Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

photosynthesis
Posted

I am reading Hail Holy Queen too... so far it's great.

Mary was never one of the Catholic doctrines I ever had a problem with. I was Protestant for awhile (i strayed away from the Church when i was in high school, then "accepted Jesus" and went to evangelical churches) but never really anti-Mary per se...

I think the reason why I was protestant was because that was how I came to know Jesus. But after I actually did some research into the history of Christianity I realized that Sola Scriptura was something Protestants invented and not something that Jesus taught. so that led me away from Protestantism and into the Catholcic Church.

Many people are Protestant because of a flawed understanding of history.

Posted

You might also provide your Dad with the "human" perspective
1. Can you believe that God would prepare for the coming of His son by making sure that the woman who bore him was pure and holy?
(that's at least half the way to Immaculate Conception and Virgin Birth)
Can you believe that Gabriel greeted her with great respect, and on behalf of God? Can you believe that Elizabeth called her the mother of the Lord while Jesus was still in her womb? She was a very special person.
2. Can you believe that Mary was a disciple and believer in her Son? That she started him on his divine ministry at Canaa and stayed with Him until Calvary; that she was praying with the apostles in the upper room at Pentecost? Because of her love and devotion to Jesus, and her sacrifices, can you believe that Jesus might give his mother a "pass" to Heaven (not that she needed a free ride, she earned every bit of it . . . but I'm trying to keep this in human terms)
(that's the Assumption)
3. Can you believe that Jesus is at least a Prince, if not a King? What historically was the title given to the royal mother?
(there's the Queen of Heaven)

It might take a little fleshing out (I'm no theologian), but I didn't have as much of a problem accepting the Marian dogma . . . nor do I have a lot of issues with the doctrine that wants to be dogma . . . but then I didn't come from one of the Protestant faiths that make Mary a symbol of all that is wrong with the Catholic church.

4. Can you believe that Jesus might listen to his mother before he listens to me?
(there's the mediatrix)

I'm sure there's a lot of detail I've missed . . . and if the belief system is that prayers have to go directly to Jesus because everyone else is dead, "just plain dead," the communion of saints is where you start, and not with Mary in particular.

If he can make the "human" connections (and he does believe that Jesus was both human and divine?), then you can reassure him that he doesn't "have" to pray to Mary if he doesn't want to. Just as he doesn't have to pray to St. Thomas More or St. Jude or St. Teresa. It is a "communion" (community?) of saints . . . and he can pray in whatever he feels most comfortable (that is limited, I think, to private prayer)

Posted

I can really relate to what you're going through Sojourner. My dad's a non-denom elder/pastor. But you're already much farther along in the discussion than we are. I'm still trying to convince him that Constantine didn't kill the true Church and that institution or heirarchy is not a dirty word.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...