Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

The quickest response of the atheist against any of Aquinas's first 3 is the "this can't go on for infinity". They claim it could. That as long as the being before the one in question was 'in motion' or was its cause or was its contingent being, there is no problem. Just an endless string of motion.

How do you respond?

Posted

[quote name='rkwright' date='Jan 18 2006, 02:05 PM']How do you respond?
[right][snapback]860072[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
There is no effecient cause for the system as a whole. They are looking at each individual thing and for that it does have an explination, but as for the whole system there is no cause.

Posted

but they would contend you are misrepresenting the system...

there is no begining for the 'whole system'; no point in which there was a system and there wasn't a system. It always was since there was always something holding it up.

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

An endless cycle just began existing?

Posted

ok I may have it, I think it lies in the 3rd way. The infinte regress of only possible beings has the possibility of every being not being. Given infinite time where all possibilities are acutalized there would be some point at which nothing existed, and since something can't come from nothing, there should be nothing in existance today. Which is flase.

This proves a what Aquinas calls a necessary being, which I take as one that cannot generate or corrupt. I'm not sure at this point if it proves a possibility of many necessary beings though, does it? He says that the necessary being must derive its necessariness from itself or another, but can a necessary being derive it from another? Doesn't this make just another contingent being? :. it must only derive it from itself.

In the end the infinte regress of contingent beings is taken care of through possibility, and any hint of an infinite regress of necessary beings is taken care because necessary beings aren't in a chain of cause, they always are. From there I could head over to the other thread on 1 God vs many self causes and prove only 1 God.

Am I right here??

Posted

[quote name='rkwright' date='Jan 18 2006, 02:49 PM']but they would contend you are misrepresenting the system...

there is no begining for the 'whole system'; no point in which there was a system and there wasn't a system.  It always was since there was always something holding it up.
[right][snapback]860151[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Since what is holding it up?

Posted

[quote name='Paphnutius' date='Jan 18 2006, 05:11 PM']Since what is holding it up?
[right][snapback]860275[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

the previous event...

I'll restate, there is no begining of the whole system; no point at which there was a system or wasn't a system, the system was always there since was always an event holding up the next event.

but anyways what do you think of what I posted in #5?

Posted

[quote name='rkwright' date='Jan 18 2006, 06:27 PM']the previous event...
[/quote]
I see. I thought that you were refering to the system as a whole. I still object on the grounds of the system having no effecient cause as a whole. It is like having a Newton's cradle. (the balls on the strings that hit eachother) You can say that ball1 was hit by ball2 which was hit by ballZ3 etc...but if there is not a ballX, or initial ball that is set in motion by an outside source ball1 can never be hit because ballX cannot move of its own accord. Those that posit this ad infinitum are trying to avoid breaking the law of conservation but in the end still come up lacking effecient cause ballX.

I read post 5 and it seems pretty sound except that you would have to prove that there being nothing is a possibility. I am not so sure that you can take that as self-evident based on the law of the conservation of matter/energy. It is neither created nor destroyed, so as long as there is something there will always be something (according to the strict laws of science that is). I have never liked the infinite time will run the course of all possiblities because I am not so sure that the possibilites is a fixed number. Others may disprove me though.

You are right though about the necessary being being self-caused. A better way to put it is the problem of infinite regress necessitates a self-caused being and this people call God.

Posted

[quote name='Paphnutius' date='Jan 18 2006, 10:56 PM']I see. I thought that you were refering to the system as a whole. I still object on the grounds of the system having no effecient cause as a whole. It is like having a Newton's cradle. (the balls on the strings that hit eachother) You can say that ball1 was hit by ball2 which was hit by ballZ3 etc...but if there is not a ballX, or initial ball that is set in motion by an outside source ball1 can never be hit because ballX cannot move of its own accord. Those that posit this ad infinitum are trying to avoid breaking the law of conservation but in the end still come up lacking effecient cause ballX. [/quote]
I see... so something like an infinite number of balls set up, but with nothing to put them in motion no motion exists. Or an infinite chain of causes, but with no first cause no other cause can exist. I mean it makes perfect sense to me, but it can't really be 100% or we wouldn't be having this discussion

[quote]I read post 5 and it seems pretty sound except that you would have to prove that there being nothing is a possibility. I am not so sure that you can take that as self-evident based on the law of the conservation of matter/energy. It is neither created nor destroyed, so as long as there is something there will always be something (according to the strict laws of science that is). I have never liked the infinite time will run the course of all possiblities because I am not so sure that the possibilites is a fixed number. Others may disprove me though.

