Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Praying to the Blessed Virgin Mary


Recommended Posts

RSV Catholic
Posted

Hello,

I pray the Rosary every night, and once while I was at my girlfriends house, I was praying, and she started to ask me questions about the rosary, btw she's "protestant" so it seems that she has a problem with praying to mary, Her parents view all that honor to her as idolatry. And I explained to her that she is "our" ark of the covenant/ bearer of the glory. And I told her that she is our heavenly mother and backed it up with "John 19:26"
And I told her that prayer is a form of talking, so it's no different than Me asking her dad to pray for me, besides our prayers to her is a form of petition, "to pray for our sins"

...so that kept her quiet for some time. :D

than she comes back, saying why do we pray to a human being, that is mortal/ and what makes me think she can hear my prayers in heaven?

...I told her that I'll get back to her on that one :D

Posted

Well one our souls are immortal, our physical bodies are mortal in the sense that they expereince death on earth. So we are not moral in the sense that we expereince an after life or after death. If our souls were motal then we would not hope for the ressurection of any kind. :)

Here are some Biblical quotes you can use that support the intercessory prayers of saints:

1) Rom 15:30- Paul asks for prayers from others
2) 1 Thess 5:25- asks for other to pray
3) 2 Thess 1:11- "To this we end, we always pray for you, ..."
4) Eph 6:18-19
5) Tob 12:12- Angel presents Tobit & Sarah's prayer to God
6) Rev 5:8- Angel offers prayers of the holy ones to God

So there is a strong sense that we ought to pray for one another, and the last two indicate that those that are close to God (ie: in heaven) may intercede for us.

We do not pray to Mary in the same sense that we pray to God either. We do not pray to Mary as in to worship her as a goddess. That would be idolatry, that is not what we do though. I am sure you are familiar with the distinciton made with hyperdulia. We praise Mary for her fiat and her role in the salvation history. We do not worship her as a goddess. We ask for her intercessions since she is so close to her son.

This stems a lot from our belief in the communion of saints. This builds on the statements that we are all one body in Christ. We all share in that one communion and death cannot seperate that since we Christ's body and His Church. The Church is both physical and spiritual, it is not contained by physical boundaries. A family of faith so to speak.

Recap:

1)Communion of saints since we are the body and Church of Christ. We are told to bear each other's burdens.
2)Death cannot seperate the Body of Christ for it is both physical and spiritual. That means those in heaven are still incorporated, even more so, into the body of Christ as we are here on earth.
3)We are commanded and asked to pray for one another.
4)Mary plays a special role, as you said as the ark fo the New Covenant, and is especially close to her Son.
5) So we pray to Mary to ask for her intercession to her Son since she played such a special role in the Church and is so close to her Son.

I am not sure if that helped at all but...I am sure there are others here that can be much more plorific about this topic.

RSV Catholic
Posted

Thank you for your great answer "Paphnutius" :)
...I like Tobit's scripture best as example.

Posted

FYI, Protestants don't accept Tobit as Scriptural. That might be an issue.

Posted

Doh! Thanks...I forgot it is part of the deuterocanonical...good point. Touche

Posted

Also, some points to consider*:

- Any true devotion to Mary is Christocentric; she never fails to lead her "Mama's boys" (and girls) to Jesus. If we see that it is not, then it is a false devotion to her.
- All of Mary's intercessory power is given her by God. It is precisely in being perfectly conformed to her Son that she's so gosh darn helpful.
- The Rosary consists of Mary guiding our meditations on the Life, Death and Resurrected Glory of Our Lord. All the mysteries, except the second-to-last Glorious mystery, are directly Scriptural, and that one has Scriptural support. (I'm assuming Rev 12 is directly supporting the Coronation of Mary; Protestants may dispute that.)

*note: all props given to St. Louis de Montfort, from whom I attribute these ideas. You can read more in True Devotion to the Blessed Virgin, The Love of Eternal Wisdom, The Secret of the Rosary and The Secret of Mary.

Posted

I was just about to suggest True Devotion to the Blessed Virgin. It is still sitting on my desk waiting for me to read it...

phatcatholic
Posted

i recently defended the practice of praying to saints in [url="http://www.youthspecialties.com/forums/message_boards/index.php?act=ST&f=32&t=14779"]this thread[/url] at another forum. maybe it will be of help to you.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...