N/A Gone Posted December 22, 2005 Posted December 22, 2005 If The pope doesnt think he is jesus' replacement than why does he blatantly wear that badge of power? You may say that the Pope has walked the walk, in regards to helping the poor, however I find that as a slight misrepresentation. If he wanted to help the poor, perhaps he should sell some of what the Catholic Church owns. Jesus never owned much, if anything; Neither did John the Baptist or Paul. I say this in the kindest way, but the Catholic Church is probably the richest organization on the face of the Earth. I agree that authority is presented in the Bible, but Paul always mentions the role of Christ as the head of the Church... not the Pope. Christ and Christ alone is the leader. ------------- If been in this debate a while..what do you think how I should answer
OLAM Dad Posted December 22, 2005 Posted December 22, 2005 I'm new here, so if responding to trolls is forbidden please forgive me. The wealth that you say the Church has is not sitting in a bank, it is in its buildings, property, and art work. These things that the Church own belong to the Church, not to the Pope. Therefore he couldn't sell them even if he desired to personally. As a member of the Church I vote that we don't sell any of our masterpieces, any of our property, or any of our beautiful buildings. I can just imagine what would happen if we did sell some of it. Michaelangelo's Pieta would be adorning Michael Jackson's neverland ranch. No thanks. Anybody else want to submit their vote?
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted December 22, 2005 Posted December 22, 2005 He's actualy presenting the opinion of someone he's debating, not his own. What I will say is that the Church does not have as much as it appears. Look at all the lawsuits, ect. going on right now. Churches are closing all over my diocese. The Church's money is donated, not taxed. The faithful can choose to put money toward Church missionary/relief projects if they want. Another thought that occurs to me is that some of the "valuables" the Church "owns" are only valuable because the Church owns them. Example: The Pieta was once just a piece of stone that was shaped by an artist. When it came into the Church's possession, it was not worth what it is now. Now that Michealangelo is famous and the Pieta is old, it is worth much more.
Church Punk Posted December 22, 2005 Posted December 22, 2005 Christ is head of the Church! There is absolutely no disputing this the Pope as well as any good Catholic will testify to this. The Pope the seat of Peter, a disciple of Christ. He has power over the Church and only because Christ gave him it. He Answers to Christ only. By no means of selling all of the treasures that are currently in the Church’s possession will be helping the poor. In fact money is the root of most of their problems. To truly help the poor we must educate them, teach them sustenance. Teach them to stick together against corrupt governments in solidarity. The Church as well as the Pope offer the nourishment of Christ for those who are poor in spirit, for those who hunger and thirst for justice. As for the statement the Church is rich (material wise) which many have claimed in the past, this is a rather gray area as in terms of material value the Church is very rich in gold, paintings buildings and land. However in this day and age these things hold less value than they did ages ago and also hold a very strong historical value but is virtually useless to anyone else but the Church. In terms of money the Church is poor in comparison to any mega tycoon. The Vatican is its own State (country) all money that runs through the Vatican is used to support the state, support the schools, to provide sustenance for all of the clergy that are in habited with in her walls and through out the world. Also the Church has in place countless missions, world aide organizations and what not. Many of its members are martyred daily for this work that they carry out. Visit any Catholic church anywhere and I defy you to find one that would claim to be financially well off. Many Churches are closing because of lack of funds!
