Paladin D Posted May 5, 2005 Posted May 5, 2005 [url="http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/kingdom_of_heaven/"]http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/kingdom_of_heaven/[/url] [b]42%[/b].
Jazz4jesus Posted May 6, 2005 Posted May 6, 2005 i never liked reviews its like asking someone else to tell you how you went about painting an artwork.
Paladin D Posted May 6, 2005 Author Posted May 6, 2005 I'm [b]glad[/b] it got bad reviews, it's anti-Catholic.
dUSt Posted May 6, 2005 Posted May 6, 2005 Reading some of the reviews, it looks like a politically correct lets not try to offend anyone even if we leave out factual history attempt at story-telling. I'll still go see it, but will probably end up leaving dissapointed.
Socrates Posted May 6, 2005 Posted May 6, 2005 From the reviews and everything I've read, it looks like it has the p.c. message of "The crusades were bad. Catholics were the bad guys. Religious tolerance is good." "Religious tolerance" is a completely anachronistic theme for the time period and would be a completely foreign idea to both Christians and Muslims of the time. And I don't like Orlando Bloom.
HomeTeamFamily Posted May 6, 2005 Posted May 6, 2005 looks from the previews like a religiously toned "Troy"
Phikoz Posted May 6, 2005 Posted May 6, 2005 Review by Steven D. Greydanus Muslim dominance first came to Jerusalem in 638 when the army of Caliph Omar conquered the Holy City, ending Christian control of Jerusalem for the next four and a half centuries. Throughout most of this period, Byzantine Christians and Western pilgrims had access to their holy sites in the city and throughout the Holy Land. Then in the eleventh century, the rise of a new Muslim faction, the Seljuk Turks, which seized control of Jerusalem in 1070, threatened the Christian presence throughout the Middle East and even into Europe. In 1095, European Christians, long preoccupied with internal conflicts, finally struck back, mounting the first Crusade against Muslim occupation in the Holy Land with the blessing of Pope Gregory VII. A decentralized campaign comprising regular armies and knights as well as peasant hordes, the Crusaders succeeded in capturing Jerusalem in 1099, but proceeded to slaughter all the city’s Muslim inhabitants, including women, children, and the elderly. The First Crusade established the Christian Kingdom of Jerusalem, which lasted until 1187, when the Muslim leader Saladin captured the city. Christian forces had already been decimated at the Battle of Hattin, but Jerusalem’s Christian population remained well defended under the leadership of one Balian of Ibelin. Balian held Saladin’s forces at bay, ultimately threatening to destroy the entire city (and, in a detail omitted from the film, kill all the Muslims in the city) rather than let the Christian population fall into Saladin’s hands. Ultimately, Balian negotiated the city’s surrender in exchange for a promise of mercy that the Crusaders had not shown the Muslims a century earlier. Subsequent crusades to reestablish Christian control in the Middle East failed and led to many unhappy consequences, perhaps the darkest of which was the sack of Constantinople in the Fourth Crusade. Kingdom of Heaven, Ridley Scott’s ambitious Crusade-era epic, idealizes the 12th-century Christian Kingdom of Jerusalem as a nexus of uneasy but briefly successful coexistence of Christians, Muslims and Jews in the Holy Land. The Kingdom of Jerusalem, Geoffrey of Ibelin (Liam Neeson) explains to Balian (Orlando Bloom), is meant to be “a better world than has ever been seen… a kingdom of conscience, peace instead of war, love instead of hate. That is what lies at the end of crusade.” In this highly fictionalized retelling, Balian is the illegitimate peasant son of the fictional Geoffrey, working as a blacksmith until tragedy, heartbreak, and eventually guilt impel him to make a pilgrimage to Jerusalem in the hope of atoning for his sins and those of his late wife, a suicide. From his father Balian learns a code of conduct for a knight to live and die by: “Be brave and upright that God may love thee; speak the truth always, even if it leads to your death; safeguard the helpless and do no wrong. That is your oath.” Then Geoffrey gives him a slap, like the symbolic blow to the cheek bishops used to give recipients