Theologian in Training Posted June 30, 2005 Posted June 30, 2005 (edited) I know I am going to get a lot of flack for this, but here goes: I realize, as anyone can realize that this sister clearly was not in line with what the Catholic Church teaches. She has her own innovations and had some interesting ideas, to say the very least. However, it is also clear that she is a very emotional and sensitive person. No one comes on a phorum for a few days and decides to leave the Catholic Church because of what a few people say. It is also clear that those emotions interfere and help her to determine what she believes, and may even take it a bit far, by believing herself a mystic, but really not discerning message as much as being aware of the great love which she feels. Now, I am not at all trying to justify her actions, nor what she has said, but I do believe that we were a bit harsh in judging her out of hand, based on a few posts that were clearly not in line with Church teaching. I am not going to get into the others we have readily accepted who wane back and forth between that teaching, and yet, whom we readily accept despite that. However, I don't believe that our encounters with her were all that charitable, and dare I say, Christian. Again, granted, she was obviously struggling with a few things, but, to be honest, we barely gave her the benefit of the doubt. We were more eager to call her out on the carpet as a heretic, a heterodox, or any other label we wanted to give her. Sometimes I think, in doing so, we make it appear as though we are a happy family, until someone else, who does not agree with us, tries to befriend us. Then, without hesitation, we slap on the label on them and send them on their merry way. I realize we are to uphold and defend the Catholic Church and all of Her beliefs, however, I don't know that some of the methods we use are as effective as much as they are damaging. Again, I am not trying to justify her actions, but I think sometimes in the heat of the battle, as it were, we forget the person with whom we are battling, and only want to argue the issues, even though it is a person who has formed those beliefs and who clearly feels and is hurt...."if you prick us do we not bleed?" Just something to think about..... God Bless Edited June 30, 2005 by Theologian in Training
Fides_et_Ratio Posted June 30, 2005 Posted June 30, 2005 I see where you are coming from (and now that you're a deacon, I suppose I have to tread carefully on my words)... However, it was never my intent in my posts to be spiteful or "mean" to her. My concern was for others who didn't recognize her words as being out of line with the Catholic faith, and the intent of my post was to understand where she was coming from. All my offensiveness was done over PM to Cmotherofpirl (to see if dUSt could put a "phishy" warning on her to help others reading her posts), and I kept all my discussions with anchoress public on the boards. At the same time, we can't just ignore misrepresentations of the Church when they appear. In this case, I think the "over sensitivity" that the internet tends to draw out since we can't see faces and read emotions played a HUGE misunderstanding. I wasn't out to attack anchoress... I wanted her to explain herself further, clarify her order (that we might see her use of the "Catholic Church" is different), and clarify that she herself is not Catholic in the sense of adhering to the Pope in Rome (as her "main website" attested to. It seemed as though many PMers were confused, etc.)... we can't just openly trust everyone who claims to be a religious. It can be dangerous. I don't know. Achoress didn't have to leave (the Church or phatmass), and it was not my intent to attack her personally... I was trying to understand where she was coming from.
Theologian in Training Posted June 30, 2005 Author Posted June 30, 2005 Ok, at the outset, I want to thank some of you for providing more information about this sister, and some of the ways in which she caused more confusion and division. However, I wrote what I did, not justify her actions, as I repeatedly said, but rather as a friendly reminder that we have to be careful how we come across. I am not at all saying anything she did was right nor any of those things she promulgated, rather, from what I saw, she was not given a chance to give her position, because so many jumped on her for her clearly wrong views. She was obviously a very fragile woman, who had a lot of things that she was wrestling with, and, personally, I believe the approach that was used in trying to help her was not the best approach. Perhaps, it is not the best time for a story, but I think it might help elucidate what I am trying to say and convey. As many of you know, last summer I was at a Veterans Hospital, visiting patients and bringing communion to those that were Catholic. One day I met a very nice man who also happened to be a Protestant minister. Immediately, he went on the defensive and, in many ways tried to convert me. I listened patiently to what he had to say, and merely listened. He then offered me a book, it was a book outlining basic Evangelical belief, I thanked him for it and left. I looked at it that night and it raised a lot of questions for me, of which I raised with him. He answered many of the questions, but all with the underlying motive of trying to convert me. However, I was prepared this time with a tract of my own to give him, of which I did. It was "Pillar of Fire Pillar of Truth." We parted ways and I never saw him again. One of the seminarians who had my wing (we shifted each week) told me he met this Protestant Minister and the minister told him to tell me how much he enjoyed the tract I gave him. The seminarian noted how happy he was and how much he really enjoyed that tract. Now, I don't quite know whether he enjoyed it so much because it laid out the fundamental Catholic beliefs of which he could refute, or because there was something in it that he liked and really latched on to. Either way, had I not sat there to listen to what he believed, and let him try to convert me he definitely would not have trusted me enough to take that tract from me. I am sure most people know what I am saying with this story, and, again, I am not trying to justify any of the sister's actions. I just believe we visibly went on the defensive before listening to everything she had to say publicly, since i am also aware she was giving private spiritual direction through email. Also, while I appreciate the fact that you respect the office to which I have been ordained, you do not have to "tread carefully" on your words....you would be surprised what I have heard and still hear God Bless
PedroX Posted June 30, 2005 Posted June 30, 2005 Theo, Thank you for sharing your concerns with us. I believe there is much wisdom in what you say, and as always I appreciate the spirit of Charity that you share with us. I am however closing this thread as it is not directly related to the subject of the board. Please continue to post freely on conversion, both to Catholicism and in an ongoing way within the Catholic faith. peace...
Recommended Posts