Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

I found this on another Catholic forum:


Recommended Posts

Posted

Pope St. Innocent, 414: “But that which Your Fraternity asserts the Pelagians preach, that even without the grace of Baptism infants are able to be endowed with the rewards of eternal life, [b]is quite idiotic[/b].” (Jurgens, The Faith of the Early Fathers, Vol. 3: 2016.)

Pope Eugene IV, Council of Florence, “Letentur coeli,” Sess. 6, July 6, 1439, [b]ex cathedra[/b]: “We [i]define [/i]also that… the souls of those who depart this life in actual mortal sin, [i]or in original sin alone[/i], go straightaway to hell, but to undergo punishments of different kinds.” (Denz. 693)

Pope Pius VI, Auctorem fidei, Aug. 28, 1794:
“26. The doctrine which rejects as a Pelagian fable, that place of the lower regions (which the faithful generally designate by the name of the limbo of the children) in which the souls of those departing with the sole guilt of original sin are punished with the punishment of the condemned, exclusive of the punishment of fire, just as if, by this very fact, that these who remove the punishment of fire introduced that middle place and state free of guilt and of punishment between the kingdom of God and eternal damnation, such as that about which the Pelagians idly talk” – Condemned as false, rash, injurious to Catholic schools. (Denz. 1596)

Pope Martin V, Council of Constance, Session 15, July 6, 1415 - Condemning the articles of John Wyclif - Proposition 6: “Those who claim that the children of the faithful dying without sacramental baptism will not be saved, are stupid and presumptuous in saying this.”- [b]Condemned[/b] (Decrees of the Ecumenical Councils, Vol. 1, p. 422.)

Pope St. Zosimus, The Council of Carthage, Canon on Sin and Grace, 417 A.D.- “It has been decided likewise that if anyone says that for this reason the Lord said: ‘In my Father’s house there are many mansions’ [John 14:2]: that it might be understood that in the kingdom of heaven there will be some middle place or some place anywhere where the blessed infants live who departed from this life without baptism, without which they cannot enter into the kingdom of heaven, which is life eternal, let him be anathema.” (Denzinger 102, authentic addition to Can. 2.)


It seems there is a problem on both ends of anyone's response to this. On the one hand, if these quotes are rejected as not having binding authority, a whole lot of quotes used elsewhere for the defense of conservative or "orthodox" Catholicism are open to the same treatment. On the other hand, if they are accepted, limbo must be accepted.

What do you think?

Posted

The Holy Father does not believe in Limbo, and in fact, would personally like to see it dropped as a theological hypothesis. His understanding of Catholic doctrine is sufficient for me.

Posted

[quote name='Era Might' date='Jan 5 2006, 09:46 AM']The Holy Father does not believe in Limbo, and in fact, would personally like to see it dropped as a theological hypothesis. His understanding of Catholic doctrine is sufficient for me.
[right][snapback]846689[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

None the less, I believe interesting points have been brougt up with the quotes. Not being a scholar myself, here are my thoughts;

1. is this spoken with infaillibility?

2. What is the meaning intended behingd 'original sin alone'?

3. There seems to be missing info to reach the conclusion. Is this quote part of a list? What is this list trying to demonstrate?

4. Need to verify the context behind this one. I find it very surprising that a council would draw a conclusion of stupidity towards people who hold a certain belief. I would dig deeper into this quote before using it myself anywhere else.

5. [quote]without baptism, without which they cannot enter into the kingdom of heaven, [/quote] This quote seems pretty straight forward to me but I have a lot of trouble accepting it. This tells me that it is not possible to go to heaven without receiving a baptism which I do believe is incorrect. (how many billions of people have never been baptised in the world today?)
After that, the passage refers to a specific verse of the bible, and I don't believe it aims to draw a general conclusion. Maybe the intent is not to supercede a different conclusion from the verse? It simply states not ot believe this from reading this; it does not states that belive this is wrong, and leaves open (logically) to believe anything else from reading this. What it rejects is linking the two.

Posted

[quote name='Era Might' date='Jan 5 2006, 10:46 AM']The Holy Father does not believe in Limbo, and in fact, would personally like to see it dropped as a theological hypothesis.
[right][snapback]846689[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
AMEN!

Posted

Double Amen!

I've only been able to find opinions by different popes, but never doctrine.

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

First step is to look them up. Sometimes you find out that the quotes are out of context or were made up entirely.

Posted

[quote]Pope Eugene IV, Council of Florence, “Letentur coeli,” Sess. 6, July 6, 1439, ex cathedra: “We define also that… the souls of those who depart this life in actual mortal sin, or in original sin alone, go straightaway to hell, but to undergo punishments of different kinds.” (Denz. 693)[/quote]

This is what the The Catholic Encyclopedia says about this quote;


[quote]Finally, in regard to the teaching of the Council of Florence, it is incredible that the Fathers there assembled had any intention of defining a question so remote from the issue on which reunion with the Greeks depended, and one which was recognized at the time as being open to free discussion and continued to be so regarded by theologians for several centuries afterwards. What the council evidently intended to deny in the passage alleged was the postponement of final awards until the day of judgement. Those dying in original sin are said to descend into Hell, but this does not necessarily mean anything more than that they are excluded eternally from the vision of God. In this sense they are damned; they have failed to reach their supernatural destiny, and this viewed objectively is a true penalty. Thus the Council of Florence, however literally interpreted, does not deny the possibility of perfect subjective happiness for those dying in original sin, and this is all that is needed from the dogmatic viewpoint to justify the prevailing Catholic notion of the children's limbo, while form the standpoint of reason, as St. Gregory of Nazianzus pointed out long ago, no harsher view can be reconciled with a worthy concept of God's justice and other attributes.
[/quote]
[url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/09256a.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/09256a.htm[/url]

