Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

Hey guys I'm new to this forum but i just felt like asking your opinions...what do you think about contemporary music in the Mass? or traditional hymns? or gregorian chant? Which is your favorite to hear in Mass...yeah i know Mass is about Eucharist and the Word, but I just wanted to know your opinions on this. Personally, I LOVE Gregorian chant (especially at monastery churches where the sound reverberates...it sounds almost angelic...) and i prefer traditional hymns in Mass...I used to hate singing altogether but now I love it. Oh yeah and my youth group has a youth Mass every month and they play contemporary Mass music at this...I find it refreshing but it gets old very quickly...One more question...sry to ramble...what do you think about the charismatic movement (lots of praise and worshippy kinda stuff). I need to be honest and say I'm not a huge fan... <_<

Edited by Bfulk
Guest Eremite
Posted

The Church distinguishes between sacred and profane (ie, secular) music. Secular music, as an artform, has no place in mass, because it is not suited to the Sacred Liturgy.

Now, this does not mean the music is bad OUTSIDE of Mass. I like to compare it to Catholic literature. We don't (and shouldn't) read GK Chesterton during Mass. We read the Bible. Does that mean there's something wrong with Chesterton? Of course not. His writings just do not belong in the Sacred Liturgy; they belong outside of it.

Posted

i agree totally and i understand that but my main question was basically do you prefer contemporary hymns or classic ones. example: "Salt and Light" or "Days of Elijah" (if u guys have heard these) is a more contemporary hymn whereas "What Wondrous Love is This" or "Were you There" would be more traditional type hymns.

Posted

traditional. :)

"Were you There"---I like that one. "at the Cross, her Station Keeping" is my favorite for Lent.

SevenSorrows
Posted

I think part of the problem with "contemporary" music in mass is this:

1. It is not even "contemporary". doesn't that word mean "up to date"...but somehow "contemporary" music in the catholic church means playing 5-20 year old protestant praise songs.

2. Maybe part of the problem is not that the music is "too rockin" but that it is cheesy protestant music. Think of the chants or latin music....TOTALLY catholic. now think of the last "praise" song you heard in mass. The last one I can think of..was last sunday....instead of singing "lamb of God"....we sang these words "hear our prayer, hear our prayer, in this BREAD and WINE we share, hear our prayer hear our prayer, something something everywhere" bread and wine??? yeah it WAS..but not anymore....

So it becomes a problem when you get music "ministers" up there that can't make up music/lyrics...so they go to their local protestant store to find out "what is cool" (Not like it is their job to make up stuff....but still).

And their aren't many catholic writers out their making up songs for mass....so even with the songs that are in breaking bread...they are usually hippie songs from the 70's.....

I am in NO WAY promoting rock music or anything even close to that in mass. I was just pointing out some problems with "contemporary" music in mass and maybe why they are problems.

Guest Eremite
Posted

In the hallowed annals of Tantum Ergo and Dies Irae comes this diddy from David Haas:

[quote]Come all you single ones, divorced and married:
Come you who have lost your spouse, all who are lonely.
With Christ our brother, we are loved and made whole!

Refrain: All is ready. Here and now. All are welcome here.

Come all you young and old, all male and female.
Come, now, all gay and straight, it does not matter.
With Christ, all people are one in God's whole!

Refrain: All is ready. Here and now. All are welcome here.[/quote]

Noel's angel
Posted

*shakes head*

Posted

[quote name='Eremite' date='May 11 2005, 04:01 PM'] In the hallowed annals of Tantum Ergo and Dies Irae comes this diddy from David Haas:

[/quote]
Is that for real, or a satire?

Guest Eremite
Posted

Sadly, it's for real.

They actually used it for the LA Religious Ed Conference. Here's the program:


Go to pages 44 and 45.

Posted

Traditional. I go to a Latin mass. I love Cantate Domino. I even sing and pray the latin. I love it. The Nicene Creed is pretty hard to say in latin but I try my hardest.

Posted

im honestly askin, are gay people not allowed to go to mass?

Guest Eremite
Posted

Osama Bin Laden is welcome to come to mass, so long as he doesn't blow anyone up while he's there.

The Holy Eucharist, however, is limited to Catholics in the state of grace.

DemonSlayer
Posted (edited)

That song can definitely give the wrong impression, some may see it as saying that Mass is for no matter what if they agree with Church teachings or not, anyway it's irreverant since it's not directed at Christ, it's not really a worship song at all, and you just cannot expect anybody to take the song seriously.

And what is up with using "You Raise me up" within the closing Mass?

Edited by DemonSlayer
Posted

yeah i live in a smaller city in Indiana (near Notre Dame) and i heard one of our parishes has a Trinitine Mass (Latin, pre-vatican 2). I've never been but i love Latin and i want to go real bad. I think Latin is the most beautiful language (Italian is awesome too). So yeah if you guys want my opinion, I love everything traditional.

Posted (edited)

sry i double posted and i dont know how to delete so i had to post this useless post :o

Edited by Bfulk
melporcristo
Posted

I love the traditional mass but yet I love LIFE TEEN mass & I am great with both. Some traditional masses can be a little extreme to the right (like my friend was scolded for wearing a sweater that had quarter sleeves) to the LT masses that have abuses, like allowing the teens on the altar, etc. I just try to remember why we are there at the Mass and that is for Christ and to recieve Him.

SevenSorrows
Posted

[quote name='Bfulk' date='May 12 2005, 07:08 PM'] yeah i live in a smaller city in Indiana (near Notre Dame) and i heard one of our parishes has a Trinitine Mass (Latin, pre-vatican 2). I've never been but i love Latin and i want to go real bad. I think Latin is the most beautiful language (Italian is awesome too). So yeah if you guys want my opinion, I love everything traditional. [/quote]
True, but just remember latin is not "traditional". Well it is traditional for the last few hundred years. But it obviously always hasn't been latin. Considering Christ didn't speak latin. It is a beautiful language, but the mass is about understanding Christ and getting closer to him. Back in the day, people knew latin, they learned it in school, and at church. but for us to go to a latin mass now, would be like Christ having the last supper in french, it would have sounded good, but his apostles wouldn't have gotten much out of the words.

oh..and about your tridentine church...make sure it is allowed to have that mass, because it HAS to be ok'd by your bishop.

Guest FiddlingFingers
Posted

Traditional Gregorian Chant ALL the way. It belongs to the Mass like....like...a keyboard belongs to a computer.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...