Paphnutius Posted December 22, 2005 Posted December 22, 2005 [quote name='Revprodeji' date='Dec 22 2005, 11:04 AM']You may say that the Pope has walked the walk, in regards to helping the poor, however I find that as a slight misrepresentation. If he wanted to help the poor, perhaps he should sell some of what the Catholic Church owns. Jesus never owned much, if anything; Neither did John the Baptist or Paul. I say this in the kindest way, but the Catholic Church is probably the richest organization on the face of the Earth. [/quote] I would like to see some statistics that would say we are the richest organization. Regardless, the Church does do a vast amount of work in missionary fields, relief, and in education. I have personally been on mission trips to Honduras where we built houses out of cinder blocks from the ground up. The people there have nothing, and the Catholic Church, among others, is doing a great amount there to relieve temporal ailments and educate the faithful there. This is a straw man that is easy to disprove. Also, the art and churches that the Church has serves a purpose of showing forth the glory of God. Also, isnt it mentioned somewhere that Paul has learned to live with both abundance and with little? There is a thread on this board that discusses the morality of possessions [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=44087"]here.[/url] It discusses how a Christian may own things and have the correct disposition of heart towards charity. I would say that the Church has its art and its possessions yet still retains that correct disposition. [quote]If The pope doesnt think he is jesus' replacement than why does he blatantly wear that badge of power? I agree that authority is presented in the Bible, but Paul always mentions the role of Christ as the head of the Church... not the Pope. Christ and Christ alone is the leader. [/quote] What is the "badge of power" that he is referring to that designates the pope as Jesus' replacement (which is false). Well, it is good that he agrees there are proofs of authority in the Bible. The next part is to get him to see that Christ chose Peter as the head of the apostles for this role. Let's begin by looking at some of the logic behind his argument. His argument is built implicitly on what he considers a logical impossibility: a thing cannot have two heads. At first glance this would seem to be what Catholics believe and would be impossible, but lets look at some of the other metaphors in the Bible. How can the Church be both the Body of Christ and the bride of Christ? How can Christ be both a cornerstone and a capstone? How can Christ have two natures? I just wanted to point out that if his argument is built off of the seeming illogical errors found in Scripture, there are quite a many things we would have to throw out. Can a body have two heads? No, but the one head can deligate its authority to another, raising him to a position of leadership. Secondly, Catholics do not believe that the pope is the absolute head of all the Church. That is God, but the pope serves as the chief shepherd because of his delegation from Christ. Christ is the head of the Church, but has appointed, or delegated this authority unto the apostles, of which Peter was the head, until His return. We are shown this by Christ telling Peter to feed His sheep (Jn 21:17). Here Christ is entrusting Peter, as head of the apostles and the Church until Christ's return, with the responsibility and authority to feed and shepherd the Church. Again in Lk 22:32 we see how Peter's faith will serve to strengthen the brethren, placing him in a leadership and authoritive role, and in Acts 1:13-26 it was Peter who conducted the metting which elected Matthias. If your friend agrees that there are instances of authority in Scripture he must answer to whom this authority was given and what it entails. I believe that it is clear from several places, including those mentioned above, that Christ chose the apostles and their successors to be leaders of the Church He was founding. Peter, as head of this apostolic body, was entrusted as the chief shepherd of Christ's flock until He returns granting him the authority to speak with His name (Lk 10:16). New Advent can explain it better than I can. From [url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/15006b.htm"]New Advent[/url] [quote] Properly speaking, this magisterium is a teaching authority; it not only presents the truth, but it has the right to impose it, since its power is the very power given by God to Christ and by Christ to His Church. This authority is called the teaching Church. The teaching Church is essentially composed of the episcopal body, which continues here below the work and mission of the Apostolic College. It was indeed in the form of a college or social body that Christ grouped His Apostles and it is likewise as a social body that the episcopate exercises its mission to teach. Doctrinal infallibility has been guaranteed to the episcopal body and to the head of that body as it was guaranteed to the Apostles, with this difference, however, between the Apostles and the bishops that each Apostle was personally infallible (in virtue of his extraordinary mission as founder and the plenitude of the Holy Ghost received on Pentecost by the Twelve and later communicated to St. Paul as to the Twelve), whereas only the body of bishops is infallible and each bishop is not so, save in proportion as he teaches in communion and concert with the entire episcopal body. At the head of this episcopal body is the supreme authority of the Roman pontiff, the successor of St. Peter in his primacy as he is his successor in his see. As supreme authority in the teaching body, which is infallible, he himself is infallible. The episcopal body is infallible also, but only in union with its head, from whom moreover it may not separate, since to do so would be to separate from the foundation on which the Church is built. The authority of the pope may be exercised without the co-operation of the bishops, and this even in infallible decisions which both bishops and faithful are bound to receive with the same submission. The authority of the bishops may be exercised in two ways; now each bishop teaches the flock confided to him, again the bishops assemble in council to draw up together and pass doctrinal or disciplinary decrees. When all the bishops of the Catholic world (this totality is to be understood as morally speaking; it suffices for the whole Church to be represented) are thus assembled in council the council is called oecumenical. The doctrinal decrees of an oecumenical council, once they are approved by the pope, are infallible as are the ex cathedra definitions of the sovereign pontiff. [/quote]
