Laudate_Dominum Posted September 10, 2005 Posted September 10, 2005 [b]From L_D:[/b] [i]While I admit the analogy of being is not, strictly speaking, apophatic (and personally I'm glad), I would say that the direction of the "analogia entis" ultimately ends on apophatism. I recently read something on the pontifications website which essentially highlights precisely what I've always known and at times attempted to articulate.[/i] I recently spoke to Fr Gregory Rocca, author of Speaking the Incomprehensible God, and asked him if the God of St Thomas Aquinas was subsumable under the categories of being. Absolutely not! he replied. For Thomas, God is ipsum esse subsistens, self-subsistent being. (Esse is the infinitive form of the verb “to be.”) This is an understanding achieved, Thomas believed, not by human reason alone but by divine revelation. As Moses learned on Mount Sinai, God’s proper name is “He Who Is” (Ex 3:13-14): [quote]The essence of God is his esse. Moses was taught this sublime truth by the Lord, when Moses asked the Lord, “If the children of Israel ask me, What is his Name?, what shall I say to them? And the Lord replied: “I am Who am. Thus thou shalt say to the children of Israel: He who Is has sent me to you,” showing that his proper name is Who Is. But every name is intended to signify the nature or essence of a thing. Hence it remains that the divine esse is God’s essence or nature. (Contra Gentiles I.xxii)[/quote] Thomas is clear that God is not a being; he is being; yet when applied to God, even being must be apophatically qualified. Interpreters of Thomas are quite clear on this point. For St Thomas deity is most definitely not subsumable under the categories of human reason. He is a God who transcends finite being, composite being, creaturely being. Thomas takes the Augustinian formula “God is being” and significantly redefines it. For Thomas, God is the sheer act of existing, the doing of all existence. God is not a noun but a verb. “When St Augustine read the name of God,” Gilson writes, “he understood ‘I am he who never changes.’ St. Thomas reading the same words understood them to mean ‘I am the pure act-of-being’” (The Christian Philosophy of Thomas Aquinas [1956], p. 93). E. L. Mascall elaborates: [quote]St. Thomas … sees God’s fundamental attribute as that of self-subsistent being. And in this he is not merely philosophizing in the abstract. His starting-point is the “metaphysic of Exodus,” the revelation of the name of God as “I am that I am.” Ego sum qui sum, ait sic dices filiis Israel, Qui est misit me ad vos. And the conception of God as ipsum esse subsistens, subsistent being itself, is fundamental to his whole discussion of divine nature. It draws into a unity all the other attributes and operations of God: simplicity, perfection, goodness, infinity, immutability, eternity, unity, his character as Prime Mover, as Uncaused Cause, as Sufficient Reason, as Perfect Pattern and as Final End of all things. It involves that, if God does exist, his existence is identical with his essence. It means that he is not merely the ens maximum, the greatest being that exists, but the maxime ens, that which completely is. (He Who Is [1966], p. 13)[/quote] Aquinas is emphatic in understanding the difference between uncreated being and created being. Again Gilson: [quote]So long as we still imagine what God is, the object of our thought is not yet God. For God is above all the beings we know or imagine. He is even above being itself. To call God being (ens), even the supreme being (summum ens), is not to describe his essence, or that which he is, but only to designate him as the cause of all being…. The cause of being is above being. As we said, it is esse, the infinite esse, in which beings participate in a finite way. This is so true that it could almost do for a definition of being: ens dictur id quod finite participat esse; but of esse itself, there is no definition. We know of it only that “to be” is the very essence of God. (The Spirit of Thomism [1964], pp. 79, 81-82)[/quote] And lest anyone think that the above represents an idiosyncratic interpretation of the Angelic Doctor, I reference the post-modernist French philosopher, Jean-Luc Marion, who provocatively refers to the God of Aquinas as “God without Being”: [quote]Even when he thinks God as esse, Saint Thomas nevertheless does not chain God either to Being or to metaphysics. He does not chain God to Being because the divine esse immeasurably surpasses (and hardly maintains an analogia with) the ens commune of creatures, which are characterized by the real distinction between esse and their essence, whereas God, and He alone absolutely merges essence with esse: God is expressed as esse, but this esse is expressed only of God, not of the being of metaphysics. In this sense, Being does not erect an idol before God, but saves his distance. Saint Thomas doesn’t chain God to metaphysics either, since he explicitly stresses that ‘res divinae non tractantur a philosophis, nisi prout sun rerum omnium principia’: divine things do not belong to metaphysics as one of its objects; rather, they only intervene in metaphysics indirectly in the cpacity of principles for its objects, ‘non tanquam subjectum scientiae, sed tanquam, principia subjecti.’ Between metaphysics (with its domain, common Being) and God, the relation, even and especially for Saint Thomas, has to do not with inclusion but with subordination: God, as principle, subjugates the subjects of philosophy to himself. Consequently, since the subjects of philosophy belong to Being, we must go so far as to conclude that their cause, God, also causes Being itself: “Deus est causa universalis totius esse.’ But if God causes Being, wouldn’t we have to admit that for Saint Thomas himself, God can be expressed without Being? (God Without Being [1991], pp. xxiii-xxiv)[/quote]
Laudate_Dominum Posted September 14, 2005 Author Posted September 14, 2005 man, no one digs this topic.
p-hawk Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 While I'm unfamiliar with some of the terms, namely apophawhatsit, this is absolutely fascinating. This is why Thomas can't accept Anselm's argument for the existence of God, since that argument from the very beginning labels God a thing.
Fides_et_Ratio Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 I like St. Anselm's argument.... and I like St. Thomas, and I'm not sure I really buy into St. Thomas' criticism of Anselm's ontological argument... I like St. Anselm. He rocks..."Come now, insignificant mortal..." Anyhow, L_D, when you're talking "Gilson" you're referring to Etienne Gilson, right?
p-hawk Posted September 20, 2005 Posted September 20, 2005 What other Gilson is there? (and that's a serious question: I'd like to know). And I [i]still[/i] don't know what apophawhatsit is.
Laudate_Dominum Posted September 20, 2005 Author Posted September 20, 2005 [quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Sep 20 2005, 09:36 AM']Anyhow, L_D, when you're talking "Gilson" you're referring to Etienne Gilson, right? [right][snapback]730930[/snapback][/right] [/quote] yup.
Guest jkriordan Posted August 29, 2006 Posted August 29, 2006 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' post='723608' date='Sep 14 2005, 05:50 PM'] man, no one digs this topic. [/quote] Apophatism is a fascinating topic, and an important one. : It's an essential key to bringing the Gospel to postmodern society! I'm writing a brief essay on the subject. When I'm done, I'll beta-test it on this thread or start a new one. Are the people who started this thread still active on this board?
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted August 29, 2006 Posted August 29, 2006 LD is active. I have not seen Apotheoun for quite some time.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now