You are right though about the necessary being being self-caused. A better way to put it is the problem of infinite regress necessitates a self-caused being and this people call God.
[right][snapback]860619[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I took the first half of the possibilities straight from Aquinas's proof. Considering his time I don't think he would have been aware of the law of mass conservation. Maybe it would be better to 'update' his premises. I'm really reaching on this, I barely have any knowledge on physics here.

1-Things have either the possibility of being matter or energy. (law of matter\energy)
2- They cannot be the 2 at the same time.
3- Mass can be converted into energy, but (so far shown) energy cannot be converted into mass.
4- There is an infinite regress.
5- Given the infinite regress there would be a possibility when everything is only energy and that possibility would be actualized at some point
6- Since mass cannot come from energy there would be no mass today.
7- There is mass today

Reject 4

Now... there is also a possibility that # 3 could be wrong. While it has not been shown in nature that energy can convert to mass, or in a lab... quatum physics does provide that mass can come from energy. But its only a theory... and it doesn't really apply on the universal level at which the theory of general relativity plays a dominate force.

Guest JeffCR07
Posted (edited)

This is not the way that you want to go about defending Aquinas because, quite simply, all of the arguments made here, so far, have been wrong.

1.) First, it was argued that the system as a whole does not have an efficient cause. However, this argument makes no sense, because it is equivocating the word "system" by making it appear as if it were a reference to a unitary ontological entity, which it is not. In fact, when we refer to the "system" in question, what we mean is the whole chain of causality. But the "whole chain of causality" cannot have a cause, because if it did, it would by definition include that cause. So this argument doesn't work whether God is the first cause in that chain or whether he isn't, because either way the [i]system[/i] - the [i]whole chain of causes[/i] - cannot have a cause.

2.) Then, it was argued that Aquinas' Third Way provides the answer. However, quite simply, Aquinas' third way is a fallacious argument. Just because every contingent being must not exist at some time does not mean that there is some one time at which every contingent being simultaneously did not exist.

2b.) Moreover, related to the above, it was argued that it is at least [i]possible[/i] that all contingent beings were simultaneously non-existent. This is true. However, it was then argued that because infinite time is being posited, it follows that all possibilities are actualized at some point in time. But this is simply not true. Time alone has absolutely no effect whatsoever on actualizing a given potential, so we cannot conclude that infinite time would somehow result in the actualization of all potentialities.

***************************

I recognize that it is much easier to criticize the arguments of others than it is to make an argument for oneself, so I will end this post with an offer of another alternative.

Now for Aquinas, it seems evident that chains of events, whether they be chains of motion or chains of efficient causality, cannot go on forever. However, this seems to be the first thing rejected by atheists and agnostics (at least the ones that I talk with). The question is "why can't it go on forever?" and saying "it just can't" certainly doesn't cut it. My response is twofold:

First, I would point out to them the fact that when they say to themselves "an endless chain of causality" or "an infinite series of motions" they don't really understand what those phrases mean. Sure, they can define "endless" or "infinite" and they can tell me what a chain of causality is, but I am not really certain that they actually understand what a combination of the two would actually be.

However, lets say that they are persistent, and claim that they really [i]do[/i] understand what it means. What then?

At this point, I would argue that they have two options before them, one that posits a cosmos in which time is infinite, and one in which time began. But all the evidence seems to support the notion that time, along with space, (or more properly speaking, time-space) began with the big bang. So, if they hold to infinite chains of causality, then they have to reject a lot of modern science.

