Kilroy the Ninja Posted June 10, 2005 Posted June 10, 2005 Wow, Eremite, don't you think it might be important to read the book before you completely condemn it? Or are you just taking people's word for it?
Dudette Posted June 10, 2005 Posted June 10, 2005 [quote name='luciana' date='Jun 10 2005, 12:39 AM']yep, I agree w/ fidei. From what I've read so far,The Triumph, The PoWer...by H.W.Crocker III, is a good general review of history. I like it, and yeah, I wouldn't use it to give to Protestants either, but just as a reference instead. I don't know what would be a good book on history to give to non-Catholics. I do know a slightly longer treatment of history would be the books by Dr. Anne Carroll, haven't read them yet. (not Warren Carroll's famous, but unfinished set of books-- these are shorter) They're history books that tell history w/ Jesus and the Church at the center of it. I know they're used by homeschoolers, so they're not a populist read like Crocker's either. There's one that focuses on history in America, so I got it to use as a reference w/ my students for school, but haven't started it yet. edited to add 1st name to differentiate the Carrolls [right][snapback]608394[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Ok, just a word, I wouldn't suggest reading Anne Caroll's history books, though I'm not a history person myself, other students who have read a lot of her books know that a lot of it isn't accurate. Her book....so far, has uh...made me go insane. Ok, that was a rant, but I couldn't resist.
Guest Eremite Posted June 10, 2005 Posted June 10, 2005 [quote]No the Truth is always Preeminent, Always![/quote] Not quite. [quote]Though I speak with the tongues of men and of angels, and have not charity, I am become as sounding brass, or a tinkling cymbal. And though I have the gift of prophecy, and understand all mysteries, and all knowledge; and though I have all faith, so that I could remove mountains, and have not charity, I am nothing. And now abideth faith, hope, charity, these three; but the greatest of these is charity. (1 Corinthians 13)[/quote] Nobody said that the demands of truth must be abolished (I specifically denied this, as does John Paul II). As GodConquers said, telling the truth and being an ass are two different things. Until we make a concerted effort for a purification of memory and conscience that John Paul II spoke of in his Encyclical Letter Ut Unum Sint, we're gonna keep going around in contentious circles with brothers in Christ. Non-Catholics are not people to be dominated by truth. We are humble servants of truth, and fellow pilgrims with all others who seek truth. Dialogue entails a true exchange of charity and ideas, not abrasive monologues. [quote]don't you think it might be important to read the book before you completely condemn it?[/quote] I did read the book, or at least the first few chapters. No, I don't think I need to read the whole thing to know that it's not something I want to read, and not something I would recommend to others. And I don't think I "condemned" the book. I was clear to note that I didn't read the whole thing. My objections were on the portions I read, which are sufficient for me to form a working judgement on it, and whether or not I would recommend it. Reviews I have read from others regarding things like its triumphalism have only confirmed my suspicions.
Guest Eremite Posted June 10, 2005 Posted June 10, 2005 [quote name='Don John of Austria' date='Jun 10 2005, 12:23 AM']please elucidate me on what exactly in Church history has been Bad. [right][snapback]608511[/snapback][/right] [/quote] You're a smart man. You have books. Read them.
Didacus Posted June 10, 2005 Posted June 10, 2005 [quote name='fidei defensor' date='Jun 9 2005, 10:03 PM']What a good book. I started it earlier, and I am up to the death of Constantine. Its a great history book! Okay, carry on as you were. [right][snapback]608358[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Where did you find the books? I looked around a bit but they are expensive... Is there a place you recommend? Which book do you suggest I read first from our new pontiff? hmmmm... maybe this should be a new thread? I read several reviews, from protestants, lutherans, catholics... and I agree, these books are a must!
Brother Adam Posted June 10, 2005 Posted June 10, 2005 [quote name='Kilroy the Ninja' date='Jun 10 2005, 03:08 AM']Wow, Eremite, don't you think it might be important to read the book before you completely condemn it? Or are you just taking people's word for it? [right][snapback]608574[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I've read it. It is sitting on my shelf. I agree its carp. I suggest "History of the Church" by Lortz-Kaiser. Hard to come by, but its an excellent book. Check it out of your local library.