Posted (edited)

[quote]The Council of Carthage, Canon on Sin and Grace, 417 A.D.- “It has been decided likewise that if anyone says that for this reason the Lord said: ‘In my Father’s house there are many mansions’ [John 14:2]: that it might be understood that in the kingdom of heaven there will be some middle place or some place anywhere where the blessed infants live who departed from this life without baptism, without which they cannot enter into the kingdom of heaven, which is life eternal, let him be anathema.” (Denzinger 102, authentic addition to Can. 2.)[/quote]

The following is from The Catholic Encyclopedia;

[quote]But even before the outbreak of the Pelagian controversy St. Augustine had already abandoned the lenient traditional view, and in the course of the controversy he himself condemned, and persuaded the Council of Carthage (418) to condemn, the substantially identical Pelagian teaching affirming the existence of "an intermediate place, or of any place anywhere at all (ullus alicubi locus), in which children who pass out of this life unbaptized live in happiness" (Denzinger 102). This means that St. Augustine and the African Fathers believed that unbaptized infants share in the common positive misery of the damned, and the very most that St. Augustine concedes is that their punishment is the mildest of all, so mild indeed that one may not say that for them non-existence would be preferable to existence in such a state (De peccat. meritis I, xxi; Contra Jul. V, 44; etc.). [b]But this Augustinian teaching was an innovation in its day, and the history of subsequent Catholic speculation on this subject is taken up chiefly with the reaction which has ended in a return to the pre-Augustinian tradition[/b].[/quote]

[url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/09256a.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/09256a.htm[/url]

Edited by Cure of Ars
Posted

Not infallibly defined and not upheld by the Ordinary Universal Magisterium.

There have been no councils on it, no [i]Ex Cathedra[/i] statements (only the two!) and no Bishop can decide on what Limbo is, much less them all hold it up.

I still like to believe in it though. :)

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

A few further points:

It is not possible to enter into the kingdom of heaven without baptism, when baptism is understood as that Grace by which we are united with the Mystical Body of Christ, this much [i]is[/i] infallible.

Thus, we believe in One Baptism, that may manifest itself through water (normative) or through Blood or Desire (extraordinary). It is evident that none of these apply to children, however, that does not mean that there does not exist some fourth means by which God unites them to the Church (i.e. a fourth manifestation of Baptism).

Therefore, it is not necessary to believe in limbo, and it is perfectly acceptable to trust the souls of the infant departed to the mercy of God. What [i]cannot[/i] be said is that those children are definitively saved. We can only say that we do not know.

This lack of knowledge is what lead many theologians to posit limbo, not an authoritative declaration from the Magisterium.

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff

goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' date='Jan 5 2006, 09:46 AM']The Holy Father does not believe in Limbo, and in fact, would personally like to see it dropped as a theological hypothesis. His understanding of Catholic doctrine is sufficient for me.
[right][snapback]846689[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Sure, but remember that all those quotes were by past popes. Respecting the beliefs of our leader is certainly commendable, but do we reject the beliefs of past popes in doing so?

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='goldenchild17' date='Jan 9 2006, 12:49 AM']Sure, but remember that all those quotes were by past popes.  Respecting the beliefs of our leader is certainly commendable, but do we reject the beliefs of past popes in doing so?
[right][snapback]850113[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Pretty much. The expressed theological opinions of the current pontiff have a priority over those of past popes. The class of theories typically called limbo is simply an attempt at a cohesive interpretation of doctrine; they aren't formally doctrinal in themselves. No particular limbo theory has ever been formally defined by the Church or proposed for belief. It is a matter of opinion. Certainly such theories have had a notable presence in speculative theology and the catechetical tradition (at least in the Western church during certain periods of history), but it still does not have a doctrinal status which warrants the assent of faith. We ought to give religious assent to the manifest mind of the current Holy Father.

And interestingly, I am aware of official, authoritative decrees of the Church which undermine limbo theory (at least many versions of it). The issue is not as simple as it may appear on the surface.

goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' date='Jan 9 2006, 01:11 AM']We ought to give religious assent to the manifest mind of the current Holy Father. [/quote]
I don't mean to argue but what is this based on? If it's nothing more than his opinion why can't a person believe as many past popes did?

