Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Another jab at Shiavo's parents...


Recommended Posts

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='Didacus' date='Jun 22 2005, 02:20 PM']But medical intervention was required in order for her to ingest food... all that was done was to remove this medical intervention.
[right][snapback]619324[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Removing the tube was not all that was done... they stopped giving her food or water. If you read the coroner's report Terri Shiavo's cause of death is "dehydration" not "removal of feeding tube". Big difference. Terri's body could digest the food and water, she just couldn't take it in through her mouth because they were worried about her choking. With a person on life support you've either got a machine that's forcing them to breathe, or forcing their heart to beat-- but the body doesn't do it on it's own. Terri's stomach and intestines worked. They first took away her means of feeding herself, and then they also took away food and water.

There was a guy that went to my high school that had a feeding tube and everything. Should we have taken away his feeding tube because it's artificial? What separates him from Terri Shiavo (his brain function was a little slow/delayed)? Because he could walk, and his tutor could translate for him that makes him worthy of food and water?

Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Jun 22 2005, 03:45 PM'] With a person on life support you've either got a machine that's forcing them to breathe, or forcing their heart to beat-- but the body doesn't do it on it's own. Terri's stomach and intestines worked. They first took away her means of feeding herself, and then they also took away food and water.

There was a guy that went to my high school that had a feeding tube and everything. Should we have taken away his feeding tube because it's artificial? What separates him from Terri Shiavo (his brain function was a little slow/delayed)? Because he could walk, and his tutor could translate for him that makes him worthy of food and water?
[right][snapback]619540[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

The tube was forcing her to eat, like other machines sometimes forces patients to breathe.

I cannot say for certain where the difference lies... dignity of life must be respected in the pursuit of its preservation. The two must go hand in hand.

I say that removing the feeding tube was not wrong.

But I agree that not at least attempting to provide her with food in a normal manner was wrong.

Hopw much dignity did she have? Had she, for a moment been able to regain all her senses, realizing that in minutes time she would return to her state... what would she have wanted? Her husband said it was clear what she wanted (granted this may be qeustionable, but endulge the possibility will you?).

What if you where in her place? Would you say "I would live as a bed ridden patient without hope of enjoying life for perhaps 60 years..." or would have said that in the proposed state "Best i be allowed to reach my lord now, for there is nothing else I can possibly accomplish with this life."?

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='crusader1234' date='Jun 22 2005, 02:12 PM']What I've said has nothing to do with the end of Terri's life.  And what you're talking about has nothing to do with it either.  You're not supporting life by gossiping about whats on her headstone and how angry that makes you.  You're just gossiping.
No, thats not gossip.  But if you'd bother to actually read the thread, nobody is talking about that.  People are talking about headstones and family affairs that don't concern them.  Nobody is talking about how we are going to stop anything - maybe two posts in this thread have been on a topic that isn't just gossip.
[right][snapback]619313[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
But... don't you see? The reason I posted this was because of what he put on the grave marker about her death date (it's all in bold). The fact that he was allowed to decide for himself on in such a dramatic way on the date of Terri's death shows his mentality... and indeed the mentality of everyone who supported his side during the very, very public case. They're cutting off life at quality. When Terri's life was deemed by Michael Shiavo to be less "valuable" (less worth living) because she was brain damaged-- he viewed her as dead.
If it's okay for Michael Shiavo to put what he put on a headstone in the name of a "promise", then this country has a lot of thinking to do (what if someone promises to shoot their spouse when their eyesight goes bad?). The Terri Shiavo fight isn't over... we are headed down the slippery slope to euthanasia... if life is only life when it's "valuable". Michael Shiavo just happens to be the poster boy for euthanasia by his choice and actions (thus he catches a lot of flack).

Lastly, if you didn't like the topic, you didn't have to post in it or even read it. If you felt others were not taking the thread in the right direction, you can take it there without crying about others "gossiping". A one-liner drive-by isn't exactly adeqautely explaining yourself.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='Didacus' date='Jun 22 2005, 04:55 PM']The tube was forcing her to eat, like other machines sometimes forces patients to breathe.

