theculturewarrior Posted May 28, 2005 Posted May 28, 2005 Hi! Now that I've returned to my better senses, and since I have a little spare time, let me tell you about something I've been thinking about. Why did God put Mexico and the United States next to eachother? There is a saying in Mexico, that goes something like, "Ay, Mexico, so far from God, so close to the United States!" And I think that some people feel that way about Mexico here. Our country has caused so much harm to Mexico. Maybe that doesn't sound patriotic, but it's just a fact. We've had several military excursions into Mexico, and our country provoked a war with Mexico in order to fill out the American Southwest. I don't know many Americans who are nostaligic for the days of Manifest Destiny, but if you ask someone from Mexico about the War with the States, they'll tell you how children died fighting to protect the Mexican Flag. And if you do ask someone from Mexico about the War, be prepared to apologize on behalf of your forefathers, because memories run deeper in other countries. But we have so much to learn from eachother. I've learned so much from living on the border. For example, Spanish is an extremely polite language, and when someone speaks Spanish well, they know how to make you feel like a king. In fact, they kind of talk like that. You can go to a restaraunt in Mexico, and the waiter will treat the oldest man there with the utmost respect, and will serve everybody as though they are knights and ladies, if he is a good waiter and if he speaks Spanish well. It's kind of embarrassing, when somebody speaks Spanish really well, and you're trying to translate in your head, and everything you say comes out really ugly. In fact, Mexicans sometimes don't understand that Americans, though we are often rude, sometimes we are polite but informal and jocular, and I think that is more often the case. In Mexico, educacion means learning your manners, but in America it means acquiring knowledge in order to get ahead. I think that is a fundamental difference. And Americans have so much to learn from Mexican immigrants. In America, we have many people who are poor, who don't have "real" jobs, and their poverty is a source of despair for them. In fact, our families sometimes push us to get ahead, to get that first "real" job, by any means necessary, sometimes. But to a Mexican, there are no imaginary jobs. Whatever feeds his family is a real job, and they usually do everything with pride, whether it's mowing the grass, or being a physician. But Mexicans have a lot to learn from Americans too, and most of them know it, better than we do ourselves. We are a country that stands for personal liberty, and for rights for every man, woman, and child. I haven't been to Mexico in years, I stopped going sometime after the War in Iraq started, but when you drive back from Mexico, you can see the difference immediately, as soon as you cross the check point. The poor and the lame are in hospitals and in housing projects, they're not sitting in the street living off of human kindness. The street vendors and the panhandlers are nowhere to be seen. In America, we're not that desparate for money yet. But the thing that strikes the Mexican most, as he crosses the border, is the traffic. If you have ever visited the Mexican border, even on this side, the thing that strikes you the most is how crazy people drive. Everybody says they have the worst drivers in their hometown until they visit the Mexican border. But what strikes the Mexican is the order! They see people driving with respect for human life. And when I see somebody who nearly ran me over in the crosswalk, the Mexican sees somebody who slowed down to save my life. So, I guess in Mexico, there are waiters who might make better foreign dignitaries then some of our ambassadors, and some of them are more well spoken than the president himself. And in Mexico, more people understand the danger of killing in the womb, because they see what a disrespect for human life has done to their country everyday. And in America, we are doing so well, and our vision for the world has done so much good. But our memory is shorter here than in other countries, and our history of making wars of aggression leaves a bitter taste in the mouths of people with longer memories than our own. Our Lady of Guadalupe must have cried at the foot of the Cross for both of her wayward children.
Qoheleth Posted May 28, 2005 Posted May 28, 2005 I am always amazed to hear about what life is like in countries less unfortunate than America. Despite poverty, ignorance, and disease, it seems like people in the third world are much more pious than happier than Americans. How can the most comfortable nations on earth be the coarsest and most cynical? "Easier it is for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle..."
theculturewarrior Posted May 28, 2005 Author Posted May 28, 2005 I don't think poverty is a good thing. Poverty in spirit is the best thing and the wealth our country has makes that harder for us, but material poverty is the absence of several good things. If you get three meals a day and have a roof over your head, praise God. I know I am right now.
theculturewarrior Posted May 28, 2005 Author Posted May 28, 2005 Oh, one last thing, just to clarify, most of Mexico is too wealthy to be considered Third World. Most families have cars in Mexico, even if their not as nice or new as the cars we have, although Mexico also has a middle class and some immigrants come into America and you don't know where they came from after the second generation. Also, Monterrey is supposed to be a cutting edge metropolis that is as safe and vibrant as an American city.
Aloysius Posted May 28, 2005 Posted May 28, 2005 it's because Mexico tried to be a Catholic Country. if you look at it, after the reformation every country that tried to be specifically Catholic got screwed over by the protestant economic system (Capitalism) Mexico... Latin America... Ireland... I think Spain... I'm not sure about Italy... sad but true. but now they've all given up... Mexico is goin the way of capitalism with some socialist twists... Ireland is goin the way of Western European socialism... didn't the communist party just take over Spain? anyway, there is no denying that the protestant economic system of America (in combination with our military excursions and such, which were often motivated by the protestant economic system <i.e. California Gold>) screwed Mexico over big time.
theculturewarrior Posted May 28, 2005 Author Posted May 28, 2005 Actually, the Mexican government has a history of persecuting the Church, although the people there are mostly Catholic.
