Dave Posted May 30, 2005 Posted May 30, 2005 Can anyone here help me out with how to respond to these specific arguments from a radical traditionalist Catholic? Rather than direct me to websites, I ask that you please interact with the specific arguments made. Thanks in advance. The first quote was something he said when I tried to defend John Paul II from this guy's "modernist" accusations. I cited the Holy Father's kissing the Koran and gatherings at Assisi, saying that one didn't have to think they were prudent things to do, but I explained how and why such things didn't make the Holy Father a Modernist. As for Assisi, I talked about how there were various saints who spread the Gospel via their example (hence his allusion to saints near the end that I'd earlier referred to) and how John Paul II tried to do so: [quote] And I still do stand on my position that John Paul 2 was a Modernist pope. Did Paul 6th, John 23rd, Pius 12th, Leo 13th or (for that matter) Pope St. Gregory the Great every invite other false religions to pray inside the Vatican!!!??? I think not!! I don't even think even St. Peter hismelf(as Pope) ever prayed at the "Wailing Wall" for peace?? The Pope is calling upon schsimatic, heretical, false religions for world peace?? If it's world peace he diesires, let him demand they all pray to Our Lady!! Let me back-track a little bit I what I just said. I don't believe it's neccessarily an evil thing to allow representatives into the Vatican. For they need conversion too (not "convergence" as the heretical Cardinal Kasper has been quoted as saying). What I feel His Holiness should have done is preach to them the Gospel of Christ!!! If he (the Pope) wants to pray with non-believers........let them pray to Mary!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Look read what Pope Leo said about ecumenism (and he's not the only one). No one is saying that ecumenism is bad. No it's good!! But just as traditional moral Catholic theology teaches, THE ENDS DO NOT JUSTIFY THE MEANS!! No, the Pope CAN'T kiss the Koran. No he can't pray in common in Assisi just so 'we can all get-along together'. What Pope John Paul did was truly inexcusable. Why? Because he is tacitly telling the entire world that what the Popes have taught about ecumemism (and the way in which prior Popes have gone about it)....well it's just all wrong!!! They (ALL PRIOR POPES).......well they really just didnt' know what they were doing. But we here in the 21st century. Well, we're "enlightened" now. So we DO know better. What bold-faced arrogance (not just for John Paul 2, but for any Pope). The Holy Father's main responsibility is to hand-down the Deposit of Faith that the Church has received from St. Peter himself, and NOT to make it into something his own. Again speaking of John Paul 2 as a Modernist Pope, did (even) John the 23rd ever have rock n' roll music at any of his Masses (not to mention of any Pre-Conciliar) popes. Or is it because only John Paul 2 really loved the youth that it doesn't really matter WHAT he (permitted)allowed......because welll.......HE CARES!!! AGAIN, NONSENSE!!!! In regards to the issue of "good-intentions"; as the saying goes; it's precisely that in which the road to hell is paved with (as the saying goes). I believe whole-heartedly that the Pope did try to reach out to the world and bring the Gospel to them. But we I (and many traditinalists) did not like, is the way in which John Paul 2 went about it. Again it's a basic tenant in moral theology (which also applies to the Pope himself). THE ENDS DO NOT JUSTIFY THE MEANS!!! In regards to ecumenism we must'nt think that these ides were ones that only John Paul 2 thought of. I believe many Popes tried to establsh relations with other religions, but all prior Popes held themselves to this constraint. With all the Saints you listed below I would be my life that not one; NOT ONE would have ever allowed in the spirit of "charity" to kiss a foreign object. Think, just think of how many Saints could've spared their own lives if they would give in....just a little. But they didn't. Many of them shed their blood for Christ, PRECISELY BECAUSE THEY NEVER WOULD KISS A FOREIGN-FALSE OBJECT. I just don't see why people like you can't see this????!!!! It's baffles my mind. It really does. You see, we don't challenge the Popes authority, but quite the opposite. Even with Pope Benedict we APPEAL to his authority to STOP THE MADNESS!! [/quote]
cmotherofpirl Posted May 30, 2005 Posted May 30, 2005 The Pope kissed the Koran as a sign of respect. yep. Was it a sin, etc, that is up to God to judge. The Pope did NOT pray in common at Assisi, he prayed only with Catholics. Dave, facts wouldn't change the mind of these people.