of confirmation: “That’s so you remember it.” Balian struggles with loss of faith, fearing that he has fallen from grace and is beyond redemption. He’s finds comfort, though, by the counsel of a priest of the order of Hospitalers (David Thewlis), who tells him, “Holiness is in right action… what God desires is here” (touching Balian’s forehead) “and here” (touching his heart). These are high ideals, though the reality is messier. The Kingdom is ruled in its final years by Baldwin IV, the Leper King (Edward Norton in a startling mask), a moderate who wishes to maintain peace with Saladin (Ghassan Massoud). The peace is threatened, however, by “fanatics of every denomination [sic],” i.e., Christian and Muslim. (What about Jews? They’re irrelevant here.) On the Christian side, these fanatics are primarily the Knights Templars, who treacherously instigate for open war with Saladin, waylaying Muslim pilgrims on the road, confident that God will give them victory over the infidels. The Templars aren’t the only rotten monastic or clerical characters in the story. The Patriarch of Jerusalem is thoroughly contemptible, and a minor character in the prologue whose odious behavior leads to tragic consequences is also a priest. On the other hand, the negative depiction of the Patriarch of Jerusalem appears to have some historical basis, and Thewlis’s Hospitaler provides a positive priestly counterpoint to the corrupt clerics. Beyond the clerics, there are also other good Christian characters, especially Jeremy Iron’s noble knight Tiberias, who supports Baldwin’s peace against Templar war-mongering. There’s also Balian himself, who refuses to murder a haughty rival even to potentially save the kingdom and get the girl (Eva Green), who is inconveniently married to the rival. This, he says, would be to sell his soul; and he’s unmoved by the girl’s objection, “The day will come when you will wish you had done a little evil to do a great good.” (On the other hand, he does commit adultery with her at least once.) Despite mention of “fanatics” on both sides, Scott devotes far less time to developing the Muslim side of things. Saladin himself is essentially the only Muslim who emerges as a real character. There are no depictions of Muslim clerics, good or bad. One very minor Muslim character briefly exemplifies Zealot-like impatience to reclaim Jerusalem; but we see no Muslim equivalent to the mustache-twirling villainy of the Templars or the hypocrisy of the Jerusalem Patriarch. Apparently Saladin is more successful at restraining fanatical Muslim elements than Baldwin is fanatical Christian elements. In fact, the story could largely be described as the failure of moderate Christians to restrain fanatical Christians from oppressing innocent Muslims, thereby provoking justifiable Muslim retaliation against the Christians, both fanatics and otherwise. Yet Saladin himself is not an uncomplicated noble figure. As he prepares to lay siege to Jerusalem, he explicitly rejects the possibility of showing mercy, relenting only when Balian fights him to a standstill. Still, the film cross-examines the Christians in a way it doesn't the Muslims. “At first I thought we were fighting for God,” says Tiberias, “but then I realized we were fighting for wealth and land.” Oh. What are the Muslims fighting for? What were they fighting for when they captured Jerusalem in the first place? More than once we see Muslims engaged in daily public prayers, but we never see Christians similarly engaged. Prayer for the Christian characters is only a solitary struggle with the sense of God's absence. Despite these contrasts, Kingdom of Heaven makes an uneven effort to bring a measure of even-handedness to the religious divide. The film’s perspective, though, is ultimately more secular than religious. Even the Hospitaler, the most positive religious character, is more a spokesman for conscience than for faith per se. Kingdom of Heaven isn’t anti-God or even necessarily anti-faith, but there’s an element of anti-religious sentiment at work here. “Thank you, your Eminence, you've taught me so much about religion,” Balian sneers after the Jerusalem Patriarch has alternately suggested abandoning the Christian populace of Jerualem to slaughter or converting to Islam and repenting later as a means of saving their necks. In a