Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group Ă—
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Hey all,

Here's the deal, I'm a Theology major at Lewis University. I transfered in this past January. In November, I was discussing this school with a Deacon from my church who mentioned that it wasn't the best for Theology. At that point, my friend whom he didn't know that also attends Lewis and is a theology major began defending the program saying how great it is.

So here's the dilemma. Today, after I spent a hour in the office of my academic advisor picking my classes for next semester i decide on one called "The Catholic Church." As I got home i got into a friendly debate with my friend and when she asked me How i knew something, i responded with "the magisterium." She did not know what I was talking about. Now, knowing that she defended this program so well, and also knowing that she is Catholic, and has taken the class "The Catholic Church", I was rather upset.

In my opinion, this should be first or second day material in a class devoted to the Church. How can we learn about something, without understanding where it comes from first? In her opinion, it was no big deal, and that i was overreacting.

Personally, I feel that if I am coughing up all this cash to get this degree, I should learn about something as important as the Magisterium. Luckily, I know about it already, but what about the stuff that I do not already know about, it is why I'm going to school. I wonder, what am I missing out on? Does anyone else feel that I have a right to be upset? Or should I just shut up, and take the class, and deal with whatever new information I can gain?

Radarpriest
Posted

Hi i am also a theology major at Lewis University, I transfered in from Quincy University last Augest, I think the first place one should start when teaching the holy roman catholic church is the "truth" and how the "truth is revealed to us. And what tiem do you have catholic church next semester i have it at 12:30 -1;45, and that girl your talking about she knows her stuff even 9if she did not know one word she knows the church

Ash Wednesday
Posted

If you take the class, don't feel like you would have to shut up. ;) If they don't discuss it, then you betcha I think you could blow the whistle.

Is your friend a Catholic? Was she a really good and attentive student?

I don't blame you for being upset. Not only because you're paying for this education, but the theological and authoritative ramifications, too.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Radarpriest' date='Apr 27 2005, 09:30 PM'] Hi i am also a theology major at Lewis University, I transfered in from Quincy University last Augest, I think the first place one should start when teaching the holy roman catholic church is the "truth" and how the "truth is revealed to us. And what tiem do you have catholic church next semester i have it at 12:30 -1;45, and that girl your talking about she knows her stuff even 9if she did not know one word she knows the church [/quote]
i'll have it at 8 am. The truth is verified through the magisterium though...at least in my understanding. and yes, i know she knows her stuff...I didn't say she didn't. I am upset at a Catholic school, that teaches about the Catholic Church, and doesn't mention something so important. I have the utmost respect for my friend, and honestly believe that I'll never be smarter then her, no matter how much i study. She knows this, even if she thinks I'm making her look like an idiot, I'm not. It's an example of a major problem I think is in this program.

Edited by Zoecool13
Radarpriest
Posted

I just found out i will have old test wisdom with you, i look fowared to it, and the church has alot of teachings "truth" one person can not know it all that is why we have a comunity, but i understand you like and are able to conected with her teachens and understandings of Magisterium, me on the other hand like the Fransican theology, and litergy, and I strugle with Lewis calling them selfs catholic to for sortean reasons dealing with litergy. We all have those things we specalise in so dont get to upset if someone conects with difrent truths then you

Posted

[quote name='Radarpriest' date='Apr 27 2005, 09:45 PM'] I just found out i will have old test wisdom with you, i look fowared to it, and the church has alot of teachings "truth" one person can not know it all [/quote]
The magisterium's job is to tell us what the truth is. That is the problem...the class that speaks about the truth does not tell us where it comes from. I don't know if I'll be in Old Test...I gotta get it approved first.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

[quote name='Zoecool13' date='Apr 27 2005, 09:37 PM'] and yes, i know she knows her stuff...I didn't say she didn't. [/quote]
Okay, that's what I wanted to verify -- because since that is the case, then the class has serious gaps, definitely.

I've heard of "theology" classes that teach pure garbage at these "Catholic" institutions.

Posted

[quote name='Radarpriest' date='Apr 27 2005, 09:45 PM'] I just found out i will have old test wisdom with you, i look fowared to it, and the church has alot of teachings "truth" one person can not know it all that is why we have a comunity, but i understand you like and are able to conected with her teachens and understandings of Magisterium, me on the other hand like the Fransican theology, and litergy, and I strugle with Lewis calling them selfs catholic to for sortean reasons dealing with litergy. We all have those things we specalise in so dont get to upset if someone conects with difrent truths then you [/quote]
woah woah woah!! different truths? everything we KNOW in the Catholic Church, all of the TRUTH comes to us THROUGH the Magesterium. They interpret scripture, tradition and set down Dogma. They are the light by which our faith is illuminated. Franciscan theology has been APPROVED by the Magisterium as has the liturgy. there is not Church without it. it is the Living Body of Christ established by Christ Himself on the rock of Peter. i repeat, without her there is no Church. And, despite some's opinions to the contrary, there is only ONE Truth, the truth of Christ handed down by the Magisterium of the One, Holy Catholic & Apostolic Church

/end rant -_-

Posted

[quote name='Zoecool13' date='Apr 27 2005, 09:19 PM'] Hey all,

Here's the deal, I'm a Theology major at Lewis University. I transfered in this past January. In November, I was discussing this school with a Deacon from my church who mentioned that it wasn't the best for Theology. At that point, my friend whom he didn't know that also attends Lewis and is a theology major began defending the program saying how great it is.

