Carolou Posted December 20, 2005 Posted December 20, 2005 Hi. I saw your question about sex without procreation. I just wanted to suggest that you read If You Really Loved Me by Jason Evert. I think it would really help you to be able to explain things like that. Because they're explained in the book and in an easily understandable way. I also suggest anyone who hasn't read that book to read it. It's a really great book!
photosynthesis Posted December 20, 2005 Posted December 20, 2005 thanks! I'll definitely check it out... this seems to be the argument I get the most when i debate contraception... I'll say that sex is meant to express wedding vows, and sex w/contraception goes against everything the wedding vows should say... and that contraception goes against God's plan for sex... so they'll say "well then people will be having kids left and right and you end up with all these unplanned pregnancies" so i'll say "then couples who have a good reason to avoid pregnancy can use NFP" and then I'll get arguments about why NFP is better than contraception and usually I'm at a loss because I don't know much about NFP (seeing that i've never been in a position where I'd need to use it.)
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted December 20, 2005 Posted December 20, 2005 isn't it wrong to use NFP with a contraceptive attitude.
qfnol31 Posted December 20, 2005 Posted December 20, 2005 [quote name='Extra ecclesiam nulla salus' date='Dec 20 2005, 01:53 PM']isn't it wrong to use NFP with a contraceptive attitude. [right][snapback]831853[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Yep.
photosynthesis Posted December 20, 2005 Posted December 20, 2005 [quote name='Extra ecclesiam nulla salus' date='Dec 20 2005, 02:53 PM']isn't it wrong to use NFP with a contraceptive attitude. [right][snapback]831853[/snapback][/right] [/quote] yes, but sometimes couples have legitimate reasons not to have children, i.e. illness, lack of money, unemployment, etc
Birgitta Noel Posted December 21, 2005 Posted December 21, 2005 Photo, Email me your snail mail addy and I'll send you a copy of West's "The Good News About Sex and Marriage" if you don't already have one....
photosynthesis Posted December 21, 2005 Posted December 21, 2005 oh yeah, i read that book before... i gave it away to my friend though, who is thinking about converting. i suppose it would have an answer in there too.
Laudate_Dominum Posted December 21, 2005 Posted December 21, 2005 [quote name='photosynthesis' date='Dec 20 2005, 10:57 PM']oh yeah, i read that book before... i gave it away to my friend though, who is thinking about converting. i suppose it would have an answer in there too. [right][snapback]832461[/snapback][/right] [/quote] did my answer smell of elderberries or something?`
Laudate_Dominum Posted December 21, 2005 Posted December 21, 2005 If you wanna post another question in the QA I'd be more than happy to provide and more comprehensive reply. I live to serve..
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted December 21, 2005 Posted December 21, 2005 [quote name='photosynthesis' date='Dec 20 2005, 02:02 PM']yes, but sometimes couples have legitimate reasons not to have children, i.e. illness, lack of money, unemployment, etc [right][snapback]831863[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Old post Yesterday at 08:52 AM Email tradcatholicmom Contact using AOL PM tradcatholicmom Reply with quote Quote: Originally Posted by Marty Well! Out of the wood work they came from everywhere trying to help this poor bloke who wanted to know if NFP was cool with the church. Which it is IN DIRE CIRCUMSTANCES ONLY. [b]Pope Pius XII: Serious motives, such as those which not rarely arise from medical, eugenic, economic and social so-called "indications," may exempt husband and wife from the obligatory, positive debt for a long period or even for the entire period of matrimonial life. From this it follows that the observance of the natural sterile periods may be lawful, from the moral viewpoint: and it is lawful in the conditions mentioned. If, however, according to a reasonable and equitable judgment, there are no such grave reasons either personal or deriving from exterior circumstances, the will to avoid the fecundity of their union, while continuing to satisfy to tile full their sensuality, can only be the result of a false appreciation of life and of motives foreign to sound ethical principles. –Address to Midwives[/b]
photosynthesis Posted December 21, 2005 Posted December 21, 2005 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' date='Dec 21 2005, 05:17 AM']did my answer smell of elderberries or something?` [right][snapback]832555[/snapback][/right] [/quote] nope!!! it was a very good answer... but here's another question I have... [quote name='L_D']"But certainly sexual activity is good for marriage, the unitive dimension and all of that; recognizing the infertile period allows the couple to responsibly abstain without compromising the conjugal life. [/quote] isn't that the same argument one could use to justify contraception and homosexuality (sexual acts that are divorced from procreation) because the contraceptive mentality sees sex as a right, not as a privilege that comes with responsibility?