historical epic genre that lately has been fueled substantially by revenge (Scott’s own Gladiator; Troy; Braveheart) or even less (King Arthur; Alexander), Kingdom of Heaven aspires to be about something more: conscience, right action, and above all peaceful coexistence. Its hero, Balian, is more engaging than, say, Gladiator’s Maximus, who neither grows nor changes throughout the course of the film. Of course Gladiator had Russell Crowe, and Bloom’s not in his league, but he grows nicely into the role, and his character arc is more interesting. The rest of the cast — Norton, Irons, Massoud, Green, Neeson — is excellent. Unfortunately, first-time screenwriter William Monohan bogs down the obligatory love story in overwrought dialogue. “I’m not here because I’m bored or wicked,” Sibylla (Green) confesses as she comes to seduce Balian. “I’m here because here in the east, between one person and another, there is only light.” Before Balian can wonder what precisely that’s supposed to mean, she blows out the candle she’s holding. Whoops, nothing between them now. Afterwards, she wonders, “What will become of us?” Balian’s profound reply: “The world will decide. The world always decides.” Epic siege sequences have become so numerous lately (The Two Towers; The Return of the King; Troy; King Arthur) that I thought I had seen it all, but Scott has some new tricks up his sleeve, and the siege of Jerusalem is more dramatic than it has any right to at this point. On the other hand, some of the violence, especially a combat scene set in France, is needlessly brutal and explicit. The climactic battle sequence, though, ends with a striking image: an overhead “God shot” of Christian and Muslim warriors pressing on either side of a breach in the wall, anonymous, indistinguishable, ineffectual. Kingdom of Heaven doesn’t take sides or fault one over the other in the struggle over Jerusalem, but it ultimately leans toward the agnostic conclusion that the world might be better off if there were no temple wall, no mosque, no sepulchre for Christians, Jews, and Muslims to fight over. Alas, the sad history of religious strife in, over and around the Holy Land makes it difficult to fault the filmmakers for finding this a tempting point of view.
Carrie Posted May 6, 2005 Posted May 6, 2005 [quote name='Socrates' date='May 5 2005, 10:40 PM'] And I don't like Orlando Bloom. [/quote] Orlando Bloom is , especially in Pirates of the Caribbean!
Carrie Posted May 6, 2005 Posted May 6, 2005 [quote name='Eremite' date='May 6 2005, 12:16 PM'] Don't forget the immortal (literally) Legolas. [/quote] Doh! How could I forget?? I love LOTR!!!
DonCamillo Posted May 6, 2005 Posted May 6, 2005 It gets a good review from Catholic News Service [url="http://www.catholicnews.com/data/movies/05mv544.htm"]http://www.catholicnews.com/data/movies/05mv544.htm[/url] [quote]Kingdom of Heaven By David DiCerto Catholic News Service NEW YORK (CNS) -- Western armies clashing with Islamic forces on a desert battlefield. Sound familiar? No, it's not a story on the nightly news. It is "Kingdom of Heaven" (20th Century Fox), a sweeping, if bloody and somewhat revisionist, historical drama set in the late 12th century between the second and third Crusades. Given the current state of the world, some may consider such subject matter ill-timed. Cultural tensions notwithstanding, director Ridley Scott has crafted a piece of muscular filmmaking -- full of lavish pageantry, romance, palace intrigue, and savage swordplay-- which, much like the Crusaders themselves, is a mix of good and bad. It must be stated right up front that the film conveys a subtle but pervasive wariness of organized religion and a not-so-subtle strain of anti-clericalism. Orlando Bloom, best known from "The Lord of the Rings" trilogy, stars as Balian (loosely based on an actual historical figure), a disillusioned young blacksmith in rural France numbed by his wife's recent suicide after the loss of their child. Liam Neeson plays Jerusalem-bound nobleman Godfrey of Ibelin, who stops at Balian's smithy while en route east with his men. Seeking forgiveness, Godfrey reveals that Balian is his illegitimate son and heir, whom he tries, unsuccessfully, to recruit for his pilgrimage. Balian is later forced to reconsider the invitation when, in a rage, he kills a snide village priest, who