White Knight Posted December 21, 2005 Posted December 21, 2005 This film is pure Christianity, and C.S. Lewis did a fantastic job in writing great details of the Faith and events of the Bible into this Novel, and the Movie itself is Faithful. This Film is more Christian than the entire LOTR Trilogy and in some sense is better than it. however, The LOTR Trilogy is more mature and darker than the Lion, The Witch, and The Wardrobe, obviously. But, I think even though, C.S. Lewis wasn't Catholic, and Tokien was, Lewis did a better job of capturing Catholicism in general with this film.
cappie Posted December 21, 2005 Posted December 21, 2005 Narnia: Not Just for Evangelicals: Andrew Greely C.S. Lewis used storytelling and visual images to dramatize his allegory of redemption in a very Catholic way. "The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe" is a new film based on the Narnia children's books by English writer C.S. Lewis. According to an unnamed Disney executive in a recent issue of the New York Times, Narnia will provide the company with a "Christian niche," among the lucrative fantasy "franchises" such as "Harry Potter" and "The Lord of the Rings." Since 80 percent of Americans claim to be Christian, this would be pretty big niche. However, it seems likely that the executive meant the evangelical Christian niche and thus was adopting the evangelical presumption that only those who believe in the literal word-for-word interpretation of the Bible can claim to be Christian. Thus a tedious and contemptuous article in the New Yorker equated the popularity of Lewis with his teaching of doctrines that appeal to evangelicals. I confess that such ignorance gives me a headache. C.S. Lewis was not a Christian in the sense of the word that "evangelicals" insist upon. He was an Anglican who sometimes skirted, in his writings at any rate, dangerously close to the thin ice of Catholicism. Indeed, many in my generation of Catholics simply assumed he was one of us. But even as an Anglican he would certainly fall out of the realm of the "saved" when the Rapture blasts all of us who do not believe in word-for-word inerrancy into oblivion. I hasten to add that not all evangelicals claim a monopoly on Christianity. Indeed, only half of those in the evangelical denominations believe in that kind of biblical literalism, and a smaller proportion believe that the rest of us will be vaporized on the day of the Rapture. Moreover, they are certainly within their rights to claim that those who disagree with them about the Bible are not "Christian" and that C.S. Lewis is a "Christian" writer. If his quasi-Catholic work helps them in their religious life, then more power to them. wish merely to make two observations. While I leave to professional movie critics like my colleague Roger Ebert (who is also destined as I am for vaporization) an evaluation of Narnia as film, I insist that the Narnia stories --charming nursery tales for young and old -- deserve a much broader audience than just biblical fundamentalists. Better or worse than "Harry Potter"? That question simply does not compute -- though they're both about the struggle between good and evil. Secondly, it seems to me that the evangelicals slip dangerously close to Catholic idolatry when they embrace a wondrous allegory as a summary of the biblical story. Jesus is not and never was a lion like Aslan in the film. To interpret him as a lion is to go light years beyond literal, word-for-word inerrancy. The evangelical enthusiasm about the sufferings of Jesus in Mel Gibson's "The Passion of the Christ" put them one step away, it seemed to me, from importing crucifixes and Stations of the Cross into their churches. I'm afraid that their enthusiasm for both films shows just how seductive the Catholic temptation is. We delight in pictures and stories and allegories and symbols and signs because they appeal to the whole human person and not just to the rigid, rational mind. We are a church designed for the media age with its deluge of pictures and stories -- though we usually don't know what to do with the opportunity. There are certainly risks in this Catholic imagination, superstition and idolatry among others -- though it does make the world a warmer and a more human place. Gibson's imagination is certainly Catholic, though perhaps with a certain masochistic twist. In his retelling of the Gospel in allegorical form, C.S. Lewis goes back to the miracle and morality plays of the Middle Ages, in a sense as if the Reformation never happened. However, I think someone should warn the evangelicals that they are playing with, one should excuse the expression, fire. They are drifting into an imaginative world where the Whore of Babylon lives and dominates. They had better beware. They are sliding towards oblivion on the day of the Rapture. On the other hand, many Catholics ashamed of their imaginative heritage may be drifting in the opposite direction. [url="http://about.beliefnet.com/story/180/story_18094_1.html"] beliefnet[/url]
homeschoolmom Posted December 21, 2005 Posted December 21, 2005 But what did you think of the movie??
Lil Red Posted December 21, 2005 Posted December 21, 2005 three youth groups are going together tonight! almost 90 people are going! i can't wait!!!
