Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

savedbygrace
Posted

So here's my thoughts. I think it is wrong, very wrong and it is something I could never do myself or advocate for someone else, but I believe that it is and should be legal. My moral beliefs are given to me by my faith and shouldn't be imposed on others by the government.

Did you know it is legal to have a labotomy done in this country? You can legally sign up to have a part of your brain removed. Why would anyone do that? Wouldn't they realize that they are removing an important part of their future that was put there for a reason? They would regret that decision for the rest of their lives, and yet the government allows it. The goverment recognizes that anyone stupid enough to remove a piece of their brain (in non health related reasons) deserves what they get. Surprisingly you don't hear of many people having this procedure done. I believe that an abortion should become as rare as a labotomy and that this can happen without government intervention.

Fidei Defensor
Posted

[quote name='savedbygrace' date='May 26 2005, 04:26 PM'] So here's my thoughts. I think it is wrong, very wrong and it is something I could never do myself or advocate for someone else, but I believe that it is and should be legal. My moral beliefs are given to me by my faith and shouldn't be imposed on others by the government.

Did you know it is legal to have a labotomy done in this country? You can legally sign up to have a part of your brain removed. Why would anyone do that? Wouldn't they realize that they are removing an important part of their future that was put there for a reason? They would regret that decision for the rest of their lives, and yet the government allows it. The goverment recognizes that anyone stupid enough to remove a piece of their brain (in non health related reasons) deserves what they get. Surprisingly you don't hear of many people having this procedure done. I believe that an abortion should become as rare as a labotomy and that this can happen without government intervention. [/quote]
Allowing something evil to happen is just as sinful as doing it yourself. If you have the power to stop it, you must do so. We have the power to stop abortions by electing pro-life officials. Abortion must stop.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

1. A labotomy only harms the person getting it directly. It also does not result in death. An abortion murders an innocent person who did not express any wish or desire to be murdered.

2. The fact that it might go away without government intervention does not mean that the government shouldn't intervene. Nazism probably would have died out over a few hundred years on its own...but the American force in WWII, a government intervention, saved millions of lives.

Posted

You are leaving out an important detail. A labotomy only involves the person making the decision. An abortion involves a completely seperate life (the child). Abortion should be illegal to protect the child's life--it has nothing to do with the mother.

It is a matter of morality to kill another person. If you think abortion should be legal, then you [b]must[/b] also support the legalization of all forms of murder. After all, it's a question of morality--and our morals shouldn't be imposed on the rest of society, correct?

savedbygrace
Posted

comparing abortion to the Nazis is a bit extreme! While I see you pont and agree on many levels, I mainly just don't think the government has the right to intervene on what a woman wants to do with her body.

Fidei Defensor
Posted

[quote name='savedbygrace' date='May 26 2005, 04:38 PM'] comparing abortion to the Nazis is a bit extreme! While I see you pont and agree on many levels, I mainly just don't think the government has the right to intervene on what a woman wants to do with her body. [/quote]
But a baby isnt "her body." And like i said, you cannot allow evil like that to occur when you can stop it. It is as bad as doing it yourself.

Noel's angel
Posted

it's not just her body though-its another person in there

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='savedbygrace' date='May 26 2005, 05:37 PM'] comparing abortion to the Nazis is a bit extreme! While I see you pont and agree on many levels, I mainly just don't think the government has the right to intervene on what a woman wants to do with her body. [/quote]
It's not extreme at all. If we hadn't stopped Nazism, it may have approached the number of murders abortion is responsible for.

I say this as a person of Jewish blood.

Abortion has nothing to do with a woman's body. That's a lie propogated by the abortion lobby. The fact is that convenience and "bodily preferences" are not nor can ever be excuses for murder. Even if pride were a legitimate reason (and I do believe that it is pride, not honest pursuit of beauty, that drives women to "cosmetic abortions"), it would still break the ethical rule of natural law: the ends do not justify the means.

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

Thats always a quite stupid philiosophy. I don't agree with murder but who am i to try and stop it? WOW.

If you do not stop something that is wrong then you are responsibile.

Nazisim has not killed nearly as many as abortion has.

ABortion is the murder of an innocent child who did not asked to be killed.

It is not the Woman's body that your killing its a baby.

Posted

Why would someone want an abortion if she can just give the baby away to an adoption agency? There is no point besides possibly gaining pounds and not suffering as much with child birth (I believe a woman still suffers in the abortion room doesnt she?)

