Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

You Know that Luther Guy...


Recommended Posts

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='DAF' date='Nov 30 2005, 07:21 PM']I knew somebody would bring this up...
Perhaps it's not prudent to willfully think such things, but give me some slack here.
[right][snapback]806055[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
It really is very much against our faith to put someone in hell.

Posted

I don't mind speculating that it is very likely that Luther went to hell. we don't know for certain of couse, but it's very likely.

the person most likely to be in Hell is Judas Iscariot, per the words of Jesus Christ Himself that it would be better for him to have never been born (any soul that ends up in heaven thus rejoicing the angels would certianly not be better off not existing). but great heretics are also very likely, and the image of them burning in hell is not at all a wrong image to suggest. Dante placed people in hell-- he was not judging, he was making a point. So too in that mindset only should we envision Martin Luther in hell. it would be Divine Justice, if he is in hell we should feel no pity for him. It is certainly grevious that one created for the purpose of being good has entered into an eternal evil state (because they eternally have a twisted nature, they are still not evil by nature)... but if it is then it is and it is COMFORTING to know such justice has been served.

you would be wrong to say you know for certain that luther is in hell, but we needn't avoid the image of luther burning in hell-- it is an image of Divine Justice, of the full just punishment deserved for helping severely damage Christian unity for five hundred years.

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' date='Dec 1 2005, 03:18 PM']you would be wrong to say you know for certain that luther is in hell, but we needn't avoid the image of luther burning in hell-- it is an image of Divine Justice, of the full just punishment deserved for helping severely damage Christian unity for five hundred years.
[right][snapback]807184[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I second this.

Posted (edited)

[quote]So too in that mindset only should we envision Martin Luther in hell. [/quote]

Why?

[quote]For the judgment is merciless to one who has not shown mercy; mercy triumphs over judgment.

--James 2:13[/quote]

I would certainly agree that it is a very realistic possibility that people like Luther are in hell. But, as John Paul II notes in "Crossing the Threshold of Hope", we are not permitted to know:

[quote]Can God, who has loved man so much, permit the man who rejects Him to be condemned to eternal torment? And yet, the words of Christ are unequivocal. In Matthew's Gospel He speaks clearly of those who will go to eternal punishment (cf. Mt 25:46). Who will these be? The Church has never made any pronouncement in this regard. This is a mystery, truly inscrutable, which embraces the holiness of God and the conscience of man. [b]The silence of the Church is, therefore, the only appropriate position for Christian faith[/b]. Even when Jesus says of Judas, the traitor, "It would be better for that man if he had never been born" (Mt 26:24), His words do not allude for certain to eternal damnation.[/quote]

[quote]you would be wrong to say you know for certain that luther is in hell, but we needn't avoid the image of luther burning in hell-- it is an image of Divine Justice, of the full just punishment deserved for helping severely damage Christian unity for five hundred years.[/quote]

The image of Luther in Heaven is an image of Divine Mercy. I can easily imagine him in Heaven or Hell. Such is the nature of God's Justice and his Mercy. But if either takes precedence, it is mercy, because, as St. James says, it has triumphed over Justice.

Edited by Era Might
Posted

I dont see logically a reason why we would think Luther is in hell anymore than viking fans dont like Farve.

Myles, You said you have done some reformation research. I have not done 2 years worth of it, but my undergrad is from a protestant college so it is always in the air. From my understanding of luther the "sola" were not formally developed until the original reform concepts didnt work, and without the church holding it back(it being a more faith-related system) they slingshot to the extreme. With scripture, I know he always wanted scripture to be the authority. In worms it is infamous that all he wanted was "scripture proof or simple reason" he just wanted a justification for why we do what we do. And we have that now in a lot of places.

Braaten(big time lutheran theologian) in his book "mother church" as well as Mark Noll(perhaps the best protestant historian) in "is the reformation over" both point to the concept that they do not feel luther would have split today. BUT, remember he didnt want to split before. He was shot-down and excommunicated. Where as all the church needed to do was discuss and allow him to help reform the practice problems that Im sure most of us would have had a problem with. Catholics say we debated him, prots said we tried to convict him.

He wanted reform, there even is a rumor he was a pope canidate. but got Married. Could you imagine how the church would be? You cant say he wasnt a great theologian if he was respected as a dr. of theology and considered a papel option.

but I guess in the same way that prots are taught to dislike the pope, we are taught to not like luther.

but myles, I agree fully with you. He never really understood catholicism. He was in a weird time in germany, and he had a bad rome experience.I say pray for him.

Posted

you should try watching the movie...its actually well put together.

Posted

[quote]I dont see logically a reason why we would think Luther is in hell anymore than viking fans dont like Farve. [/quote]

I see why his probability of being in hell is greater than, say, my grandmother, for the same reason Hitler is very likely in hell. Luther was perhaps the greatest heretic in Christian history.