So here's the dilemma. Today, after I spent a hour in the office of my academic advisor picking my classes for next semester i decide on one called "The Catholic Church." As I got home i got into a friendly debate with my friend and when she asked me How i knew something, i responded with "the magisterium." She did not know what I was talking about. Now, knowing that she defended this program so well, and also knowing that she is Catholic, and has taken the class "The Catholic Church", I was rather upset.

In my opinion, this should be first or second day material in a class devoted to the Church. How can we learn about something, without understanding where it comes from first? In her opinion, it was no big deal, and that i was overreacting.

Personally, I feel that if I am coughing up all this cash to get this degree, I should learn about something as important as the Magisterium. Luckily, I know about it already, but what about the stuff that I do not already know about, it is why I'm going to school. I wonder, what am I missing out on? Does anyone else feel that I have a right to be upset? Or should I just shut up, and take the class, and deal with whatever new information I can gain? [/quote]
Great news, finish the degree....it is totally worth it. I should know, I have one.

You have every right to question that. I would look to your friend and ask a simple question.....If you are Catholic, who defines what you believe?

That is Theology 101.

However, here is the other side of the coin.....you do need to "shut up" (your term, not mine) and learn. Questioning is great, but it can build ignorance, especially if they don't answer it the way you want it to be answered. Part of the point of learning the Theological prinicples is critical thinking. I didn't do that very well and class was hard.

Now, as I go back and study again, I see where my professors were coming from and I was being a bit pig headed. I questioned EVERYTHING, all the time.

Kick back, enjoy the courses, get your degree and have a ton of fun. I love theology and I will continue to study and study and study.....I learn something new every day.

God Bless....if you have any questions...feel free to PM me. I can't guarantee an answer, but I can guarantee that I will try.

Do all of this in the light of faith and prayer......and learn your philosophy, it is just as important.

Cam

Piccoli Fiori JMJ
Posted

I'd say continue with the education, but strive to make a difference at the school and stick up for the truth of the magisterium :) even if you alone have to teach about it...

Defender_of_the_Faith
Posted

Wow. I go to Lewis University too. Except I'm a Biology major. I'm looking forward to taking "The Catholic Church" for one of my required theology classes as soon as I can find a semester to fit it into my schedule. I hope everything i up to par when I take it.

Posted

[quote name='Cam42' date='Apr 27 2005, 10:59 PM'] However, here is the other side of the coin.....you do need to "shut up" (your term, not mine) and learn. Questioning is great, but it can build ignorance, especially if they don't answer it the way you want it to be answered. Part of the point of learning the Theological prinicples is critical thinking. I didn't do that very well and class was hard.
[/quote]
My biggest concern is that I don't know it all. And if the school isn't teaching something so important, then what else am I going to miss out on? I'm not questioning anything but the creditability of the school. It's not my friend's fault she wasn't taught it. But in 2 years from now, and I stand proudly with that piece of paper called a degree, I should know the basic structure of our beloved church, especially if it's a Catholic University, I am Catholic, and took a class called the Catholic Church. That is where I see the problem.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Did the theology profs at your school sign the mandatum?

It is a statement that they are teaching only authentic CATHOLIC teaching.

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='Apr 28 2005, 07:12 AM'] Did the theology profs at your school sign the mandatum?

It is a statement that they are teaching only authentic CATHOLIC teaching. [/quote]
yea, i know of the mandatum, but I don't know if Lewis signs it. In fact, I doubt it, but that's not the issue...the issue is not teaching the wrong thing, but not teaching an important thing at all.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='Apr 28 2005, 07:12 AM'] Did the theology profs at your school sign the mandatum?

It is a statement  that they are teaching only authentic CATHOLIC teaching. [/quote]
P.S. that is not necessarily true.


I have no Idea where Louis College is, but if you want an Orthodox undergraduate degree I know that Benedictine College in Atchison Kansas, U of Dallas Dallas Texas, Thomas Aquinas in California, Franciscan University of Steubenville Ohio, And Christendom College in Virgina are the best places with Orthodox Teachers.

Edited by Theoketos

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...