argent_paladin Posted April 24, 2005 Posted April 24, 2005 [b]Vatican likely to end divorcee communion ban[/b] Rome - The Vatican, in response to growing expectations of many Roman Catholics, is likely to consider lifting the Church's ban on communion for divorcees, a senior cardinal was quoted Saturday as saying. "It is a delicate issue which the Church will have to discuss, question and confront itself with," Spain's Cardinal Julian Herranz told Italy's La Repubblica daily. The Church will take "into account the expectations, the many social, theological and human nuances linked to such an important issue," the cardinal said. The paper reported that prior to his election Pope Benedict XVI himself had prepared a draft document on lifting the ban on divorcees receiving communion imposed by the Church, which does not recognize divorce. As head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of Faith, the then-cardinal Joseph Ratzinger argued that Catholics who were abandoned by their spouses and thus "forced" into divorce were "guiltless" and should not be excluded from the holy sacraments, the newspaper said. Catholic activists battling for a lifting of the ban hailed the reported document as a breakthrough. "We have learned with huge satisfaction that the new pope will promote an epic change for... divorcees: their readmission to the sacraments," Giorgio Ceccarelli, head of the "Denied Children" group, told La Repubblica. The pope, who was elected by his fellow cardinals Tuesday, has yet to name his successor at the Vatican's doctrinal office, who will inherit the controversial dossier and the draft document. Before being named to succeed John Paul II, Ratzinger also proposed that the retirement age for prelates be raised from the current 75. "One must consider that a bishop at that age (75), if he has no health problems, is at the peak of his pastoral mission and he has the benefit of experience," Herranz told La Repubblica. - Sapa-AFP
Dave Posted April 24, 2005 Posted April 24, 2005 The only time divorcees are barred from the sacraments is if they've remarried without an annulment. If the article you provided was referring to those who are divorced and remarried, then it's surely a bunch of hooey. But if it was referring to those who are divorced but not remarried, then why would the Church lift a ban that never existed in the first place? So that would be a bunch of hooey as well.
argent_paladin Posted April 24, 2005 Author Posted April 24, 2005 I just heard during CBS's coverage of the inaugural mass, that this is a myth. Augustine DeNoia said that the document on this in the CDF doesn't exist and never has. I trust that.
Guest Eremite Posted April 24, 2005 Posted April 24, 2005 [quote]I just heard during CBS's coverage of the inaugural mass, that this is a myth. Augustine DeNoia said that the document on this in the CDF doesn't exist and never has. I trust that.[/quote] Exactly. You can't trust the media anymore.
cmotherofpirl Posted April 24, 2005 Posted April 24, 2005 The article is based on a fallacy which ia easily recognized. Where did you find it??
dspen2005 Posted April 24, 2005 Posted April 24, 2005 to remove the ban, would also make it easy for abuse.... some could argue that their spouses left, when in fact that is not the case... yet, the Church would rightly assume them to be honest and sincere. Their reception of Communion would be a profanation of the Sacrament.
the_rev Posted April 24, 2005 Posted April 24, 2005 When the Pope has written it is permissable, then I will believe it.
Norseman82 Posted April 24, 2005 Posted April 24, 2005 Yeah, it can be abused, but I'd like clarification, especially with regards to CCC 2386, which is vague.
Theoketos Posted April 24, 2005 Posted April 24, 2005 I bet that there were a buch of articles concerning how contraception was going to be ok'ed before Humanae Vitae. Although I did read that annulments were going to be harder to come by.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted April 24, 2005 Posted April 24, 2005 [quote name='Theoketos' date='Apr 24 2005, 04:26 PM'] I bet that there were a buch of articles concerning how contraception was going to be ok'ed before Humanae Vitae. Although I did read that annulments were going to be harder to come by. [/quote] I'm told there were.
cmotherofpirl Posted April 24, 2005 Posted April 24, 2005 [quote name='dspen2005' date='Apr 24 2005, 12:34 PM'] to remove the ban, would also make it easy for abuse.... some could argue that their spouses left, when in fact that is not the case... yet, the Church would rightly assume them to be honest and sincere. Their reception of Communion would be a profanation of the Sacrament. [/quote] This is NO ban on divorcees recieving Communion. The ban is on remarried people who didn't have annulments prior to remarriage.