Guest Eremite Posted June 10, 2005 Posted June 10, 2005 Cambridge University Press is publishing a nine-volume "History of Christianity". [quote]...[it will] provide the first complete chronological account of the development of Christianity in all its aspects - theological, social, political, regional, global - from the time of Christ to the present day. This ambitious project in nine volumes will connect the institutional history of the churches with the study of systematic and applied (pastoral) theology, and will cover popular piety and non-formal expressions of Christian faith as well as the more formal. The sociology of Christian formation, worship and devotion will be placed in a broad cultural context, and proper attention will be paid throughout to issues of spirituality and the spiritual content of Christianity's development. This is not a history merely of Western Christianity. Into the study of the early church and beyond, consideration of Eastern and Coptic Christianity will be properly integrated; and later, African, Far Eastern, New World, South Asian and other non-European developments in Christianity will receive proper coverage. The relations between Christianity and Islam, Christianity and Hinduism, and Christianity and Judaism will be kept in sight. Each of the nine volumes will be of value as a free-standing contribution within its own period; and when complete, The Cambridge History of Christianity will constitute one of the major works of academic reference of our times.[/quote]
Fidei Defensor Posted June 10, 2005 Author Posted June 10, 2005 eh people, people. If you like it, thats good, if you dont, thats fine too. I happen to like the style. :ph34r:
Don John of Austria Posted June 11, 2005 Posted June 11, 2005 [quote name='Eremite' date='Jun 10 2005, 08:03 AM']Not quite. Nobody said that the demands of truth must be abolished (I specifically denied this, as does John Paul II). As GodConquers said, telling the truth and being an ass are two different things. Until we make a concerted effort for a purification of memory and conscience that John Paul II spoke of in his Encyclical Letter Ut Unum Sint, we're gonna keep going around in contentious circles with brothers in Christ. Non-Catholics are not people to be dominated by truth. We are humble servants of truth, and fellow pilgrims with all others who seek truth. Dialogue entails a true exchange of charity and ideas, not abrasive monologues. I did read the book, or at least the first few chapters. No, I don't think I need to read the whole thing to know that it's not something I want to read, and not something I would recommend to others. And I don't think I "condemned" the book. I was clear to note that I didn't read the whole thing. My objections were on the portions I read, which are sufficient for me to form a working judgement on it, and whether or not I would recommend it. Reviews I have read from others regarding things like its triumphalism have only confirmed my suspicions. [right][snapback]608603[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Yes Quite, The Truth is always first, without it there can be no salvation. Please show me any scripture which says that Charity supercedes Truth... Can you I doubt it.
Don John of Austria Posted June 11, 2005 Posted June 11, 2005 [quote name='Eremite' date='Jun 10 2005, 08:10 AM']You're a smart man. You have books. Read them. [right][snapback]608604[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Your right I am a smart man and I have books, but you see I have read them, I studied Church history, for years, spenttime in the Seminary all of that, but I didn't make the Claim that there was aspects of the Churches history which was Bad, YOU DID. So I ask agian please enlighten me, what exactly in the History of the Church was Bad.
Guest Eremite Posted June 11, 2005 Posted June 11, 2005 [quote] Please show me any scripture which says that Charity supercedes Truth[/quote] I already have. [quote]And though I have the gift of prophecy, and understand all mysteries, and all knowledge; and though I have all faith, so that I could remove mountains, and have not charity, I am nothing. --1Corinthians 13[/quote] Having all "knowledge" of truth is useless unless you first have charity. Speaking truth "with the tongues of angels" is also useless, unless it is imbued with charity. St. Paul never says charity without knowledge is useless. Charity is the preeminent virtue, above even faith and hope. "Charity, the form of all the virtues, 'binds everything together in perfect harmony'" (CCC 1844). [quote]but I didn't make the Claim that there was aspects of the Churches history which was Bad, YOU DID. So I ask agian please enlighten me, what exactly in the History of the Church was Bad.[/quote] This is like asking someone to prove 2+2=4. Could they prove it? Sure. But the proof would be self-evident to anyone who has studied mathematics in its most basic form. What can I tell you? Maybe you need new books. [quote]For although the Catholic Church has been endowed with all divinely revealed truth and with all means of grace, yet its members fail to live by them with all the fervor that they should, so that the radiance of the Church's image is less clear in the eyes of our separated brethren and of the world at large, and the growth of God's kingdom is delayed. All Catholics must therefore aim at Christian perfection and, each according to his station, play his part [b]that the Church may daily be more purified and renewed[/b]. For the Church must bear in her own body the humility and dying of Jesus, against the day when Christ will present her to Himself in all her glory without spot or wrinkle. --Second Vatican Ecumenical Council, "Unitatis Redintegratio"[/quote]
Don John of Austria Posted June 11, 2005 Posted June 11, 2005 [quote name='Eremite' date='Jun 11 2005, 06:18 AM']I already have. Having all "knowledge" of truth is useless unless you first have charity. Speaking truth "with the tongues of angels" is also useless, unless it is imbued with charity. St. Paul never says charity without knowledge is useless. Charity is the preeminent virtue, above even faith and hope. "Charity, the form of all the virtues, 'binds everything together in perfect harmony'" (CCC 1844). This is like asking someone to prove 2+2=4. Could they prove it? Sure. But the proof would be self-evident to anyone who has studied mathematics in its most basic form. What can I tell you? Maybe you need new books. [right][snapback]609166[/snapback][/right] [/quote] No you haven't you quoted saint Paul saying that without charity Faith is meaningless, wow, I don't see where that says that Charity is preeminint over Truth. You are reading far more than was inended into a very short Passage. It certianly never Claims that Charity comes first in any of these things only that it is needed for these things to have value. It is not like saving 2+2=4 it is like saying that 4 is first, that it is preeminent over 2, and if our Goal is 7 of course 4 is absolutly essential but it does not come before Truth, Truth is the foundation, without it Charity is meaningless drival, Truth to continue your analogy is 1it is the foundation for all things.
