Iacobus Posted April 26, 2005 Posted April 26, 2005 Okay, I am a know it all. I am pretty well versed in my history and a bit of philsopsy, but not spelling and no Greek. This is great, it helps you formulate arguments and improves your writing quite a bit with the number of allisiouns you can use. (Forgive my spelling, it has been a long day) I love having this skill, writing essays is much easier. However, now for my AP English class we have to write a paper (really an augmented essay) about how social changes influnced our novelist. I am doing [i]The Brothers Karamazov[/i] by Dostoevsky and addressing his response to the raise of nihilism, esp the "If God is dead, all is premissilbe" school of nihilism. Just knowing to address that topic and knowing about the schools of thought that are members of the debate and having read the novel puts you in a good postion to reply to the question. There is a wonderful difference between Ivan (Vanka) and Smer... my Russian spelling is horrid. You can use the two men to write about Dos.'s reply to nihilism and their actions can be used to add examples to the defention of the school. The short paper, merely five pages, can be created easily with this topic. I am ready to reply, I could write the full paper using three sources, two bios of Dostoevsky and the novel itself. But we are supposed to write using ten citition items. This is bugging me, am I not being removed from a criticism of the novel of my own creation, something I formulated? What good does it do my mind to merely paraphase and analysis someone elses writings about the novel which I have choosen? Argh, any ideas on what to do, should I talk to the teacher about this or should I just bite the bullet?
theculturewarrior Posted April 26, 2005 Posted April 26, 2005 Ugh. You're bringing back memories of literature class. Not quite sure what you're asking, but it seems like you're looking for something more challenging. There have been times when I have bit off more than I could chew and I have learned to be happy with simple tasks, but I'm sure your teacher would accomodate you if you wanted something more challenging. God bless, TCW
Carnanc Posted April 26, 2005 Posted April 26, 2005 This means using two new citations with each page, which really allows for plenty of room for your own argument. I am sure there has to be much analysis on this which you could use, while still making the point pretty much all your own. That is really what your supposed to do in a research paper anyway.
toledo_jesus Posted April 26, 2005 Posted April 26, 2005 Write an A worthy piece of drivel and move on with life. Then write a book and make many dollars.
Iacobus Posted April 26, 2005 Author Posted April 26, 2005 I wish I could write a book that would make me rich... but my writing has "put God to sleep." Or so it has been claimed.
Carnanc Posted April 26, 2005 Posted April 26, 2005 I'm amazed you read that The Brothers Karamazov . My sister was reading it, and it is by far the longest book i've ever seen.
journeyman Posted April 26, 2005 Posted April 26, 2005 Modern scholarship seems to look more and more like lining up sources pro and con and not having (or presenting) original thoughts. If your analysis is truly original, then you will not find sources pro and con your positions. If you find the requisite 10 sources, you can present a summary of the "existing" views in broad brush . . . cite 1, cite 2, cite 3, which are an extension/repetition of the classical views, cite 4, cite 5, cite 6 . . . even though the earliest view was cite 7, cite 8, cite 9. However, based on my reading, I feel the prior analysis ignores a most interesting presentation. And then write your paper with your three sources, and you've got a couple of extras for those who count headings inthe bibliography. To follow up on another poster, several books started out as an essay, that grew into a doctoral theses, that got rewritten for the popular market. This paper doesn't HAVE to be drivel, it can be an outline of brilliance to come.
Iacobus Posted April 26, 2005 Author Posted April 26, 2005 [quote name='slywakka250' date='Apr 25 2005, 09:52 PM'] I'm amazed you read that The Brothers Karamazov . My sister was reading it, and it is by far the longest book i've ever seen. [/quote] I feel like singing, but am horrid, so pretend like I am not singing right now. I can't belive I read all of The Brothers Karamazov (It is almost as schocking that I can spell both Karamazov and Dostoevsky without looking it up). Do you want to know something scary? That is just the first half, he died before he wrote the rest...
