Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

The Unmoved Mover's Perfection


Recommended Posts

Fiat_Voluntas_Tua
Posted

Here is my Philosophy Paper... It has yet been editted so don't rip apart it grammatically.

[i]Andrew Joseph Jaeger
April 26, 2005
Philosophy of Nature PH 231 B[/i]

The Unmoved Mover’s Perfection

In the words of the Philosopher, “Nature has been defined as a ‘principle of motion and change’ and it is the subject of our inquiry.” Nature is the subject of inquiry within this demonstration. To be precise, it is the nature of various mover’s that will be the inquired. A definition of motion will be given to better understand how matter is moved. This definition will be made in regards to potency and actuality, and their definitions will also be given. After the principles of motion have been set forth, an investigation of the various mover’s will proceed. At this point a “Scientia Quia” demonstration will be the basis of the argument.
It will be demonstrated that whatever is moved is moved by another. Then it will be stated that it is necessary to posit one of the following: that either motion will regress to infinity or that an unmoved mover must by the first cause of the first motion. It will follow that an infinite regression is not possible, thus we must conclude that there is an Unmoved Mover. From here the “nature” of the Unmoved Mover will be looked at in regards to potency and actuality. It will follow that since the Unmoved Mover exists and that it is not in potency, that the Unmoved Mover must be “Pure Act”. Finally, to conclude this “Scientia Quia” (from effect to cause) demonstration, it will be proven that that which is “Pure Act” is perfect (perfectio), for the definition of “perfectio” will be given by St. Thomas Aquinas.
“A thing is perfect in proportion to its actuality.” It will be proven that the Unmoved Mover is “perfect” precisely because it is pure actuality.
To begin this demonstration it will be necessary to know what it is that will be demonstrated, and as it was stated earlier that the nature of different mover’s will be investigated. Aristotle wrote in his Physics, “We must therefore see that we understand the meaning of ‘motion’; for if it were unknown, the meaning of ‘nature’ too would be unknown.” With this in mind we will begin to look at what motion is. Motion is defined by the Philosopher as, “The fulfilment of what exists potentially, in so far as it exists potential.”
The phrase “The fulfilment” can easily be replaced with the phrase the actuality. It is stated by St. Thomas Aquinas that the fulfilment of a potential is known as the “actuality” of the potential. A substance that has potency is one that consists of matter (material substance) and form (shape), thus giving it the power or ability to act or to be acted upon. A material substance, matter, is in potency because it is capable of undergoing motion in respect to either: magnitude, affection, or place.
The meaning of actuality is not the power a substance has to be moved, rather actuality is the existence of the substance. As it was stated earlier, actuality is the fulfilment of potency. However, potency is not a prerequisite for actuality, because without actuality there would be no potentiality. Nothing would be able to be “fulfilled.” Actuality is a simple notion, and simple notions can not be defined, thus actuality can not be defined. Actuality can only be understood inductively through examples. Here is an extended example that will aid in the understanding of potency and actuality.
Flour, water, eggs, sugar, and baking soda are potentially a cake in as much as they are able to be baked, “bake-able’s.” If these bake-able items are mixed, stirred, and cooked properly a cake, in matter and form, will exist actually. If these bake-able’s undergo the act of making a cake (mixing, stirring, cooking) they will become an actual cake. No longer will the bake-able’s (which we can no longer properly call them) have the potency of a cake, because they would have been moved from the potency of the bake-able’s to the actuality of the cake. The bake-able’s are no longer separate material substances with separate forms; rather, they loose their plurality and are now a single material substance (contained of many bake-able’s) and a single form of an actual cake. As the Philosopher states, “...it is the shape or form of things which have in themselves a source of motion.” The process that the bake-able’s underwent to become an actual cake is known as motion. “In other words, this sort of production is a process, a “movement” from potency to act; it is a mutation, transformation, change.”
Now that there is an understanding of potency and actuality, and that an example has been laid out relating potency and act with motion, we can proceed in understanding the various movers and how they move things. The first types of movers which I will mention are material substance’s, for these movers are easily sensed by us an their immediate cause and effect is also able to be sensed. However, we primarily sense them as moveable’s and not mover’s. They are mover’s in as much as they are moveable’s. It is their existing motion that moves other objects. “In other words: Whatever is moved is moved either by itself or by another. But it is not moved by itself, for, in that hypothesis, it would be at one and the same time in potency and in act with respect to the same determination. Therefore it is moved by another.” These material substances are mover’s because they are moveable.
The Philosopher states, “Everything that is in motion is moved by something...for there must be something else that moves it.” Let us take a billiard game as an example of this axiom which is has been laid out. Person A is trying to hit the “2-ball” into a pocket. The 2-ball will not change its’ position (local motion) unless something else, such as the cue-ball, moves it. The 2-ball has the potential to be in the pocket. However, the 2-ball must be moved by another in order for the potentiality to become act. In this example, the cue-ball will be the cause which brings the potential of the 2-ball to the actuality. It was stated earlier that ‘whatever is moved is moved by another.’ In this example we see the 2-ball being moved by the cue ball. However, it was the cue-stick that moved the cue-ball, and it was the hand that moved the cue-stick, etc. Some would argue that if we state that ‘whatever is moved is moved by another,’ then we must posit an infinite regress. But, an infinite regress is not possible and it will now be shown why.