Don John of Austria Posted June 11, 2005 Posted June 11, 2005 And so I ask agian please inform me--- what in the Church's History is Bad. Either put up or shut up. Make your case or withdraw your statement.
Brother Adam Posted June 11, 2005 Posted June 11, 2005 (edited) Hey, how about not being an τρύπα γαιδάρων? Every time the Church, as induviduals in the collective visible body of Christ's faithful sins, it is 'bad'. Edited June 11, 2005 by Brother Adam
Don John of Austria Posted June 11, 2005 Posted June 11, 2005 (edited) [quote name='Brother Adam' date='Jun 11 2005, 01:43 PM']Hey, how about not being an τρύπα γαιδάρων? Every time the Church, as induviduals in the collective visible body of Christ's faithful sins, it is 'bad'. [right][snapback]609309[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Individuals are not the Church, individuals are members of the Church, individual sins are not reflections on the Church anymore than the behavior of an individual blood cell is reflective on your body. Oh and I am not being anything, he made a very serious statement which he needs to justify or withdraw, so I say agian -- put up or shut up, support your statment or withdraw it. Edited June 11, 2005 by Don John of Austria
Brother Adam Posted June 11, 2005 Posted June 11, 2005 Induviduals represent the Church, especially figures of authority such as Bishops and Popes. They indeed are reflections on the Bride of Christ for if there were no members of the Church there would be no Church. He did not call the Church bad, he called parts of the Churches history bad. Ditto. Some of the non-fallible statements and lifestyles of past Popes, Bishops, and priests, have reflected poorly on the Church, not to mention the sins of laymen acting on behalf of their Catholic faith. Every induvidual sin effects the whole Church. The sole reason this Church stands is because of Christ, a fact you would do good not to forget.
Guest Eremite Posted June 11, 2005 Posted June 11, 2005 DonJohn, What would you do if I replied, and actually proved my assertion? Would you be satisfied? No. You would respond with 10 pages of argument. And I would respond with 10 pages of argument. And so on, and so on, ad infinitum. I'm not going to respond, for that very reason. I see no chance for a reasoned discussion, without it becoming an occasion of pride for both of us. So I'll leave it at that. God bless.
Fidei Defensor Posted June 11, 2005 Author Posted June 11, 2005 Children, this thread was supposed to be about a book that i thought was good. If you want to debate out whether or not the Church was bad or all that fun stuff, please go to the debate board.
Technicoid Posted June 12, 2005 Posted June 12, 2005 I read this book as well. As much as I enjoyed aspects of it and believe that it presents a perspective about Catholic (Christian) Church history that is sorely lacking in our media these days, I also believe that it white washes those areas where people acting in the name of the Church have done horrific things. Our Church doesn't need white wash. We need plain talk. Flippancy (which is far too rampant in this book) might be entertaining to those "in the know," but it is useless in the defense of the faith. How can we respond to the sacking of Constantinople in 1204 in good faith without acknowledging the pain it has caused to our Eastern brethren?* Is it charitable of us to speak of crusades flippantly when we recognize that some people set out on crusades with purely selfish purposes? I'm right up front in defending the Crusades as necessary. Without them, Christianity would've left the European continent much sooner. However, we also need to acnkowledge that not all who operated under the auspices of the Church were (or are) holy, compassionate people who intended to do the will of the Lord. That's a fault of humanity, not the Church.
Azriel Posted June 12, 2005 Posted June 12, 2005 Ok, ya'll want to debate take to the debate board. Adam, not sure what those characters mean, but I doubt its charitable. Chill out peeps, summer's just starting. Brought to you by your friendly neighbor velvet hammer ... smacking down politely since 2002.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now