Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

The Judge Alito confirmation hearings


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

[quote name='zwergel88' date='Jan 10 2006, 01:37 PM']I firmly believe that it doesn't matter if Alito gets confirmed because he is going to kill everyone.  He says that Roe v. Wade is established precedent and as far as I can tell from his comments will not overturn it.  He is also for the death penalty and does not have a good record on things like civil rights and corporate corruption.  If Bush appointed a real pro-life judge that would be great but so far his judges have seemed only nominally pro-life.[/quote]

First, you have to understand a few things about how a judicial confirmation process works. I worked on the Senate Judiciary committee for awhile and I sat in on many judicial hearings, so I am familiar with the process. These men and women com before a bunch of blowhard senators who think they know everything and then grill someone about where he or she stands on certain issues. Legally speaking, Alito, like any judicial nominee, cannot come right out and say that he is pro-life and anti-abortion. First of all, it would be political suicide. Secondly, it would be alluding to how one would rule if such a case came before the court. A judge's impartiality is removed, and thus he or she would have to recuse himself or herself from the case.

When Alito says that Roe/Wade is established precedent, he is correct. The case has been decided and upheld at the Supreme Court in cases such as Planned Parenthood vs. Casey and Stenberg vs. Carhart. That does not mean that it cannot be overturned one day, as I think it will be. Dred Scott vs. Sanford and Plessy vs. Ferguson were also "established precedent" that were eventually overturned.

[quote]In response to the comments about the democratic party...Democrats for Life is way stonger than "Nazis for Jews" or whatever you guys said.  There are pro-life democrats at nearly every echelon of the american government.  The current minority leader of the senate Harry Reid is pro-life.  One of the leading candidates to head the DNC and a major force in the party, Tim Roemer is pro-life.  The candidate for US senate who will take part in one of the most importanted senate elections in the country, Bob Casey Jr. is pro-life.  There are many many pro-life democrats in power and they are gaining power everyday.  Don't believe the comments you hear about the democrats not allowing pro-life people in the party.  The most widespread myth is that the DNC wouldn't let Bob Casey speak at the 1992 convention because he is pro-life.  THat is untrue.  Casey didn't speak because he didn't support the candidate for president.  So in other words, the democrats are a big tent who allow all sorts of view points and the pro-life movement is growing.[/quote]

Democrats for life is an oxymoron in practice. Sorry, but it's true. They might be gaining power, but that is only because the libs see the writing on the wall and realize that the majority of Americans want restrictions on abortion. To call Harry Reid pro-life is a major, major stretch. The fact that he opposed partial birth abortion does not make him pro-life. Check the rest of his voting record. Tom Daschle also opposed PBA.

For every Zell Miller or Ben Nelson, I can point out 20 Barbara Boxers and Chris Dodds. The Democratic party has as its official party platform to be pro-abortion and pro-gay marriage. This was officially adopted at the 2004 Democratic National Convention.

[quote]Therefore, I think that Alito is not really pro-life but the democrats have a well established pro-life movement and are becoming more pro-life all the time.  Check out www.democratsorlife.org.

;)
[right][snapback]851796[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Um, no. The dems might be becoming more pro-life, but I assure you that it is a ploy to simply garner more votes from mainstream America. After Bush trounced Kerry in '04, the dems realized that mainstream America does not agree with the East and West Coast and that the current party lines of the Democratic Party are out of step with mainstream America. You won't hear this on television, but in their strategy meetings, I assure you that this is what is going on. DON'T BELIEVE IT! THE DEMOCRATIC PARTY IS NOT PRO-LIFE! IF THEY ARE PUT BACK IN POWER, THE MORAL DECAY OF AMERICAN SOCIETY WILL ESCALATE, I ASSURE YOU.

Edited by JP2Iloveyou
Posted

[quote name='zwergel88' date='Jan 10 2006, 01:37 PM']I firmly believe that it doesn't matter if Alito gets confirmed because he is going to kill everyone.  He says that Roe v. Wade is established precedent and as far as I can tell from his comments will not overturn it.  He is also for the death penalty and does not have a good record on things like civil rights and corporate corruption.  If Bush appointed a real pro-life judge that would be great but so far his judges have seemed only nominally pro-life.