I cannot say for certain where the difference lies...  dignity of life must be respected in the pursuit of its preservation.  The two must go hand in hand.

I say that removing the feeding tube was not wrong.[/quote]
It was not forcing her to eat... :blink: her stomach and intestines worked fine.

So when your parents fed you as a baby they were forcing you to eat? (if that's the case, praise God for forceful parents!)



[quote]Hopw much dignity did she have?  Had she, for a moment been able to regain all her senses, realizing that in minutes time she would return to her state... what would she have wanted?  Her husband said it was clear what she wanted (granted this may be qeustionable, but endulge the possibility will you?).

What if you where in her place?  Would you say "I would live as a bed ridden patient without hope of enjoying life for perhaps 60 years..." or would have said that in the proposed state "Best i be allowed to reach my lord now, for there is nothing else I can possibly accomplish with this life."?
[right][snapback]619563[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
How much dignity!?! A person retains ALL their personal dignity no matter their state.

Regardless of Terri's possible statement about not wanting to be kept alive artificially... receiving food and water is NOT artificial care--it's a basic necessity. Michael Shiavo did not pull out Terri's feeding tube because the tube was artificial... he pulled it out because she was drastically brain damaged. That much was clear all through the case, and is now in print on that headstone.

I told my parents and family very clearly when this case was in the news that they didn't have to keep me alive artificially, but they sure as Hell better not starve me to death! All I ask for are my basic necessities... food, water, and shelter.

Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Jun 22 2005, 03:58 PM'][snip].

.. and indeed the mentality of everyone who supported his side during the very, very public case.[snip]

[right][snapback]619568[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I take a little offesnse to that. I never said that I supported his every view and his every decision. I just called for a little compassion since this ordeal must not have been easy for him as well.

Love thy ennemy remember.

As for my own views... i admitted (didn't I) that I was a little perplexed about the whole issue and uncertain where to place myself.

Life is worth fighting for, but there comes a time when one should be able to throw in the towel and go to the Lord with dignity. it's simply that line that I am trying to define for myself, or should I say try to completely understand the church's teachings on the subject.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='Didacus' date='Jun 22 2005, 05:05 PM']I take a little offesnse to that.  I never said that I supported his every view and his every decision.  I just called for a little compassion since this ordeal must not have been easy for him as well.

Love thy ennemy remember.

As for my own views... i admitted (didn't I) that I was a little perplexed about the whole issue and uncertain where to place myself.

Life is worth fighting for, but there comes a time when one should be able to throw in the towel and go to the Lord with dignity.  it's simply that line that I am trying to define for myself, or should I say try to completely understand the church's teachings on the subject.
[right][snapback]619580[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
That was not directed at you personally, but the american public in general.... :huh:

Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Jun 22 2005, 04:04 PM']It was not forcing her to eat... :blink:  her stomach and intestines worked fine.

[snip]
[right][snapback]619577[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

It was a medical intervention allowing her to ingest food.

Is that better? You cannot realistically claim that a feeding tube is not a medical intervention?

Bringing food to a babie's mouth is not medical intervention, and I tend to agree that bringing food and water to Shiavo's mouth should at least have been attempted. I cannot see a reason why it should not have been carried out. but to my logic, I cannot see a concrete argument to removing the tube...

Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Jun 22 2005, 04:07 PM']That was not directed at you personally, but the american public in general.... :huh:
[right][snapback]619583[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Am I not amongst the public?

Posted

And granted, 'dignity' was not the proper choice of words.

The word i was thinking of was 'epanouissement' which does not seem to have proper english translation.
Ils sont fous ces anglais!

rather, how much enjoyment of life could see have? You must admit it was a sad state she had...Was she even able to communicate?

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='Didacus' date='Jun 22 2005, 05:09 PM']It was a medical intervention allowing her to ingest food.

Is that better?  You cannot realistically claim that a feeding tube is not a medical intervention?

