Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Okay, here's another crazy idea from the warped mind of Aloysius...

is it legal to set up your own sub-system of currency while in the U.S. that you and a group of like-minded individuals could use to trade amongst yourselves? what laws set up would be in the way? I know the U.S. Dollar is to be considered legal tender in all debts public and private, and as such it would still have to be accepted... but could we also accept this currency we invent ourselves amongst ourselves?

I mean, we could theoretically trade goods for goods legally... and we could theoretically trade goods for gold legally... and we could theoretically trade goods for pieces of metal or peices of paper legally... right? so where would we be breaking the law by having our own currency?

yeah... I'm probably gonna land myself in jail one day for tax evasion or treason or something with all these crazy ideas... I'm just tryin to find somethin simple with finances grounded in reality :cool:

crusader1234
Posted

Yes, thats illegal. Confederate money.

Posted

I don't think it's illegal. After all, it's just bartering. If I agree that your piece of paper is worth my TV, we'll trade.

Mateo el Feo
Posted

Despite the fact that video arcades and casinos "have their own currency," I believe that this is 100% illegal within the borders of the US of A.

Posted

so what's the law about it?

Posted

it's not conterfeit, and we're not refusing to accept dollars in any and all debts public and private... I wonder if the law is specifically opposed to this?

Posted

Actually Al I'm all for testing this out!!

I would like to purchase your car and I am will to offer you

300 Luxmarians!!!

Really you have to admit I probably shouldn't pay more than 275 luxmarians but I like you!!

Do we have a deal?

Posted

I think it deals with taxation -- they don't want you to get around paying tax.

But I am just guessing, really.

Posted

lol yeah right... we'd have to set it all up and keep track of how many everyone has... and you'd have to be willing to accept the currency for the same level of thing... like if you can buy my car for 300 "luxmarians" (i don't have a name for them) then I must be able to buy something from you of the same value for 300 "luxmarians"

perhaps the currency, both singular and plural, could be "lux"

1 lux
2 lux
300 lux

lol... I'm soo gonna be phatmassing from a federal tax prison some day.

Posted (edited)

Don't worry, Aloysius, it's legal. And it's being done, in Ithaca, NY. Check out [url="http://www.gdrc.org/icm/hours.html"]this site[/url] for some details. There's many other sites too. Apparently it's legal to make your own currency, so long as you pay taxes on it.

The plural of lux is probably luces. Although it would be awesome to bring back the denarius.

Edited by Qoheleth
Posted

why does everyone always steal my idea before I have it!!! argh

anyway, if you recall my previous post about creating a Chesterbellocian Market... I may just have to create a whole new currency for it! :cool:


what's a denarius? I think it'd be cool if we made lux not change for number.. 1 lux or 2 lux, it both sounds fine.

Posted

I can't figure out how they have it be taxed... do they give the government "hours" or do they convert it into dollars and give it to the government? how was the taxation set up? I'm confused on that.

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' date='Jun 1 2005, 10:15 PM'] why does everyone always steal my idea before I have it!!! argh

what's a denarius? [/quote]
1) "Nothing is new under the sun. Even the thing of which we say, "See, this is new!" has already existed in the ages that preceded us."
-- as the real Qoheleth said

2) The denarius was the Roman currency used in the Holy Land at the time of Christ.

Posted

yeah yeah I know... I just wish I was more original lol

and it's not so much that I wanted to be new... as much as I wanted to be the first one to do such a thing in modern times.. I wouldn't mind finding out someone had tried it a century ago or something.

Posted

[quote name='crusader1234' date='Jun 1 2005, 08:58 PM'] Yes, thats illegal. Confederate money. [/quote]
Cant be having that Rebel money....

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' date='Jun 1 2005, 10:26 PM'] yeah yeah I know... I just wish I was more original lol

and it's not so much that I wanted to be new... as much as I wanted to be the first one to do such a thing in modern times.. I wouldn't mind finding out someone had tried it a century ago or something. [/quote]
Hey, if you can successfully create a nation ex nihilo (which we now know to pronounce nickelo), that's impressive enough.

Posted

well I'm gonna darn well try.


just need to get a following for my Luxmarian Chivalric Order, establish my own currency and the Chesterbellocian Market, and then find the best site to squat (which most legally could only be done in international waters)

is it pronounced nickelo in ecclesiastical latin then? or classical?

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' date='Jun 1 2005, 10:31 PM'] is it pronounced nickelo in ecclesiastical latin then? or classical? [/quote]
Ecclesiastical. The ancient Romans had more sense than that.

Mateo el Feo
Posted

I believe that the "hours" example is of a "substitute currency." It's clearly tied to the dollar. It's a little like a gift certificate. I would guess that the following would have to be true:
1) The "Luxmarian" currency must be valued in terms of dollars.
2) The use of the "Luxmarian" currency in trade is subject to the same taxation (e.g. sales tax) regulations as any other transaction.

A good parallel would be a store gift certificate. Let's say I get a $40 Best Buy gift card, and Best Buy choose to call them "Best Bux." When I make my purchase using my "Best Bux," I'm still responsible for sales tax. At some point, Uncle Sam gets his share. :)

Posted

so what is the legality if you don't have it tied to the dollar? what if you just are willing to give someone a good in exchange for x number of things with a certain thing printed on them? taxes were probably paid in the making of the good... but they want to tax the transaction I imagine (if it's a state with sales tax). so are any laws being broken if we just trade amongst ourselves and in our own little group accept this currency?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...