Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

bush is also one of the few who are willing to put a stop to abortion.

through him millions of innocent babies can be saved from this horrific crime.

Posted

Ummm . . . do you have an idea how the legal system works?  The governor does not order the death penalty, judges and juries do.  In Texas the governor can't even pardon people on Death Row, nor can he commute their sentences.  According to State Law, all the governor can do is delay their death by 30 days.  That's it.

Didn't a governor eliminate or stop the execution of a death row prisoner when JPII personally asked that governor to intervene? Even if this is the law, governors still have the obligation to intervene if the person being executed has not been completely cleared of innocence. Why would you go to an execution vigil outside a prison if you believe the state has not sinned in it's quest to insure security for the public, I would personally like to know why?

Posted (edited)

the methods, whether itsSuction Curettage Abortion (the vaccum method, body part by body part from the womb) , Dilatation and Evacuation (D & E) (using forceps to pull the baby out, again part by part), or any other procedure....(such as the intake of harmful salts, etc that slowly kills the child by poisoning,etc.)

the procedures of abortion are what make it so evil then any thing ever....and not only the procedures but the place that it takes place to kill the unborn child.

from the womb.

if we can do that, anything can be allowed.

You forgot to mention the little known Saline Method where the baby in burned inside out. I had to watch all of these on video as a junior pro-life religion requirement in high school.

I wasn't trying to downplay the horrors of abortion, but I ask the question if murder is murder in God's eyes - all equally damnable to hell to the unrepentant person(s) responsible and accountable.

Just like I feel acountable when my money goes towards contaceptives and abortion in charity donations, I also feel partially responsible if my tax dollars are paying for the executions of possibly innocent people.

Edited by M.SIGGA
littleflower+JMJ
Posted

You forgot to mention the little known Saline Method where the baby in burned inside out. I had to watch all of these on video as a junior pro-life religion requirement in high school.

I wasn't trying to downplay the horrors of abortion, but I ask the question if murder is murder in God's eyes - all equally damnable to hell to the unrepentant  person(s) responsible and accountable.

reread my post. i mention it.

good job. what i didn't know was the technical term for it. :)

+JMJ

Posted

Didn't a governor eliminate or stop the execution of a death row prisoner when JPII personally asked that governor to intervene? Even if this is the law, governors still have the obligation to intervene if the person being executed has not been completely cleared of innocence. Why would you go to an execution vigil outside a prison if you believe the state has not sinned in it's quest to insure security for the public, I would personally like to know why?

Governors from different states have different laws they have to abide by. I was just pointing out what the law is in Texas. Governors from other states may or may not have the authority to pardon or commute.

Posted

M. Sigga . . .the state cannot sin it doesn't have a soul. I don't go to Vigils because I believe the state is culpable, I go to Vigils to give witness to this man who is being killed (not murdered). I want him to know, spiritually and symbollically, that his life is important to me too. That I want him to have life and have it abundantly. I also go to give witness to the power of prayer and conversion. I go to send a message to the state that, although it might have the authority to do this, I am very much against it exercising this authority.

Think of this way, Parents may have the authority to make their children sit on the floor and eat their food out of a dog dish when they misbehave. This may not even be a sin (although I don't really know) but I still think this is the wrong way to go about disciplining your child because you don't give full expression to their human dignity with this punishment. The same, in a way, goes for the death penalty. I think it is allowable but I also think, in my prudential judgement, that there are better ways to punish a criminal and redress the wrongs they committed which enhances even the criminals human dignity and by virtue of that, all of our human dignity.

Posted

M. Sigga . . .the state cannot sin it doesn't have a soul.  I don't go to Vigils because I believe the state is culpable, I go to Vigils to give witness to this man who is being killed (not murdered).  I want him to know, spiritually and symbollically, that his life is important to me too.  That I want him to have life and have it abundantly.  I also go to give witness to the power of prayer and conversion.  I go to send a message to the state that, although it might have the authority to do this, I am very much against it exercising this authority.

Think of this way, Parents may have the authority to make their children sit on the floor and eat their food out of a dog dish when they misbehave.  This may not even be a sin (although I don't really know) but I still think this is the wrong way to go about disciplining your child because you don't give full expression to their human dignity with this punishment.  The same, in a way, goes for the death penalty.  I think it is allowable but I also think, in my prudential judgement, that there are better ways to punish a criminal and redress the wrongs they committed which enhances even the criminals human dignity and by virtue of that, all of our human dignity.

I think your R. compassionate conservatism and my D. bleeding heart are bumping heads b/c I agree with you for the most part. Thanks for answering my question honestly and with complete charity.

Posted (edited)

I'm a Republican because, quite frankly, they still drink, smoke, and cuss and recognize that we're a bunch of screwed up SOB's who think that we're right. And when we get together we drink good beers and eat red meat and talk like sailors and then go smoke a pipe.

In my experience Liberals are bunch of people who are accidentally right on some things but think they are perfect and Know everything and its ebcause they are so beaver dam perfect. And because they are so annoying with their Trees and No Smoking and imitation leather pantaloons while they eat their vegetarian hummus pita and drink their designer waters . . . blech

Liberals just have a lot of sex, but no fun.

And by the way, I don't think of you as a liberal. You're too cool to be one of "those" people in my mind . .. lol

Edited by BLAZEr
cmotherofpirl
Posted

Avery Cardinal Dulles said on the Legacy of Vatican II (shown on EWTN tonight) that one cannot say that it is wrong for a catholic to be pro-life and also beleive in the death penalty. He said the two could NOT be equated.

Posted

Without getting into a heated debate, isn't the mortal sin of committing murder equally damnable? To the human eye it is worse to murder an innocent baby, but doesn't God love every human unconditionally despite if they are innocent babies or convicts?

Thank you M. Sigga for that question. I wonder if as humans we have a suitable answer...

I suppose the lives are the same worth Loved by God,

yet the reasons for the occurences are not equal....hmm?

Posted

Can we write the Pope in?

I think we should try!!!

Posted (edited)

Avery Cardinal Dulles said on the Legacy of Vatican II (shown on EWTN tonight) that one cannot say that it is wrong for a catholic to be pro-life and also beleive in the death penalty. He said the two could NOT be equated.

Thanks. This question is something that really bothers me and I can't just dismiss it right away so I'm praying on it.

Edited by M.SIGGA
Posted

KUCINCH! ( Dean if Kucinich drops out).

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Is he pro-life ?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...