thessalonian Posted April 26, 2005 Posted April 26, 2005 Mark 6:3 and Matt 13:55 are most often cited as "proof" that Mary had other children. Matt.13 [55] Is not this the carpenter's son? Is not his mother called Mary? And are not his brothers James and Joseph and Simon and Judas? I've not heard this stated apologetically before but one other thing I find odd. I do not think that people named children by the first name of their fathers in the hebrew culture, but rather identified with their fathers as son of their father. For instance Peter is called Simon Bar Jona, i.e. Simon son of Jona. Now it is said that Mary had children with Joseph. If what I think is true, (I need to do some checking) then it is extremely unlikely that they would have a son named Joseph. Joseph bar Joseph? Thoughts? Any info with regard to Hebrew naming of children? Blessings
thessalonian Posted April 26, 2005 Author Posted April 26, 2005 There are hundres of X son of Y listings throughout the Old Testament. I have just gone through a couple of hundred and it isn't looking good for the possibility that a Jew would have called his son, Joseph son of Joseph, like we call our son's Jerry Junior.
thessalonian Posted April 26, 2005 Author Posted April 26, 2005 I've gone through all the verses with x son of y of which there are over 1000 and so far have only found this one where the son had the name of the father. 1Mac.10 [67] In the one hundred and sixty-fifth year Demetrius the son of Demetrius came from Crete to the land of his fathers. I do not believe that his was a Jew but will have to do some more reasearch. i still have to go through "the sons of..."
thessalonian Posted April 26, 2005 Author Posted April 26, 2005 There is a verse that says that they were amazed that John was not named after Zechariah. Not sure what this means. There are those who have similar names in the OT such as Imri and Omri and Ner and Abner as Father and son.
Totus Tuus Posted April 26, 2005 Posted April 26, 2005 That is so interesting. That may be a completely new approach to defending the topic of Mary's virginity. Thanks so much.
thessalonian Posted April 26, 2005 Author Posted April 26, 2005 [quote name='Totus Tuus' date='Apr 26 2005, 04:08 PM'] That is so interesting. That may be a completely new approach to defending the topic of Mary's virginity. Thanks so much. [/quote] It needs more study. I'll let you know the results.
thessalonian Posted April 26, 2005 Author Posted April 26, 2005 It seems it is not a great arguement. Though it is rare the fact that John was to be named Zechariah after his father if the angel had not called him John rules it out as an absolute. [59] And on the eighth day they came to circumcise the child; and they would have named him Zechari'ah after his father, I thought it just said he would be named after his father but it is more specific than that. Blessings
Antonius Posted April 27, 2005 Posted April 27, 2005 Looks like you would need more research than the Bible to see if the argument is valid. You would need to talk to a scholar of ancient Hebrew customs and such.
phatcatholic Posted April 27, 2005 Posted April 27, 2005 always check the Jewish Encyclopedia for information like this. it has as much information about Judaism as New Advent has about Catholicism. anyway, there's an entry on [url="http://www.jewishencyclopedia.com/view.jsp?artid=51&letter=N"][b]Names (Personal)[/b][/url] that may be of help to you. i haven't read it yet, so tell me if you find anything helpful. pax christi, phatcatholic
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now