Lil Red Posted December 22, 2005 Posted December 22, 2005 what an amazing movie! did anyone else notice the part where susan & lucy came back after the stone table was broken, and susan said "what have they done to him?" - talk about plagiarism from the Bible! lol
Gandalf Posted December 22, 2005 Posted December 22, 2005 That was a good catch I didn't notice that! :applause:
rkwright Posted December 24, 2005 Posted December 24, 2005 I just saw this one tonight and wow! blown away! So I just have some questions... I knew going into it that it was a Biblical allegory so I was watching for things right from the begining. When they first came into Narnia, the beavers speak of a prophecy, that the son of adam would return and make things cool (haha forgive the pun : ) in Narnia. So I expected one of the boys to be the sacrifice. Of course into the movie its obvious that Anslem will be the Christ figure. So whats the prophecy all about? It seems to be a disjunct... I might be missing something from the books, but I just brushed off the dust on all 7 books on my bookshelf time to re-read! Also, what of the characters? I figured Peter represented Peter, kinda leader of the Church? Edmond the sinner\judas\fallen human race? The girls?? no clue on those 2... your thoughts on all those?? Good movie though!
homeschoolmom Posted December 24, 2005 Posted December 24, 2005 It's not an exact parallel, so lining up characters to themes won't work. I think Lewis describes it like this: What if there were other worlds in need of redemption and Jesus when to save them? What might that look like?
Sojourner Posted December 25, 2005 Posted December 25, 2005 [quote name='homeschoolmom' date='Dec 24 2005, 10:52 AM']It's not an exact parallel, so lining up characters to themes won't work. I think Lewis describes it like this: What if there were other worlds in need of redemption and Jesus when to save them? What might that look like? [right][snapback]835365[/snapback][/right] [/quote] That's pretty much the basic idea behind the Space Trilogy too, at least the first two books.
Fides_et_Ratio Posted December 26, 2005 Posted December 26, 2005 Aslan is the Lion. St. Anselm was a Saint during the 1000s.
rkwright Posted December 26, 2005 Posted December 26, 2005 [quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Dec 25 2005, 05:28 PM']Aslan is the Lion. St. Anselm was a Saint during the 1000s. [right][snapback]835993[/snapback][/right] [/quote] :
sarcasmguy126 Posted December 26, 2005 Posted December 26, 2005 [quote name='Aloysius' date='Dec 12 2005, 01:28 PM']you mean not to have Walden make all seven and then distribute it under their name Disney itself has been nearly reduced to the movie-making skills of a highschooler (plus some better special effects)... have you seen Sky High? [right][snapback]821934[/snapback][/right] [/quote] wait...no, you mean Walden Media should make all seven in association with Disney and release all seven movies under Disney's name. the fact is, DISNEY DOESN'T MAKE THE MOVIE, JUST DISTRIBUTES IT! Walden Media is the company that is REALLY behind "The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe". But I think that (when it comes) a movie on "The Last Battle" (under Andrew Adamson) would be really cool!
Aloysius Posted December 26, 2005 Posted December 26, 2005 yeah, that's what I said. what do you think they'll do, though... if they want to make the Magicians Nephew, they'll need the same white witch, but they have to make Prince Caspian with the kids at the right age. so do you think perhaps they could film both 1 and 4 at the same time? they wouldn't need any of the same charecters. 3 of course will need the adult kings and queens, or well I don't quite remember how old they were at that point I'm not sure it even says... this will be interesting to see how they coordinate all this. I suppose that actress won't age too much if they wait till they do all the ones with the kids in them before they do #1, and they could make her up not to look older.. hmm...
sarcasmguy126 Posted December 26, 2005 Posted December 26, 2005 here's what i think they should do... just like the LOTR trilogy, film all the movies that have Peter, Edmund, Susan, or Lucy (as young kids) all at once (The Voyage of the Dawn Treader, Prince Caspian) and film the ones with Eustace and Jill all at once (The Silver Chair, The Last Battle), and film the others (with Digory and Polly) after those this way, none of the kids mentioned above grow as old as the actors of Harry Potter, and when any of them are portrayed older (like in The Last Battle, or even at the end of "The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe" film), they just use totally different, older people!
homeschoolmom Posted December 26, 2005 Posted December 26, 2005 The lion who plays Aslan is too busy to shoot two films at the same time.
Avier Posted December 27, 2005 Posted December 27, 2005 Just a thought, When I was weathcing Aslan on the table, you see Lucie and Susan on thier knees. THe second I saw this I was like, Mary. Maybe its me though.
DemonSlayer Posted December 28, 2005 Posted December 28, 2005 I just saw the film, it wasn't bad, but it should've been 3 hrs long.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now