If a material substance, ‘D’, was moved by material substance ‘C’ and ‘C’ by ‘B’ and ‘B’ by ‘A’, we must conclude that there was a substance that started the motion. However, if we do not conclude that there was a substance that started the motion, then it must be that nothing that follows is in motion. Now, this is known to be false because we can observe that material substance’s move from place to place, grow and decay, etc. Thus, it must be that there is a First Mover.
If it can be posited that there was a First Mover, than it must follow that that Mover is Unmoved. If it is said that there is a First Mover who initiates the first movement, that mover must either move itself or be immobile. Let us look at the possibility of a First Self-Moved Mover. In Kretzmann’s book, The Metaphysics of Theism, he shows how some say it is fairly reasonable to believe in the Self-moved Mover. “And that seems probable [a self-moved mover], because what occurs on its own is always prior to what occurs in virtue of something else... it is reasonable that the first thing moved be moved by itself.” But if we take a deeper look at how a substance moves itself we will see that it moves itself not as a whole but as parts. “It does not impart motion as a whole nor is it moved as a whole.” The whole substance can not be moved by the whole substance. If the whole was moved by the whole the substance would be both actuality and potentiality. “For what is acting as a mover is in a state of actuality, but what is moved is in a state of potentiality.” Now the substance can not both be actuality and potentiality at the same time and in the same respect, so it must be concluded that part of the substance is the actuality and the other part the potentiality. We come to the conclusion that it is the actuality part that moves the potentiality part. Thus, the actuality part must be an un-moved mover and the potentiality part is the moved part. “But one can not say that both parts are moved...or that one part moves itself and moves the other, or that a whole moves a part, or that a part moves a whole.” If any of these were said, it would be nonsense because the whole can not both be actuality and potentiality at the same time in the same respect. This brings us back to the claim of an Unmoved First Mover. It has been demonstrated that if the claim is made that the First Mover is self-moving, that mover must be made up of parts (because the whole can not move the whole). It also must follow that within that mover there is an Unmoved part which is actuality. Thus, the First Mover necessarily has to be Unmoved.
We can now proceed in showing that the Unmoved Mover is Pure Act. It was shown above that the Unmoved Mover is immobile (unmoved). It was also stated above that motion is the “fulfillment of a potential.” However, if a substance is not movable it must be that the substance has no potency, because potency gives the substance the power to be moved. If the Unmoved Mover does not have any potency, then it must be either actuality or neither. Now, we have proven the existence of the Unmoved Mover, so it would follow that the Unmoved Mover be entirely actuality.
It has been demonstrated from effect to cause (“Scientia Quia”) that there must be an Unmoved Mover who imparts motion on other substances. These substances are put into motion, thus giving them the potentiality to be moved by other substances. It was stated earlier that whatever is moved is moved by another, and this can be observed in the natural world around us. It can be said the part of the nature of the Unmoved Mover is its pure act. Now it is possible to go a little further in demonstrating that the Unmoved Mover is Perfect. (“perfectio”)
According to Thomas Aquinas perfection, perfectio in Latin, means actuality, completeness, fulfillment. Thus it would make sense that the perfect substance be that which is in Pure Actuality, that substance is the Unmoved Mover. It was stated earlier that matter, by nature, contains potency for motion. We know that the Unmoved Mover is immobile. Thus it follows that the Unmoved Mover is not a material substance. As Thomas Aquinas states, “Hence, the first active principle must needs be most actual, and therefore most perfect; for a thing is perfect in proportion to its state of actuality, because we call that perfect which lacks nothing of the mode of its perfection.” In conclusion, the substance which is entirely pure actuality is the most perfect, for perfection is proportionate to actuality. If the substance that is pure actuality is perfect, and the Unmoved Mover is pure actuality, then the Unmoved Mover is Perfect.
It has been proven that motion is “The fulfilment of what exists potentially, in so far as it exists potential” and that “whatever is moved is moved by another.” It also has been shown that ‘it is impossible to posit an infinite regress’ and that ‘there must be an Unmoved First Mover.’ Also it was shown how ‘the Unmoved Mover is pure act.’ Saint Thomas Aquinas wrote that that which is in pure act is perfect. Finally, it was demonstrated in a logically sound syllogism that the unmoved Mover is Perfect.



Totus Tuus,
Andrew Joseph

Noel's angel
Posted

i didn't get a chance to read it all yet, i''m doing some work of my own at the miunte so i'm pretty busy, but i'll definately read it all tomorrow and tell you what i think (even though it will probably be totally over my head lol)

Posted

I am taking Thomism this semester and we covered the 5 ways earlier this year. I will try to get around to reading it and responding. Right now I am busy writing a paper for that class that covers how the 5 ways relates to the problem of beatitude and its practical implications. Ugh

Fiat_Voluntas_Tua
Posted

ahhh...thankyou for your devotion to helping me out... God Bless you.

Totus Tuus,
Andrew Joseph

Posted

One thing that will help direct my reading is are you looking for proofreading grammar, content, style, pattern of thought? Something else perhaps?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...