Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Can our natures change? I would say no, because it would be our very being as humans which cannot ever change.. but my Baptist friend cited some Bible verse as proof that we can-- "our old natures are gone away and we have new natures," or something like that. He would also argue that because we used to sin (that being our old nature) and now God sees Jesus and it doesn't matter if we sin (our new nature), they somehow changed. This obviously doesn't make logical sense for a number of reasons, but I don't know how to explain it to him from a Catholic standpoint.

Am I correct, and if so, how would I prove my point using this verse and any others out there? Or is he right?

Please help me and thanks in advance!

phatcatholic
Posted

well, when we speak of "human nature" we think of those aspects of our makeup that make us human, that separate us from other living things. our unique inclinations also come to mind (for example, its part of our human nature to search for a higher being). maybe "essence" could be substituted for "nature", if that helps. anyway, God's grace perfects our human nature, allows us to transcend those parts of our nature (passions, concupiscience, original sin and ultimately death) that exist as a result of "The Fall" of Adam and that work to prevent us from achieving yet again the glorified "nature" that was ours before the Fall. so, you could say that grace makes us a "new creature" but we are still human. our nature isn't changed into another nature, it is just effected by grace, it is made more like it was intended to be.

does that help? i was basically just thinking out loud there and i acknowledge that my wording could possibly be more precise. paphnutius may be of help here.....

phatcatholic
Posted

[url="http://phorum.phatmass.com/index.php?showtopic=15222"][b]this thread[/b][/url] is a wealth of information on the topic, and has all the scripture, as well as ECFs and Church documents that you could ever ask for. this question is basically one that concerns "theosis", the partaking by man of the divine nature while still retaining his humanity. grace accomplishes this end in our lives, an end that is ultimately fulfilled in heaven, when we see God "face to face". this differs from mormonism, in which our human nature is exchanged for a divine one. we do not become "gods". instead, we become "like God."

here are some excertps from apotheoun's many posts on the subject:

[quote]Any texts from Sacred Scripture, the Church Fathers, or the Catechism of the Catholic Church, which speak about a man's communion or union with God; of his reception of the gift of divine filiation, i.e., of his becoming a son of God in the only begotten Son of God; of the restoration of the divine likeness lost through sin; of a man's being configured to the image of the Son; of a man's becoming a member of Christ, i.e., of his being incorporated into Christ's Body; of a man's participation in the divine nature or glory; of a man's becoming a temple of the Holy Spirit; of God taking up His abode with a man; of a man seeing God's face; of a man's abiding in Christ; or of a man becoming a "new creation" in Christ; all concern the doctrine of theosis, i.e., the doctrine of a man's deification by grace.[/quote]

[quote]This doctrine must not be thought of in a "Mormon" way, as if men become little gods with their own planets, but must be understood as a true deification of man and as an intimate communion of man with God in Christ. It must never be reduced to a mere metaphor, because by his incorporation into Christ, man is really made a partaker of the divine nature. [cf., 2nd Peter 1:4] This does not involve a change in man's essence, but entails an indwelling of God's Spirit within the human person, enlivening both body and soul to everlasting life. There is an analogy between the incarnation and deification, which is most clearly indicated in the prayer of the priest during the offertory at Mass when he mixes the water with the wine and says, "By the mystery of this water and wine, may we come to share in the divinity of Christ, who humbled Himself to share in our humanity." [The Sacramentary, (New York: Catholic Book Publishing Co., 1985), page 370.] [/quote]

[quote]Let me once again emphasize that theosis does not involve a type of transubstantiation of man's nature into the divine nature, because that would not bring about man's deification, but instead would involve his annihilation. Theosis involves a true divinization (theopoiesis) of man, in which the divine likenss (theoeideis) lost by sin is restored, but this process is neither pantheistic nor monistic, and so man is not going to be absorbed into the divine nature; instead, he participates in the uncreated divine eneriges (grace) which flow out from the divine essence. Ultimately, theosis concerns God's gift to man of a share in His own divine life and energy, it involves an elevation of man to a state of existence that exceeds his own natural capabilities, and so what Christ is by nature, man becomes by grace. The Catechism of the Catholic Church, quoting several ancient and medieval sources, says the following about theosis, "The Word became flesh to make us 'partakers of the divine nature.' 'For this is why the Word became man, and the Son of God became the Son of man: so that man, by entering into communion with the Word and thus receiving divine sonship, might become a son of God.' 'For the Son of God became man so that we might become God.' 'The only-begotten Son of God, wanting to make us sharers in His divinity, assumed our nature, so that He, made man, might make men gods.'" [Catechism of the Catholic Church, no. 460][/quote]

[quote]It follows from what has been said already, that divinized man is totally dependent upon God for this supernatural gift, and so even after the process of theosis is complete: God is All-powerful, man is not; God is All-knowing, man is not; God is Creator, man is created; God is Redeemer, man is redeemed; God is Sanctifier, man is sanctified; and God is Deifier, while man is deified. Man's divinization does not alter his human nature in itself, and so he remains fully human even after being deified; but he truly, and not merely in appearance, participates in the divine nature, that is, in the divine life and glory through the uncreated energies of God (i.e., grace). Man's mortal life is infused with God's immortal life, and he is vivified by God's Spirit unto eternal life. Clearly, this is something that man cannot naturally possess, but through the incarnation and the Paschal Mystery of our Lord Jesus Christ, this wondrous gift is bestowed by God upon man. This is the whole point of the incarnation, because as I mentioned before, "God became man, so that man might become God." [St. Augustine, Sermo 13 de Tempore, from The Office of Readings, page 125, (Boston: St. Paul Editions, 1983)] It is important to note that when St. Augustine said this, he was not saying anything new, because St. Athanasius, the Cappadocians, St. Irenaeus, and many other Church Fathers had already said the same thing.[/quote]

