Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

The Role of the Confessor


Recommended Posts

franciscanheart
Posted

What exactly is the role of a confessor in a person's life and how does this differ from a spiritual director? In addition, is an outside counselor necessary if one or both of these are present in a person's life?

Posted

You need both in your life from the early years to the later years.

They don't have to be the same person. :)

You don't have to have a regular confessor, but it is good because this person will know you well and it will help in your spiritual life.

The spiritual director helps you see where God is working in your life and helps you when you need help discerning God's will, or when you need good advice (such as regarding prayer), and is almost an accountability person for you helping you stay faithful. :)

franciscanheart
Posted

and the counselor?

Posted

I'm actually not sure of the question about the inside counselor.

I have one of my parish Priests as a spiritual director and he's pretty present in my life...

I'm a little confused by the question. :idontknow:

franciscanheart
Posted

.... well i guess if no one else answers by tonight ill repost this in the Q & A board.... thanks for your help though Zach!

Posted

Well, if you reask the question I might be able to help. :P:

franciscanheart
Posted

hmmm okay... if a regular confessor isnt necessary but simply helpful and the spiritual director helps you in matters of faith and spiritual growth, is there room still for a counselor? to my understanding the spiritual director and the counselor would serve different purposes. is this correct?

Posted

I guess that it could, but unless you're having emotional problems, then I wouldn't see it as necessary. :)

The spiritual director should in a way work both, so that you spiritual life can overflow (actually integrate) with the rest of your life. I think that this is good place for faith to influence how you interact with the rest of your life. :)

Posted

However, if there are more than just you going, then I would suggest a counselor. :)

Posted

i don' know if a counselor per say would be necessary.

The only idea that i can think of is a close friend who is willing to help you see a new perspective and challenge you on some issues, but really a spiritual director should be doing that.

The spiritual life should impact everything a person does and a spiritual director is the one who works on the spiritual life.

Posted

[quote name='hugheyforlife' date='Dec 13 2005, 12:24 PM']hmmm okay... if a regular confessor isnt necessary but simply helpful and the spiritual director helps you in matters of faith and spiritual growth, is there room still for a counselor? to my understanding the spiritual director and the counselor would serve different purposes. is this correct?
[right][snapback]823605[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
A spiritual director's primary purpose is to help you see and understand how God is working in your life, and where He might be leading you. Spiritual directors aid you in spiritual areas, which certainly impacts every minute detail of your life, but they may not be able to help with clinical depression.

A counselor aids in psycholigical areas and what not.

A spitirual director is always helpful, but his specific area of expertise might not include psychology and the like. He may acutally recommend that you see a counselor to assist you where he cannot.

It is unfair to assume that a spiritual director (even the very good ones) are wonder workers and can help everyone through everything. Besides being unfair, it can set things up for disaster. They are human and have their own limitations.

That is if I am understanding correctly what you mean by counselor. If you mean like a school counselor; I would say stick with the spiritual director. If you mean like a clinical counselor, they can and do serve in areas that might be out of some directo's grasps.

franciscanheart
Posted

maybe im weird but i dont think of counselors the same way every one else seems to... or maybe im just taking what yall are saying the wrong way. i dont think anyone necessarily needs to be crazy or depressed to have a counselor.

Posted

What else would you say you should have one for?

franciscanheart
Posted

for sorting out psychological ... tendencies? to pinpoint why certain behaviors are present and how to eliminate them or use them for constructiveness. to... sort out other things. i wish phatcatholic would answer something as well since he is a counselor but i guess he doesnt wanna? :idontknow:

Posted (edited)

[quote name='hugheyforlife' date='Dec 13 2005, 03:46 PM']for sorting out psychological ... tendencies? to pinpoint why certain behaviors are present and how to eliminate them or use them for constructiveness. to... sort out other things. i wish phatcatholic would answer something as well since he is a counselor but i guess he doesnt wanna? :idontknow:
[right][snapback]823985[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Oh I did not meant that one had to be clinical depressed or have some diagnosis in order to need a counselor. I was only using it as an example. My apologies if anyone understood me as such.

I meant that counselors specialize in psychological tendencies, as you said, that spiritual directors might not always be too well informed on. So yes I can see a need for a counselor in one's life alongside a spiritual director.

Edited by Paphnutius
Posted

[quote name='hugheyforlife' date='Dec 13 2005, 05:46 PM']for sorting out psychological ... tendencies? to pinpoint why certain behaviors are present and how to eliminate them or use them for constructiveness. to... sort out other things. i wish phatcatholic would answer something as well since he is a counselor but i guess he doesnt wanna? :idontknow:
[right][snapback]823985[/snapback][/right][/quote]

i so-wee :blush: i've been really busy with the following 3 things:

1. preparing for college
2. working
3. sleeping

......so i haven't been on phatmass as much here recently. i'll try to answer your question tho

ok, first, i think a confessor should be used primarily for the confession of sins. it is amazingly helpful when one is able to receive instruction or advice from a confessor, but the particulars of the situation, in my opinion, don't really make it conducive to offering the type of advice that a counselor and a spiritual director can provide. the confessor is not always well trained to give advice, there is often a line of people waiting for you to finish, and the grill or wall between you and the priest can make it difficult to engage in very much back-and-forth discussion.

the combination of a counselor and a spiritual directory is in my mind the most beneficial b/c they make up for what is lacking in the other. a counselor has training in therapy, and psychology, cognitive process, human development and behavior, and how to approach and respond to all of that. however, he often times does not have a solid christian background with which to inform what he knows and root it in Christian principles.

the spiritual director has this background. he knows the teachings of the Church and her moral principles. he understands the connection between the body and the spirit. he can help us to discern the will of the Lord and to nuture our relationship with him. however, he often times does not have the knowledge that the counselor possesses, so he may not know how to confront and treat deep-seated insecurities, or phobias, or psychological/behavioral disorders.

so, you put them together and they balance each other out. now, i'm not really here to debate how psychological problems can find their source in spiritual problems, or vice versa. i'm only saying that each professional is a specialist in his own way and so we can and should be open to benefitting from the expertise that each one has to offer.

i hope that helps

pax christi,
phatcatholic

franciscanheart
Posted

it was all very helpful. thank you.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...