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

By the way Christ didn't die for the Sins of the Wolrd so people could blantantly disrespect him by Killing His Children in the disgusting gruesome act of Abortion. I can't believe that anyone who personally thinks its wrong can't say that it IS wrong for it to be legal in the UNited States.

cmotherofpirl
Posted (edited)

[quote name='savedbygrace' date='May 26 2005, 06:26 PM'] So  here's my thoughts. I think it is wrong, very wrong and it is something I could never do myself or advocate for someone else, but I believe that it is and should be legal. My moral beliefs are given to me by my faith and shouldn't be imposed on others by the government.

[/quote]
My moral beliefs are share and share alike, so I decide you will share with me at the point of a gun. :ph34r:

Or

I beleive in abortion so I have the right to take anyone else's life that inconveniences me. So if you cut me off at a yield sign look out

and

since I have the right to take anyone else's life that inconveniences me, my teenagers are doomed. If I can kill them when there are inside kicking me, why can't I kill them now when they are truely annoying. THhe only difference is size and location.

Same logic. :sadder:

Government has the right and duty to protect ALL its citizens.

And anybody who thinks its ok to cut up a living human being is sick.

Edited by cmotherofpirl
savedbygrace
Posted

Basically I think it is disgusting gross and wrong but the government doesn't have the right to tell me that.

savedbygrace
Posted

Basically I think it is disgusting gross and wrong but the government doesn't have the right to tell me that.

Fidei Defensor
Posted

[quote name='savedbygrace' date='May 26 2005, 08:56 PM'] Basically I think it is disgusting gross and wrong but the government doesn't have the right to tell me that. [/quote]
... Is it just me or does that not make sense?

I understand what you mean, but in this case, there are no other options. Its wrong. Period.

This is not the same as if the government would say that smoking is wrong and it's illegal, because you can chose to do that to your body.

Abortion is wrong no matter what the government says, so why shouldnt they tell the truth and prevent it at all costs?

KizlarAgha
Posted

Here's a different way to think about this:

Why is it wrong to impose your religious beliefs on others but it's okay for them to impose their secular views on you? They like to think that their secular philosophy allows everyone the freedom to do as they please. That's completely and utterly fallacious. My religious viewpoint is no less valid, or well thought out, than some stupid liberal's secular views. America elects representatives for a reason - to represent the views of the populace. Not voting your views is the same thing as not being represented.

In addtion, there is the issue of what is a law? I mean, why is murder illegal? If you don't have the right to force a view on someone, then maybe murder isn't wrong? Yet, we have laws against murder. So clearly, SOMEONE has imposed their views on other people. Abortion and other moral issues are the same. Without a law against it, there will be people doing it, claiming it to be right. And that may be all well and good to moral relativists, but it doesn't work, and it's wrong.

Without making the categorical statements I could make, I'll say this - I think abortion is evil. That's more than enough justification for me to take legal measures to stop it.

Posted

So basically youre saying you dont think abortion is right, but you think the government should not make it illegal?

This doesnt make a whole lot of sense.

Murder is illegal. But abortion is? So was slavery! The government isnt the be all end all when it comes to issues concerning natural law, Ill grant that. But if murder is wrong, then abortion is wrong. It is the direct taking of another persons life. It may be a clump of cells, but they are a clump of human cells that are a developing human being.

Comparing abortion to Nazism? I cant think of a better comparison. The Nazis killed whoever wasnt useful in society, such as cripples and the elderly. Abortion kills a child who is not wanted, because they arent seen as useful.

You see my point?

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='savedbygrace' date='May 26 2005, 09:52 PM'] Basically I think it is disgusting gross and wrong but the government doesn't have the right to tell me that. [/quote]
If the government does not have the right to tell you what you can and can't do, then what does it have the right to do?

Why have government at all?

The fact of the matter is that government is intrinsically good and has every right to enforce what is moral. Abortion is not moral.

When you seriously believe that abortion is wrong, you will realize just how wrong, and then you will stop at nothing to make it illegal.

CreepyCrawler
Posted

the government can't tell someone what to do with their bodies, that's true. for example, if a woman wants to have sex, the govt. can't tell her not to, right? but abortion affects another human being. that is not the government telling her what to do with her body, it's the govt. telling her what to do with her child's body, that is, not kill it. and i believe the government has the right to tell people what to do with their children's bodies, or else infanticide, child pornography, and child molestation is okay, too.

Posted

Abortion is the taking of an innocent human life - murder.

Murder is against the law.

This is like arguing, "Yeah, I'm against murder -I think it's bad and all, but I don't think the government has any right telling us what we should do with our own bodies. If I choose to murder someone that should be my own decision."

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...