Qoheleth Posted May 30, 2005 Posted May 30, 2005 Mark 9:40 -- "For whoever is not against us is for us." JP2 was not surrendering to the representatives of other faiths, and agreeing to twist Catholicism to conform with them, but wishing that people of all faiths could coexist in peace. When dealing with other religions with which there is plenty of common ground, Catholics can capitalize on it to create an enviroment in which there will be no suspicion between parties--the only environment from which effective conversion can result. So why should we force them to pray to Mary, if we can both pray to God who hears everyone's prayers? Acknowledging our own truth (and that therefore Catholicism understands the complete message of God) we can still rely on the lowest common denominator to remind us that there is, in every human heart, a desire for God. Anyway, if the ends do not justify the means, the responsibilities of world leaders like the Pope is multiplied. Does the ends of maintaining a fortress Church, willfully ignorant of the world outside it, justify the means of breeding discord and even violence between various peoples?
journeyman Posted May 30, 2005 Posted May 30, 2005 being modern is not modernism - the error in modernism was the belief that salvation was not necessary (of if it was, that it could be obtained/found through one's own efforts, rather than through Jesus) so ends-means analysis doesn't seem entirely appropriate in the context of world youth day Quoting: Again speaking of John Paul 2 as a Modernist Pope, did (even) John the 23rd ever have rock n' roll music at any of his Masses (not to mention of any Pre-Conciliar) popes. Or is it because only John Paul 2 really loved the youth that it doesn't really matter WHAT he (permitted)allowed......because welll.......HE CARES!!! AGAIN, NONSENSE!!!! In regards to the issue of "good-intentions"; as the saying goes; it's precisely that in which the road to hell is paved with (as the saying goes). Stop Quoting: That's a far cry from the Cam/hot stuff debate over guitars - and I don't think they mentioned modernism once. I've thought, but with little in the way of documented support, that one reason for the various orders was a call to spread the gospel to a certain place or group that was not being evangelized by the Church . . . What worked in Gaul does not necessarily work in India . . . what works in the inner city may not work in the rural mountains . . . what works for 60 year olds does not necessarily work for 20 year olds . . . what works for one 20 year old may not work for another . . . to a man with only a hammer, every job looks like it needs nails . . . the Church needs to use the best tools to do its work when Gregorian chant works, use it; when chant doesn't work and rock and roll does, use it instead . . . is that modernism, or finding the universal church in everything? it sounds to me like your correspondent doesn't like the means, and so is not looking at the ends at all.
journeyman Posted May 30, 2005 Posted May 30, 2005 There is, therefore in the Church progress of dogma, progress of theology, progress to a certain extent of faith itself, but this progress does not consist in the addition of fresh information nor the change of ideas. What is believed has always been believed, but in time it is more commonly and thoroughly understood and explicitly expressed. Thus, thanks to the living magisterium and ecclesiastical preaching, thanks to the living sense of truth in the Church, to the action of the Holy Ghost simultaneously directing master and faithful, traditional truth lives and develops in the Church, always the same, at once ancient and new--ancient, for the first Christians already beheld it to a certain extent, new, because we see it with our own eyes and in harmony with our present ideas. Such is the notion of tradition in the double meaning of the word; it is Divine truth coming down to us in the mind of the Church and it is the guardianship and transmission of this Divine truth by the organ of the living magisterium, by ecclesiastical preaching, by the profession of it made by all in the Christian life. From the Catholic Encyclopedia article on Tradition and Living Magisterium
phatcatholic Posted May 31, 2005 Posted May 31, 2005 dave, why do you opponents yell so much? i wouldn't even dialogue w/ them until they agreed to calm down, maybe drink less of what journeyman has in his sig
phatcatholic Posted May 31, 2005 Posted May 31, 2005 also, i know you don't want links, but the ultratraditionalism entry has been EXTENSIVELY updated w/ new links, so i suggest checking that out, especially the section on ecumenism.
journeyman Posted June 1, 2005 Posted June 1, 2005 [quote name='phatcatholic' date='May 31 2005, 06:20 AM'] dave, why do you opponents yell so much? i wouldn't even dialogue w/ them until they agreed to calm down, maybe drink less of what journeyman has in his sig [/quote] I was kind of fond of that sig . . . I think I'll go drown my sorrows
phatcatholic Posted June 2, 2005 Posted June 2, 2005 [quote name='journeyman' date='May 31 2005, 09:12 PM'] I was kind of fond of that sig . . . I think I'll go drown my sorrows [/quote] hehe, don't worry, i dig ur sig bro
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now