Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

return2truth
Posted

Have there been confirmed Marian or Jesus apparitions before any adherents of another Christian denomination outside of Catholicism? Are there any Incorruptables outside of the Catholic faith. If not, would this be sign that that God does in fact favor the Catholic Church?

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Never heard of any,

thessalonian
Posted

[quote name='return2truth' date='May 10 2005, 09:51 AM'] Have there been confirmed Marian or Jesus apparitions before any adherents of another Christian denomination outside of Catholicism? Are there any Incorruptables outside of the Catholic faith. If not, would this be sign that that God does in fact favor the Catholic Church? [/quote]
There have been some apparitions within the Orthodox community I believe. There are no incorruptables from other denominations that I know of. In my understanding that requires a very high level of sanctity which I do not believe would be possible without the Eucharist and other sacraments.

Posted

I've heard of story where there was a unexplained Marian image in a Presbyterian church. I don't recall the details except that the pastors were a bit rattled. A Presbyterian pastor told me the story.

Of course when you throw the word confirmed in, you have a whole different ball of wax now don't you?

return2truth
Posted

[quote name='hot stuff' date='May 10 2005, 10:50 AM']
Of course when you throw the word confirmed in, you have a whole different ball of wax now don't you? [/quote]
Of course. But I think you all get my meaning. I don't mean the random person who might have only had an halucination.

Posted

[quote name='return2truth' date='May 10 2005, 10:51 AM'] Have there been confirmed Marian or Jesus apparitions before any adherents of another Christian denomination outside of Catholicism? Are there any Incorruptables outside of the Catholic faith. If not, would this be sign that that God does in fact favor the Catholic Church? [/quote]
I don't know if this really counts towards what you're asking....but here are some pictures of the Blessed Mother above a Coptic Church in Egypt. Muslims saw it, too and there are detailed reports about this apparation.

[url="http://www.maxkol.org/gallery/g347.htm"]Mary1[/url]

[url="http://www.maxkol.org/gallery/g348.htm"]Mary2[/url]

franciscan13
Posted

there is a russian orthodox monestary near me that has a weeping icon of Our Blessed Mother

savedbygrace
Posted

Any from Mary wouldn't occur. Mary is mention 1 time in every typical service in my church during the creed and that's it.

Fidei Defensor
Posted

[quote name='savedbygrace' date='May 10 2005, 06:26 PM'] Any from Mary wouldn't occur. Mary is mention 1 time in every typical service in my church during the creed and that's it. [/quote]
I wouldnt be so sure about that.

Ever heard of Fatima or Lourdes?

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted (edited)

their are Coptic Catholics that are in communion with Rome. and coptic orthodox.

God does not favor the Catholic church. It is his one true holy Catholic and apastolic church. Their is none other, and God does not look on any others as his own.

P.s My Greek orthodox buddy has seen the body of an incruptibile Greek orthodox saint. But it might have been a saint from before the schism.

Edited by Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
MissScripture
Posted

I have a question to add, what do the Protestants think of our Marian apparitions? I mean, do they think they actually happen?

Posted

Protestant denominations really don't think about Mary at all except for a 'brief' appearance at Christmas! One of the biggest shifts in thinking when a protestant converts is the role of Mary so Marian apparations are often viewed with great suspicion.

Posted

[quote name='MissScripture' date='May 11 2005, 08:36 PM'] I have a question to add, what do the Protestants think of our Marian apparitions? I mean, do they think they actually happen? [/quote]
Many believe that it's the devil posing as Mary and leading Catholics astray.

Posted

how can they think that?

return2truth
Posted

[quote name='jezic' date='May 11 2005, 11:21 PM'] how can they think that? [/quote]
Well, I guess their logic would be: Catholics are wrong, Mary wouldn't possibly appear before the unfaithful, therefore, the apparitions must be a lie, optical illusion, hallucination or a real phenomena from a deceptive force: Satan.

Gal. 5:22,23
Posted

[quote name='return2truth' date='May 10 2005, 09:51 AM'] Have there been confirmed Marian or Jesus apparitions before any adherents of another Christian denomination outside of Catholicism? [/quote]
If you mean confirmed by the Catholic Church, I would highly doubt it. But many people claim to have had an encounter with Christ. I always look for the fruit in people who make those claims.

For example, back in the 60's, a man had an encounter with Christ and experienced a miraculous healing. Afterward, he dedicated his life to building a museum and garden in honor of the Lord. It is located in Gatlinburg, TN, and we recently took our family there.

You can read about it here:http://www.christusgardens.com/

Posted

[quote name='return2truth' date='May 12 2005, 08:05 AM'] Well, I guess their logic would be: Catholics are wrong, Mary wouldn't possibly appear before the unfaithful, therefore, the apparitions must be a lie, optical illusion, hallucination or a real phenomena from a deceptive force: Satan. [/quote]
Yeah, exactly. They think we're not Christians and that we actually worship Mary as a god. They think she was just a tool used by God and has no place in salvation history whatsoever. Any visions of her are considered either something made up by the person or the devil showing himself to the person in the form of Mary. They don't believe God allows the saints and Mary to hear our prayers and consider the fact that we pray to the saints and Mary as proof that we're not Christians. And because they don't believe that He allows that, they don't believe He would ever in a million years let Mary show herself to anyone as a "representative" of Him(sorry, can't think of a better word right now).

It's true what people say though.....our veneration of Mary is one of the hardest things for a Protestant to overcome before they can convert. They basically outright reject anything having to do with Mary other than she carried the child Jesus in her womb for 9 months. After that, she doesn't matter to them.

Posted

They often quote the Bible verse where it says that even satan can appear as a being of light. The Blessed Mother however is not some ambiguous being of light but the Mother of God and I highly doubt that Jesus would allow His most beloved Mother to be impersonated and used by the devil to lead people astray.

Posted

[quote name='LSW' date='May 12 2005, 07:22 PM'] They often quote the Bible verse where it says that even satan can appear as a being of light. The Blessed Mother however is not some ambiguous being of light but the Mother of God and I highly doubt that Jesus would allow His most beloved Mother to be impersonated and used by the devil to lead people astray. [/quote]
good point :)

return2truth
Posted

[quote name='SarahB' date='May 12 2005, 01:22 PM']

It's true what people say though.....our veneration of Mary is one of the hardest things for a Protestant to overcome before they can convert. They basically outright reject anything having to do with Mary other than she carried the child Jesus in her womb for 9 months. After that, she doesn't matter to them. [/quote]
I couldn't imagine a form of Chrisitanity that didn't revere and honor those who helped to pave the way to a better understanding and mastery of Our Lord's mysteries.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...