geetarplayer Posted April 25, 2005 Posted April 25, 2005 Yeah, whoever wrote this definately needs to get his or her facts straight. [quote]The paper reported that prior to his election Pope Benedict XVI himself had prepared a draft document on lifting the ban on divorcees receiving communion imposed by the Church, which does not recognize divorce.[/quote] "Does not recognize divorce"? -Mark
argent_paladin Posted April 25, 2005 Author Posted April 25, 2005 Well, technically, that is true. She recognizes annulments, that the marriage was invalid. Or a dissolution (Pauline or Petrine privilege). And the logic of the article dosn't make sense. It implies that getting civilly divorced is a sin and that that teaching is unfair because some people get civilly divorced through circumstanes out of their control. But, civil divorce is not a sin. The Church is not in the divorce business but in the marriage business and when someone wants to get married, the Church has to determine whether the person is eligible. If a man is in Holy Orders he is ineligible. If someone has a prior bond (a valid marriage) that person cannot marry again. And anyone who is living in a simulated marriage cannot recieve communion. That would go for same-sex marriages and also for couples living together. It even goes for couples in a sexual relationship outside of marriage. Divorced and remarried Catholics are not distinct in the gravity of their sin, but only in the publicness of the sin and thus the potential for scandal. On the other hand, in the contemporary world, it is difficult to enforce this rule. It is impossible to tell just by looking at a couple that one of them was previously married. Only if the couple somehow makes it obvious that they are living in sin would they be stopped.
cmotherofpirl Posted April 25, 2005 Posted April 25, 2005 [quote name='argent_paladin' date='Apr 25 2005, 02:14 AM'] Divorced and remarried Catholics are not distinct in the gravity of their sin, but only in the publicness of the sin and thus the potential for scandal. [/quote] Divorce is NOT a sin and does NOT bar one from Communion.
Myles Domini Posted April 25, 2005 Posted April 25, 2005 [quote]Divorce is NOT a sin and does NOT bar one from Communion. [/quote] I dont get it?
argent_paladin Posted April 25, 2005 Author Posted April 25, 2005 [quote]QUOTE (argent_paladin @ Apr 25 2005, 02:14 AM) Divorced and remarried Catholics are not distinct in the gravity of their sin, but only in the publicness of the sin and thus the potential for scandal. Divorce is NOT a sin and does NOT bar one from Communion. [/quote] Cmom, I suggest you read carefully before you quote and reply. I wrote about "divorced and remarried Catholics", and from the context it is clear that I was not referring to those who recieved annulments. Then you say that "Divorce is not a sin". And I never said otherwise. So why the all capital letters and the emphasis? Why are you contradicting something that I never said? And civil divorce is not a sin because the Church doesn't recognize its effacaciousness. That is, civil divorce, in the Church's eyes, has no effect on the marriage. Please clarify your disagreement, as it doesn't seem to be anything I said, but you felt the need to repeat your statement in the space of three posts. In fact, I will compare what you said, to what I said: "Divorced and remarried Catholics are not distinct in the gravity of their sin..." "The ban is on remarried people who didn't have annulments prior to remarriage." In fact, one can recieve communion if you annul your prior bond after your remarriage. You would simply petition for a sanatio, which would retroactively validate your current marriage, after the original impediment is taken care of.
cmotherofpirl Posted April 25, 2005 Posted April 25, 2005 Because you use the phrase " in the gravity of their sin". There is no sin in divorce.
argent_paladin Posted April 25, 2005 Author Posted April 25, 2005 To further clarify: The Church teaches that a valid marriage (one having proper matter (man and woman) and form (both free to marry, both informed of the meaning of marriage, and both consenting, and if they are Catholic, observing the Catholic forms) is eternal. It is a one-flesh union. Therefore, it cannot be dissolved and so civil divorce has no real effect on a marriage. It is still a marriage, even though they may not love one another, live in the same state or even if they are civilly remarried. The Church also teaches that it is a sin to have sexual relations with someone who is not your spouse. So, that is what a remarried person is doing in their new marriage. And the Church assumes all marriages are valid until proven otherwise and also assumes that a man and a woman living together are having sexual relations. Thus, a divorced and remarried Catholic cannot recieve commnion because he/she is objectively in the state of mortal sin. One cannot recieve absolution until one makes arrangements to end the sinful circumstances, say by moving out of the house. Thus, divorce and remarriage is one of the very few times that one can objectively know if someone is in mortal sin because marriage is a public institution. It would be no different if you were very publically cohabitating with someone else, outside of marriage. The only circumstances that someone could deny communion is if they are certain that the matter is grave, the person has knowledge of it, that it is ongoing and that they haven't recieved absolution. It is very rare for all of these condidtions to be in place, unless you somehow announce it. About the only other public sins of this kind are politicians who hold moral positions opposed to the Church (such as abortion), protesters of organizations opposed to Church doctrine and wearing distinctive sashes or buttons, or a public apostate (like Luther). And as I said before, the matter of adultery is no more grave than many other sins, but it is very public in nature, and thus offensive to many people who place inclusivity and avoidance of hurt feelings above doctrine.
argent_paladin Posted April 25, 2005 Author Posted April 25, 2005 Ahhh!! I said "the gravity of sin in divorced AND remarried Catholics"!! Why do you refuse to read the words "and remarried"? Catholics who divorce AND remarry have sinned. I didn't say: "the gravity of sin on divorced Catholics", I said "divorced AND REMARRIED"! That second part is critical and I don't undestand how you can just casually discard it.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now