Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted January 10, 2006 Posted January 10, 2006 If Peter founded the church in Antioch why doesn't Antioch have primacy? sam
qfnol31 Posted January 10, 2006 Posted January 10, 2006 It does, but just not over Rome. It was one of the main patriarchal sees and still is (at least in the East).
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted January 10, 2006 Author Posted January 10, 2006 let me rephrase: why does Rome have Control over the entire church? why does Rome have primacy above all Bishops and infallibility if Peter also went to Antioch? sam
qfnol31 Posted January 10, 2006 Posted January 10, 2006 It's because Peter finished in Rome...that's where he passed on his Ordination as Bishop to another and passed on his position. It's not just because Peter founded that particular Church, but because he also finished up there. Likewise, Paul ended there too giving it another extra emphasis.
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted January 10, 2006 Author Posted January 10, 2006 (edited) cool thanks Q like you said earlier it is hard to debate the orthodox Edited January 10, 2006 by Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
qfnol31 Posted January 10, 2006 Posted January 10, 2006 Yes, I agree. It's even more difficult in person!
MilesChristi Posted January 10, 2006 Posted January 10, 2006 I think that primacy is in the person of the pope. Wherever his seat is located enjoys primacy over all other sees. The seat of the pope was located at Antioch for some time. When St. Peter decided to move to Rome, the primacy went with him. The Catholic Church used to celebrate this with two feasts - St. Peter's Chair in Rome on January 18 and St. Peter's Chair in Antioch on February 22. The two feasts were later condensed into one celebration on February 22.
Era Might Posted January 10, 2006 Posted January 10, 2006 Rome was established as St. Peter's final See of authority, along with St. Paul (said to be the two "eyes" of the Church). The Fathers of the Church always recognized Rome as the See of ultimate authority; never Antioch.
thessalonian Posted January 10, 2006 Posted January 10, 2006 (edited) One could also consider the hiatus to Avignon. Most certainly the Papacy was in Avignon during that time. The papacy moved with him. It did not invalidate the papacy because the popes were not in rome. As I recall there were seven popes in Avignon. The office is a man, more so than a place. Though the place, Rome certainly has significance. [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avignon_Papacy"]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avignon_Papacy[/url] I think it would be fruitful to reflect on this hiatus from Rome. I think of the antipopes and for me they show the truth of the Catholic faith rather than detract from it. It shows that Rome was in fact considered the head of the Christian Church, before Cornelius, since Hippolatus and Novation, the first two antipopes lived before him. The weakness of the Church and the sins of the papacy also allow us to reflect on how it is by the power and will of God that this institution has servived, inspite of some of the men. Not on the strength of men. There has to be some reason that shows the glory of God in the Avignon Papacy as well. Edited January 10, 2006 by thessalonian
rkwright Posted January 10, 2006 Posted January 10, 2006 yes like thess said primacy follows the person not the location. Peter is the head of the Church not Rome or Antioch. Christ gave Peter the keys not Rome. So it doesn't reallly matter that Peter went to Rome, he could have gone anywhere, but whoever his sucessor is whom the power is passed down to.
rkwright Posted January 10, 2006 Posted January 10, 2006 [quote name='Extra ecclesiam nulla salus' date='Jan 10 2006, 10:54 AM']cool thanks Q like you said earlier it is hard to debate the orthodox [right][snapback]851647[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I've seen this and some other threads you started mainly about the Primacy of Peter issues with the Orthodox, one of the biggest questions that I had for the Orthodox that they never really could answer if there were any fathers that point to the opposite, the first among equal doctrine. There are a few that point to a Primacy of Peter doctrine (Clement of Rome being a huge one) but I know of none that point out that their Church or their Bishop is an equal or not under Rome.
Guest Rick777 Posted January 10, 2006 Posted January 10, 2006 [quote name='thessalonian' date='Jan 10 2006, 11:14 AM']One could also consider the hiatus to Avignon. Most certainly the Papacy was in Avignon during that time. The papacy moved with him. It did not invalidate the papacy because the popes were not in rome. As I recall there were seven popes in Avignon. The office is a man, more so than a place. Though the place, Rome certainly has significance. [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avignon_Papacy"]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avignon_Papacy[/url] I think it would be fruitful to reflect on this hiatus from Rome. I think of the antipopes and for me they show the truth of the Catholic faith rather than detract from it. It shows that Rome was in fact considered the head of the Christian Church, before Cornelius, since Hippolatus and Novation, the first two antipopes lived before him. The weakness of the Church and the sins of the papacy also allow us to reflect on how it is by the power and will of God that this institution has servived, inspite of some of the men. Not on the strength of men. There has to be some reason that shows the glory of God in the Avignon Papacy as well. [right][snapback]851683[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Yes, but remember St.Catherine of Siena? She implored Pope Gregory XI to go back to Rome, why, because it is the See of ultimate authority.
Myles Domini Posted January 11, 2006 Posted January 11, 2006 (edited) [quote name='Rick777' date='Jan 10 2006, 10:20 PM']Yes, but remember St.Catherine of Siena? She implored Pope Gregory XI to go back to Rome, why, because it is the See of ultimate authority. [right][snapback]851994[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Agreed. The situation post-Peter has changed. When the Popes were in Avignon they were still Bishops of Rome. They didn't change the title of their See. Now Peter has died the see itself has taken on greater significance. Indeed, Peter did found the See of Antioch and the Melkites and Antiochiene church are proud of that. But St Ignatius of Antioch its 3rd Bishop (including Peter) gives Rome primacy as church presiding over the others in love as early as the turn of the 1st century. Clearly the place where Peter poured out his teaching, Rome, gives it its significance. Because of their Petrine connection Antioch and Alexandria with Rome are known as primatial Sees (cf Council of Nicea, Canons) but it is Rome which is universally acknowledged by the Fathers as guardian of the Orthodox faith. Edited January 11, 2006 by Myles
thessalonian Posted January 11, 2006 Posted January 11, 2006 [quote name='Rick777' date='Jan 10 2006, 04:20 PM']Yes, but remember St.Catherine of Siena? She implored Pope Gregory XI to go back to Rome, why, because it is the See of ultimate authority. [right][snapback]851994[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Yes. Rome did take on a significance and it is certainly the will of God that Rome be the head of the Church. But there was a purpose in that hiatus.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now