Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Read: Prevalence Of Couples Living Together


Recommended Posts

Posted

i guess that's what i wanted to say lil' red. living together b4 marraige is bad, but i'm not ready to say that it's impossible for people who do so to stay together.

exactly! We don't know if people are going to get married or not. Maybe they think living together is the best thing for them to do. We don't know their hearts. I'm just trying to say that marriage is hard enough as it is. I didn't really want to read that article (after I found out what was about) because, you know, marriage is hard enough without all the statistics. And we can't tell someone that they are doomed to fail just because they did something they shouldn't have. All of us have made mistakes, and I'm sure that my parents' prayers for us had a lot to do with my hubby and I finally making a commitment to each other.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Living in sin ( what we used to call it) simply means I will have sex with you exclusively until I find somebody else to have sex with exclusively.

Without a commitment, there is simply sin.

People have had successful marriages after living in sin, but it is much harder.

Relationship patterns are set up without committment do not easily turn into relationship patterns OF committment.

If you are having sex with someone before marriage , chances are you are not paying attention to all the other things that are needed in a good relationship. You are probably also using contraception which is a basic denial of the marriage act, although sex is probably the reasoning you are living together in the first place. Contraception teaches men to treat women as objects of pleasure, rather than a partner given to them by God.

Posted (edited)

Very well put! I do believe that people who are having sex outside of marriage are blinded by the physical pleasure rather than using there intellect. We have to accept the ideal that sex is a beautiful gift from the Lord to show your love for your SPOUSE but it has to be done in the right context.

Personally, I think sex in a dating relationship cheapens/lessens the commitment between the two. I myself would have to wonder if I was in that situation, if I loved her or what she is giving me.

Like everything else in life you have to follow the proper path to attain the goal.

Edited by Frankcdnj
Kilroy the Ninja
Posted

Lil Red - I believe that a marriage can work after cohabitation - particularly if that marriage is in the Church. Frank was just pointing out the statics he found and my situation happened to agree with those statistics. It's wonderful that your situation has turned into the real deal. Please don't take offense at his post as I'm sure it was not directed at you personally.

Posted

Lil Red, I did not start this thread to offend anyone. I wanted to show some of the younger forum members that it may not be a good idea. And as the statistics show the overwhelming majority of cohabitant relationships do not end in marriage. I have to nieces who lived with there boyfriends and they never married those they lived with.

Be grateful that you are an exception to the norm and be happy!

So, do not take offense to this.

Posted

More stats:

Eight years. If you do manage to marry somebody, close your eyes, shut your mouth, and hang around for eight years. Statistically, marriages that last eight years have a terrific chance of lasting a lifetime.

Two parents. . . marriages with children have a much higher success rate than childless ones.

hyperdulia again
Posted

not everyone who isn't lucky enough to be heterosexual, married, and catholic is necessarily running around mindlessly mounting things/people.

Posted

Living in sin ( what we used to call it) simply means I will have sex with you exclusively until I find somebody else to have sex with exclusively.

Without a commitment, there is simply sin.

People have had successful marriages after living in sin, but it is much harder.

Relationship patterns are set up without committment do not easily turn into relationship patterns OF committment.

If you are having sex with someone before marriage , chances are you are not paying attention to all the other things that are needed in a good relationship. You are probably also using contraception which is a basic denial of the marriage act, although sex  is probably the reasoning you are living together in the first place. Contraception teaches men to treat women as objects of pleasure, rather than a partner given to them by God.

;)

Living in sin is still what it is. I have friends who are now getting married in the Church now and that is much prayer that has been answered. We are not judging them, but making them aware that by living in sin is wrong. I love my friends so much and at first they took a HUGE offense. Now, they are getting married in the Church. They will have the blessings and graces from the Church. God is good and merciful but hurt feelings will not stop me from helping my friends get to heaven. and it's a two way street, we help each other.

Posted

jmjtina,

I could not have said it better myself. We are all sinners but not to the same degree. I talk with people who are living together or have relations outside of marriage to help them and NOT judge them. Remember those without sin shall cast the first stone. Well, you had better believe it will not be I.

Plus, the sins of the world result in chastisements or punishment. As our Blessed Mother said at Fatima: "War is a punishment from God for sins !"

And we are all paying dearly for the free love that has come upon our world.

We are above the animal kingdom because we have free will to make a choice between good and evil. And it would be nice if people used the gifts God instilled in them at birth and throughout their lives.

Posted

Kilroy and Frank, no offense taken. ;)

Posted

Thank you Lil Red, that makes me feel better!

And you may like this. I met a man who told me he married a virgin bride and divorced her 3 years later. The reason being she did not like normal/regular sex, she thought it was dirty. So, the next woman he married he had relations prior to marriage. And they have been married for 14 years.

