Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

I have to see Brokeback Mountain...


Recommended Posts

Posted

I am taking a class called Contemporary Arts and Culture and for one of our discuession we are required to see the movie Brokeback Mountain on our own time.

I am really distressed about the whole situation because I have no desire to see for obvious reasons. Do you think I should talk to my teacher and tell him I won't see it or do you think I should smell of elderberries it up and see it and just be ready to discuss why I disagree with the movie?

On a good note though, he opened up to suggestion for other movies to watch that are culturally important and I said The Passion and he agreed. Needless to say, I am not the most popular person in my class right now.

Posted

hmm i am not really sure what i woudl tell a college teacher. I suppose that it would depend on how class is going.

You could go and take headphones and sleep through the whole thing ...

Posted

jezic, but the $$$ to support the movie would already be done.

Posted

well true. But honestly you pay a lot more for the class so getting a bad grade on something would be worse.

Posted

Sadly typical of the Left-wing social indoctrination passing for higher education these days. :ohno:

Posted

Where do you go to school?

Posted

[quote name='Norseman82' date='Jan 18 2006, 05:18 PM']Where do you go to school?
[right][snapback]860331[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
I go to school at Oakton Community College in Des Plaines, IL.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

I would actually go ahead and see the movie and like you suggested, discuss what you find problematic about it. I thought that USCCB was very even-handed and sensible about the film in their review. They explained issues of emotional fragility in the characters and gave credit to where the film was well crafted and acted, but pointed out how the film was problematic from a Catholic standpoint in giving tacit approval of same-sex relationships.

[url="http://www.usccb.org/movies/b/brokebackmountain.shtml"]http://www.usccb.org/movies/b/brokebackmountain.shtml[/url]

Posted

[quote name='khouse' date='Jan 18 2006, 04:24 PM']I am taking a class called Contemporary Arts and Culture and for one of our discuession we are required to see the movie Brokeback Mountain on our own time. 

I am really distressed about the whole situation because I have no desire to see for obvious reasons.  Do you think I should talk to my teacher and tell him I won't see it or do you think I should smell of elderberries it up and see it and just be ready to discuss why I disagree with the movie?

On  a good note though, he opened up to suggestion for other movies to watch that are culturally important and I said The Passion and he agreed.  Needless to say, I am not the most popular person in my class right now.
[right][snapback]860210[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

This is where we are called to remain true to our faith. This is but one of many choices [free will] that will be put in front of you by the secular world. If Our Lord were standing in front of you, what choice would you make?

Approach your teacher will kindness and hope. Tell him very simply, in a nonaccusing manner, that your religious faith prevents you from doing the assignment. Ask him if there is any alternative for you. If not, rest easy in the embrace of Our Lord, and know you did the right thing.

Prayers,
Mary-Kathryn

Posted

In school, as in your employment, you are called upon to do things that you may not want to do. I have not yet seen the movie, though plan on it. Teachers are not realy pleased by students who do not complete assignments. From what I understand, there are some objectionable scenes in the movie, but it is not all that way. You can't always run away from things, you are an adult(at least I feel if you are in college you must be around 20), so watch the movie as if this were a homework assignment. Be objective.
In my job as a nurse I am exposed to many many things that I find morally objectionable. I meet people whom I would not like to really associate with. but you know what, I have to. I attempt to just get through things, as you will have to do with this movie.
And in life, you will be faced with far bigger dilemmas.
Good luck!

Ash Wednesday
Posted

I hear you, alicemary. I work in the art field and come across art I find objectionable from time to time. Generally in art, the intention behind the work is something to take into account. Artists aren't always out to shock but are trying to shed light on the reality of the human condition. I've seen work where I could understand the complexity of the message, but I certainly am able to walk away and know what is problematic with it from a Catholic standpoint. I think the most important thing when dealing with the secular world is to be well-educated and rooted in the Catholic faith and to have a solid relationship with God. It allows us to distance and separate ourselves from the things we do find objectionable despite having to be confronted by them.

Again I think USCCB discusses what to expect in the film very well.

Posted

[quote name='alicemary' date='Jan 19 2006, 01:21 PM']In school, as in your employment, you are called upon to do things that you may not want to do. I have not yet seen the movie, though plan on it. Teachers are not realy pleased by students who do not complete assignments. From what I understand, there are some objectionable scenes in the movie, but it is not all that way. You can't always run away from things, you are an adult(at least I feel if you are in college you must be around 20),  so watch the movie as if this were a homework assignment. Be objective.
In my job as a nurse I am exposed to many many things that I find morally objectionable. I meet people whom I would not like to really associate with. but you know what, I have to. I attempt to just get through things, as you will have to do with this movie.
And in life, you will be faced with far bigger dilemmas.
Good luck!
[right][snapback]860496[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I agree with the above. You will be faced with bigger dilemmas. You can just go to the movie treat it as an assignment put your talent at work critique the movie and then get on with it. It is not as if you are going to be converted by the movie to the lifestyle it seems to promote.

blovedwolfofgod
Posted

i feel that if he agreed to assign The Passion, the least you can do is see brokeback. The Passion is basically gratuitous violence and possibley would have been the most offensive thing id have ever seen if i were not a believer.

Posted

I'm aware that it's a long thread, but [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=44348"]the conversation entitled "gay cowboy movie" from the Muzik thread[/url] may be helpful for you before/after you see it.

Posted

hmmmm, i remember in college I didn't have money to go to the movies.

rent is one thing, it's like 4 bucks, but a new movie?

during college, I could only afford the dollar movies.

Maybe that was just me.

Give a good critique. Here is another one worth reading. it's really good.

[url="http://lookingcloser.org/movie%20reviews/A-G/brokebackmountain.htm"]http://lookingcloser.org/movie%20reviews/A...ackmountain.htm[/url]

Posted

[quote name='blovedwolfofgod' date='Jan 18 2006, 08:11 PM']i feel that if he agreed to assign The Passion, the least you can do is see brokeback. The Passion is basically gratuitous violence and possibley would have been the most offensive thing id have ever seen if i were not a believer.
[right][snapback]860535[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Are you implying the Passion and Death of Our Lord and Savior was gratuitous???

Posted

[url="http://www.decentfilms.com/sections/reviews/2645"]This is the best review of it I have seen. Though the movie from all accounts is artistically well done and maybe even handed it is still morally offensive and dangerous to your soul.[/url]

Posted

[quote name='Theoketos' date='Jan 18 2006, 09:50 PM'][url="http://www.decentfilms.com/sections/reviews/2645"]This is the best review of it I have seen.  Though the movie from all accounts is artistically well done and maybe even handed it is still morally offensive and dangerous to your soul.[/url]
[right][snapback]860569[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Wow, thanks for providing this link.

Laurentina1975
Posted

[quote name='khouse' date='Jan 18 2006, 04:24 PM']I am taking a class called Contemporary Arts and Culture and for one of our discuession we are required to see the movie Brokeback Mountain on our own time. 

I am really distressed about the whole situation because I have no desire to see for obvious reasons.  Do you think I should talk to my teacher and tell him I won't see it or do you think I should smell of elderberries it up and see it and just be ready to discuss why I disagree with the movie?

On  a good note though, he opened up to suggestion for other movies to watch that are culturally important and I said The Passion and he agreed.  Needless to say, I am not the most popular person in my class right now.
[right][snapback]860210[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

All I know is I wouldn't go see it and I don't know what else to say. Speak your mind though.
:idontknow:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...