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum' date='Jan 9 2006, 01:11 AM']And interestingly, I am aware of official, authoritative decrees of the Church which undermine limbo theory (at least many versions of it). The issue is not as simple as it may appear on the surface.
[right][snapback]850117[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
I'm sure you are and I'm sure it isn't :). I don't intend to argue the doctrine itself as my beliefs are a bit messed up right now and I need to sort them out before defending to many specific positions.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='goldenchild17' date='Jan 9 2006, 01:49 AM']I don't mean to argue but what is this based on?  If it's nothing more than his opinion why can't a person believe as many past popes did? 
[right][snapback]850118[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

[color=gray]From Dr. Ludwig Ott:[/color]
[i]Only those are infallible which emanate from General Councils representing the whole episcopate, and the Papal Decisions Ex Cathedra (cf. D 1839). The ordinary and usual form of the Papal teaching activity is not infallible. Further, the decisions of the Roman Congregations (Holy Office, Bible Commission) are not infallible. Nevertheless normally [b]they are to be accepted with an inner assent which is based on the high supernatural authority of the Holy See [/b](assensus internus supernaturalis, assensus religiosus). The so-called "silentium obsequiosum." that is "reverent silence," does not generally suffice. By way of exception, the obligation of inner agreement may cease if a competent expert, after a renewed scientific investigation of all grounds, arrives at the positive conviction that the decision rests on an error.[/i]

[color=gray]Fr. John Trugilio:[/color]
[i]According to Pope Pius XII in Humani Generis & Vatican II in Lumen Gentium #25, [b]even non-infallible teachings are to receive the submission of mind and will of the faithful[/b]. While not requiring the ASSENT OF FAITH, they CANNOT be disputed nor rejected publicly and the benefit of the doubt must be given to the one possessing the fullness of teaching authority. The heterodox concept of a dual magisteria, i.e., the theologians, is not based on scriptural nor traditional grounds. Some have gone as far as to propose a triple magisteria, the body of believers. While it is true that as a whole, the body of believers is infallible in that SENSUS FIDEI is that the Church as the Mystical Body cannot be in error on matters of faith and morals, the TEACHING AUTHORITY (Magisterium) resides solely with the Roman Pontiff and the College of Bishops in union with him.[/i]

[color=gray]And finally, from the Dogmatic Constitution on the Church (Lumen Gentium) no. 25:[/color]
[i]Bishops who teach in communion with the Roman Pontiff are to be revered by all as witnesses of divine and Catholic truth; the faithful, for their part, are obliged to submit to their bishops' decision, made in the name of Christ, in matters of faith and morals, and to adhere to it with a ready and respectful allegiance of mind. [b]This loyal submission of the will and intellect must be given, in a special way, to the authentic teaching authority of the Roman Pontiff, even when he does not speak ex cathedra[/b] in such wise, indeed, that his supreme teaching authority be acknowledged with respect, and [b]sincere assent be given to decisions made by him, conformably with his manifest mind and intention[/b], which is made known principally either by the character of the documents in question, or by the frequency with which a certain doctrine is proposed, or by the manner in which the doctrine is formulated. [/i]

But a Catholic is still free to hold to limbo theory as it has never been condemned. But it would be a gross error to suggest that limbo is an authoritative doctrine or that the Pope is in error for not speaking of it.
However, I would say that it is best to try and understand and conform to the mind of the Church in this epoch. Limbo theory has never been universally accepted and is really a pretty poor solution to the problem (IMHO). You might be a bit surprised by some of the names I could drop of venerable theologians who had serious reservations regarding limbo theory. I personally am quite open to the insight and direction of the current Pontiff and the Bishops in union with him.

Posted

See, what's interesting to me though is that there are lots of things that we believe that have never *formally* been "defined" - it's quite a loophole. Most the people on these boards feel free to pick and choose what parts of the CCC are binding on all believers and what parts aren't (contraception, for instance, versus Islam's God being our God, death penalty, grave social and government obligations, etc.). That sounds pretty subjective and relative, to me.

I've seen threads were a whole slew of quotes will pop up in an attempt to prove that if you don't believe something, you're not Catholic. But here's a whole slew of quotes that have suddenly become very relative.

P.S. I bet if somebody tried telling the common lay person or a pope hundreds of years ago that limbo didn't exist, they would think you were a heretic at worst and a very uneducated Catholic at best.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Ziggamafu' date='Jan 9 2006, 05:41 AM']See, what's interesting to me though is that there are lots of things that we believe that have never *formally* been "defined" - it's quite a loophole. Most the people on these boards feel free to pick and choose what parts of the CCC are binding on all believers and what parts aren't (contraception, for instance, versus Islam's God being our God, death penalty, grave social and government obligations, etc.). That sounds pretty subjective and relative, to me.

I've seen threads were a whole slew of quotes will pop up in an attempt to prove that if you don't believe something, you're not Catholic. But here's a whole slew of quotes that have suddenly become very relative.
[right][snapback]850166[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Aren't you the one picking and choosing, and making the interpretation of formal doctrine something quite subjective? The fact is the baltimore catechism style limbo theory is incompatible with the hope for the salvation of unbaptized infants that the universal catechism speaks of.
If limbo is true, we have no hope, unbaptized infants simply go to this third place (or maybe its just the nicest pit of hell depending on who you ask), the problem is solved, why speak of hope?

There are plenty of aspects of Catholic theology that are in the realm of opinion and speculation. Generally these are things which are not strictly in the realm of that which has been revealed. Just as the details of the mystery of free-will and grace have not been altogether revealed, and thus numerous interpretations and theories are possible, so too with the fate of unbaptized infants. Limbo theories are often a twisted over-simplification of the matter. The Catholic Faith teaches that there is heaven and hell, not heaven, hell and limbo (purgatory is a temporal not an eternal state so I've omitted it). How do you understand limbo anyway? Would you say it is hell minus the positive punishments? Heaven minus beatific vision? A third place/state altogether? Perhaps a state of pure nature and new kind of earth in which the unbaptized who have no actual sin live out their eternity in a merely natural happiness Jehova's Witness style? I am convinced that any of the classical approaches to limbo theory have insurmountable problems and heretical tendencies. And one can produce magisterial statements throughout history which pose problems for those who think that dogma favours limbo.