So, in principle, we cannot reject the notion of infinite causal chains, but our best bet is to show them that it is an extremely untenable position to maintain, and shaky at best.

Also, it should be pointed out that if I ever get to that point with an atheist/agnostic, I will always use the ontological argument, as I find it a stronger argument in every respect than any of the [i]a posteriori[/i] arguments.

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff

Edited by JeffCR07
Posted

[quote name='JeffCR07' date='Jan 19 2006, 12:00 AM']This is not the way that you want to go about defending Aquinas because, quite simply, all of the arguments made here, so far, have been wrong.
[/quote]
ehh I'm sad to hear that... but willing to learn

[quote]2.) Then, it was argued that Aquinas' Third Way provides the answer. However, quite simply, Aquinas' third way is a fallacious argument. Just because every contingent being must not exist at some time does not mean that there is some one time at which every contingent being simultaneously did not exist.
[/quote]
In time yes... it relies on the infinite time

[quote]    2b.) Moreover, related to the above, it was argued that it is at least [i]possible[/i] that all contingent beings were simultaneously non-existent. This is true. However, it was then argued that because infinite time is being posited, it follows that all possibilities are actualized at some point in time. But this is simply not true. Time alone has absolutely no effect whatsoever on actualizing a given potential, so we cannot conclude that infinite time would somehow result in the actualization of all potentialities.
[/quote]
I'm struggling with this one... the line 'time alone has absolutely no effect whatsoever on actualizing a given potential'. Isn't this what probability and possibility are all about? If it was never actualized it would be impossible. If theres a % chance of happening, that means that it will happen at some point. Infinite regress just ensures that is has already happened. If I have a 1 to 100 chance of flipping tails on a weighted coin, then by the 101th flip I should have got one tail. Time is the only constraint on my flipping.

[quote]I recognize that it is much easier to criticize the arguments of others than it is to make an argument for oneself, so I will end this post with an offer of another alternative.
[/quote] no doubt, thanks for helping me out here! greatly appreciated

[quote]Now for Aquinas, it seems evident that chains of events, whether they be chains of motion or chains of efficient causality, cannot go on forever. However, this seems to be the first thing rejected by atheists and agnostics (at least the ones that I talk with). The question is "why can't it go on forever?" and saying "it just can't" certainly doesn't cut it. My response is twofold:

First, I would point out to them the fact that when they say to themselves "an endless chain of causality" or "an infinite series of motions" they don't really understand what those phrases mean. Sure, they can define "endless" or "infinite" and they can tell me what a chain of causality is, but I am not really certain that they actually understand what a combination of the two would actually be.

However, lets say that they are persistent, and claim that they really [i]do[/i] understand what it means. What then?

At this point, I would argue that they have two options before them, one that posits a cosmos in which time is infinite, and one in which time began. But all the evidence seems to support the notion that time, along with space, (or more properly speaking, time-space) began with the big bang. So, if they hold to infinite chains of causality, then they have to reject a lot of modern science.

So, in principle, we cannot reject the notion of infinite causal chains, but our best bet is to show them that it is an extremely untenable position to maintain, and shaky at best.
[/quote]
seems easier to rely on this to kill the infinite regress...

[quote]Also, it should be pointed out that if I ever get to that point with an atheist/agnostic, I will always use the ontological argument, as I find it a stronger argument in every respect than any of the [i]a posteriori[/i] arguments.

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff
[right][snapback]860662[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

No doubt, I'm beginning to like Anslem's ideas better every time I read them and then have to work on this! We'll get to the ontological arguments in my class in a few weeks, so you might see some more questions right up your path ;)

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

I like Copleston and Bouyer's take on what you are discussing.

Posted

[quote name='rkwright' date='Jan 18 2006, 08:05 PM']The quickest response of the atheist against any of Aquinas's first 3 is the "this can't go on for infinity".  They claim it could.  That as long as the being before the one in question was 'in motion' or was its cause or was its contingent being, there is no problem.  Just an endless string of motion.