Mickey's_Girl Posted April 27, 2005 Posted April 27, 2005 [quote name='Iacobus' date='Apr 25 2005, 07:33 PM'] The short paper, merely five pages, can be created easily with this topic. I am ready to reply, I could write the full paper using three sources, two bios of Dostoevsky and the novel itself. But we are supposed to write using ten citition items. This is bugging me, am I not being removed from a criticism of the novel of my own creation, something I formulated? What good does it do my mind to merely paraphase and analysis someone elses writings about the novel which I have choosen? Argh, any ideas on what to do, should I talk to the teacher about this or should I just bite the bullet? [/quote] I hear what you are saying about doing your own analysis, and not wanting to just paraphrase other people. This is admirable: scholarly originality is in short supply these days. However, the need for 10 citations (does this mean 10 separate sources, or just 10 in-text citations total for the whole paper?) is meant to make you do in-depth research, instead of something off-the-cuff. Smart people don't usually like that. They like to go off-the-cuff (or totally in-depth), and they don't like to be told how to do it, either. Another thing: if you do enough research across a wide field (such as 10 sources) it becomes more likely that you'll get a range of discussion on a particular issue, instead of finding the one article or book that is revolutionary, and then everyone else's take on that one idea. Are you meant to do more than one social change? Is it supposed to be about history, philosophy, both? It sounds like you should talk to your teacher, run your paper idea by him/her, and clarify the issues. My guess is that you either aren't clear on some aspect of the paper, you haven't got the right-sized idea for that particular assignment (yours may be too large or too small), or you haven't done enough research. Of course, it's always possible that the assignment is not as well-planned as it should be. That, too, has been known to happen. (I mean, it seems awfully short for such a topic...) Be smart: talk to your teacher at the first opportunity. Don't assume that random online people who aren't in your class will be able to read your teacher's mind. Good luck! Let us know how it goes. MG
Iacobus Posted April 27, 2005 Author Posted April 27, 2005 I didn't assume you would be able to read his mind, I was just hoping that you would all say "He is evil and a soundrel and should be exiled to Sebria. I shall break the sword over his head" etc. Just kidding. No, I really wanted to see if I was nuts for thinking this way. I have talked it over with my dad (a teacher, though it was art) and he said basicly "Do your own criticism." I decided I am going to talk to the teacher (I have the class tomorrow) and present my argument in favor of "freedom from other influnces." When I write a research paper, yes I look up other sources. This is supposed to have ten sources cited, but that doesn't mean two a page or whatever, rather it means 10 sources cited every few lines (at least). This is wonderful when writing a research paper. For example, when I wrote about AIDS in the elderly, I was writing a research paper. I had to gather data, in this case secondary sets, to compose my paper. I didn't just say "This is what they said." I did that in my "methodolgy" and "data results" sections, but my discussion, aside from citing the sources when I used their data in reaching that point or was lead to investagate this from them, was entirly my own extensions. That ran on for about ten pages. It was the part of the paper that should be relativly citation free in that all the data was listed above and all points discussed came from the data's support or lack thereof. In essence, my discussion was a lit review. In this case, my English paper now, I have read the "data," which is the novel. Going from this data collection shouldn't I, in theory, reach my results? Perhaps, I will want to draw in quotes or a source or two in explaining nihilism (though the word and the novel do that rather well). I guess I am just going to have to talk to him. It isn't like I am trying to not do the paper.
Theoketos Posted April 27, 2005 Posted April 27, 2005 [quote name='Iacobus' date='Apr 25 2005, 09:49 PM'] I wish I could write a book that would make me rich... but my writing has "put God to sleep." Or so it has been claimed. [/quote] You mezmorize me some times. Never stop writting.
Iacobus Posted April 27, 2005 Author Posted April 27, 2005 [quote name='Theoketos' date='Apr 26 2005, 10:04 PM'] You mezmorize me some times. Never stop writting. [/quote] Oh, I never plan on stoping my writing. It is fun, even when I am being boring.
Carnanc Posted April 27, 2005 Posted April 27, 2005 in a researh paper, regardles sof number of sources, you can have two citations a page at a minimum and be just fine.
Mickey's_Girl Posted April 27, 2005 Posted April 27, 2005 I hear what you're saying, Iacobus. Just talk to your teacher before worrying any more. Let us know how it goes! MG
Guest Eremite Posted April 27, 2005 Posted April 27, 2005 A paper should always contain the word "hitherto". If you're going to fail, at least be a pretentious failure.
Mickey's_Girl Posted April 27, 2005 Posted April 27, 2005 [quote name='Eremite' date='Apr 27 2005, 03:18 PM'] A paper should always contain the word "hitherto". If you're going to fail, at least be a pretentious failure. [/quote] AHA! AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHHAA! :rotfl: I love it. May I quote you? MG
Iacobus Posted April 28, 2005 Author Posted April 28, 2005 [quote name='Eremite' date='Apr 27 2005, 03:18 PM'] A paper should always contain the word "hitherto". If you're going to fail, at least be a pretentious failure. [/quote] I agrue that same point, but with "therefore," "thus," "nevertheless," and something in a different language (French or Latin are nice ones, esp titles).
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now