Laudate_Dominum Posted December 22, 2005 Posted December 22, 2005 [quote name='photosynthesis' date='Dec 21 2005, 12:03 PM'][quote name='L_D']"But certainly sexual activity is good for marriage, the unitive dimension and all of that; recognizing the infertile period allows the couple to responsibly abstain without compromising the conjugal life. [/quote] isn't that the same argument one could use to justify contraception and homosexuality (sexual acts that are divorced from procreation) because the contraceptive mentality sees sex as a right, not as a privilege that comes with responsibility? [right][snapback]832889[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Taken out of context one could try to draw a conclusion of that sort. But my post as a whole was utterly contrary to such a perspective. One hardly needs to devalue the unitive dimension to understand NFP. The thing to remember is that intentionally separating the unitive and procreative dimensions is a moral evil. Contraceptive sex is analogous to sex in which the unitive dimension does not exist. It would be a perversion to have sex with someone outside the context of love and spousal union, only for the sake of some utilitarian intention to beget a child. Similarly the pursuit of the unitive without the procreative would be a perversion. In fact the true meaning of either dimension only exists so long as both dimensions coexist in their complimentarity. This does not mean that an infertile act of sex has less meaning than an act which results in conception. The meaning is more personalistic than that. What is required is openness to life, not necessarily a direct conscious intention to beget a child in a particular act. This openness is already implied in the wedding vows and the very nature of marriage, so as a Catholic contraceptive sex would devalue those vows in that this aspect of the wedding vows would become a lie. Contraception doesn't just distort an act of sex (since the language of body expresses total, life-giving love in the conjugal embrace, contraceptive sex is a lie told with the body since it contradicts part of the essential meaning of the act, namely the fruitfulness of sexual love), it also distorts the meaning of the marriage, making it a kind of facade of conjugal unity. A marriage without openness to life is much like a homosexual union. It is a contradiction of the meaning and nature of marriage. NFP is not a sterilized sex act explicitly closed to life (as is artificial contraception), it is rather the absence of a sex act when it wouldn't be prudent or moral because of possible circumstances which would make sexual activity irresponsible at that time. As I said before, the licit practice of NFP reverences sexual fecundity (fruitfulness) it does not attack it and distort the nature and meaning of human sexuality. NFP has more in common with a scenario in which a couple ought to abstain because the wife just had an operation south of the border and the doctor said that sex would be unhealthy (not to mention painful and messy). Or even the case of a married couple being in a public place. They have a legitimate reason to abstain from sex given the circumstances. Similarly with NFP, if the couple has a serious reason why they should not have a child (perhaps a situation of grave poverty) and the woman was known to be fertile at that time, they ought to abstain from sex. If the woman is known to be infertile, why should they abstain? That's more the logic of NFP. And the basic intention ought not be the rejection of the fecundity of sex, or the life-giving, fruitful dimension; this would rather be the unfortunate consequence of that grave circumstance which necessitates abstinence during the fertile time. Thus it is still possible to have sex whilst being open to life. Just as it is possible to abstain from sex but be open, or have a desire/intention to have sex, if only those grave circumstances weren't present which make it irresponsible, imprudent or possibly immoral. The logic of artificial contraception on the other hand says that I want to have sex at any time, without openness to life, and without responsibility or respect for the nature and meaning of the act. It is an explicit rejection and distortion of the nature of sexuality. Conugal love and union is something quite essential to the human person and human dignity. It is also essential with regard to the family and the responsibilities of having children. The family is essential to society. I would say that contraception is a poison which strikes at the heart of humanity. Read Humanae Vitae for more details.
photosynthesis Posted December 22, 2005 Posted December 22, 2005 awesome... that helps answer my question. so by the nature of the act, NFP is fundamentlaly different from contraception because it's not saying "No" to God by trying to stop the body's natural way of reproduction, it's not really saying anything because there's nothing to be said.
Laudate_Dominum Posted December 22, 2005 Posted December 22, 2005 [quote name='photosynthesis' date='Dec 22 2005, 12:54 AM']awesome... that helps answer my question. so by the nature of the act, NFP is fundamentlaly different from contraception because it's not saying "No" to God by trying to stop the body's natural way of reproduction, it's not really saying anything because there's nothing to be said. [right][snapback]833475[/snapback][/right] [/quote] pretty much it's like if there was a scenario in which a couple shouldn't procreate (even though they're faithful to their wedding vows and thus open to life) so they must abstain forever.. This would be sad. But fortunately this would also be very silly since a woman is only ovulating for a small fraction of the month. Thus, when the woman isn't ovulating, the circumstances are changed and the imperative to abstain doesn't exist. That's it in a nutshell. Contraception basically imposes its own false definition of what marriage and sexuality means. It is in essence a lie. I know this point isn't necessarily easy to see since we're so used to the culture of contraception. But it does in fact threaten the heart of marriage and family, and thus society. This is why many wise people have noted the connection between contraception, abortion, the destruction of the family, sexual immorality, divorce, etc..
photosynthesis Posted December 22, 2005 Posted December 22, 2005 yeah, contraception is really at the root of a lot of the evils in society today. It's the whole anti-child, anti-human way of thinking... Also, how effective is NFP?