[quote]The Fathers of the Church are insistent that deified man's participation in the divine nature does not mean that he participates in either the divine essence (ousia), which is and remains wholly incommunicable and incomprehensible, nor in the personal (hypostatic) reality of any one of the three divine persons, because personality is not something that can be communicated or imparted from one being to another. The divine essence, and the personal (hypostatic) reality of the three divine persons, are utterly transcendent and incommunicable properties of God. So man is not absorbed by an essential participation in the divine nature, nor are human persons added to the Trinity; instead, through the process of deification (theosis) man participates in the uncreated divine energies (energia) which flow out from the divine essence as a gift to man from the three divine persons. In other words, by a completely unmerited gift of grace, man is elevated to a participation in the divine nature through the uncreated divine energies (energia), and this involves no essential change, nor personal (hypostatic) addition, to either God or man; instead, it entails an abiding communion (koinonia) of life and love between the Trinity and humanity. [/quote]

the articles that are linked to in the thread i provided are helpful as well. all this would appear to answer your question, but if you have further questions (this can be somewhat difficult to understand), just let me know.

pax christi,
phatcatholic

phatcatholic
Posted

[url="http://phorum.phatmass.com/index.php?showtopic=17619"][b]here[/b][/url] is another thread that should be of help to you as well.

phatcatholic
Posted

i just read [url="http://www.seattlecatholic.com/article_20020807_Mystical_vs_Eucharistic_Body.html"][b]this article[/b][/url], which provides a very helpful analogy:

[i]"When a human person is in the state of grace, he merely 'participates' in that which flows from God, as from its source. The sun is the source of light which illuminates the earth, but the earth does not become the sun by participation in its light; in the same way, God is the source of Grace which 'illuminates' man, but man does not become God by his participation in Divine grace."[/i]

thus, man maintains his human nature even while participating in the divine.

phatcatholic
Posted

here is another helpful analogy, from the same article:

"If two light bulbs are being illuminated by the power generated by one battery, they share the same power source; the power is not derived from a union between the two light bulbs, but rather by the light bulbs union with the Battery. Both light bulbs participate in the power generated by the battery, but they do not, therefore, become the battery. In the same way, we merely participate in the grace that flows from God as from its source, and just as the light bulb can be cut off from the power of the battery, we too can be cut off from grace."

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='McKenzie' date='May 12 2005, 01:59 AM'] Can our natures change? I would say no, because it would be our very being as humans which cannot ever change.. but my Baptist friend cited some Bible verse as proof that we can-- "our old natures are gone away and we have new natures," or something like that. He would also argue that because we used to sin (that being our old nature) and now God sees Jesus and it doesn't matter if we sin (our new nature), they somehow changed. This obviously doesn't make logical sense for a number of reasons, but I don't know how to explain it to him from a Catholic standpoint.

Am I correct, and if so, how would I prove my point using this verse and any others out there? Or is he right?

Please help me and thanks in advance! [/quote]
Our nature is human, so if it changed what would it be?
Is he asking if our characters can change?

The answer to the second one would be yes. The lives of the Saints is ample proof of that.

Posted

Below are a couple links to papers that I've written while at FUS on the topic of grace (energia) and deification (theosis). The first is a paper on the nature of grace itself (from an Eastern Catholic perspective), while the second is a review of a book (a dissertation) written by Fr. M. Edmund Hussey:

[url="http://www.geocities.com/apotheoun/paper07b"][u]Grace as God's Uncreated Energy[/u][/url]

and

[url="http://www.geocities.com/apotheoun/paper05b"][u]Book Review: The Doctrine of the Trinity in the Theology of Gregory Palamas[/u][/url]

It is important to remember that man's deification is not a mere metaphor, and that man is really divinized through his participation in God's uncreated energies. But this process of divinization does not involve an essential change in man's nature; rather, it involves an ontological participation in God's uncreated life and glory, i.e., in God's own being outside of His essence. God and man, even after man's deification by grace, remain hetero-essential (heteroousios), while they are simultaneously united in their personal (enhypostatic) energies.

phatcatholic
Posted

apotheoun...........i added links to ur papers to the "tracts by phatmassers" thread

Posted

[quote name='phatcatholic' date='May 12 2005, 02:43 PM'] apotheoun...........i added links to ur papers to the "tracts by phatmassers" thread [/quote]
Thanks. My humble little website rarely gets any hits, so I do appreciate your posting my links.

:D

Posted

Hey, nice website!

I have an icon just like that sitting next to my monitor. :)

Now I wish I had the brain cells present to actually read anything above a grade school level. Maybe someday my mind will return to me...

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='phatcatholic' date='May 12 2005, 06:43 PM'] apotheoun...........i added links to ur papers to the "tracts by phatmassers" thread [/quote]
phat do we have a section for all the websites done by phatmassers?

phatcatholic
Posted

tracts? yes
websites? no

cmotherofpirl
Posted
:idea: :)

We have a lot of Pmers with excellent sites :D

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...