In response to the comments about the democratic party...Democrats for Life is way stonger than "Nazis for Jews" or whatever you guys said.  There are pro-life democrats at nearly every echelon of the american government.  The current minority leader of the senate Harry Reid is pro-life.  One of the leading candidates to head the DNC and a major force in the party, Tim Roemer is pro-life.  The candidate for US senate who will take part in one of the most importanted senate elections in the country, Bob Casey Jr. is pro-life.  There are many many pro-life democrats in power and they are gaining power everyday.  Don't believe the comments you hear about the democrats not allowing pro-life people in the party.  The most widespread myth is that the DNC wouldn't let Bob Casey speak at the 1992 convention because he is pro-life.  THat is untrue.  Casey didn't speak because he didn't support the candidate for president.  So in other words, the democrats are a big tent who allow all sorts of view points and the pro-life movement is growing.

Therefore, I think that Alito is not really pro-life but the democrats have a well established pro-life movement and are becoming more pro-life all the time.  Check out www.democratsorlife.org.

;)
[right][snapback]851796[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
I find it ironic (to put it mildly) that someone who proudly voted for John Kerry is saying that Alito should not be confirmed because he is not pro-life enough!

Do you honestly, seriously believe that the 100% pro-abortion Kerry would have nominated anybody even remotely pro-life if he were President??!!

No, I can assure you, Kerry (or almost any other prominent national Democrat) would have nominated candidates who would have done everything in their power to confirm and further the Culture of Death!

Who is it that is grilling Alito on abortion and threatening to block his nomination if he gives any sign of opposing abortion?

. . . That's right, your beloved Democrats!!

The Dems have a bizarre and unhealthy (I'd say Satanic) obsession with promoting abortion, and insuring that it remains entirely unrestricted by law.

Seriously, if you think the Democrats are the more pro-life Party, you're living in Never-never land!

And yes, I realize that there are some pro-life Democrats, and I salute them, but the fact is that there are many more pro-life Republicans.
Sadly, the Democratic Party leadership seems determined to do all it can to promote the Culture of Death.

Posted

[quote name='Raphael' date='Jan 10 2006, 02:48 PM']They're double agents, that's how. ;) :P:

More socially conscious democrats would be wonderful.  If the Republicans went for abortion and the Democrats went pro-life for some reason, I'd switch parties.

Although, even then, I'd be about as Democratic as Zell Miller.
[right][snapback]851883[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Same here. But the Dem candidates would have to be very clearly and seriously pro-life to get my vote. I don't disagree with the Democrats on abortion only, but nearly everything else as well.

For me to respect "pro-life Democrats," it is vital that they be seriously working to make their party pro-life, not just trying to draw pro-lifers into the Democratic Party.

I'm sorry, but "pro-life Democrats" who insist on voting for and supporting completely pro-abortion candidates such as John Kerry have absolutely zero credibility with me.

Posted

i think it is garbage that abortion is the only thing they talk about. It is all we ever hear about in regards to these hearings. One would think that the only thing coming to the high court is abortion cases.

Posted (edited)

If anyone is interested...

[url="http://www.vote-smart.org/issue_rating_category.php?can_id=S0561103&type=category&category=Abortion%2BIssues&go.x=9&go.y=6"]http://www.vote-smart.org/issue_rating_cat...s&go.x=9&go.y=6[/url]

This website is actually really good for finding out where a candidate REALLY stands on issues based on his or her voting record, not just what he or she says. It is non-partisan and completely unbiased. It's sole purpose is to inform voters. Very good info.

Here is one more for you.

[url="http://www.vote-smart.org/issue_keyvote_detail.php?vote_id=3489&can_id=S0561103"]http://www.vote-smart.org/issue_keyvote_de...can_id=S0561103[/url]

This was labeled S. Con. Res. 18 which stands for Senate Concurant Resolution #18. Essentially, it was an amendment to another bill last year. Sen. Reid voted to increase tax payer funding for providing artificial contraceptives and access to family planning services (read "abortion providers). He was joined in his yea vote by such staunch pro-lifers as Maria Cantwell, Patty Murray, Tom Harkin, and Ted Kennedy. He was opposed by such staunch pro-abortionists as Rick Santorum, Sam Brownback, and Jeff Sessions.

(Just in case anyone was wondering, yes, I'm being facitious when refering to the former as pro-life and the latter as pro-abortion.)

Edited by JP2Iloveyou
Mrs. Bro. Adam
Posted

[quote name='jezic' date='Jan 10 2006, 07:49 PM']i think it is garbage that abortion is the only thing they talk about. It is all we ever hear about in regards to these hearings. One would think that the only thing coming to the high court is abortion cases.
[right][snapback]852188[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

It's a shame that abortion isn't discussed more in politics nowadays. I mean, what's a few minutes a day discusssing the both sides of abortion; we always are hoping that life will prevail in this predominate Culture of Death.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...