Laudate_Dominum Posted December 22, 2005 Posted December 22, 2005 [quote name='photosynthesis' date='Dec 22 2005, 01:04 AM']yeah, contraception is really at the root of a lot of the evils in society today. It's the whole anti-child, anti-human way of thinking... Also, how effective is NFP? [right][snapback]833478[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I recall a study published in the British Medical Journal some years back which discovered that sympto-thermal method as practiced among the population of couples monitored, has a lower degree of failure than condoms and the pill. Upper 90 something percent effectiveness, but I forget the exact figure.. This site probably has lots of stuff that would interest you: [url="http://www.ccli.org/"]http://www.ccli.org/[/url]
Laudate_Dominum Posted December 23, 2005 Posted December 23, 2005 [i]Studies conducted in Canada, Colombia, France, Germany, Mauritius and the United States have demonstrated a 99% method effectiveness for the Sympto-Thermal and Temperature-Only Methods. These studies were conducted under a variety of conditions and demonstrate beyond any reasonable question of a doubt that this extremely high effectiveness can be achieved by ordinary couples who receive adequate instruction and follow the relatively simple rules of these methods.[/i] The Los Angeles Study = 99% - 100% effectiveness The Fairfield Study = 99% effectiveness The Roetzer Studies = 99% - 100% effectiveness The Doring Temperature-Only Study = 97% - 99% effectiveness The Vincent Study = 99% effectiveness World Health Organization study = 97.4% effectiveness Billings Ovulation Method Studies: - China (987 couples) = 100% effectiveness - Indonesia (1,331 couples) = 99% effectiveness - India (2,059 couples) = 99.15% effectiveness [i]The 1984-1985 edition of Robert A. Hatcher's Contraceptive Technology. Table 10:2, "Efficacy rates: fertility awareness of birth control" lists figures for ten different systems of NFP from calendar-only to temperature-only, mucus-only, and sympto-thermal, and the effectiveness rates ranged from 70% (calendar-only) to 99.7% (Phase III only, temperature-only). [/i] From Wikipedia: [i]According to proponents, the Billings Ovulation Method has a 99% method effectiveness rate and 95% user effectiveness rate. In one study2, a Creighton method achieved 99.5% method effectiveness but only 96.8% user effectiveness. In another study, a Creighton method had 17% of users getting pregnant, with a vast majority of these getting pregnant due to lack of correct use, so that only 0.14% of the actual users experienced a perfect-use pregnancy (Howard and Stanford, 1999).[/i] [i]Research conducted by Ecochard, et al. (1998) found that: FA (fertility awareness) users can achieve a 98.9% effectiveness rate under ideal conditions. FA users who break one or more rules will average 93.5% effectiveness rate. By comparison, the Alan Guttmacher Institute reports a user effectiveness rate of 92.0% for "the pill").[/i]
Laudate_Dominum Posted December 23, 2005 Posted December 23, 2005 I just had a goofy idea. I don't know how plausible it is, but it sounds at least somewhat possible to me. The first part would be something like a cross between a home pregnancy test and those disks you put in your toilet that turn the water blue. The idea is that when a woman pees in a toilet with this special disk, the chemicals would react with certain hormones in the urine and if the woman is fertile or near fertility the water would change color. There would also be a portable device, something like a pregnancy test, that a woman could use when on vacation or something. The second part is a software program in which the woman can chart her cycle. The software would support all of the major NFP methods but would also have a thing for simply selecting what color your urine was that day. This way a woman could include further NFP methods in order to be extra careful, or just rely on the toilet bowl tablet thingy. Ideally it would be as simple as, if the toilet water turns red, you're fertile or near fertility; if the water stays blue, you are incapable of conceiving. Just a random and probably dumb idea.. It just seems like there should be a simpler way to detect fertility. All the mucous and cervix stuff seems weird to me.
Ash Wednesday Posted December 23, 2005 Posted December 23, 2005 I now look at that commercial with the gleeful guy praising "10,000 flushes!" with his big grin in a whole new light.
prose Posted December 23, 2005 Posted December 23, 2005 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' date='Dec 23 2005, 02:18 AM']It just seems like there should be a simpler way to detect fertility. All the mucous and cervix stuff seems weird to me. [right][snapback]834422[/snapback][/right] [/quote] My husband and I have always used the Billings Method (we are instructors too). It is simple. It just SOUNDS complicated. It is as easy as any artificial methods of family planning, but healthier both spiritually and physically. And it is 99.9% effective. See [url="http://www.billingsmethod.com"]http://www.billingsmethod.com[/url] or [url="http://www.woomb.com"]http://www.woomb.com[/url] for more info.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now