Bringing food to a babie's mouth is not medical intervention, and I tend to agree that bringing food and water to Shiavo's mouth should at least have been attempted.  I cannot see a reason why it should not have been carried out.  but to my logic, I cannot see a concrete argument to removing the tube...
[right][snapback]619586[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Sure, I've not denied medical intervention... but it was necessary intervention to provide for a basic need... not something extraordinary. We are called in the Catechism to take all ordinary measures for the preservation of life, it is the extraordinary measures that are optional.

[quote]Am I not amongst the public?[/quote]
Yes, but I was addressing the public on Michael Shiavo's side... if you were one of the people who wanted them to remove Terri's feeding tube, then yes, the comment stands and was directed you.
At the same time, this is not a shot at Michael Shiavo.. I think he needs many prayers (and much grace)... Lil Red posted an article a while back called "I am Michael Shiavo" and I greatly appreciated its sentiments. However, his actions were morally wrong, objectively speaking--that is what I am speaking out against... his actions, not his person. I'm not the One with authority over his person.

[quote]And granted, 'dignity' was not the proper choice of words.

The word i was thinking of was 'epanouissement' which does not seem to have proper english translation.
Ils sont fous ces anglais!

rather, how much enjoyment of life could see have? You must admit it was a sad state she had...Was she even able to communicate?[/quote]
(sorry, I can only count in French! so I don't understand the term)

However, life is life. Quality is irrelevant. We don't have to "enjoy" life to be worthy of it. Yes, it was a sad state... but that doesn't give us the right to rip away what she had. Her dignity and worth remains intact regardless the state of her body. And we have the duty to respect that in all circumstances by providing basic needs.

Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Jun 22 2005, 05:15 PM']Sure, I've not denied medical intervention... but it was necessary intervention to provide for a basic need... not something extraordinary. We are called in the Catechism to take all ordinary measures for the preservation of life, it is the extraordinary measures that are optional.
[snip]
[right][snapback]619695[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I think then our disagreement is between what is ordinary and what is extraordinary treatment. I would classify a feeding tube as extraordinary. At least I would tend to. Life-support will fulfill the basic need of breathing by forcing air into the lungs, yet if I recall, you had no dilema about disconnecting life support upon an individual.

A feeding tube is just a different life support, uncommon maybe?

And let me re-affirm that although I see nothing against removing the feeding tube, feeding her and giving her water through ordinary means should have been made possible.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='Didacus' date='Jun 24 2005, 07:04 AM']I think then our disagreement is between what is ordinary and what is extraordinary treatment.  I would classify a feeding tube as extraordinary.  At least I would tend to.  Life-support will fulfill the basic need of breathing by forcing air into the lungs, yet if I recall, you had no dilema about disconnecting life support upon an individual.

A feeding tube is just a different life support, uncommon maybe?

And let me re-affirm that although I see nothing against removing the feeding tube, feeding her and giving her water through ordinary means should have been made possible.
[right][snapback]621357[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Here's the issue: Terri's stomach, intestines... digestive system WORKED COMPLETELY FINE.... ON ITS OWN. Thus, medical interventions aren't going to be extraordinary. A heart-lung machine forces the heart to pump blood and the lungs to expand because they CAN NOT do it themselves. You take the person off the machine, the heart stops, the lungs don't move and they die. You pull out Terri's feeding tube and her entire digestive system still works... it takes her TWO WEEKS to slowly die from dehydration (as the coroner's report attests!). It's like locking a baby in a closet and refusing to feed it until it starves to death...

Extraordinary means force the BODY to work. Terri's body was working properly, just troubles swallowing but M. Shiavo refused to allow her to have therapy to learn to swallow on her own again... thus, in order to get food and water to her stomach, they used a feeding tube.

Like I said somewhere before... A kid I went to high school with talked through a hole in his throat-- and couldn't eat through his mouth, so he had a feeding tube (and will have to have one his entire life). Other than the fact that he's not confined to his bed like Terri, they have most everything else in common (he even had minor brain damage). Is it okay to remove his feeding tube?

Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Jun 24 2005, 07:50 AM'][snip]

Terri's body was working properly, just troubles swallowing but M. Shiavo refused to allow her to have therapy to learn to swallow on her own again...

[snip]
[right][snapback]621397[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

THAT is where I see the wrong, not in the removing of the feeding tube. the feeding tube wasx the means by which to ingest the food, not digest it. Like a lung machine forces air into the lungs, but does not perform the functions of the lung itself. the lung machine forces the lungs to 'ingest' the air - that is all.

Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Jun 24 2005, 07:50 AM'][snip]
Like I said somewhere before... A kid I went to high school with talked through a hole in his throat-- and couldn't eat through his mouth, so he had a feeding tube (and will have to have one his entire life). Other than the fact that he's not confined to his bed like Terri, they have most everything else in common (he even had minor brain damage). Is it okay to remove his feeding tube?
[right][snapback]621397[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Refusing extraordinary treatment is not a sin? If the 'kid' you refer to chose to have such means, it is perfectly permissible. I do not contrest this.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='Didacus' date='Jun 24 2005, 09:00 AM']THAT is where I see the wrong, not in the removing of the feeding tube.  the feeding tube wasx the means by which to ingest the food, not digest it.  Like a lung machine forces air into the lungs, but does not perform the functions of the lung itself.  the lung machine forces the lungs to 'ingest' the air - that is all.
[right][snapback]621402[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
NO... the lung machine forces the lungs to perform because the don't perfom on their own... I'm serious. Get out a medical textbook or something.

[quote]Refusing extraordinary treatment is not a sin? If the 'kid' you refer to chose to have such means, it is perfectly permissible. I do not contrest this.[/quote]
No, it's not a sin. But a feeding tube is NOT extraordinary means. The body works completely fine (with a heart/lung machine the body does NOT work on it's own).
The kid I went to high school with could walk, talk, and do a lot on his own (he had to be supervised because of the brain damage)... but you would honestly think it okay for his parents to remove his feeding tube (when it's IMPOSSIBLE for him to be fed through his mouth... he would choke to death and suffocate)? Honestly? It would take him that same 2 weeks, if not more before he died like Terri.

...you take away a heart/lung machine and the person dies within minutes.

Other than that. I don't think I can calmly discuss this topic anymore, as my opinion is not going to waver in the slightest bit because it goes against the principles of the Catholic faith:

CCC 2277 "Whatever its motives and means, [u]direct euthanasia consists in putting an end to the lives of handicapped, sick, or dying persons[/u]. [b]It is morally unacceptable[/b].

Thus an act or[b] omission which, of itself or by intention, causes death in order to eliminate suffering constitutes a murder gravely contrary to the dignity of the human person [/b]and to the respect due to the living God, his Creator. The error of judgment into which one can fall in good faith does not change the nature of this murderous act, which must always be forbidden and excluded. "

Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Jun 24 2005, 08:27 AM']NO... the lung machine forces the lungs to perform because the don't perfom on their own... I'm serious. Get out a medical textbook or something.
[right][snapback]621416[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Whatever... So breathing aparratus only force air into the lungs... i was not refering to an iron lung...

The misfunction of her body was that it could no longer ingest food on its own... not a question of digestion.

I restate that this is where we disagree.

I believe we agree on just about everything else...

Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Jun 24 2005, 08:27 AM'][snip]
CCC 2277 "Whatever its motives and means, [u]direct euthanasia consists in putting an end to the lives of handicapped, sick, or dying persons[/u]. [b]It is morally unacceptable[/b].
snip][right][snapback]621416[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

By reading this, refusal of any medical treatment that may extend life is unaccpetable.

Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Jun 24 2005, 08:27 AM'][snip]
Other than that. I don't think I can calmly discuss this topic anymore, as my opinion is not going to waver in the slightest bit because it goes against the principles of the Catholic faith:
[snip][right][snapback]621416[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

As you wish...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...