geetarplayer Posted August 23, 2005 Posted August 23, 2005 Should the Church declare the notion of Mary as "Coredemptrix, Mediatrix and Advocate of Nations" to be the fifth Marian dogma? Explain your answer. -Mark
Fides_et_Ratio Posted August 23, 2005 Posted August 23, 2005 It's already doctrine, and therefore must be believed, making it dogma would only solidify what is already true about our Blessed Mother and would complete all Marian teachings of the Church.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted August 23, 2005 Posted August 23, 2005 Yes, I believe so. Just read "With Jesus" by Dr. Mark Miravalle. Brilliant and simple.
Era Might Posted August 23, 2005 Posted August 23, 2005 Pope Benedict is strongly against this title, as he explains in his book "God and the World": [quote]"I do not think there will be any compliance with this demand, which in the meantime is being supported by several million people, within the foreseeable future. The response of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith is, broadly, that what is signified by this is already better expressed in other titles of Mary, while the formula 'Co-redemptrix' departs to too great an extent from the language of Scripture and of the Fathers and therefore gives rise to misunderstandings. "What is true here? Well, it is true that Christ does not remain outside us or to one side of us, but builds a profound and new community with us. Everything that is his becomes ours, and everything that is ours he has taken upon himself, so that it becomes his: this great exchange is the actual content of redemption, the removal of limitations from our self and its extension into community with God. Because Mary is the prototype of the Church as such and is, so to say, the Church in person, this being “with” is realized in her in exemplary fashion. "But this 'with' must not lead us to forget the 'first' of Christ: Everything comes from Him, as the Letter to the Ephesians and the Letter to Colossians, in particular, tell us; Mary, too, is everything that she is through Him. "The word 'Co-redemptrix' would obscure this origin. For matters of faith, continuity of terminology with the language of Scripture and that of the Fathers is itself an essential element; it is improper simply to manipulate language."[/quote]
geetarplayer Posted August 23, 2005 Author Posted August 23, 2005 Hmm. That makes me sad. I don't think it's appropriate at all. -Mark
Fides_et_Ratio Posted August 23, 2005 Posted August 23, 2005 Very interesting Era Might... thanks for posting that. I wonder how this will develop under his papacy now. The movement was definitely gaining speed under JPII, who was a large proponent (many thought he would declare it).
SarahB Posted August 23, 2005 Posted August 23, 2005 That's interesting. I've always heard arguments for both sides of this debate, but never quite anything like that for the "no" category. He gives a very good explination, though. Gotta love our Papa.
Fides_et_Ratio Posted August 23, 2005 Posted August 23, 2005 [quote name='geetarplayer' date='Aug 23 2005, 04:32 PM']Hmm. That makes me sad. I don't think it's appropriate at all. -Mark [right][snapback]696017[/snapback][/right] [/quote] The "co" means "with" NOT "equal" to, which is the common misconception, and why so many reject it.. and probably why many consider it unScriptural. Mary IS the "woman WITH the Redeemer" ("co-redemptrix" in Latin)... Mary is very clearly with Christ our Redeemer all throughout Scripture, even unto the Cross. The language of "co-redemptrix", however, can be confusing for the majority, and is probably why the title is disliked so much.
Laudate_Dominum Posted August 23, 2005 Posted August 23, 2005 It's definitive doctrine.. True there is some controversy regarding which title is the best expression of the doctrine. But considering the number of saints and popes who have promoted the title, I don't think there is anything wrong with it. Ratzinger's opinion (pre B16) in that book is no uncommon, but there are a great many cardinals who would disagree. JP2 had no problem using the title for example. But I admit it can take some explaining. And if the title was used in proclaiming the doctrine of Our Lady's role in the redemption, it would certainly require a lot of explaining since many people (esp. Protestants) would not understand what it means. God bless.
StColette Posted August 23, 2005 Posted August 23, 2005 From what I understand, just reading that section that Era posted, he doesn't seem to disagree with the fact that Mary is called Co-Redemptrix merely he sees a problem with the terminology. He seems to point out what many other Theologians have said. That we must truly understand what the title would mean and not get confused with the "co" part. I've researched until I was exhausted on this topic. I believe in it and think it should be declared dogma. If it isn't declared dogma, it will continue to be doctrine, I'm sure, and thus still be held as truth.
