of the different houses of elves... Wow.

I should read more Classics, like Vergil, Homer, and such.

The Silmarillion is too awesome.

Edit: Ok, the only way I could see them making it into a successful film is if... A team of super duper ultra japanese (or american i guess!) got together and decided to make a multi-part epic. But that would be sooo hard... You would need someone with a really specific vision (preferably Catholic, so as to understand Tolkien best) and then a super talented team of artists and then a really awesome script...

I don't know how you could write a script that does justice to the book. You'd have to focus... on what? Just Feanor and the Silmarils? But what about Turin and Gondolin and such? I dunno. Some things are best left as books, no? You cannot beat the written word.

It is probably impossible to make a worthy film on the Silmarillion, but I'm sure one could make smaller plays or ballets or operas or paintings based on parts of the Silmarillion. For instance, I heard that someone wrote a ballet about Beren and Luthien. Now that's cool...

Edited by Antonius
Posted

[quote name='ardillacid' date='Apr 23 2005, 11:40 PM'] Just wondering. I am totally addicted to Tolkien. I've read the Silmarillion 4 or 5 times now.











Ardillacid who would kill a chipmunk for a taco [/quote]
I am an Inkling through and through.....hot stuff will attest to that......

He actually makes fun of me for it.....can you believe that?????? :blink:

Posted

[quote]For instance, I heard that someone wrote a ballet about Beren and Luthien. Now that's cool...[/quote]

Yeah, it's called the Lay of Luthien.

I agree that some things should be left to books and the Silmarillion is one of those things. Although I never thought that the LOTR would be made into a major motion picture.

If they were to do it, there would have to be artistic liscense taken as in the Trilogy.....

[url="http://www.glyphweb.com/arda/"]The Encyclopedia of Arda[/url] just in case you don't have it listed in your favorites...

If you don't, what's keeping you?

Cam

Posted
:o :o :o Very :cool: Thank you, Cam, I definitely bookmarked it. When I have more time, I'm going to be wandering through their articles.
Posted

[quote]For instance, I heard that someone wrote a ballet about Beren and Luthien. Now that's cool...


Yeah, it's called the Lay of Luthien.[/quote] One of my favorite parts of non-trilogy stuff so far.

Trivia: J. R> R. Tolkien had Luthien inscribed on his wife's tombstone, and Beren on his.

Posted

[quote name='luciana' date='Apr 24 2005, 10:19 PM'] :o :o :o Very :cool: Thank you, Cam, I definitely bookmarked it. When I have more time, I'm going to be wandering through their articles. [/quote]
It is the most exhaustive understanding of Tolkien on the net. If you have a question, he will answer you quickly too....

Cam

Posted

Yeah, thanks, Cam.

The two best Tolkien sites on the net are The Encycolpedia of Arda and of course, my favorite, [url="http://www.theonering.net"]TheOneRing.net[/url]. It's a huge fansite, and the Green Books staff are really intelligent. Think our Catholic Apologetics board bigshots, but these are Tolkien scholars. Wowies.

Posted

I've read the Silmarillion 3+ times. :punk:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...