D0RK4JP2 Posted April 28, 2005 Posted April 28, 2005 Gday folks, I play this RPG call tibia. There are heaps like it and heaps more which are more advanced and time consuming. I have no doubt that other PMpeeps play RPG's, but the question that constantly niggles at me is........should we? They are a virtual world; a place where real life doesn't directly apply - often not even relevent - and sometimes directly opposed to the nature of the real world. This is all really a moral crisis, for me at least. The thing that bugs me about playing - even though I still do because it's fun - is that it isn't the 'world' that God created, but a virtual world that man created where God's morality sometimes takes no place at all. The BIGGEST example is the use of magic. When playing I hate talking about it, using any reference to it, let alone using 'it'. I know it's not real, and I know I'm not really using magic, but...why even pretend? It's games like that that can lead people into REAL magic where the greater damage is. Then there's the issue of laziness where it can be such a source of sloth that, even when you're not being slothful in your game-playing, you may be encouraging sloth for someone else. ...goodness, the more I explain this the less I actually want to play it, or any computer game for that matter. PMpeeps, I call for your input ! Am I being too scrupulous and not seeing the more positive side of RPG'ing, or is it even more evil that I realise? What's the G.O!? JMJ.
Ash Wednesday Posted April 28, 2005 Posted April 28, 2005 I never got into RPGs so I can only say so much, but I think your concerns are justified. What is the so-called "positive" side of RPGs that you alluded to?
Piccoli Fiori JMJ Posted April 28, 2005 Posted April 28, 2005 AHHH!!! Biblical Studies has me thinking about 1 Corinthians on this topic, but slightly different...
Philippe Posted April 28, 2005 Posted April 28, 2005 ive also noticed in lots of these communities that they arent exactly Christ centered and are often occasions of sin. Maybe thats just for me though
Ash Wednesday Posted April 28, 2005 Posted April 28, 2005 Do many hardcore RPGs get into the occult or wicca? I think sometimes people get into things that can lead to regular activity that "replaces" one's spiritual life. I remember an EWTN priest once saying that sometimes hardcore martial artists get into eastern religions. At the time I thought he was going a bit overboard with that statement, and I was even a bit put off by it, but now I think there's something to what he had said. Ever since I got to black belt, I really have lost a lot of the interest I had in it before, because often when you move in the really advanced stages, depending on the club you are in, if it's "traditional" arts it can get really monotonous and it's no longer just sport and exercise to you. If you don't start getting into the "spiritual" aspect, you generally don't advance and "benefit" in the same way. At least that's in my experience. To some people in my club, it literally replaces religion in their lives. Some of the RPGs I've met online seem into the "magick" thing.
D0RK4JP2 Posted April 28, 2005 Author Posted April 28, 2005 Thanks for your replies. I know what I'm going to do. What of the difficulties in to give up playing is the *gulps* peer pressure. IT'S SO TRUE! THE REALITY OF YOUR FAITH IS SHOWN BY YOUR WEAKNESS! This is soooo humbling . I'm going to open up the game, write note down all the things which are intrically immoral about it so when I tell me m8s I'm not playing I can tell them, in a matter-of-fact way, why I'm not so they too can consider not playing it anymore. Thanks everyone! JMJ.
Don John of Austria Posted April 28, 2005 Posted April 28, 2005 Well I don't know about tibia, is it a computer RPG or a pen and paper RPG, I have played RPG's since I was a small child and have never seen any occult connection, lets take D&D many of those who play D&D are into neopagan stuff, many are also hardcore traditionalist Catholics ( I mean I have known a lot of them!) RPG's are an activity people who play them gravitate to groups of like minded people who indulge in that activity, further RPG's are game, you are not morally responsable for the actuions of a character you play in a RPG anymore han you are responsable for your actions in a game of monopoly.... IT IS A GAME. Now if the Gome is dominating your life or something that might be a problem related to gluttony but not to the act of Playing an RPG.
return2truth Posted April 28, 2005 Posted April 28, 2005 [quote name='Ash Wednesday' date='Apr 28 2005, 01:51 AM'] Do many hardcore RPGs get into the occult or wicca? [/quote] I did, but I do not think it was [i]because[/i] of RPG's. At the time, I was allowing myself to explore and indulge in an alternative spiritual culture both in my real life (Wicca) and my fantasy life (Dungeons & Dragons.) I still enjoy fantasy literature and computer games. Within them are presented worlds where the distinction between good and evil is clear,where heroes can rise from humble beginings to vanquish a horrible enemy, and save the world-- all in one day! Do they forge my world view? I admit that they used to, but even then I don't think they were a negative influence. Now that I have grown in wisdom, I can extract from them the values and morals that are righteous or simply be entertained by the story. There is one book that inspires me beyond all others though, that truly does guide my actions. In this book, the greatest hero to have ever lived vanquishes the greatest evil the world has ever know. It's epic. It's spine-tingling. Best of all, it's true.
Crispy Posted April 28, 2005 Posted April 28, 2005 so what is the solution?? im kinda in the same boat here cause ive grown up liking all the knights, wizards, and magic fantasy stuff. im a big fan of computer games like warcraft III and other games like RPGs. ive been trying to figure this problem out to little avail. it will be hard to give up such a big part of my life, but ill do it if necessary.
