GodsGrace Posted July 18, 2003 Posted July 18, 2003 hey Jake....a friend once told me that if you go to confession & you say father forgive me of the sins I choose NOT to mention....although it is hard to believe you can say that, I'm going ask you that!!..can you say that & still be forgiven. B/c there is ONE sin that I have never been able to bring myself to say infront of a priest. Not like thay've never heard it, but b/c I'm sooooooembarrassed & b/c it's just a stupid thing.
GodsThespianChic Posted July 18, 2003 Posted July 18, 2003 Yeah, you can do that, because I did that when I went to confessionn with Fr. Gary on Sunday night. He was like "You basically said it, but God knows you're sorry, so..." and then he went on with the absolvation (or whatever you call it). Ya know how Fr. J gives the cool penances? Like not the traditional ones? Well, Fr. Gary is like that and I love it!! But the answer is yes. Because I did it. And Fr. Gary told me I was forgiven anyway.
GodsGrace Posted July 19, 2003 Posted July 19, 2003 so I can just say, can I be forgiven of sins I don't want to mention? b/c I tried that on an old priest of mine & he like butted me out!
GodsThespianChic Posted July 19, 2003 Posted July 19, 2003 Well, then just go to Fr. Gary for confession. Or Fr. J.
Joyful Posted July 19, 2003 Posted July 19, 2003 GodsGrace, I think you need to learn a little more about confession. I would highly highly suggest you put this question up for discussion on the debate table. If you don't want to I will. Just let me know. I just don't want you to get the wrong idea about confession. Joyful
Qamidalash Posted July 20, 2003 Posted July 20, 2003 I chose the Eucharist (isn't it gr8 that nearly all of us knew what that meant??!!) b/c that's what makes the CC so unique! To actually have Christ's body inside of us is such a blessing... btw, joyful, I love your quote!!
Jake Huether Posted July 21, 2003 Posted July 21, 2003 So sorry not to get back to you sooner. I've never heard of that before. If you have a sin on your conscience, then the Sacrament of penance is to confess that sin. And confessing that sin, as I understand, is specifying which sin. If you simply say, "I want to be forgiven for the sins I cannot mention" (i.e. cannot confess) then I don't think that that is a licit confession. Albeit, if the priest grants you forgivness, then you have been forgiven. But the point of confession is to confess. I could be wrong, you should talk to the priest about it, but if you don't mention your sins, how can the priest help you to overcome the sin? You see, this Sacrament is a benefit to us not only because we KNOW for sure that we've been forgiven when the priest says, I absolve you of your sins..., but it is a great benefit because the priest can counsil you on how to better avoid these sins. This particular Sacrament is troublesome for many people, because it requires a great amount of humility. But the humility, or humiliation, isn't what makes it a Sacrament. It isn't "God's punishment". Confessing to a priest, the representative of Christ, is a special benefit to us, granted by God. I'd like to make clear, however, that when you confess (generally speaking) you don't make a shopping list of every single specific sin you've commited. What I do is go through an examination of conscience (they should have these note papers available at your church), and I look for the main sins. If you axamine yourself you should notice that there are certain sins that are the root of other sins. Take for instance the sin of Lust. Say you are addicted to masterbation, and it's causing you to look with lust on girls, or at magazines, or whatever. Then when you confess, you don't need to make note of all the specific sins that fall in line. The main root of the problem is the sin of lust. Sometimes the priest will ask for specificts in order to counsil you on how to avoid the sin. And that's the time you can mention specifics. I hope that answers your questions. In sum: I wouldn't recommend asking for forgiveness without confessing the sin. Although you will be embarassed, you will no doubt feel the weight lifted off your shoulders. Also, you will benefit from the advice the priest can give. If it is truly embarassing, then just go to confession at another parish. I have a backup parish that does confessions behind the screen for my really ugly sins.
GodsThespianChic Posted July 21, 2003 Posted July 21, 2003 That's a good idea, Jake. I was able to confess a lot of things on a retreat a couple months back, because we had a couple of priests that aren't from our parish and it was a lot easier like that. I guess the main fear is basically like seeing the priest later, and feel like you're being judged. Or if you are somewhat close with your priest, like me and my friends are to Fr. J, it can be hard to say those things, because you feel like you're letting them down.
