Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted December 14, 2005 Posted December 14, 2005 does an independent Catholic Chapel fufill one's sunday obligation?
jezic Posted December 14, 2005 Posted December 14, 2005 um dude.... what is an indepedent Catholic Church? and why are independent and Catholic referring to the same thing?
Dave Posted December 14, 2005 Posted December 14, 2005 [quote name='jezic' date='Dec 13 2005, 07:10 PM']um dude.... what is an indepedent Catholic Church? and why are independent and Catholic referring to the same thing? [right][snapback]824112[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I believe he meant those ultra-traditionalist chapels offering the Tridentine Mass that aren't in union with Rome yet also aren't affiliated with the SSPX or any other established rad-trad organization.
jezic Posted December 14, 2005 Posted December 14, 2005 hmm... interesting. I have never heard of those.
brendan1104 Posted December 14, 2005 Posted December 14, 2005 As traditional as I am, I'm going to say its doubtful. God bless, Brendan
popestpiusx Posted December 14, 2005 Posted December 14, 2005 [quote name='brendan1104' date='Dec 13 2005, 07:19 PM']As traditional as I am, I'm going to say its doubtful. God bless, Brendan [right][snapback]824120[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I would agree (for the most part).
Ave Maria Totus Tuus Posted December 14, 2005 Posted December 14, 2005 [quote name='jezic' date='Dec 13 2005, 07:15 PM']hmm... interesting. I have never heard of those. [right][snapback]824117[/snapback][/right] [/quote] What is it?
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted December 14, 2005 Author Posted December 14, 2005 an ultra-traditional chapel, not part of the SSPX or sspv etc.
p0lar_bear Posted December 15, 2005 Posted December 15, 2005 Only if it is impossible to attend a Mass at a church in union with the Church (the same goes for the SSPX, SSPV, Easter Orthodox Church, or any other schismatic group with valid sacraments).
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted December 15, 2005 Author Posted December 15, 2005 actually SSPX masses fuffil sunday obligations.
jezic Posted December 15, 2005 Posted December 15, 2005 they do? of all the strange things .... hm.... how can a group of people who are excommunicated have valid Masses? unless one thought for some reason it was valid and went because of that.
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted December 15, 2005 Author Posted December 15, 2005 yes. the sspx has a valid mass as well as the orthodox.
p0lar_bear Posted December 15, 2005 Posted December 15, 2005 [quote name='Extra ecclesiam nulla salus' date='Dec 14 2005, 07:38 PM']actually SSPX masses fuffil sunday obligations. [right][snapback]825932[/snapback][/right] [/quote] An SSPX Mass (or any other schismatic liturgy) only fulfill the Sunday obligation when the conditions of Canon 844 have been met: [quote]Whenever necessity requires it or true spiritual advantage suggests it, and provided that danger of error or of indifferentism is avoided, the Christian faithful f[i]or whom it is physically or morally impossible [/i]to approach a Catholic minister are permitted to receive the sacraments of penance, Eucharist, and anointing of the sick from non-Catholic ministers in whose Churches these sacraments are valid (emphasis added).[/quote] This has been clearly, and repeatedly, stated by Msgr. Perl of the Ecclesia Dei Commission (the Vatican office in charge of relations with groups such as the SSPX).
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted December 15, 2005 Author Posted December 15, 2005 from what i understand an sspx chapel will fufill the obligation no matter what. i can't find the document. can anyone else?
p0lar_bear Posted December 15, 2005 Posted December 15, 2005 [quote name='Extra ecclesiam nulla salus' date='Dec 15 2005, 11:37 AM']from what i understand an sspx chapel will fufill the obligation no matter what. i can't find the document. can anyone else? [right][snapback]826877[/snapback][/right] [/quote] There was a lot of hoopla a couple of years ago because a personal letter Msgr. Perl wrote in response to a specific situation said that [i]in that situation[/i] the SSPX Mass fulfilled the obligation. The letter was never intended to be made public and refered to earlier correspondence that was not published. (In fact, according to Msgr. Perl's later responses, a good deal of the original letter was left out, clearly distorting the actual meaning). Since it was published, Msgr. Perl wrote an additional letter to be published that explained the first letter. In that second letter Msgr. Perl did say that "in the strict sense" attending an SSPX Mass would fulfill the Sunday obligation. However, that "strict sense" must be interpreted in light of canon 844, which he had previously quoted in response to the issue. [url="http://www.unavoce.org/articles/2003/perl-011803.htm"]Here[/url] is a copy of the letter Msgr. Perl released to address the questions raised by the publication of the private correspondence.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now