How do you respond?
[right][snapback]860072[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I'd say that anyone who actually believes this is quite illogical. I believe that much of what Jeff said has its advantages but I also think that you are all departing significantly from the work of the Common Doctor himself and thus ending up in space. The fact of the matter is that he is called the Common Doctor for a reason and thats because his arguments are based around common sense.

Aquinas uses instances from the world to illustrate his arguments in order to achieve what Jeff suggested, that is, to make the atheists arguments look completely untenable. Aquinas' reasoning is a posteriori, that is, from the world around. His first recourse would not have been to the big bang but to efficient causes throughout the Universe as his own work illustrates.

One might say that Aquinas could illustrate his work by saying something like this: I have a key, how was this key made I ask the keymaker? He replies from another key. I ask him how was that key made he replies from another key. I ask him again how was that key made? He replies from another key. I say my good man do you mean to tell me that all the keys you made are copies of other keys? He nods assertively and says indeed every key I've made is the copy of another key. Aquinas says this is the atheists argument. Then he says this is the thinking man's response.

But my good sir this cannot go on forever? The keymaker says 'why not?' Aquinas says if at one time there was not a first key how could there have been a key to be copied from it. That doesn't make sense there cannot be an infinite regress of key copying if there isn't a key in the start to be copied from. The key maker says 'thats true'. Aquinas says somewhere at some point for there to be subsequent keys made there must have been a first key, a master key, some key from which all other keys were subsequently copied. The key maker says 'makes sense to me' you're right infinite regress just sounds stupid.

Aquinas doesn't retreat into physics for his examples. His aim is far more practical than that. He relates his arguments to every day experiences to judge a posteriori that anything that is in a sequence must have a start point. Indeed, the world is so littered with examples of this fact that it would be mind boggling for the atheist to insist that this is not so. If I said to an atheist "my goodman you live in a lovely Victorian house" and he said "yes I do, gorgeous isnt it?" to which I replied "yeah I wonder who lives in the oldest victorian house in the world?" and he replied "nobody. The style of victorian houses doesnt have any start or end there are an infinite regress of victorian style houses from which subsequent victorian style homes were built" I would look at him and wonder whether this man was in sound mind.

Our experience, which is key for Aquinas, makes it unfeasible to maintain that an infinite series can exist in anything. For wherever motion or causality exist, wherever there is a series, every single example we have of this from our own mundane experiences of opening doors and turning on lights to the apex of physics there is so much evidence against the idea of an infinite regress that to maintain such an idea just looks silly.

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

First, I would like to say that Myles' post is an excellent defense of the Thomistic argument, and did a much better job at illustrating the absurdity of the infinite regress claim. Thanks Myles ;)

Now, regarding this:

[quote]I'm struggling with this one... the line 'time alone has absolutely no effect whatsoever on actualizing a given potential'. Isn't this what probability and possibility are all about? If it was never actualized it would be impossible. If theres a % chance of happening, that means that it will happen at some point. Infinite regress just ensures that is has already happened. If I have a 1 to 100 chance of flipping tails on a weighted coin, then by the 101th flip I should have got one tail. Time is the only constraint on my flipping.[/quote]

Your key misunderstanding comes from the notion that if a thing "is never actualized it would be impossible." This is not true. Let's imagine the young Thomas of Aquin, before he grew into the Universal Doctor that we celebrate today. The boy is [i]potentially[/i] whatever he might become [i]actually[/i], so, for example, the boy is potentially a genius if he might become a genius. But now let us imagine that Tommy falls into a well and dies, long before he had the chance to actualize his potential. Does this mean that he never had the potential? Of course not, it simply means that the potentiality never became actual.

