Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

Only us Americans receive it by hand... Rome really shouldn't allow it... Yeah I know I'm gunna get a comeback to this but think about it, what's worse? Having your privalige to receive God's gift by hand taken away and stopping the improper use of the Eucharist or keeping the right to recieve it in your hands but have people steal the Eucharist, drop it, or do something else with it.

I wonder if that will cause an increase in the number of altar boys? One of the major duties of altar boys when I grew up was holding the paten under the recipient's chin to catch a falling Body.

(I guess I'm showing my age by referring to them as altar boys as well as the paten !!)

Edited by Norseman82
Posted

thats not true, because i've recieved communion in other countries (canada, the czheck repuplic, poland, and italy) and people recieved w/ their hands.

i've been to Papal Mass where people recieved w/ the hand...

Posted

Ya, it's not just a NAmerican thing. And it shouldn't be revoked.

Although we have a duty to defend Christ when possible, I sincerely believe that he can look after himself. He asked the apostles on Gethsemene to put away their swords.

We have to hope that Christ is acting in these people's lives even though they abuse Him (intentionally or not)

It is due to a lack of catechesis, and not the practice of receiveing in the hands.

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

there are martyrs and saints who have died to defend the holy eucharist.

are we not called to do the same?

Posted

I will defend the Eucharist at all costs. ALL COSTS.

If your friend was being abused and insulted would you just stand by?

Christ died for his friends. I'll do the same if i must to defend the Eucharist.

Posted

any priest who would notice such an act and do nothing is potentially in grave sin. There is no excuse for that at all. I have no problem with receiving in the hand if it is done with reverence, and people are truly making a throne with their hands to receive. I did receive on the tongue prior to ordination and it is the way I would prefer it, but I don't think it is wrong.

But the two things are totally different.

Personally, when I have an assembly that I know has non-Catholics I make an announcement before I begin to distribute. "For our brothers and sisters that are here and are not Catholic, if you still would like to come up in the the procession, please cross your arms acrossed your chest, and I will give you a blessing instead."

It works and it takes like 10 secs. geesh. My brothers, I apologize for them.

I love you all. Keep the faith.

Pontifex

Posted

Yes, but when appropriate. I think going over to someone after mass if you notice them doing something is appropriate, but jumping out of your pew and slaying them in the middle of communion may not be.

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

Yes, but when appropriate. I think going over to someone after mass if you notice them doing something is appropriate, but jumping out of your pew and slaying them in the middle of communion may not be.

i dont know. each incident is different.

but i do know if someone takes off running, im going after them.

whatever it takes. -_-

Posted

really? I guess i should rule that out then...... ;)

but i do know if someone takes off running, im going after them.

;)

Posted

I admire your zeal and courage.

Posted

As an older person who remembers Mass in the old way we were taught to receive communion kneeling and on the tongue at the altar rails. We had to fast for three hours from all food and drink and Mass was not celebrated in the evening.

Today one may receive on the hand, standing and attend Mass at almost any hour.

Whilst there are certainly some unfortunate incidents as a young child I was told that the satanists used to leave the church straight after communion and remove the host from their mouths so the same story still does the rounds!!

On balance, now as a priest, I believe the practice of communion on the hand is better but people always have the right to receive on the tongue. Cardinal Meri De Val once secretary of State in the 19th Century is reported to have said Jesus said take and eat not take and look at.

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

I admire your zeal and courage.

well im more worried about the what happens to Jesus then what embarrassment i might cause. and whats appropiate and whats not. :)

Posted

i don't have a problem with faithful recieving w/ reverance... thats obviously fine.

it's when faithful are irreverant, or unfaithful make up their own rules that is the problem.

a demand for propper respect and adoration at all times for the Body and Blood of Christ is what i assume we are all in agreement with.

Re:Fr Pontifex

that short speach is an excelent idea.

i recall priests saying that several times in my home parrish/diocies.

people are always going to lie.

wherever the Lord is at work, the devil has a tent pitched nearby, despite his inevidable failure.

perhaps, we can recruit the PhatmasSeals.

troops specialy trained to defend the Eucharist "at all costs"

armed with an all but deadly holy water cannon (i.e. super soaker), they lurk in the catacombs, sanctuaries, and choir loft...

and soon a parrish near you!!!

CatholicAndFanatical
Posted

how do you know that Christ dwelling in them isn't going to start a revelation in thier life? how do you know if withholding thier desire for Christ, although just in your eyes, wont cause them to feel abandoned? when has Christ withheld anything from his children? who are we to make up His mind?

this is all fine if it werent against Church teaching. You must be in the state of grace in order to receive Christ. No ands, if's or buts.

perhaps, we can recruit the PhatmasSeals.

troops specialy trained to defend the Eucharist "at all costs"

armed with an all but deadly holy water cannon (i.e. super soaker), they lurk in the catacombs, sanctuaries, and choir loft...

and soon a parrish near you!!!

I LOVE this idea..Im so there!

And PedroX, yes I am in the Lafayette Diocese, in Kokomo as a matter of fact. I attend St. Joan of Arc Parish. Where you from??

God Bless,

CatholicAndFanatical

CatholicAndFanatical
Posted

Thanks Father for your input, Id still like to know what us laymen can do to lessen the mediocrity in the Church, get more people involved with Ministries and get people more excited about receiving Christ.

God Bless

CatholicAndFanatical
Posted

By Cappie

On balance, now as a priest, I believe the practice of communion on the hand is better but people always have the right to receive on the tongue. Cardinal Meri De Val once secretary of State in the 19th Century is reported to have said Jesus said take and eat not take and look at.

Cappie, I didnt know you was a Priest. Thats amesome! We should have different levels for Priests on this board. Thank you for being here cappie, God Bless you!

CatholicAndFanatical

Posted

I'm an EEM and I can't tell you how many times people come to receive Christ and they try to walk away without consuming, I just politly tapp them on the shoulder and ask them to please consume the eucharist before walking away. I know this interupts the flow of Communion, but I would rather interupt the flow than to let someone just walk away with Christ in their hands. I have also been asked not to do this because it interupts everything, but I never have been one to go with the flow.

And about the receiving in the hands or on the tounge. I used to receive in my hands, but then I went and spent time with Consecrated women and they all receive on the tounge, and after mass one day I talked to them about it and I now understand the reverance issue.

Posted

i'm also an EEM or EME or whatever, and i just rememebred a funny story....

my last Mass at home before leaving for school this semester was said w/o any electricity, because the power went out.

at comunion time, more recieved by mouth than i've ever had before on my line.

i couldn't tell you how many time i missed their mouth because i misjudged the distance in the darkness.

my friend was also an EME that night and told me he experienced the same thing, missing some woman so bad, he hit her in the nose.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...