[quote name='Ziggamafu' date='Jan 9 2006, 05:41 AM']P.S. I bet if somebody tried telling the common lay person or a pope hundreds of years ago that limbo didn't exist, they would think you were a heretic at worst and a very uneducated Catholic at best.
[right][snapback]850166[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Many esteemed theologians of the past couple hundred years have rejected limbo, or at least what people commonly have in mind when they speak of limbo. For example Griolamo Savonarola, Ambrose Catharinus (glorified bodies), Cardinal Cajetan (vicarious baptism of desire), Heinrich Klee (enlightened choice at the moment of death), Cardinal Journet (participation in the resurrected body of Christ).

According to Divine Revelation and the deposit of Faith there are two eternal dwellings, heaven and hell. The positing of new eternal abodes cannot be grounded in Revelation, it is conjecture. This is why perhaps the majority of theologians in the limbo tradition equate it with hell. It is hell minus the positive punishments, or a kind of "painless" hell, if that makes any sense at all. The later (post medieval) versions are often based on an idea of pure nature which I would say is pure nonsense. And nevermind the fact that the Church condemned the ultra-augustinian version of limbo theory present in Jansenism. I tend to consider the pop-limbo theory that crept into certain local catechisms in the not too distant past to be a kind of creeping Jansenism.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[i]Almost two years ago I rambled on about limbo for some time on a certain thread. My position remains essentially the same to this day (with some exceptions). I've decided to save myself some typing and do a bit of copy and paste. Sadly, it is pretty much informal babbling, I wish it was more systematic and less repetitive[/i]

I claim that:

1. Limbo is a theory, not a doctrine taught by the Church.
2. I think the theories of limbo (as I understand them) are problematic.
3. I believe we have reason to hope for the salvation of the unbaptised babies.
4. I think an adequate interpretation of what has been revealed is possible that does not require positing limbo.
5. I have no problem with people holding to limbo and I don't think my opinion is necessarily correct; it's just what I think based on my limited, fallible knowledge.

I've always considered the idea of limbo to be linked with the neo-scholastic distortions of the medieval theory of pure nature.. Since I reject the idea of pure nature I tend to not see the necessity of positing limbo.
And while it might be the case that certain aspects of the theology pertaining to limbo are a substantial part of the Catholic tradition, I tend toward the idea that much of the formal theologizing on limbo in the post-Trent period is baggage that the Church would do well to shed, which perhaps is something of what the Pope has encouraged by possibly trying to redirect and reorient the discussion on these issues. I do believe that much of the Tridentine theorizing on limbo has come under attack and scrutiny in late 20th century Theology. For the Pope to support the neo-scholastic formulations would be to ignore the more recent developments.

Limbo is almost exclusively a matter of speculative Theology and different approaches are possible whilst still remaining within the bounds of orthodoxy. I would not absolutize specific traditions or theories as if they constitute a part of Sacred Tradition. This is similar to the issue of predestination. There are various schools, various dominant approaches during different periods, different controversies, and definitive teachings which guide the debate. One can be an Augustinian, a Thomist, a Molinist, etc. and still be orthodox. Heck, one can come pretty darn close to Calvinism and still be orthodox.
Similarly with limbo, I think one can reject the term altogether and still remain in orthodoxy. There are developments in the Theology of nature and grace which reorient the understanding of the issues surrounding limbo.

And the idea that novelty on the part of a Roman Pontiff is suspect is hardly consistent with the history of the development of doctrine. What's so new or unusual about that? Ultimately it is the authority of the Magisterium alone that can interpret and expound upon such matters with any real weight. The term limbo and much of the theological speculation that comes along with that term are matters of small "t" tradition. And the Pope is not bound to the consensus of the Fathers or medievals by any means. If this was the case the definition of the Immaculate Conception would hardly be consistent considering a large case can be made against it on these terms. Consider how many Fathers even attribute actual sin to Our Lady, or how many great doctors argue against the doctrine (St. Bernard and Aquinas for example). Developments and even dogmas can fly in the face of centuries of theologizing because private speculative Theology is not synonymous with the deposit of Faith. And the Church's understanding of certain issues is not always adequate in times past. New breakthroughs (such as Scotus' great defense of the Immaculate Conception) lead to new directions and developments which render older views and approaches obsolete, even if they were held by many great Fathers and Doctors. And Augustine had many novel views that were foreign to the Fathers before him. Some have become standard or even dogmatic, others have been rejected. I think it is best to leave such discernment to the Magisterium which has such a charism. Otherwise you will likely fall into error. If you hold the current Pontiff or Magisterium in suspicion this is a clear sign of this danger of error.