told him that his wife was damned to hell for taking her own life. Godfrey is mortally wounded in an ambush, and dies soon after, but not before he makes Balian a knight, charging him to uphold the code of chivalry and keep alive his dream of a "kingdom of heaven" where Christian, Muslim and Jew can live in harmony. Balian continues on to Palestine in search of redemption and to regain the faith which he lost with his wife's death. Once there, he becomes embroiled in the power struggles between the tolerance-advocating Latin King of Jerusalem Baldwin IV (Edward Norton) -- a leper who keeps his disfigurement hidden behind a silver face mask and to whom Balian swears fealty -- and Guy de Lusignan (Marton Csokas) a would-be usurper who threatens to disrupt the tenuous truce between the Christian and Muslim forces. Rounding out the top-notch ensemble are Jeremy Irons as Tiberias, Baldwin's wise military adviser; Ghassan Massoud as legendary Muslim leader Saladin; Brendan Gleeson as Reynald of Chatillon, a bloodthirsty Templar; and David Thewlis as a Hospitaler knight-confessor. Eva Green plays the exotically beautiful Princess Sibylla, Baldwin's sister, who is trapped in a forced marriage to the boorish Guy and who becomes Balian's lover. From a cinematic standpoint, "Kingdom of Heaven," is grand-scale moviemaking at its best, with epic battle sequences, including the climactic -- but drawn out -- siege of Jerusalem by the Saracen army. Filmed in Spain and Morocco, the movie's eye-filling sets and costumes are impressive and the painstaking attention to period detail should pay dividends come Oscar time, as should the luscious palette caught by the lens which ranges from the slate-gray drabness of medieval Europe to vibrant David Lean-inspired desertscapes. The eclectic score is a medley of rousing chorales and sacred chants accented with Arabic-sounding motifs. Making the transition from Middle Earth to the Middle East, Bloom adequately conveys the reluctant hero's idealism, but somewhat lacks the gravitas the role demands, a want most evident in the "Henry V"-like speech with which he rallies his vastly outnumbered band of brothers as they prepare to defend Jerusalem. (The improbability of a simple blacksmith becoming so adept at warfare is never explained.) The film does take dramatic license with the historical facts (especially in its painting of certain characters in an overly righteous or villainous light, its injection of 21st-century sensibilities into a 12th-century milieu, and its truth-fudging resolution) but remains -- in its general outline -- mostly accurate. As for the violence, of which there is much, it is graphic in its realism, but arguably it is there for a purpose and clearly illustrates the obscenity of war, as in a shot during the siege sequence offering a bird's-eye view of the carnage. The tableau resembles a kingdom of hell. Another chink in the narrative's armor is that many of the characters are one-dimensional and much of the human drama is drowned out by the DeMille-style spectacle, which though visually stunning plays to diminishing returns. Scott (who also directed "Gladiator") and screenwriter William Monahan manage to work in some thoughtful exchanges about following one's conscience and the primacy of right action in defining true holiness, but the message-heavy script's overall treatment of both Islam and Christianity is superficial. Though the portrayal of both Christians and Muslims shows that neither side had a monopoly on vice, the scales of virtue are slightly tipped in favor of the Muslims (with the exception of one overzealous mullah). And while it is true that both cross and crescent were used to justify all sorts of hateful atrocities, here it is the Christians who come across as the primary aggressors. Whereas Saladin is shown reverently picking up a fallen cross, priests send Christians off to war with the un-Christian assurance that "killing an infidel is not murder. It is the path to heaven." While such toxic chauvinism no doubt existed and sowed the seeds of slaughter, the film subscribes to the skewed view that the Crusades were fueled purely by fanaticism and greed, and fails to convey that -- initially -- they were, rightly or wrongly, in the words of medieval scholar Thomas F. Madden "defensive wars ... an attempt to turn back