Aloysius Posted May 28, 2005 Posted May 28, 2005 I'm thinkin early early on.. they did try a Catholic country... power was changed like 5 times or something there though.. I'm not that familiar. but there was a bunch of different groups and a bunch of different revolutions or something or other... and I do believe part of their plight today is that they (as a people even if not as a government) wanted to make a Catholic economic system.
theculturewarrior Posted May 28, 2005 Author Posted May 28, 2005 One of my regrets is having never taken a class on the history of Mexico, but I think my professors would say that Mexico was corrupt probably from the beginning or even before their War for Independence from Spain. I think in Mexico, the economic system is one of guarding the interests of a corrupt power elite. I think that's the way it's always been. But again, I confess my ignorance of the subject.
Aloysius Posted May 28, 2005 Posted May 28, 2005 me too... I'm more familiar with how Ireland got screwed over. but I do know that Capitalism has been screwing over Catholic nations since it was born in the reformation.
theculturewarrior Posted May 28, 2005 Author Posted May 28, 2005 Oh, and just to clarify, they did incorporate some Catholic ideas into their constitution but they were taking a leap in declaring War against Spain and there was no Catholic economic system as yet. That question is still being developed.
theculturewarrior Posted May 28, 2005 Author Posted May 28, 2005 Oh, and just to clarify, they did incorporate some Catholic ideas into their constitution but they were taking a leap in declaring War against Spain and there was no Catholic economic system as yet. That question is still being developed.
Fidei Defensor Posted May 28, 2005 Posted May 28, 2005 [quote name='Aloysius' date='May 28 2005, 03:42 PM'] but I do know that Capitalism has been screwing over Catholic nations since it was born in the reformation. [/quote] Im curious, how exactly did it form, and how is it involved with protestants? You made me interested in this now
philothea Posted May 28, 2005 Posted May 28, 2005 Around Chicago all landscaping work is done by Mexican immigrants, and lately most of the construction work is too. The landscapers used to frighten me, because they'd whistle when I was walking. I realize now that this is nearly a cultural requirement, stating: "I see that you are an unescorted female." Whenever I'd wave or say hello they'd get all shy. The Mexicans who do the construction work are fabulous, they're so happy they sing while working! It's great. Huge improvement from the mopey guys I see elsewhere. I want to learn Spanish. I want to read St. John of the Cross at St. Teresa of Avila in the original.
Aloysius Posted May 28, 2005 Posted May 28, 2005 you gotta read Belloc, man!!!! Capitalism is the Reformation's child! Before then, the rules of Christendom governed economic practice. Money was focused on its natural end as understood by the Aristotle, the Fourth Lateran Council, and Aquinas. It was grounded in actual material production. Usury was forbidden. Then came Martin Luther, who still had reservations about usury. Then came John Calvin, who with some small reservations made mutliple allowances for usury. (usury used to be defined as interest rates on loans) With the advent of protestantism, specifically Calvinism, came more and more of an idea of the earthly ends of man. There was Amsterdam forming the first stock market... more and more economics was based on capital and theory, rather than production and reality. Those nations that held to the old moral code were dessimated, because all the other nations began to ammass greater and greater wealth making the wealth of the nations of Old Christendom less and less relatively.
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted May 28, 2005 Posted May 28, 2005 [quote]but I do know that Capitalism has been screwing over Catholic nations since it was born in the reformation. [/quote] what do prepose instead?
Aloysius Posted May 28, 2005 Posted May 28, 2005 distributism, the economic system of old christendom (to be developed to fit into the modern world of course) "The problem of capitalism is not too many capitalists, it is too few" -G.K. Chesterton Distributism is the only Godly alternative. Capitalism breeds societies with large gaps between the classes. Socialism abuses those gaps for class warfare and decides to deny private property to ALL because in Capitalism real private property is only ever found by few (real private property is something completely owned by a person, he needn't pay continual fees on it to a government or a usurious lender). Distributism seeks to promote private property for all so long as they will work for it and allow them to own their own means of production. A distributist society is one with tons of small businesses owned personally. More and more people not only own their own property, but own their own business through which they get their own property. Take the example of a pizza maker. In Capitalism the pizza maker works for Pizza Hutt. He goes to pizza hutt and uses pizza hutt's oven. In full Socialism the pizza maker works for 'the society'... the government usually... he goes to the government's pizza shop everyday and uses the government's pizza oven In Distributism the pizza maker works for himself. Everyday he makes pizza out of his pizza oven and sells it to people who want pizza.
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted May 28, 2005 Posted May 28, 2005 sound interesting... any countries use this system? is there a website about this?
Aloysius Posted May 28, 2005 Posted May 28, 2005 [url="http://www.distributism.com"]http://www.distributism.com[/url] some of the stuff there comes off to me as a little like.. using a socialist action to attempt to acheive a distributist society which I would oppose.. but all in all it's got a pretty good primer on the system. check out its Compare Them section Leo XIII's Rerum Novarum is a good read as well as Belloc's Restoration of Property
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted May 28, 2005 Posted May 28, 2005 question... you said there are many small bussinesses what if the bussiness grow and become large corporatiosn, don't big corporations service the needs of the people better then small bussiness?
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted May 28, 2005 Posted May 28, 2005 does the church offical support this distributism
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now