It's been a while since I've really looked into the theories on limbo but I have some impressions that remain from past study. First of all there have been many different theories proposed throughout the course of the Church's history; ranging from the positive damnation of unbaptized infants, to their full sharing in beatific vision and a bodily resurrection. I think the commonly proposed view of these babies partaking of a state of natural happiness is problematic for a number of reasons. For one I think it's inner logic suffers from a kind of residual Platonism which is not authentically Catholic. I would also argue that its post-Trent formulations, which were largely based on Thomas' theory of natural happiness, are tainted by various reactionary trends in the Augustinian tradition (contra Pelagius). For example the concept of original sin based primarily in terms of the positive effects of concupiscence as opposed to the negative loss of original justice. This leads to a working concept of nature which obscures the 'imago Dei' and is something more or less opposed to grace. Whereas I believe the understanding of nature as being fundamentally ordered toward grace is more Catholic and would give speculation on the limbo issues a different inner dynamic. The concept of pure nature is more or less speculative nonsense based on inadequate trends in Theology. Something else that I think is important to consider is the Theological development on this subject in the East, independent of the Augustinian and scholastic traditions. Here we find a substantially different thrust on these issues which might bring some new life into the discussion.
I'm far from an expert on the subject and am just spouting off for what its worth. If I am way off and/or totally wrong so be it.
Oh, something else I wonder about is the influence of things such as Jansenism on the more recent development of limbo. There was definitely a kind of Augustinian extremism in the air for a while there. A Pope formally condemned the Jansenist view which was basically at the same time a condemnation of the Augustinian view which was so influential on the development of this theory.

The Theological traditions that opposed the doctrine of the Immaculate Conception did so largely based on theological problematics that were insurmountable at the time. Later breakthroughs (e.g., Scotus) rendered these past theologies obsolete and paved the way for the eventual definition. So now when we look back on theological traditions we see errors and shortcomings in the reasoning and conclusions because our understanding of the deposit of faith has deepened. What was inconceivable at one time (no pun intended) is now dogma. And it should also be kept in mind that the dogma is not a complete innovation because in the earlier theological traditions there is a discernable trend of believing that Our Lady possessed the highest possible honor and perfection of sanctity possible. The earlier theologies had certain confusions and lacked an adequate understanding of the operations of the Redemption which could allow for something like the Immaculate Conception.

I think an analogy can be made between this development and that of limbo. Earlier theologies wrestled with lofty problems on a speculative level on which Scripture has nothing explicit to offer. These speculations were made within primitive frameworks of understanding and lacked the foundations necessary to really resolve the problems. Hence various compromise theories were proposed. The damnation of the unbaptized souls proposal rests upon theological premises which are outdated so one can say that the conclusions are faulty. (You have to look at more than just the fact that so and so said it, or x number of people said it. The actual validity of the inner logic must be examined in light of the Church's current understanding of theology). Similarly the natural happiness approach is naive in some ways and perhaps presupposes a theology of nature/grace that is incomplete and lacking. So the point is I think there is room for a legitimate development on this issue that may lead to a definition of some kind in the near future based on the deeper understanding of theology that the Church has now. And this is an important question especially today in light of the tragedy of abortion. Where have all the babies gone? Where do people's dead infants and miscarried children go? Are they suffering eternal torment in hell? Are they in a state of natural happiness and able to interact with the souls in heaven? In other words will mothers be with their babies in heaven? Or are they in a natural happiness but forever separated from the souls in heaven? Are they perhaps little bundles of joy in heaven praying for their parents on earth? There are other possibilities too I imagine. I think a case can be made that they are in heaven and that this view has a place in tradition (esp. in the East) and that much of the limbo speculations have been misguided. A discernable trend in the theologies has been trying to do justice to God's goodness in the face of the current understanding of original sin, nature and grace, salvation, etc. It is most certainly false to assert the damnation of these holy innocents (the carthage problem is not much of a problem-- talk later), in my opinion natural happiness is a kind of by-product of underdeveloped Theology, and I believe that the more pleasant alternative will prove to be most reasonable and will hopefully be revealed as the true teaching through the teaching authority of the Church. This will do justice to the nature of God as Absolute Goodness, Love, etc. and to the fuller Catholic vision of the world in relation to God as well as the oikonomia. It will also be more expressive of the truth about human nature and original sin which is not tainted with a kind of creeping Gnostic dualism. It would also elucidate more God's Trinitarian dynamism and relatedness to the world as opposed to the otherness. I think this is why the "more pleasant alternative" comes more naturally to the East; their theological development has a deeper awareness of this fundamental relatedness and Trinitarian dynamism as well as the cosmic dimensions of the Incarnation and Redemption.


[quote] From Fr. Mateo:
"The notion of a Limbo for unbaptized babies never was a doctrine of the Church and the Church never taught it. At most it was a speculation on the part of certain theologians, and one never hears of it nowadays. There is no "official doctrine on the subject." God has not revealed the destiny of babies who die before baptism."

Fr. William Saunders:
"Note that the Church has never officially defined the doctrine of limbo. Rather, limbo is a theological supposition that became a popular way of dealing with a teaching of our Lord regarding the necessity of baptism for eternal salvation and what happens to the souls of individuals who die without being baptized."

Fr Phil Bloom:
"It [limbo] was never taught as an 'official' church doctrine"

Mario Derksen:
"The Limbo of Infants is the traditional opinion of the Church, and it originated with the thought of St. Augustine. It's not a doctrine; you're not required to believe it as a Catholic. We speculate about this."

