JohnDoe Posted January 7, 2006 Posted January 7, 2006 Hi everyone: I had the WEIRDEST experience and I'm wondering if it in fact may even have been sinful. Basically there is this girl- lets call her Kate. Kate and I have been freinds for a while. We don't see each other nearly as much as we used to. We are really good freinds but we used to be better when we spent more time together. I knew for a while that she liked me more than just a freind, and its very apparent in how she talks to me, especially now that she doesn't see me as much. Now, while thats all going on, I have a good freind of mine, lets call him Bob. Now Bob likes Kate in the way that Kate likes Me. I've thought many times about weather or not I like Kate or not. I thought I did, but it turns out I didn't. But I'm still not sure. Ok so Kate wanted me to go hang out with her, but I coulnt cause I have stuff I have to do. So shes on the phone begging me to go out so she can see me. Now I mean I really wanted to go, but I really couldnt. And she's begging me and she's got this voice and by what she says and how she says it (her voice) you know I can really tell shes in love with me. And so I started gettin aroused. Not on purpose, but it was just what she was saying and how she said it( she wasnt saying anything dirty- it was just like I miss you I love you and I want to give you a hug). now this is where it gets really weird. I felt like I had no controll over myself and like I just wanted to ask her "Are you in love with me?" and I wanted to like tell her that I was in love with her to. It almost came out. But it didnt. What did come out was this "I love you too" ( when we say taht we don't mean "in love" we mean like freinds) and I want to give u a hug too. And then i had like these thoughts and temptations to make out with her and I still felt like i was in a trance like someone was controlling me. Through it I was praying to Jesus but it wasn't doing anything. And I'm like God I don't wanna do this, I don't wanna. Then like I snapped out of it and calmed down. I told her I'd call her back and then I stopped being aroused. It was so weird. I know that voluntary arousal outside of Marriage is a mortal sin, I dont know if wat I did was sinful or not. I don't even know what I did. I still feel compelled to like ask her out. Its so weird. Any advice would be greatly appreciated. thank you.
philothea Posted January 8, 2006 Posted January 8, 2006 Doesn't sound to me like you were reacting voluntarily [i]at all[/i]. Don't stress about it. Bodies are weird. I couldn't say if you should ask her out or not.
Luthien Posted January 8, 2006 Posted January 8, 2006 I think he was insinuating you kill Bob? I think it was a parody on the Kill Bill thing. Yeah I dont think it was sinful, just know your triggers I guess.
alicemary Posted January 8, 2006 Posted January 8, 2006 If you don't respond to the feelings of love I fear you might be dead. Don't fret, you are normal and it is no sin. To say that these feelings are a mortal sin you have to be very tradional, that is for sure. Guilt is a terrible burden, don't live you life by it...you are human, accept and love yourself. Am sure this will set off some of our members, but I don't care what the church teaches, we are human beings and subject to temptation. Guilt is a terrible waste, so don't dwell on this. Good luck to you
God the Father Posted January 8, 2006 Posted January 8, 2006 At first I was going to tell you to kill Bob, so that you could have Kate all to yourself. Jokingly, of course. Then I realized Kill Bob sounds like Kill Bill, so I added the "vol. 2" for additional parody.
JohnDoe Posted January 8, 2006 Author Posted January 8, 2006 I appreciate the attempt to cheer me up with humor, but killing Bob really wouldn't work. And thats the thing. I don't know if I really do like Kate or not. Now that I'm snapped out of that "trance" I feel like those feelings of affection towards her were caused by the whole incident.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted January 8, 2006 Posted January 8, 2006 [quote name='JohnDoe' date='Jan 7 2006, 07:57 PM']I appreciate the attempt to cheer me up with humor, but killing Bob really wouldn't work. And thats the thing. I don't know if I really do like Kate or not. Now that I'm snapped out of that "trance" I feel like those feelings of affection towards her were caused by the whole incident. [right][snapback]849155[/snapback][/right] [/quote] It's hard to keep our heads on straight sometimes.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted January 8, 2006 Posted January 8, 2006 [quote name='JohnDoe' date='Jan 7 2006, 08:57 PM']what do you mean? [right][snapback]849187[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Well, we have a hard time focusing...we let our emotions get a control of us...we lose ourselves in the moment, etc. Sounds like your experience was typical of such a situation.