But, as I said, I can also very easily see him in Heaven, which is why we must respect the silence from beyond the grave.

Posted

[quote name='Era Might' date='Dec 1 2005, 02:55 PM']I see why his probability of being in hell is greater than, say, my grandmother, for the same reason Hitler is very likely in hell. Luther was perhaps the greatest heretic in Christian history.

But, as I said, I can also very easily see him in Heaven, which is why we must respect the silence from beyond the grave.
[right][snapback]807243[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Agreed. I hate to think the he could be in hell because of my background and always being told that he was such a great person and whatnot. And then the fact that I did once believe what he taught...and my family still does. It's just kinda hard to think about. But then you get my pastor, who after JP2 died, made a remark about he thinks he's possibly in hell. Blah. It's just a complicated thing...cause none of us really have any idea what was in their hearts...just what their lives and actions showed. Anyways....

Posted

well, luther battled depression alot, he followed the view that he felt God was leading him to. He had a good education, but in a limited field. In his conscience being pulled he obeyed his conscience. In the famous worms hearing he even says how he wanted proof in scripture or in simple reason, because he cant go against what his conscience tells him. But, instead of answering him and working to explain it shows that he was convicted. Many of the reforms he wanted have happened. I wonder what would have happened if he did get a position in the higher parts of the papacy.

The sola's were an extreme reaction of the evils he saw. He wanted scripture as an authority. We have that available for the lay now. he wanted a faith more focused on faith not deeds, even today in the news the pope speaks about personal faith. These views were good, they became extreme.

But after the excomunication his depression got the worse. I feel he is in heaven, that he was a faithful servant. I think he spent a bit of time in purgatory, but most of us will.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

I don't think its right to think of people as being in hell. We have no way of knowing that. And God desires that all will be saved so we should desire and hope for that as well. I hope Martin Luther is in heaven, and I won't be terribly surprised if he is. Certainly this would be in spite of his heresy and sins.

But I still think that its uncharitable to presume someone is in hell. Some of the most evil people in history have had deathbed conversions. There is always hope for everyone, and it is better to hope than to presume the worst.

Posted

The section quoted from Triumph that starts this thread is representative of a very popular new strand of Lutheran biographical work. All of a sudden...last 10 years or so...everybody's psychoanalyzing the man. I forget who wrote the book that started it.

I have to admit it's an interesting diversion, but it isn't good history or good psychology...there's just far to little substance behind the conclusions.

For example, that old story about Luther coming up with "sola fide" in an outhouse, the very moment he was, um, delivered from a long and uncomfortable gastrointestinal situation. It's based on a very questionable metaphorical interpretation of Luther's own account. It really sounded like a stretch to me when I read the actual text.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

pschoanalysis isn't all that hot. It's not uncommon for five different psychologists to come up with five different diagnoses for one neurotic patient. And when we're talking about someone who lived so long ago it becomes even less credible.

But I would be interested in reading that stuff. I'd just take it with a grain of salt.

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

I don't like how people can say that Luther is in heaven. there are letters from him to his mother telling her not to leave Catholicism which he calls the true relegion after his excommunication and refusal to go to the counicl of trent. He may be in heaven but lets not say things that we no nothing of.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Extra ecclesiam nulla salus' date='Dec 1 2005, 05:34 PM']I don't like how people can say that Luther is in heaven. there are letters from him to his mother telling her not to leave Catholicism which he calls the true relegion after his excommunication and refusal to go to the counicl of trent. He may be in heaven but lets not say things that we no nothing of.
[right][snapback]807454[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
I'm not saying he's in heaven. I'm just saying we don't know where he is and its best to "hope" that he's saved. If mass murderers have had death bed conversions, why couldn't someone who was at least trying to follow God? I don't think its a stretch to give Luther the benefit of the doubt and assume that his intentions were not all bad.

But still, I'm talking about hope, not judging where he ended up. We don't know that and can't know that. Unless Luther was canonized, which is never going to happen. hehe

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

no not yoy LD i agree with what you say. Revprodeji said he felt that luther was in heaven.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Extra ecclesiam nulla salus' date='Dec 1 2005, 05:39 PM']no not yoy LD i agree with what you say. Revprodeji said he felt that luther was in heaven.
[right][snapback]807463[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
oh :blush: , I guess I should read more carefully. my bad.

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

no problem.

Posted

I say I "feel" he is in heaven, its the same assumption you could but shouldnt make about anyone else. I have no insider(lost Miss cleo's number) but based on what I have read I feel he would be. I mean, he had a radical faith. Thats great

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

Radical faith does not get you into heaven.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...