McKenzie Posted April 25, 2005 Posted April 25, 2005 Do souls have gender? I'm thinking not, since they are an immaterial substance, but then where does gender come from? In the metaphysical sense? I mean, how do get gender roles-- if they are based on biology that is too cold and doesn't seem to portray the fullness of creation, and they can't be based on the oppressive male heirarcy, because that's just silly. So do gender roles come from our souls? Sorry if I proceeded to confuse anyone.
Paphnutius Posted April 25, 2005 Posted April 25, 2005 [quote name='McKenzie' date='Apr 24 2005, 07:32 PM'] Do souls have gender? I'm thinking not, since they are an immaterial substance, but then where does gender come from? In the metaphysical sense? I mean, how do get gender roles-- if they are based on biology that is too cold and doesn't seem to portray the fullness of creation, and they can't be based on the oppressive male heirarcy, because that's just silly. So do gender roles come from our souls? Sorry if I proceeded to confuse anyone. [/quote] Well I believe that souls do have gener in the sense that I have a masculine soul, and a female would have a feminine soul. That is different from it having a sex however, that is biological. A part of who I am is that I am male both in body and soul. This kinda of gets tricky because I have actually heard of people saying they have a masculine soul but are trapped in a woman's body... I am not sure if God would do that or could make a mistake like that. Gender comes from your sex and social roles. Some societies have different gender roles, such as the male is the homemaker. *Probably going to get slammed on that on. Your sex defines your gender, and your society defines your gender role. Just thinking out loud...
cmotherofpirl Posted April 25, 2005 Posted April 25, 2005 Since we are a combination - body and soul your soul would have a gender.
scardella Posted April 25, 2005 Posted April 25, 2005 any documentation on that, in case I ever need to back that up with a reference?
phatcatholic Posted April 26, 2005 Posted April 26, 2005 it appears that McKensie is wondering if the soul has gender in and of itself, or separate from the body. i'm inclined to say that it does not, but i will have to research this more.......
Guest JeffCR07 Posted April 26, 2005 Posted April 26, 2005 It seems to me that each soul, even seperated from the body, must necessarily be gendered. If the soul is androgenous, and only the physical body is gendered, that would mean that gender is nothing more than a philosophical accident. However, if gender were a philosophical accident, then women would be able to be priests just as men are priests, because nothing would stop them from standing [i]in persona Christi[/i]. But this is absurd. Therefore, we see that, by necessity, the soul must be either male or female, with each being equally human to the other. Your Brother In Christ, Jeff
p0lar_bear Posted April 27, 2005 Posted April 27, 2005 Well, it depends on who you ask. Plato would say no. Augustine kind of varied. He maintained that women were malformed men, but also said that there would be gender differences in heaven (meaning gender differences are eternal). John Paul the Great would say yes. Like others have said, because man is a composite of body and soul (not a soul trapped in a body), it seems that gender is reflected in the soul as well as the body. Gender differences don't end at biology. If the soul weren't gendered, then it would. As for references, I'd check out Theology of the Body.
argent_paladin Posted April 29, 2005 Posted April 29, 2005 I've had this discussion a couple of times before. I think the answer has to be yes, but beyond that, it gets tricky. One has to hold to the belief that gener is more than with the biology and that it is part of the form of a human being. But, a male soul and a female soul cannot be so different that they are different species. So, it is more than an accidental but less than a substantial difference.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now