Don John of Austria Posted April 28, 2005 Posted April 28, 2005 I don't think it's an issue, just keep fantasy in perspective as fantasy and you'll be fine.
return2truth Posted April 28, 2005 Posted April 28, 2005 [quote name='Crispy' date='Apr 28 2005, 10:05 AM'] so what is the solution?? im kinda in the same boat here cause ive grown up liking all the knights, wizards, and magic fantasy stuff. im a big fan of computer games like warcraft III and other games like RPGs. ive been trying to figure this problem out to little avail. it will be hard to give up such a big part of my life, but ill do it if necessary. [/quote] An interest in RPG's and fantasy worlds is not sinful in and unto itself. Like ALL things, you must avoid practicing or finding value in things that lead you away from God. Fantasy stories can potentially contain ideas that can help one understand Our Lord in a better light than the harshness of our present day world sometimes might. God gave us the ability to create entire worlds in our minds. It is one of the ways in which we were created in His image. It is our privilege to celebrate his gift of imagination, but we should also listen to the council of the Holy Spirit to know when we have taken it too far from the intentions of Our Father. God is real; fantasy worlds are not. When fantasy, [i]of any kind[/i], replaces God's place in your heart; when you begin to live for the fantasy, [i]then[/i] you will have turned your back on God. Then you will have missed the mark.
Carnanc Posted April 28, 2005 Posted April 28, 2005 I've never tried RPG's of any kind, but I've always had a bad impression of them. I think it depends on who you are playing with, and the exact nature of the one your doing. Overall, I think they can be ok depending on the content, and that you don't spend to much time with them.
philothea Posted April 28, 2005 Posted April 28, 2005 In my experience, the real-time online RPGs have a huge danger of addiction and excessive emotional attachment. Please don't ask me how I know.... I only play single-player games on my computer, or sometimes network games with my husband. I still risk wasting time, though. I don't think there's anything inherently wrong with role playing games. Just risky, especially for some types of personalities.
let_go_let_God Posted April 28, 2005 Posted April 28, 2005 [quote name='return2truth' date='Apr 28 2005, 10:42 AM'] An interest in RPG's and fantasy worlds is not sinful in and unto itself. Like ALL things, you must avoid practicing or finding value in things that lead you away from God. Fantasy stories can potentially contain ideas that can help one understand Our Lord in a better light than the harshness of our present day world sometimes might. God gave us the ability to create entire worlds in our minds. It is one of the ways in which we were created in His image. It is our privilege to celebrate his gift of imagination, but we should also listen to the council of the Holy Spirit to know when we have taken it too far from the intentions of Our Father. God is real; fantasy worlds are not. When fantasy, [i]of any kind[/i], replaces God's place in your heart; when you begin to live for the fantasy, [i]then[/i] you will have turned your back on God. Then you will have missed the mark. [/quote] I agree with return2truth on this. Playing in itself would not be sinful, you would only be crossing the line when you believe what you are doing is true and you put the RPG above God and his will. As long as you can distinguish from what is fact and what is fiction all should be fine. As another example look at gambling. It is legal in all 50 states and as long as you are spending money within your own means nothing is wrong. Once you develop an addiction then you have to take a look at what you are doing. If you are taking money set aside for buying food, clothing, basic amenities for you and your family (if you have a family of your own) then you are not only depriving yourself of what you need but the needs of others. God bless- LGLG
nikkan_hanil Posted April 29, 2005 Posted April 29, 2005 RPGs are great. I was so emotionally overwhelmed when I finally beat FFVIII.
zealousdefender Posted April 29, 2005 Posted April 29, 2005 I'm glad to see that so many of you are of the opinion that RPG's are ok, as long as they are kept in perspective. For many years I used to play D&D, (pen and paper type,) but I haven't played in a couple of years. It was a HUGE point of contention between my godfather and I. He was adamant that it was mortally sinful. I disagreed, though I could see how it could become so. Nevertheless, I was able to keep it in perspective. As far as it being escapism, (my godfather's charge,) I liken it to watching a movie or better yet, [i]acting[/i] in a movie. I can't see the difference.
journeyman Posted April 29, 2005 Posted April 29, 2005 dUSt was talking at one time of incorporating one into PM . . . [url="http://phorum.phatmass.com/index.php?showtopic=28880&hl=role+playing+game"]http://phorum.phatmass.com/index.php?showt...le+playing+game[/url] . . . what ever happened to that?
Carnanc Posted April 29, 2005 Posted April 29, 2005 during RPG's can the gameplay extend throughout your whole life, like do you start acting like characters arround your friends even when not focusing on the game?
philothea Posted April 29, 2005 Posted April 29, 2005 [quote name='journeyman' date='Apr 28 2005, 08:51 PM'] dUSt was talking at one time of incorporating one into PM . . . [url="http://phorum.phatmass.com/index.php?showtopic=28880&hl=role+playing+game"]http://phorum.phatmass.com/index.php?showt...le+playing+game[/url] . . . what ever happened to that? [/quote] Oh that would be so cool! I had no idea; the original post was before my time. I wonder what the status of the project is.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now