Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I have a traditionalist acquaintance who claims that Pope John Paul II changed the Church teaching on the husband being head of the family by encouraging mutual submission, and he claims that the pope was a modernist because of that. Here's an e-mail I received from him. How would you respond to his claims? By the way, the opening quote is from an article in "The Wanderer" that I'd provided for him earlier.


The Holy Father in no way denies that in the order of authority the
wife
is only subject to the husband, because he is not concerning himself
with
the order of authority in this document.>>

Well once again the "neo-conservatives" have done it. You guys supply
us
with all the ammunition we need.

The quote that I just pulled from below, summarizes nicely the
pontificate
of John Paul 2 and all other post-Vatican 2 Popes (up to this point).
You
see, some will say that the Holy Father (John Paul 2) has never
"denied"
pre-Conciliar teachings, but then again, dead-silence on an issue
sometimes
speaks louder than words. The very fact that the Holy Father (John
Paul 2)
in this encylical completely sides-stepped the issue is to me a
indication
of a Modernist (worldly point-of-view) Pope. This has always bothered
me
about His Holiness. I've also read his encyclical "The Role of the
Christian Marriage in the Modern World". In fact, I've read it a few
times
and again, no where is this issue (of authority, just simple authority.
Not
the virtue of charity. That goes without saying. We must do all
things in
charity. OK??? That's beside the point. The fact is Pope John Paul 2
completely (yet again) side-stepped the issue. In my opinion, because
he
was afraid. Maybe he felt that the world wasn't ready for him to
repeat the
constant traditional Teaching of the Church. But to that I say, that is
(was) his job. For me, I would rather have a Pope that is
despised/hated by
the world, as opposed to someone who is (was) beloved by it. To me, it
sends a subltle message. The Church has been bending over backwards
since
Vatican 2 to show how "new and worldly-friendly" She is (as opposed to
the
terrible, mean-spirited-homophobic-all male-dominated Church). And
quite
frankly, I'm sick of seeing the Church trying to curry favor with one
of Her
supernatural enemies (the world itself). That is a clear distinction
(also)
between traditionalists and other Catholics. Most Catholics today look
at
(and view) the world as a "friend" whereas we realize that we must live
in
the world, but that the world is not our friend because it was never
Christ's.

And lastly, I am fed up with traditionalist's being labled "out-of
touch,
schismatics, heretics, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, etc. etc.) WE ARE
NOT
AND NEITHER IS THE SSPX!!!! NO ONE, NOT JOHN PAUL 2, NO ANY OTHER
CHURCH
OFFICE HAS FORMALLY DECLARED THE SSPX SOCIETY TO BE IN SCHISM!!! GET
YOUR
FACTS STRAIGHT!! I do not mind arguing/debating issues. But I don't
throw
around ad-hominum attacks and neither should you. I will debate the
issue(s), not the person.

Pax Domini sit semper vobiscum,

Stephen

Cure of Ars
Posted

[quote]The Holy Father in no way denies that in the order of authority the
wife is only subject to the husband, because he is not concerning himself
with the order of authority in this document.>>

Well once again the "neo-conservatives" have done it. You guys supply
us with all the ammunition we need.[/quote]

Why do you need ammunition? Why so hostile? Are we not both Catholic’s? It is not healthy to slit up the Church into different groups. “Is Christ divided?” (1 Cor 1:13)

[quote]see, some will say that the Holy Father (John Paul 2) has never
"denied" pre-Conciliar teachings, but then again, dead-silence on an issue
sometimes speaks louder than words.[/quote]

The job of Pope is a hard calling. You are free to disagree on how he chooses to address some issues. But really this is not a doctrinal issue. The truth is that the Church’s enemies will twist what he says, so he has to be careful about what he says. If he says something that can be easily twisted it could lead to alienating more people from Christ and his Church. And the virtue of Charity does not “go without saying”. Radical feminist try to caricature husband leadership as oppression without love. The whole issue needs to be seen in the light of Christ’s Charity and those not from a Christian viewpoint can not understand it. The can not understand what Jesus means by leading. They only understand power. But for Christ to lead is to serve.

[quote]But Jesus summoned them and said, "You know that the rulers of the Gentiles lord it over them, and the great ones make their authority over them felt.  But it shall not be so among you. Rather, whoever wishes to be great among you shall be your servant; whoever wishes to be first among you shall be your slave. Just so, the Son of Man did not come to be served but to serve and to give his life as a ransom for many."(Matt 20:25-27) [/quote]

Husbands are called to “love your wives, even as Christ loved the church and handed himself over for her” (Eph 5:25) So if the Pope said that Husbands are the head of her wife like Christ is to the Church. They will not understand what this means. To them, all they will hear is oppression. So for those who come from a secular world view will first need to understand Christ and his charity and how he is the head of the Church. As the head Christ was not served but served. He submitted to the Church out of love. He submitted to death on the cross. Now you might still not agree how the Pope taught about the family. But he had good reason for doing what he did. One thing is for sure, John Paul II is not a coward and he is not a modernist.


