Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Prove it. :)

Posted

By the way... Where's the Bible Study on Genesis? It used to be a sticky...

Posted

its in the debate table..........or were u suggesting that it should be in all the tables?

Posted

Dissprove it.  :P

"You can't disprove a negative."

Thats the reponse I've gotten.

Posted

its in the debate table..........or were u suggesting that it should be in all the tables?

I know. I'm a dork. I saw it right after I posted this. For some reason I thought it was in the "open Mic" phorum. my bad...

cmotherofpirl
Posted

THe Bible study should be in the apologetics thread.

Posted

In order for anything to have come into existence, there must have been something or someone who always has been and always will be.

Posted

In order for anything to have come into existence, there must have been something or someone who always has been and always will be.

Yeah, I wish it was that simple. But try convincing an atheist that humans haven't just simply been around forever...

There really is no proof either way... Thus, faith.

Posted

ummm, doesn't SCIENCE prove that humans haven't been around forever?

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Yeah, I wish it was that simple.  But try convincing an atheist that humans haven't just simply been around forever...

There really is no proof either way...  Thus, faith.

THere are 15 or so arguments for the existance of God...

Posted

What are specifically those 15 arguments? And who are they each by plz. Thanks!

cmotherofpirl
Posted (edited)

I will list the arguments but not the details, that would take about 30 pages of typing. There are actually 20. :)

Argument from change

Argument from efficient causality

Argument from time and contingency

Argument from degrees of perfection

Argument from design

Kalam argument

argument from contingency

Argument from the world as an interacting whole

Argument from miracles

Argument from consciousness

Argument from truth

Argument from the origin of the idea of God

ontological argument

A Anselms argument

B Modal version

C possible worlds version

moral argument

Argument from consciousness

Argument from desire

Argument from aestetic experience

Argument from religious experience

Argument common consent argument

Pascal's wager

Handbook of Christian Apologetics

Edited by cmotherofpirl
Posted

cmom,

if u get a chance, a short explanation of those 20 arguments would be amesome for this board! i may look them up if i have the time.

thanks for the input,

phatcatholic

Posted

I know this is a personal one, but that my Coach is still here and WALKING on top of that is enough proof for me if i ever need it.

Posted

all of creation, and especially the miracles that occur in our lives, are proof of his existence

Posted

Hi everybody :lol:

Let me give you guys this scenario:

A man was walking along the sidewalk and then he saw 12 coins scattered on the ground. Was it a coincidence the coins were there? ... most will answer, yes.

Well then, the next day... the man walks along the same sidewalk at the same hour and again he saw 12 coins on the ground, this time stacked neatly side by side, 6 on each side. Was it a coincidence or was it planned? :D I would say it was planned.

-----

Was it a coincidence that the earth was the third planet from the Sun? Not too hot for us and not too cold.

Was it a coincidence that plants supply us oxygen, in return they get carbon dioxide?

Was it a coincidence that our body can work so efficiently? Even the best technology now and most sophisticated machine cannot fully imitate one of the vital organs?

Was it a coincidence that the elements(Carbon, Oxygen, Nitrogen, etc..) in our body can also be found in the soil? If that was a coincidence, why don't we see humans sprouting from the ground?

And if someone would tell me that all these were to be a coincidence, I would ask: what are the chances that the organisms, elements, temperature, weather and other factors all complement each other?

I believe that all those above was never a coincidence because I know it was all planned.

The BIG question now is by who?

Well, I tell you that person is God. :lol:

Posted

There wouldn't be anything if there wasn't Something (or Someone, as the case may be) to create it all. Don't tell me that EVERYTHING is just here, because that makes for an arbitrary and pointless existence.

"Consider the daffodil. And while you're doing that, I'll be over here, looking through your stuff." --Jack Handy :lol:

Anywho, consider a leaf. Are you aware of the chemical composition of a leaf? Of the chemical reactions that take place every day? They are so complex that scientists can't even make one living leaf up from scratch themselves. So to say that the leaf came into existence "all by itself, coincidentally" is absurd.

How about the human body? Scientists have acknowledged it as the most complex and efficient machine the world has to offer. The brain! That organ alone is so complex that scientists are STILL trying to determine its intricate nature.

Life is full of power with structure. Did humans just kind of randomly become who they are today? From a bunch of tiny one-celled organisms? With no outside help? Please. I don't care to give us that much credit. So how can we say that all those rocks that we call planets just kind of randomly became what they are today? Rocks can't even think, let alone plan their own destinies. So the big question is this: Who put them into orbit?

-Mark

Posted

Here are a few points in my opinion:

The people bearing the wounds of Christ, the stigmata, a sign from God telling I Got 2 Believe!

Secondly, Mirarcoulsly healings at Lourdes and fatima, I place where a super natural event occured, where healings from terminally ill people have attributed to their living!!

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

Out of the twenty listed by Cmother, I would have to say Pascals Wager is not technically proof, but in objectively deciding whether or not to believe that's the one I would go with. I'll give the senario that I am trying to convince an athiest that God does exist, and only that, you have to take into account both possibilities and then decide. Pascal's Wager (not ver batem) says that if there is a God I should believe in Him, and if there's no God I didn't lose anything because I believed.

I also really like the arguement of the religious sense. Every person wants some thing higher than themselves; they seek God. Whether they know it or not through out life people search for the purest and truest forms of love, beauty, truth, and justice. This search implies that there is something which is intrinsically perfect. We chose to call that something God because we know that this ultimate perfection is not here on Earth, and it has to be infinite.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...