thessalonian Posted December 22, 2005 Posted December 22, 2005 (edited) [quote name='Revprodeji' date='Dec 22 2005, 11:04 AM'] I agree that authority is presented in the Bible, but Paul always mentions the role of Christ as the head of the Church... not the Pope. Christ and Christ alone is the leader. [/quote] This is the key to where I head for the answer. It presents a false dichotomy which is common in Protestantism and which even Catholics have many trouble filtering out. I've caught protestants saying that Peter is not any part of the foundation of the Church, siting 1 Cor 3:11 which says that Christ is the foundation of the Church. However to make such a claim that Peter is not a part of the foundation is to deny eph 2:20 and put it in conflict with 1 Cor 3:11. To assert that Christ is the foundation does not mean that noone else is. Likewise in your case to assert that Christ is the head of the Church must recognize that he works through men and so it is not a contradiction to say that the Pope or Peter is the head of the Church. Christ works through them and so they and Christ are one in the same head. I know this will rankly Protestant feathers. But would any Protestant deny that Christians are the light of the world? Yet scripture also says Christ is the light of the world. There are other examples of these false dichotomies. It is clear that Peter was the leader of the Church, duly appointed by Christ in Matt 16:18. Peter alone was given the keys, reminisent of Is 22:22 and the authority given to eliakim. The Steward of the Old Testament Davidic Kingdom spoke for the king. Peter is always mentioned first in lists of the Apostles. He always speaks when the group is asked questions. He is mentioned far more than any other of the 12. He walks on water like Christ. Christ preaches from his boat (the Barque of Peter). Lot's of other little interesting facts that point to Peter being the chief of the Apostles. Further Peter takes the lead in the council in Acts 16. Blessings Edited December 22, 2005 by thessalonian
Nathan Posted December 22, 2005 Posted December 22, 2005 I read somewhere that the Catholic Church, all over the world, operates on an annual budget of about $50 million. That's $50 million to serve one BILLION Catholics worldwide. It's peanuts.
phatcatholic Posted December 23, 2005 Posted December 23, 2005 here are some articles that may help: [b]--[url="http://davidmacd.com/catholic/isn_church_rich.htm"]Isn't the Church Rich?[/url] --[url="http://www.geocities.com/Athens/Acropolis/5743/answers2.html"]Questions on Policy and Practices[/url] [/b](see questions 4-6) [b]--[url="http://www.catholicapologetics.net/WORLDLINESS.htm"]The "Wealth" and "Worldliness" of the Catholic Church[/url] --[url="http://www.cuf.org/Faithfacts/details_view.asp?ffID=242"]Vatican Wealth[/url][/b] pax christi, phatcatholic
Era Might Posted January 5, 2006 Posted January 5, 2006 (edited) Interestingly enough, Pope John Paul II spoke of the need to part with the Church's temporal goods in some cases: [quote]Thus, part of the teaching and most ancient practice of the Church is her conviction that she is obliged by her vocation - she herself, her ministers and each of her members - to relieve the misery of the suffering, both far and near, not only out of her "abundance" but also out of her "necessities." Faced by cases of need, one cannot ignore them in favor of superfluous church ornaments and costly furnishings for divine worship; on the contrary it could be obligatory to sell these goods in order to provide food, drink, clothing and shelter for those who lack these things. As has been already noted, here we are shown a "hierarchy of values" - in the framework of the right to property - between"having" and "being," especially when the "having" of a few can be to the detriment of the "being" of many others. --Encyclical Letter "Sollicitudo rei socialis"[/quote] This has been done many times throughout the centuries. One of the most well-known examples is St. Lawrence the Deacon, who was in charge of the Church's treasury, which he sold off to help the poor. Popes have melted down tiaras in the past to aid an urgent cause. The key here is context. It's not wrong for the Church to present beauty and wealth to the Lord, as Mary Magdalene anointed Jesus with expensive oil, contrary to the protest of the Apostles. The treasures of the Roman See, in particular, are unique, because they are universal treasures, and are beacons of beauty and truth to the entire Church. In the local Churches, and even in the diocese of Rome, as I mentioned, times come when we must sacrifice. But we are not Manichees. Edited January 5, 2006 by Era Might
Matty_boy Posted January 5, 2006 Posted January 5, 2006 [quote name='Revprodeji' date='Dec 22 2005, 11:04 AM']If The pope doesnt think he is jesus' replacement than why does he blatantly wear that badge of power? [right][snapback]833783[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Jesus didn't wear a badge of power. The construct of your statement implies that Jesus wore a badge of power and that Jesus' replacement takes his place by wearing the badge.
Didacus Posted January 5, 2006 Posted January 5, 2006 Ask the people who lost their beloved dioceses in the region of Timmins (my home town), where several parishes where closed because of financial troubles what they think of this subject. Their reply might not be the most polite however. My vote: Sell nothing. And I agree as posted above, to help the poor is much more than simply throuwing money thier way.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now