From a popular Catholic Q&A:
"Limbo was a theological speculation."
"Limbo is not now and never was an official doctrine of the Church. It was simply a popular theory concerning the eternal fate of unbaptized but innocent persons."

Fr. Brian Wilson, L.C.
"A well-known pre-Vatican II catechetical source, Kilgallon and Weber’s Christ in Us, terms it [limbo] just 'the usual explanation of theologians.' In sum, even if the existence of limbo was once taught by some teachers of the Church, it was most certainly not irreformable or 'unchangeable' teaching."

Fr. Jim Corkery:
"The teaching office of the Church has never taken any official position on the question of limbo. Unofficially, limbo may have enjoyed a certain favour for a time."

Very Rev.Kevin Michael Quirk, JCD (Diocese of Wheeling-Charleston)
"With regard to Limbo, the Church has never officially taught the existence of Limbo and has never officially denied the existence of Limbo. The best teaching on the four final things (death, judgment, heaven, and hell) can be found in the papal encyclical Benedictus Deus by Pope Benedict XVI."

"Theologian and one of the authors of the new Catechism of the Catholic Church Bishop Alessandro Maggiolini has explained that limbo no longer appears in Christian doctrine, but instead we should consider that unbaptised babies as simply entrusted to the mercy of God. He said limbo was never defined as a dogma, but was a 'theological hypothesis not solidly founded on Revelation.'"

From the OSC Catholic Encyclopedia:
"It should be noted, however, that no official teaching ever advocated this notion [limbo]."

The Catechism of the Catholic Church does not use the term limbo nor does it present any theory of limbo.
"The Church does not know of any means other than baptism that assures entry into eternal beatitude. As regards children who have died without baptism, the Church can only entrust them to the mercy of God, as she does in her funeral rites for them . . the great mercy of God allows us to hope that there is a way of salvation for children who have died without baptism." (CCC 1257-1261)

The Roman Catechism of the Council of Trent did not even mention limbo.

From the Encarta Encyclopedia:
"Although the existence of limbo has frequently been discussed by theologians, the Roman Catholic church has no official position regarding the subject."
"The concept of limbo has remained similarly undefined and problematical in modern Roman Catholic doctrine."

Note that the Catholic Encyclopedia article on NewAdvent.org indicates the intent of the article with these words: "to give a brief sketch of the history of Catholic opinion on the subject."

A statement from a Catholics United for the Faith:
"Limbo has never been a formally defined doctrine of the Church, but rather a theological opinion. What Catholics believe regarding children who die without Baptism is summarized in Catechism, no. 1261."

Another statement from CUF:
"Limbo has never been a formally defined doctrine of the faith, but rather is a theological opinion used to harmonize (a) the necessity of Baptism; (b) God’s universal salvific will (cf. 1 Tim. 2:4); and © the fact that such children are without actual sin. Despite contemporary ridicule, limbo remains a respectable theological opinion that may be held by the faithful." [/quote]


I certainly admit that there are dogmatic teachings that relate to the theory of limbo, but that does not mean that limbo is dogmatic or the only possible solution to the problems posed. The common, Thomistic-based theory of limbo is one interpretation or proposed solution to the problem of infant, pre-baptismal death. There have been other theories and interpretations.
For example Cardinal Cajetan held the view that the desire of the parents to have their child baptized would be sufficient in the case of the child's death.
Here is a kind of intermediate theory:

[quote] "The great Swiss Cardinal, Charles Journet (A.D. 1891-1975), one of the few men made a cardinal because of his theological expertise, explained the doctrine of limbo in terms of salvation. According to Journet, children in limbo share in salvation because of the resurrection of Christ, in which it is absolutely certain they will share. Thus along with the natural happiness which is theirs because of their innocence, they will have the gifts of immortality and a happy social life with the rest of the human race, in particular with their parents. The fact that they don't share in the beatific vision does not deprive them of the other real and necessary elements of human happiness, or the happy association with those who do possess the beatific vision. Cardinal Journet says they will know and love Christ as the cause of their resurrection. Their resurrection will be their share in the salvation won by Christ for the human race of which they are a part. This view has the happy characteristics of being based only on dogmatic certainties: the resurrection of the dead, the necessity of baptism for supernatural life, and of emphasizing that our salvation consists not only in the supernatural beatific vision, even though this is its essential aspect, but also in the miraculous restoration of natural life, the survival of our person because of Christ's triumph over death." [/quote]

Using the argument of baptism by desire, some theologians speculated that God in His mercy would look favorably upon the desire for salvation of the Church, the family, the unbaptized infant, and even of Himself, and welcome the unbaptized child to Heaven. Here again the Magisterium provided succinct guidance. Pope Pius XII asserted that "an act of love can suffice for an adult to acquire sanctifying grace and supply for the lack of baptism; to the unborn or newly born infant, this way is not open" (Acta Apostolicae Sedis, XLIII, 84).

I don't mean to say that I think limbo is false and no one should hold to it. I think it is a theory that conforms to the revealed datum. But I do think it is a matter of speculative Theology and one can deny it and remain orthodox (so long as one does not reject the definitive teachings in the process).