Joyful Posted July 21, 2003 Posted July 21, 2003 Thanks Jake! I agree with what you said. One other thing I would add~ If the reason you won't confess that sin is because of embarrassment, have you ever thought about Satan's role in that? Satan wants us to think that the priest will judge us or that by audibly saying it out loud it makes us a bad person. He would do anything to keep us from receiving the forgiveness that we deserve. This may sound sooooo dumb, but whenever I don't want to confess out of embarrassment, I consider it as Satan attacking me. I then tell myself that by going to confession and being honest, I'm doing my part in the war of good vs evil. Sounds soooo dumb, I know, but sometimes it takes that to get me to do it. Then afterwards, when I can just feel the grace a-flowin' I know what true forgiveness is. GodsGrace, I know how hard it is and good luck!
Jake Huether Posted July 21, 2003 Posted July 21, 2003 Not dumb at all Joyfull! Absolutly correct! And actually, GTC, believe it or not, it's quite the contrary. I had a very close priest, and like you I was so very emberassed to confess my stupid sins to him. Especially if I've already confessed the same sin a couple times! However, he continually told me how honored he was that I was actually confessing to him! I actually was an inspiration to him when I came to him in confession (even with the same sins). You see, as Joyful noted, Satan tries to make us feel embarassed or think that the priest is going to laugh at us or judge us. In reallity, the priest (and God above all) is so happy that we are confessing. Although we've sinned, if we confess that sin we have NOT failed at all! It's when we sin and are too embarassed to say sorry to God in the Sacrament of Confession that we fail.
nippy316 Posted July 21, 2003 Posted July 21, 2003 Ya know how Fr. J gives the cool penances? Like not the traditional ones? You call 10 rosaries a cool penance? I think that's pretty traditional to me. Actually, I think he dislikes me. maybe that's why. Justine
GodsThespianChic Posted July 21, 2003 Posted July 21, 2003 You call 10 rosaries a cool penance? I think that's pretty traditional to me. Actually, I think he dislikes me. maybe that's why. Justine I never got anything like that. Like once, I got "Pray with your boyfriend before you 2 go out the next 2 times" and then "Just do a good deed for someone at this retreat" and Fr. Gary, last Sunday, gave me "Pray for someone here who is feeling broken". So those are totally not that bad. So it took you like 5 hours to do your penance??
nippy316 Posted July 21, 2003 Posted July 21, 2003 So it took you like 5 hours to do your penance?? Well I had to split it up. Needless to say, it definitely gave me a greater appreciation for the rosary. But I've learned my lesson: go to normal confession from 3-4 on Saturdays and go to Fr. Domeck (s/p??) who barely speaks English. Justine
Good Friday Posted July 22, 2003 Posted July 22, 2003 I chose "our God died for us." I know that may sound like the typical Protestant answer but, if you think about it, the fact that our God died for us is the most wonderful thing about the Catholic Church, and it's what all the other wonderful things are based on. If Jesus hadn't died, then the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass wouldn't exist. It was after Jesus' death and resurrection that He gave the Apostles the power to forgive sins. It was after Jesus' ascension that the Holy Spirit was sent into the world, and without the Holy Spirit there could be no Pope and no Church. So without Jesus' death, there is no Pope. And without the Pope, and the Church, we would have no reason to be pro-life other than the natural law. And hey, if our God didn't die for us, what would we have to sing about?
Paladin D Posted July 25, 2003 Posted July 25, 2003 Oh this is very very hard. I'm stuck between option 1 and 2...
StColette Posted June 26, 2004 Posted June 26, 2004 I would say the Eucharist of course another thing is having devotion to the Virgin Mary, sometimes I feel sorry for non-Catholics that don't have this devotion because they don't know what they are missing.
Iacobus Posted June 26, 2004 Posted June 26, 2004 Way too hard. I see commuion and confession and Christs death as tied into one big gift bag. Way too hard.
Gunga_ann Posted June 26, 2004 Posted June 26, 2004 I love the Eucharist to death, and I am sorry I could only vote for one. I would of liked to vote for the Pope!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now