or defend against Muslim conquests of Christian lands." This is not to deny that Christians' actions often fell grievously short of Gospel ideals. But it is distressing when, in the movie, the Christian camp is comprised of mostly caricaturized clerics -- of the arrogant or cowardly variety -- and war-mongering brutes drunk with ambition, bloodlust and religious fervor. And the few "enlightened" Christian characters -- including Balian, the peace-loving Baldwin and Tiberias -- seem less motivated by firm faith, than by a vague humanism. Even Thewlis' sympathetic knight admits, "I put no stock in religion." Though at times presenting an unflattering picture of religion, "Kingdom of Heaven" mainly takes issue with using it for divisive ends. So too, Balian's threat to raze both traditions' holy sites and burn down "every last thing that drives men mad" suggests that, while private spirituality is of value, organized religion often does more harm than good. Still, with its themes of peaceful coexistence, ecumenical kinship, the value of human life, and using one's heart and head to make the world a better place, as well as its strong condemnation of violence, ideological enmity and war, "Kingdom of Heaven" ultimately imparts a timely message for a world still sadly divided by religious conflicts. The film contains recurring intense battlefield violence and associated gore, including decapitations, hacked limbs and flaming bodies, as well as a brief adulterous sexual encounter. The USCCB Office for Film & Broadcasting classification is L -- limited adult audience, films whose problematic content many adults would find troubling. The Motion Picture Association of America rating is R -- restricted. - - - DiCerto is on the staff of the Office for Film & Broadcasting of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops. [/quote]
daugher-of-Mary Posted May 6, 2005 Posted May 6, 2005 The title of this thread made me laugh yeah, no sleep in such a long time...
Paladin D Posted May 7, 2005 Author Posted May 7, 2005 Wow, why did the USCCB give it a good rating? [url="http://www.usccb.org/movies/k/kingdomofheaven.htm"]http://www.usccb.org/movies/k/kingdomofheaven.htm[/url]
VeraMaria Posted May 7, 2005 Posted May 7, 2005 I saw it today...waste of time... It's just [i]bad[/i] plot-wise (and this is the girl who LOVES historical movies, any type) and 2 hours and 25 minutes of "let's make a historically accurate movie of medieval methods of bloodshed and piece together a plot to go with it"...
Guest Eremite Posted May 7, 2005 Posted May 7, 2005 [quote]as well as a brief adulterous sexual encounter[/quote] Why do these types of movies always have to include a romantic angle? Do they do this just to throw a bone to the female audience? Please, spare us the smarmy marmy love plot. Lord of the Rings is an excellent example of this. I don't care about that guy and that girl. I want to see orcs falling into lava, not a king and his damsel play out their drama.
ardillacid Posted May 7, 2005 Posted May 7, 2005 what are you talkin about? There is hardly any romance in LOTR. I thought it a nice hard core action killing show. (but the books are still way way way way better)
luciana Posted May 8, 2005 Posted May 8, 2005 [quote name='Eremite' date='May 7 2005, 12:42 AM'] Why do these types of movies always have to include a romantic angle? Do they do this just to throw a bone to the female audience? Please, spare us the smarmy marmy love plot. Lord of the Rings is an excellent example of this. I don't care about that guy and that girl. I want to see orcs falling into lava, not a king and his damsel play out their drama. [/quote] ardillacid said:[quote] what are you talkin about? There is hardly any romance in LOTR.[/quote] And the romance IS part of the work; the scenes w/ Aragorn and Arwen are from the appendicies, and some like the wedding is in the rrilogogy storyline itself. BTW, I probably won't see it, cause of the anti-religion, anti- Catholic themes. if my siblings or non- Catholic cousins/ friends want to see it, then i'll go, but just to point out the biases of the movie.
ironman Posted May 8, 2005 Posted May 8, 2005 I saw it last night.......everyone who wants to see it, see it......but it is truly lousy and total Hollywood.............
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now