You could also use this.



[quote]"Let the husband render to his wife the affection due her, and likewise also the wife to her husband. The wife does not have authority over her own body, but the husband does. And likewise the husband does not have authority over his own body, but the wife does. Do not deprive one another except with consent for a time, that you may give yourselves to fasting and prayer; and come together again so that Satan does not tempt you because of your lack of self-control" (1 Cor. 7:3-5).[/quote]

I have to go. I have not read over my work because my wife is calling me. But this would be how I respond.

phatcatholic
Posted

[quote name='Dave' date='May 23 2005, 01:09 AM'] Well once again the "neo-conservatives" have done it. You guys supply us with all the ammunition we need. [/quote]
i think the one thing that bothers me the most about ultratraditionalists is their arrogance!! but anyway.....

[quote]The quote that I just pulled from below, summarizes nicely the pontificate of John Paul 2 and all other post-Vatican 2 Popes (up to this point). You see, some will say that the Holy Father (John Paul 2) has never "denied" pre-Conciliar teachings, but then again, dead-silence on an issue sometimes speaks louder than words.[/quote]
this is poor logic. silence can neither be seen as an affirmation or a rejection of a point.

[quote]The very fact that the Holy Father (John Paul 2) in this encylical completely sides-stepped the issue is to me a indication of a Modernist (worldly point-of-view) Pope. This has always bothered me about His Holiness.[/quote]
for one, can we even say that JPII is silent on this issue? i havne't read every encyclical and address JPII has given on this topic. has your opponent? also, he seems to be reading into the pope's supposed "silence" what he wants to believe about the pope, when in all actuality such a silence would not support either of us.

[quote] I've also read his encyclical "The Role of the Christian Marriage in the Modern World". In fact, I've read it a few times and again, no where is this issue (of authority, just simple authority. Not the virtue of charity. That goes without saying. We must do all things in charity. OK??? That's beside the point. [/quote]
just b/c he does not address the authority of man in this document, that does not mean that he doesn't believe in the authority of man, nor does it mean that JPII has not addressed this in other documents

[quote]The fact is Pope John Paul 2 completely (yet again) side-stepped the issue. In my opinion, because he was afraid. Maybe he felt that the world wasn't ready for him to repeat the constant traditional Teaching of the Church. But to that I say, that is (was) his job. For me, I would rather have a Pope that is despised/hated by the world, as opposed to someone who is (was) beloved by it. To me, it sends a subltle message.[/quote]
JPII is afraid to confront the world?!?! i only have to provide one little piece of proof to totally destroy that idea:

--[url="http://www.catholicculture.org/docs/doc_view.cfm?recnum=4237"][b]exhibit A[/b][/url]

[quote] The Church has been bending over backwards since Vatican 2 to show how "new and worldly-friendly" She is (as opposed to the terrible, mean-spirited-homophobic-all male-dominated Church). And quite frankly, I'm sick of seeing the Church trying to curry favor with one of Her supernatural enemies (the world itself). That is a clear distinction (also) between traditionalists and other Catholics. Most Catholics today look at (and view) the world as a "friend" whereas we realize that we must live in the world, but that the world is not our friend because it was never Christ's.[/quote]
best to stick w/ what one can prove. he would be hard-pressed i think to ever substantiate this claim, especially if he is basing it on JPII's supposed silence on only one issue.

[quote]And lastly, I am fed up with traditionalist's being labled "out-of touch, schismatics, heretics, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, etc. etc.) WE ARE NOT AND NEITHER IS THE SSPX!!!! NO ONE, NOT JOHN PAUL 2, NO ANY OTHER CHURCH OFFICE HAS FORMALLY DECLARED THE SSPX SOCIETY TO BE IN SCHISM!!! GET YOUR FACTS STRAIGHT!! I do not mind arguing/debating issues. But I don't throw around ad-hominum attacks and neither should you. I will debate the
issue(s), not the person.[/quote]
we're yelling now? woh, deeeeep breaths. :blink: they are most certainly in schism, and its not a ad hominem attack to say so. but that's not the issue here, so i wouldn't even address it if i were you. your opponent's response is full of opinion and rather void of actual facts that prove his point. i would ask that he provide them.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...