BeenaBobba Posted June 15, 2005 Posted June 15, 2005 Howdy, I'm presently in a discussion concerning the intercession of saints. The girl I'm discussing this issue with is Protestant. She concedes that those in Heaven are perhaps aware of our prayers, but she does not believe that they can actually [i]hear[/i] them, as she says the Bible does not mention saints actually hearing our prayers. To that, I think I'm going to say that she's right. After all, how could the saints in Heaven hear our prayers if they haven't got bodies (and ears)? I believe this bolsters the Catholic case even more, as not having ears, but being aware of prayers, could also imply that they're aware of the prayers' contents. Also, she doesn't think we should assume the elders mentioned in Revelations 5:8 are necessarily saints. She said the elders could be angels. I don't think that's likely, as angels are referred to by name in Revelations, and if they're not angels, what are they? Do any of you have any knowledge of the original Greek in this passage? Anyhow, what are your thoughts on this? God bless, Jen
Technicoid Posted June 15, 2005 Posted June 15, 2005 [quote name='BeenaBobba' date='Jun 14 2005, 11:21 PM']I'm presently in a discussion concerning the intercession of saints. The girl I'm discussing this issue with is Protestant. She concedes that those in Heaven are perhaps aware of our prayers, but she does not believe that they can actually [i]hear[/i] them, as she says the Bible does not mention saints actually hearing our prayers.[/quote] The Bible also doesn't mention that Christ or any of the Apostles ever have to... uh... "use the little prophets' room." Does that mean that they never had to address a call from nature? Don't be drawn in by the "not explicitly stated in the Bible" claim. Instead, turn it around and have her prove that all revelation is contained solely in scripture (sola scriptura). She won't be able to do it, and the Catholic Church doesn't teach it. [quote name='BeenaBobba' date='Jun 14 2005, 11:21 PM']To that, I think I'm going to say that she's right. After all, how could the saints in Heaven hear our prayers if they haven't got bodies (and ears)?[/quote] How does God hear our prayers? She's trying to apply worldly experience to an other-worldly existence. [quote]I believe this bolsters the Catholic case even more, as not having ears, but being aware of prayers, could also imply that they're aware of the prayers' contents.[/quote] Ears are not the only means of perception. If the body is really more of a prison, ears could just be channels that otherwise wouldn't be necessary. Again, who knows? She's trying to overlay our world on the other-worldly. [quote]Also, she doesn't think we should assume the elders mentioned in Revelations 5:8 are necessarily saints. She said the elders could be angels.[/quote] How about this: [quote]When he took it, the four living creatures and the twenty-four elders fell down before the Lamb. Each of the elders held a harp and gold bowls filled with incense, which are the prayers of the holy ones. 9 They sang a new hymn: "Worthy are you to receive the scroll and to break open its seals, for you were slain and with your blood you purchased for God those from every tribe and tongue, people and nation. 10 You made them a kingdom and priests for our God, and they will reign on earth." 11 I looked again and heard the voices of many angels who surrounded the throne and the living creatures and the elders. They were countless 5 in number, 12 and they cried out in a loud voice: "Worthy is the Lamb that was slain to receive power and riches, wisdom and strength, honor and glory and blessing."[/quote] If the elders are angels, then why are the elders distinguished from the angels in the very same verse? We only know of two orders of intelligent, created beings (angels and humans). Unless your friend has had an alien visitation and has some other confirmation of another order of intelligent beings, then she's sort of stuck. Elders cannot be angels. The passage she cites shows them to be two different orders of creatures. BTW, you might want to explain just what a saint is. You might pose it this way. We believe that people who die are not gone or asleep. They're either in Heaven (and saints), in Purgatory (and on their way to being saints), or in Hell. In Hell, we can't reach them. They're cut off from God and everyone by their own choices. In Purgatory and in Heaven, they're just as alive in spirit as they always have been. And just as we ask our living friends and family members to pray for us, we can ask those who are spiritually alive to do the same. For those in Purgatory, it could help them along the purgation process (although I'm a bit fuzzy on the theology around this and could be off the mark). In Heaven, the saints love us more perfectly than they could while here on earth, so it isn't a stretch of the imagination that their prayers are both more fervent and more effective. Hope this helps. God bless.
phatcatholic Posted June 15, 2005 Posted June 15, 2005 (edited) [quote name='BeenaBobba' date='Jun 14 2005, 11:21 PM']Howdy, I'm presently in a discussion concerning the intercession of saints. The girl I'm discussing this issue with is Protestant. She concedes that those in Heaven are perhaps aware of our prayers, but she does not believe that they can actually [i]hear[/i] them, as she says the Bible does not mention saints actually hearing our prayers. To that, I think I'm going to say that she's right. After all, how could the saints in Heaven hear our prayers if they haven't got bodies (and ears)?[/quote] but the catholic argument is not that they technically hear our prayers, as we hear by collecting sound waves w/ our ears. we use the word "hear" in a more metaphorical sense to mean that they perceive them and are aware of them. so, there is really no difference in meaning between "hearing" and "being aware." as technicoid said, the saints "hear" our prayers the same way God "hears" our prayers. this is not to say that the saints are omnipresent. instead, it means that they are in a place that transcends space and time and our laws of physics. btw, i wouldn't suggest turning this into a debate on sola scriptura. i think that would take the discussion off-topic and its not necessary in order to prove your point. [quote]I believe this bolsters the Catholic case even more, as not having ears, but being aware of prayers, could also imply that they're aware of the prayers' contents.[/quote] well, they act in response to them, so that surely means that they perceive the contents of them. if they only knew that people were praying, w/o knowing what they were praying about, i don't think they would know how to act in response. [quote]Also, she doesn't think we should assume the elders mentioned in Revelations 5:8 are necessarily saints. She said the elders could be angels. I don't think that's likely, as angels are referred to by name in Revelations, and if they're not angels, what are they? Do any of you have any knowledge of the original Greek in this passage? Anyhow, what are your thoughts on this?[/quote] you two are making this alot more difficult then it needs to be. rather they are angels, or elders, or whatever, we know that these people are in heaven. therefore, they are saints. its that simple. as for the greek, the word translated as "elders" here is [i]presbuvteroß[/i], or "presbuteros." one of its meanings is "the twenty four members of the heavenly Sanhedrin or court seated on thrones around the throne of God" (see [url="http://bible.crosswalk.com/Lexicons/Greek/grk.cgi?number=4245&version=kjv"]here[/url]), which further proves my point. the best defense of the communion of saints that i have EVER seen is [url="http://catholic-legate.com/articles/commsaints.html"]this article[/url], which may also be of help to you. pax christi, phatcatholic Edited June 15, 2005 by phatcatholic
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now