theculturewarrior Posted November 16, 2005 Posted November 16, 2005 Not everybody has the same health issues I have. If I neglect my health, it is DEFINITELY a near occassion for sin. I guess according to the examination of conscience it is a sin in itself, but for me it is also an occassion to other sins, some of them very serious!
photosynthesis Posted November 16, 2005 Author Posted November 16, 2005 but what about all of the holy saints who fasted for days/weeks on end?
scardella Posted November 16, 2005 Posted November 16, 2005 [quote name='photosynthesis' date='Nov 16 2005, 10:28 AM']but what about all of the holy saints who fasted for days/weeks on end? [right][snapback]791362[/snapback][/right] [/quote] This reminds me of something GK Chesterton said in the book I'm reading. He said that people are proud of being, for instance, non-violent. However, people are non-violent for two reasons: some are not violent because they are magnanimous and show mercy, while others are not violent because they are cowards. Are we to praise those who are non violent because they are cowards? In your case, sleeping, is it praiseworthy if you do not sleep because you cannot? Why did the saints wind up staying up all night? They were caught up in prayer. They had the right ordering of the supernatural over the natural. Fasting can be a sin if you do it for the wrong reasons. As a great example, let us look at St. Francis. You might think that Francis, being so inspired by God's creation and nature, would not fast regularly because of his delight in being incarnational. However, if you were to study his life, this is not the case. He fasted and called his body Brother Ass. Later in life, he lamented how harshly he treated his body. In fact, he died at about 42-44 years old. He had abused his body somewhat to the point that it gave out on him early.
Proud2BCatholic139 Posted November 16, 2005 Posted November 16, 2005 [quote name='ardillacid' date='Nov 16 2005, 12:59 AM']actually if you don't sleep eventually you wil die. [right][snapback]790994[/snapback][/right] [/quote] If you sleep too much, then you will die sooner.
Totus Tuus Posted November 16, 2005 Posted November 16, 2005 Well I think the Bible would have had to also say how much we SHOULD sleep in order to say that not sleeping ENOUGH is a sin. So don't feel bad. Your friend doesn't understand the difference between [i]literal[/i] and [i]literalist[/i] interpreatations of the Scriptures.
iggyjoan Posted June 2, 2007 Posted June 2, 2007 [quote name='ardillacid' post='790994' date='Nov 16 2005, 02:59 AM']actually if you don't sleep eventually you wil die. [/quote] well eventully u will die anyways
Ash Wednesday Posted June 2, 2007 Posted June 2, 2007 I should have told landscapers running a chainsaw at a ridiculous hour this morning that they were causing me to sin and should be tied to a millstone and drowned.
prose Posted June 2, 2007 Posted June 2, 2007 [quote name='photosynthesis' post='791349' date='Nov 16 2005, 10:08 AM']that's kind of what allison said. after I felt really bad, she said "well, for me it's a sin. I don't know if it is for you." and I said, "OK, so if I murder, it's a sin... but if someone else murders, it's not a sin for them? that doesn't work for me." I know that distinguishing a mortal vs. venial sin can depend on the individual, but as for whether something is or is not a sin... it seems to me like that would be applied universally. It's either a sin, or it's not.[/quote] Well, let's say that you are a paranoid schizophrenic. In your delusions, you killed someone. Are you as culpable as a completely sane person? I don't think so. Same thing here. If you are ill and can not sleep, then it is not the same as abusing your body by forcing it to stay up for extended periods of time. So if you want to go with either it is a sin, or it is not, you are going to find that sometimes there are grey areas.
franciscanheart Posted June 2, 2007 Posted June 2, 2007 [quote name='photosynthesis' post='791349' date='Nov 16 2005, 10:08 AM']that's kind of what allison said. after I felt really bad, she said "well, for me it's a sin. I don't know if it is for you." and I said, "OK, so if I murder, it's a sin... but if someone else murders, it's not a sin for them? that doesn't work for me." I know that distinguishing a mortal vs. venial sin can depend on the individual, but as for whether something is or is not a sin... it seems to me like that would be applied universally. It's either a sin, or it's not.[/quote] So many things could be labeled 'sins' though! And I think your protestant friend is right and I'm sad that you blamed it on her being protestant!! Very sad... Something that is sinful for me (or could lead to sin) may not be sinful for you because (1) you do not know what you are doing (2) the action does not violate some other moral or virtue which you posess/it will not lead you to further sinfulness. I guess it's a little difficult to explain. Watching a certain show may not be sinful for me but it could be for you. I may be able to watch the show and laugh at some jokes or appreciate struggles. You, however, may watch the show knowing that you are 'turned on' by a certain character or what-have-you. You cannot watch that show without it being sinful for you. However, that show does not have that effect for me. So, because it is not sinful for me, does that mean it is not sinful for you? Or because it's sinful for you, does that then mean that it is also sinful for me? You see, it's not a cut and dry thing. It's not in determining sin just as it is not in determining types of sin. We have the Ten Commandments which define for us what exactly is a sin by Law. However, we all know that there are 'little' things that are grouped with each sin that is not stated exactly in the ten. Does that mean they are not sin? No. It does not. The fact that this bothered you (way back when) seems to say that you were aware that it could be sinful for you. If you are neglecting your body, you are not caring for something which God has entrusted to you. Does it say in the Ten Commandments, "Take care of your body which I have entrusted to you"? No. But do we know that neglecting it, or hurting it, is sinful? Yes. So why are you not sleeping? Why do you not study in other hours of the night? I guess this is not really directed at you so much as it is a question I have had on my own end lately. Why do so many neglect their bodies? They stay up really late 'hanging out' -- not being at all productive -- to wake up early and exhaust themselves the next day. And do they retire early that next night? Most likely not. They push and push and push and it IS sinful. It is a lack of prudence. It is idiocy -- and I say that because I know it's not ignorance!! Anyway...
Anastasia13 Posted June 2, 2007 Posted June 2, 2007 [quote name='ardillacid' post='791108' date='Nov 16 2005, 12:29 AM']hmm i prefer pi. once upon a time i knew the 1st 300 digits of it. lol that was fun[/quote] Oh my gosh. That is so awesome. I have only ever had 114 or so digits memorized, though I think I only about 15-20 right now.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now