Now with regards to probability, it seems you have a small misunderstanding here as well. You used the example of flipping a coin, so I will use that example as well. If I have a 50% chance of flipping heads, then the statistically normal rate of getting heads is 1 out of every 2 flips. But, like you said in your quote, that only means that I [i]should[/i] get heads half the time, not that I must. Therein lies the problem with your argument. It is theoretically possible that I could spend my entire life flipping a coin and never get a single "heads" in my life. The reason is because every single flip is random, and no flip has any effect on any other flip. Even if I flipped that coin for infinity, that would simply result in an infinite series of single flips, each with a 50% chance of coming up heads. Just because it is my 100th flip and I still haven't gotten a "heads" yet doesn't mean that my chance of getting heads on the 101st flip is any greater than 50%.

Would it be a statistical anomaly for an infinite series of flips to not yeild a single heads? Definately. Is it impossible? Absolutely not.

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff

Posted

thanks for all your help guys! My class should be discussing it either today or monday.

Myles I like the example of the key, it makes better sense than the balls yet makes the same point.

Jeff maybe I was holding on a bit too tight to the 3rd argument. It seemed to me to have 'all the answers'. On the probability, maybe I was treating it too much like a computer or on paper. If something had a 50% then by flip 2 I should (in I guess the non-real math world) have both instances occuring. But in the real world it may not be so. No you've got me thinking probablity is a bunch of carp! haha my stats prof will love that :P:

I also had to read an essay by Willian Rowe, which really relies on the PSR. He brought up two really good qeustions\arguments
1- What cuses the contigent being?
2- Why are there any contingent beings at all?

to the infinite regressor the first would cause a circluar argument, which sounds absrud prima facea, and the second can't be answered unless there is a first mover.

Thanks for the help guys! I might be back in a few weeks with the ontological stuff....

Posted (edited)

[quote]First, it was argued that the system as a whole does not have an efficient cause. However, this argument makes no sense, because it is equivocating the word "system" by making it appear as if it were a reference to a unitary ontological entity, which it is not. In fact, when we refer to the "system" in question, what we mean is the whole chain of causality. But the "whole chain of causality" cannot have a cause, because if it did, it would by definition include that cause. So this argument doesn't work whether God is the first cause in that chain or whether he isn't, because either way the system - the whole chain of causes - cannot have a cause.[/quote]My apologies for imprecise word usage. I should have used the "whole chain of causality," but system came to mind first since it typically involves causes and effects (mechanical or chemical systems where each part of the machine is seperate but may also be considered part of the whole. So we may say that I am indeed an individual but I am included when I speak of the earth, galaxy, universe, etc...) Regardless, I now see that by definition the initial cause would indeed be included in the chain, but Aquinas' point was that that initial cause must be self-caused. I was working from the presupposition that the initial cause would not be included in the chain for one reason or another, when I should have stated that either the chain must be caused by something other than itself (ie: the initial cause is not included in the chain), or the initial cause or movement within the chain must be self-caused. I am honestly not sure why I drew a mental line between the second movement and the first, self-caused movement.

I would then run into the problem that if the initial cause within the chain is self-caused then would the chain as a whole not be self-caused? At this point I would have to fall back on the atheist's first defense of looking at each movement or cause also as an independent to show them that while the chain may be considered as a whole, each movement may also be considered individually.

My problem was the presup that the starting cause was not included in the chain. I should have been wokring to show that there is an initial cause in the chain that is self-caused.

Also on probability Jeff: There are two different types of probability systems. I, however, have conveniently forgotten the names since I took algebra so many years ago. You have one system as you have shown with the flipping of the coin. In this system the outcome of one does not affect another. But there is also another system. In this other (I really wish I knew the names) system the outcome of one does directly affect the next. This could be likened to a deck of cards where you discard the drawn card. So instead of having exactly the same number of possiblities the next draw, the number has decreased by one.

That really does not have too much to deal with what you have stated, but I felt that I should clarify that there are modes where one outcome affects another. I also believe that this could be a closer parallel to life rather than a coin. When someone makes a choice that person makes an action of both creating more possibilites but also diminishing others. This is so since when you choose X, you do not only choose X but choose against, or do not choose, Y, Z, etc... But as I said, it really has no bearence on your statment.

Edited by Paphnutius

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...