[quote] James Likoudis:
"The Catholic Church teaches that "God has bound salvation to the Sacrament of Baptism, but He Himself is not bound by His sacraments" (CCC n. 1257). God can make whatever exceptions He wishes as regards unbaptized infants. Perhaps those unborn children killed by abortion in odium fidei (in real hatred of Christ and His teachings) may have the status of martyrs (like the Holy Innocents). It is true that Limbo cannot be taught as certain Catholic doctrine proposed by the Magisterium, but it has not been definitively rejected by the Magisterium either." [/quote]

And studying the history of this problem reveals that there have always been different theories. I think a study of the traditions of the East in this regard would be beneficial since they tend to have a more positive view of the fate of unbaptized infants. Do you deny that the Theology of the East is a valid part of Catholic tradition?
And I think the Immaculate Conception analogy was most fitting (there are many other examples too). The point was that there have often been theological problems with differing theories and proposed solutions. The pre-Scotistic solutions to the problem of the Immaculate Conception were inadequate and produced results that by today’s standards were often heretical. I think this is a good analogy with the various understandings of the status of dead, non-baptized infants. It's conceivable that someday a better theory will be proposed and possibly even endorsed as official doctrine. If this hypothetical theory were to disagree with Aquinas or Augustine I don't think it would matter. As I briefly indicated before, I think much of the weakness of the more common approaches to limbo is the conception of nature and grace that is implied. I do not believe in 'pure nature' and I think for the medievals this was not meant to be a literal thing that actually exists somewhere but was more a hypothetical thing. I think the common theories of limbo are perhaps a bit simplistic and do not do justice to the theophanic nature of reality nor to the contiguous, teleological ordering of nature and grace. But anyway, the discussion is more on the status of limbo as a doctrine or theory rather than on my own personal views on the matter of non-baptized babes.

There are many aspects of Divine Revelation which I believe are not taken into account with the standard theory of limbo. I will present just a few things to consider. There are many more.

God can raise up sons of Abraham from the stones. God's ability to bestow sanctifying grace (the phrase "sons of Abraham" suggests those who are in covenant relation with God, which is what sanctifying grace does) is not limited to the normal means of salvation.

The state of original sin is primarily a lack of sanctifying grace. God has the power to remedy this lack of grace even without a Sacrament. As St. Thomas Aquinas wrote when he said that God "is not bound to the visible sacraments." - Summa II. 68.2.c.

To deny this fact is to betray a kind of triumphalism which is contrary to the teachings of the Church and which puts God in a box.

There are examples of this from Scripture. Also the fact of the souls of the just who died before the coming of Christ. Also the teaching on baptism by desire is an application of this principle.

Consider the fact of infant baptism. How is it that a person before the age of reason can receive baptism? Obviously I'm not challenging this practice, but the implications of it's inner logic apply to this issue. I'm just bringing it up for reflection. Since the early Church it has been taught that a catechumen who dies before being baptized will receive a baptism by desire. Considering the nature of infant baptism is it not conceivable that an infant who dies before the parents were able to have them baptized might receive a baptism by desire? Other such questions come time mind while reflecting on these things.

1 Cor 7:14 = "For the unbelieving husband is consecrated through his wife, and the unbelieving wife is consecrated through her husband. Otherwise, your children would be unclean, but as it is they are holy."
I bring up this verse because I think it also has significance for this issue. Consider what St. Paul is saying here and what it says about how God's justice manifests itself. Also good if pondered in connection with infant baptism and baptism by desire. A heathen husband is consecrated through his wife, their children are holy! These are huge statements. God's grace is powerful and radical.

Also consider the holy innocents. The Church has celebrated a feast in their honor since the fourth of fifth century. I like to read the prophecy which Matthew quotes regarding these babes.
"A voice was heard in Ramah, wailing and loud lamentation, Rachel weeping for her children; she refused to be consoled, because they were no more."
But this prophecy of Jeremiah goes on.
"There is hope for your future, says the Lord, and your children shall come back to their own country... Is Ephraim my dear son? Is he my darling child? For as often as I speak against him, I do remember him still. Therefore my heart yearns for him; I will surely have mercy on him, says the Lord."

I believe that "the great mercy of God allows us to hope that there is a way of salvation for children who have died without baptism", as the catechism says.
The theory of limbo stifles this hope because it claims to have a cut and dry rule for how God operates, but let us remember that God has not revealed limbo, it is a construct of human speculation. Besides having reasons for a hope which goes beyond the confines of the limbo theory, I also have positive criticisms of limbo; perhaps another time.

The opinion of Augustine of Aquinas or whoever does not make something part of Tradition. Much of the speculation on the Immaculate Conception was based on problems that had not been revolved (for example preservative redemption) and so things like a sanctification in the womb were posited which we know now to be false. Since things like this have happened in the past it seems logical to assume this could happen with limbo, and in fact it has. Some had posited that the souls of unbaptised babies burn in eternal hell fire. I doubt you hold this view. It's not a matter of something developing into it's opposite, when did I suggest that? I suggested there might be a tendency in the speculation on unbaptised babies analogous to the tendency in the speculation on the Immaculate Conception. For the latter the tendency was the highest level of sanctification for Our Lady. For some the highest level of sanctification included the stain of original sin, for some it even included actual sins. When the issues involved were understood more fully the full truth of the Immaculate Conception came to light. Part of my analogy was that it's conceivable (though not certain by any means) that the Church's understanding of the issues related to limbo might be deepened and the Church could move beyond positing states of pure natural happiness and pure nature and all of that, theories that I believe are problematic and inconsistent with other aspects of Theology. I actually think the issue of predestination is a better example of something similar. There is a certain amount of biblical data, certain dogmatic decrees and things connected with the issues of predestination, but not enough to give a definitive explanation of predestination. Thus there are a number of theories that explain and interpret the revealed data. I think this is true of unbaptised infants. There is some scriptural data, some dogma, and multiple possible interpretations of that data. You seem to want to absolutize one particular theory. I don't have a problem with that. I don't feel it's necessary for me to argue my view and try to convince anyone. If someone is convinced of limbo that's fine by me. Just as I'm not about to argue a particular theory of predestination with someone.