StColette Posted August 23, 2005 Posted August 23, 2005 [quote name='SarahB' date='Aug 23 2005, 03:34 PM']That's interesting. I've always heard arguments for both sides of this debate, but never quite anything like that for the "no" category. He gives a very good explination, though. Gotta love our Papa. [right][snapback]696023[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Papa Ben is not saying no to the dogma, he is saying no to the terminology. Co-Redemptrix confuses a number of people because of the "co" part, which some people take to mean "equal" when it actually means "with". He is merely stating that we need better terminology for the dogma, not that the dogma is a "no go"
Fides_et_Ratio Posted August 23, 2005 Posted August 23, 2005 the reason it has not been declared dogma is precisely the wording. one has to say faithfully and briefly exactly that which needs to be said and nothing more. such a loaded title oftentimes takes more explanation for now.
SarahB Posted August 23, 2005 Posted August 23, 2005 Well, I certaintly believe it to be true as it is doctrine, but I think the Holy Father gives a good explination as to why it shouldn't be declared dogma, at least at this point. However, if it ever is declared dogma that will be great also. We'll just have to wait and see.
Laudate_Dominum Posted August 23, 2005 Posted August 23, 2005 "the formula 'Co-redemptrix' departs to too great an extent from the language of Scripture and of the Fathers" There is very strong support for the Title in Scripture and the Fathers. Heck, many Fathers refer to Our Lady as the Redemptrix.. Co-Redemptrix wasn't used until like the 15th century and is watered down compared to the patristic title. And I can think of a great many formulas and titles that depart from the language of Scripture and the Fathers.. How many doctrines are based on the language of scholastic Theology rather than Scriptural or Patristic language? Why is this a problem now. And calling Mary the New Eve (along side the New Adam), seems to be at least as extreme as Co-Redemptrix, and yet this is a Sciptural motif and is used by the Fathers from the very beginning (the fragments of Papias are the earliest writings that I know of which uses this and they predate many of the New Testament writings). I could go on, as there are many problems with that statement, but suffice it to say that I am pretty disappointed.
StColette Posted August 23, 2005 Posted August 23, 2005 [quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Aug 23 2005, 03:42 PM']the reason it has not been declared dogma is precisely the wording. one has to say faithfully and briefly exactly that which needs to be said and nothing more. such a loaded title oftentimes takes more explanation for now. [right][snapback]696041[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Exactly, I've had to explain this title a number of times and it can really be troublesome.
Laudate_Dominum Posted August 23, 2005 Posted August 23, 2005 And furthermore.. Based on Marian journals that I've seen before the council (such as Marian Studies, which before the mid 60's published beautiful articles about Mariology, but today seems to publish more about feminine godess imagery in Buddhism than Catholic Mariology), there was no legitimate opposition to the title prior to the onslaught of false-ecumenism and anti-Marianism that followed the Council. When I consider the sheer number of Saints and Popes who have used the Title, I wonder how it can even be considered an issue. I mean, isn't something considered definitively taught by the magisterium after many repeated papal statements? I remember reading that in something else Cardinal Ratzinger wrote, in the name of the CDF.
Theoketos Posted August 23, 2005 Posted August 23, 2005 My soul proclaims the greatness of the Lord, and my spirit rejoices in God, my salvation. For he has shown me such favour – me, his lowly handmaiden. Now all generations will call me blessed, because the mighty one has done great things for me. His name is holy, his mercy lasts for generation after generation for those who revere him. He has put forth his strength: he has scattered the proud and conceited, torn princes from their thrones; but lifted up the lowly. He has filled the hungry with good things; the rich he has sent away empty. He has come to the help of his servant Israel, he has remembered his mercy as he promised to our fathers, to Abraham and his children for ever. Glory be to the Father and to the Son and to the Holy Spirit, as it was in the beginning, is now, and ever shall be, world without end. Amen.
Era Might Posted August 23, 2005 Posted August 23, 2005 (edited) Someone above mentioned a work by Miravelle. I found this critique, for reference: [url="http://www.catholicculture.org/docs/doc_view.cfm?recnum=4074"]http://www.catholicculture.org/docs/doc_view.cfm?recnum=4074[/url] (I don't necessarily agree with all the author's conclusions.) Edited August 23, 2005 by Era Might
Fides_et_Ratio Posted August 23, 2005 Posted August 23, 2005 I took Miravalle's class (well, Mariology I anyhow), and own the book in question (as well as a few others by him). At first, I was a bit concerned... but his Mariology is really Christocentric once you hear him out... you just have to pay attention for more than 5 minutes. He draws EXTENSIVELY on the Scriptures and Sacred Tradition and also on the words of the Popes themselves... the catholicculture.org author's critique of Miravalle's etymology falls painfully short in one large respect. Miravalle's etymology is based on the LATIN. The English "co"s that the author come up with cannot compare because they are in a different language! Perhaps the title should be changed to "Cum Redemptrix" but that's for the Holy Father who declares the dogma to decide.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now