picchick Posted January 8, 2006 Posted January 8, 2006 I think what he means is when emotions run high it can sometimes take over our though process making us confused. It happens to the best of us
Father_Phil Posted January 8, 2006 Posted January 8, 2006 (edited) A couple of things: First, remember the definition of a mortal sin. Three things are required: 1.) The sin itself must be grave matter -- i.e., seriously, intrinisically wrong. 2.) You must have full knowledge (i.e., a sure conscience) that the act that you are considering is one that is seriously wrong. 3.) Your action must be a free and voluntary choice. No one can be forced to commit a mortal sin. In other words, "It's really wrong, I know it's really wrong, and I'm doing it anyway." If one or more of these three conditions is missing, the action may still be a sin, but not a mortal sin. Your reaction to this intimate conversation seems like it was just that -- a reaction. You didn't invite the reaction, didn't dwell on it, and didn't consent to it. In fact, you asked Jesus to remove it, and told him that you didn't want it. Your body responded on its own, but it doesn't seem possible that you committed a mortal sin here, because you didn't consent. There is an old story about an old monk and a young monk who were on a journey. As they approached a river, they saw a very attractive young woman on the riverbank, who was crying. The old monk asked her why she was crying, and she told him that she had to get to the other side to visit her father who was ill, but the bridge had washed out and the current was too strong for her to wade across. The old monk picked her up in his arms and carried her across, then he put her down and they all went their separate ways. After about two hours, the younger monk spoke up. "Father," he said, "I don't understand how you could do what you did back there. You have spent your whole life struggling to be chaste, and don't even look at women, much less talk to them. But you picked that woman up and held her in your arms. How could you do such a thing?" The old monk smiled and replied, "My son, you are right. I did pick up that woman. But then I put her down. You have been carrying her for two hours." Our emotions and attractions are responses to the world around us. If they are spontaneous reactions, they are neither good nor bad, yet. They are simply there. Where evil comes in is when we nurture them, embellish them, consent to them --- or when we have put ourselves in the situation on purpose by our thoughts or actions, and they are not really spontaneous. But if we don't create them or encourage them, and they simply happen, the best thing to do is not to worry too much about them and let them pass. The fact that we have physical, emotional and spiritual reactions to people of the opposite sex is part of us by God's design, and in the proper context these feelings are good and holy things. It is good that you are attracted to girls -- God may use this (and other things) to point out to you the one he has in mind for you to marry. And the fact that a man and a woman who are growing in love for each other experience a desire to be close to the other that includes a desire to be physically intimate is also a good thing in context. A sexual relationship within marriage has the power to strengthen and build up the whole married relationship. Where the evil comes in is when people who are not married let these feelings linger and take control, or when they act on them by themselves or with someone who is not their spouse. Then they are separating the action from its purpose, and taking the pleasure of the thought or act, without making the total gift of themselves that only marriage truly is. Just because something seems "natural" doesn't mean anyone has the right to act on it outside of the proper context. Marriage is not just about sex, but sex is all about marriage. Remember that chastity is a lifestyle, and requires a commitment that is 24/7/365. There are some basic steps to living a chaste life, and dealing with sexual responses and temptations: 1.) DON'T PANIC. One of the biggest weapons the Enemy uses against us is fear. If you haven't encouraged or created the thought, and haven't consented to it, calm down and move on. If you have, learn from your mistake and be more careful next time. 2.) Avoid the occasion of sin. Make sure you are being prudent about the people, places and things that are part of your life. If you know being alone with a certain person will put thoughts in your head, don't be alone with them. If you know reading or looking at certain material will be arousing, stay away from it. Keep a watch over where you let your thoughts linger, and how you think about the people around you. But do this patiently, and refer to #1. 3.) When the thoughts are there, don't argue with them, worry about them, tell yourself how awful they are, or do anything else to address them. Simply find a way to change the subject and focus your attention somewhere else. If someone tells you not to think about something, it's all you will think about. So the best thing to do is calmly (see #1), patiently, shift your attention somewhere else. 4.) Remember that God desires this from you, so if you are willing to work with him, most of the responsibility is on him. If you can look him in the eye and say "I'm doing my best to understand what you want from me and to follow through on it," then keep looking him in the eye and tell him, "I'm not strong enough to do this on my own. Even my own body is against me. But this was your idea, not mine. You figure it out." You'll be amazed how quick God is to help us once we admit we need him to and give him permission. And remember that he is your Father, which means that he is pleased with every effort you make to be more like his Son, Jesus. He is happy that you try to walk with Christ, even when you fall, as long as you keep getting up and trying again. 5. Trust in the power of the Sacraments. Get to confession regularly -- once a month is a good idea -- and as much as possible go to the same priest every time. Find someone you can trust, and be as honest as possible about your struggles. And above all get to Mass every Sunday, and receive the Eucharist as often as you can. In holy Communion we receive Jesus's own body into our body, and he has the power to strengthen and transform us from the inside out. 6. Remember, too, that Jesus was once a teenage boy, with a real human soul and a real human body. He knows what you're going through, and he is not embarrassed to go through it with you. Don't be embarrassed to ask him for help. To sum up: Your body reacted naturally and understandably to a conversation that was in its own way very intimate. The fact that you had the reaction is neither good nor bad. If you let the feeling linger and increase, it would have been sinful, but since you fought the temptation and did not consent you don't need to worry about this event. But you can learn from it how easy it would be to fall into sin if you let your guard down. Stick to the basic rules of a chaste lifestyle, and re-commit yourself to following through on what God asks you every day. Know that you are in my prayers. I will offer Mass for you and your intentions this Sunday. Father Phil Edited January 8, 2006 by Father_Phil
JohnDoe Posted January 9, 2006 Author Posted January 9, 2006 again I'd like to say thanks alot to everyone and I have one more question: how do i go about with Kate now? I realized that Im pretty sure I dont like her. But the fact that she likes me so much and when and how she expresses it in words and actions can still be arousing to me. How do I deal with her without telling her this. Should I just try to ignore her when I feel it might lead to an occasion of sin?
Akalyte Posted January 9, 2006 Posted January 9, 2006 (edited) [quote name='Father_Phil' date='Jan 7 2006, 08:02 PM'] Father Phil [right][snapback]849190[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Whoa! Are you an Oratorian Father? I go to a parish run by the oratori of Saint Phillip Neri.. Edited January 9, 2006 by Akalyte
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now