Perhaps you believe a particular version of limbo theory is the better approach because it's been around for a while. Whereas I hold my own view based on recent magisterial statements which avoid the term limbo and have a different thrust, namely the hope in God's mercy and power. I believe this is better considering these kinds of matters are known only to God anyway. Do you think that the Church cannot abandon the theory of limbo? Do you think the catechism and the Pope should use the term limbo and endorse some particular formulation of the theory?

The Church is not bound to particular traditions which offer different interpretations of that data. And certainly new, novel interpretations are acceptable and in fact normal. There are many instances of this occurring in the history of the Church.
How about an example: St. Augustine taught that sex was part of God's plan before the fall. That God intended Adam and Eve to have sex. The Fathers prior to Augustine taught the opposite, that carnal union was a consequence of the fall; therefore this was a radical and novel proposal. This is not a matter of dogma, but it's connected with more central truths of the faith and has implications. Had this novel teaching not been introduced we might believe that sex is just a by-product of the fall, not an icon of the Trinity manifested through man and woman as creatures made in the image of God. Perhaps marriage would not be described as the "primordial sacrament".
There are certainly many other examples. And as I've indicated before, there are other traditions in the Church besides limbo. Eastern Theology tends to hold that the unbaptised infants are "with Christ", which reminds me of an expression the Pope once used when he said that the babes are "with the Lord". Anyway, if some Theologian came along and proposed a totally new, novel interpretation of the revealed data that happened to deal with it in a better, fully way I don't see how that would be a problem at all, that's kind of Theologies job. Faith seeking understanding. And limbo does not demand our faith so it's not a seed of Theology.

And as I'm intimated before, I am somewhat influenced by Eastern Theology and appeal to their traditions as a source of fresh insight on these matters.
Here is a quote from one of Bishop Kallistos Ware's books:

[quote] Most orthodox theologians reject the idea of ‘original guilt,’ put forward by Augustine and still accepted (albeit in a mitigated form) by the Roman Catholic Church. Men (Orthodox usually teach) automatically inherit Adam’s corruption and mortality, but not his guilt: they are only guilty in so far as by their own free choice they imitate Adam. Many western Christians believe that whatever a man does in his fallen and unredeemed state, since it is tainted by original guilt, cannot possibly be pleasing to God: ‘Works before Justification,’ says the thirteenth of the Thirty-nine Articles of the Church of England, ‘...are not pleasant to God ... but have the nature of sin.’ Orthodox would hesitate to say this. And Orthodox have never held (as Augustine and many others in the west have done) that unbaptized babies, because tainted with original guilt, are consigned by the just God to the everlasting games of Hell (Thomas Aquinas, in his discussion of the fall, on the whole followed Augustine, and in particular retained the idea of original guilt; but as regards unbaptized babies, he maintained that they go not to Hell but to Limbo — a view now generally accepted by Roman theologians. So far as I can discover, Orthodox writers do not make use of the idea of Limbo. It should be noted that an Augustinian view of the fall is found from time to time in Orthodox theological literature; but this is usually the result of western influence. The Orthodox Confession by Peter of Moghila is, as one might expect, strongly Augustinian; on the other hand the Confession of Dositheus is free from Augustinianism). The Orthodox picture of fallen humanity is far less sombre than the Augustinian or Calvinist view.

But although Orthodox maintain that man after the fall still possessed free will and was still capable of good actions, yet they certainly agree with the west in believing that man’s sin had set up between him and God a barrier, which man by his own efforts could never break down. Sin blocked the path to union with God. Since man could not come to God, God came to man. [/quote]

Posted

The Dopple-ganger L_D is my hero.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

wow.


what's the post character limit? :blink:

Posted (edited)

[quote name='goldenchild17' date='Jan 9 2006, 02:49 AM']Sure, but remember that all those quotes were by past popes.  Respecting the beliefs of our leader is certainly commendable, but do we reject the beliefs of past popes in doing so?
[right][snapback]850113[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

We are not Protestants. It is not our job, as laymen, to classify Papal statements, and determine what exactly they are saying, or what authority they hold. This duty is given to the Bishops of the Church, and in a unique way, to the Bishop of Rome. It just so happens that he does not believe in Limbo. Because we cannot be more Catholic than the Pope, we know that Limbo is not a point of Catholic doctrine; otherwise, the Pope would be bound to accept it.

That is not to say we cannot personally believe in Limbo. It remains a valid theological opinion. So long as we recognize it as such, and do not elevate it to Church doctrine, we are free to express ourselves accordingly.

Edited by Era Might

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...