So, there it goes to show you that on rare ocassions what the church feels is best is not always best for everyone.

Again, I do not condone his actions but then again in the same breath I can not blame him. This is a very touchy issue for me.

Posted (edited)

And you may like this.  I met a man who told me he married a virgin bride and divorced her 3 years later.  The reason being she did not like normal/regular sex, she thought it was dirty. So, the next woman he married he had relations prior to marriage.  And they have been married for 14 years.

Keep in mind too that unless his first wife has died or his first marriage was not a marriage recognized by the Catholic Church or he had an annulment he is living in a state of adultery......

So, there it goes to show you that on rare ocassions what the church feels is best is not always best for everyone.

Now I have to add something to this.....

I could easily say that cheating on my income taxes, or statutory rape, or aborting a child is best for me, if you want to carry that stance to it's logical outcome.

Edited by Norseman82
Posted (edited)

You are sharp! I neglected to mention the man was granted an annulment since the church viewed sexual relations a necessary part of a marriage.

Now I have to add something to this.....

I could easily say that cheating on my income taxes, or statutory rape, or aborting a child is best for me, if you want to carry that stance to it's logical outcome.

Yes, you are right but I did not say the church was wrong very much, this could be 1/100 of a percent that marrying a virgin did not work. He said he did think of marrying another virgin or dating a woman whom was not a virgin and asking both how they thought about sex. But I am getting off the issue aren't I.

So, say you had a first child who was mentally challenged, you then decide to abort the next fearing it maybe the same. Obviously that is serious and a grave sin. You can not say that the church is wrong regarding abortion in this case because you never gave the child the benefit of the doubt. Plus, regardless of the child's condition it would be murder.

You are right, never can a sin be regarded as a correct choice no matter what the circumstances.

Good Job Sherlock, I made a faux paus!

And I showed my fallibilty, I must go and hide. Just kidding!

Seriously, that was a good call.

Edited by Frankcdnj
Posted

Saying that a study says something is different than a study actually saying that. Anyone can twist the words of research. It's called propaganda.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Saying that a study says something is different than a study actually saying that. Anyone can twist the words of research. It's called propaganda.

Fortunately this study isn't propaganda.

Posted

I see this study as correct. My goodness, everyone I know is shacking up with their lover as they put it. I have never and never will do this. But then again I am old fashion and not up to speed with the current in crowd.

My grandmother, God rest her soul, at 85 years of age told me she would look less favorably upon me if I ever lived with a woman. And I stayed my ground for her and my own personal beliefs.

Well as many priests tell you in their homily, they have the feeling that many of their preachings go upon deaf ears.

Feel sorry for those blinded by sin.

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

I emailed my friend the exorcist this question:

Father, is it wrong for me to pursue a non-virtuous woman as a spouse even though I am still a virgin? In knowing a woman has repented of her past life, is this enough to assure me she will be a devoted wife?

Reply:

Greetings and may God be with you. You are to be commended for your attempt and desire to do the right thing. However, I am confident that there are many women who remain virgins until they are married.

But more importantly, remember that sinners can be forgiven when they have sorrow for their sin. Anyone can commit a sin, but only the faithful can be forgiven (because the others do not have sorrow for their sin.

When a person has gone to confession and her or his sins have been forgiven, we do not need to recall any sin that was committed--because God does not.

Therefore the answer to your question is that you certainly marry someone who had fallen into sin before. For if God has forgiven the sin, should no we do so also?

Of course, there are other considerations too, such as the other person's lifestyle, danger of AIDS or other disease, and his or her basic belief system. For one of these reasons, one may conclude it is not in the best interest of either person to marry.

Morally speaking, however, if the person has been to confession and had the sins forgiven, we have no reason to remember the sin either.

But of course they’re other considerations that come into the picture. The likelihood of faithfulness throughout the marriage must be considered also.

I hope this helps.

Posted (edited)

I believe the reason all these statistics are true is that most of those who cohabit do not have God in their lives like they should. They may believe in God, but they have to walk the walk, too. Those who take their faith very seriously would most likely not cohabit because they know what a horrible sin it is, and would want to avoid something like that. Cohabitation cheapens love and marriage, and I believe that these are the same people who wouldn't take marriage seriously enough to stay faithful and monogomous. As for these couples being unhappy, I'd be pretty unhappy, too, if I didn't have God in my life!

I am not trying to offend anyone by saying these things. I know that there have been successful marriages of cohabiting couples. But that's the exception, it seems, and not the norm. If you're reading this and you're cohabiting with someone, please take a good look at these statistics and reconsider what you're doing. Please pray about it, and I'll be praying for you, too.

God bless. :)

Edited by MrsFrozen

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...