Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

methods of biblical exegesis


Recommended Posts

photosynthesis
Posted

so I'm in this informal theology seminar, and it's about the Church's teaching regarding the interpretation of Scripture.

So far we've talked about the historical-critical method and its strengths and weaknesses. What are some of the other methods? The priest only talked about literalist & historical-critical methods.

Posted

The historical-critical method is all the rave today among biblical scholars (Catholic (ie, the Pontifical Biblical Commission) and non). It's been a topic of discussion here in this forum lately, too. But I'll let someone else share their views about the H-C method/

Photo- the short answer to your question would be [i]"there are dozens of other methods!"[/i] But allow me to elaborate some.... there are [b]methods [/b]and there are [b]approaches[/b]. (If this is something your prof has already addressed, please forgive me for being redundant.)

[b]Method:[/b] A group of scientific procedures employed in order to explain texts. (i.e. Historical-Critical Method[b][i][u]s[/u][/i][/b]. I emphasize here that there is more than one way to utilize this hermeneutic. There is no universal historical-critical method.)
[b]Approach:[/b] An inquiry proceeding from a particular point of view. (i.e. feminist, mujerista, liberation, cultural-anthropological/ social-scientific (some scholars see this as a method more than an approach))
* Definitions cited as put forth in the PBC's [i]Document on the Interpretation of the Bible in the Church[/i], 21 September 1993.


I hope that's a somewhat helpful response to your question. My question for you is: what sort of books are you using/looking at this semester?

Happy Monday. :)

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

check out "The Interpretation of Scripture in the Church" by the Pontifical Biblical Commission. I bet it will cover a lot for that seminar, and it does go over a few methods.

Posted

[quote name='shortnun' date='Jan 23 2006, 09:12 AM']The historical-critical method is all the rave today among biblical scholars (Catholic (ie, the Pontifical Biblical Commission) and non).
[right][snapback]863910[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


Um, I seriously doubt that, as one of my professors is on the Commession and constantly (but I would say fairly) rails against the method. :idontknow:

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='Theoketos' date='Jan 23 2006, 11:54 AM']Um, I seriously doubt that, as one of my professors is on the Commession and constantly (but I would say fairly) rails against the method. :idontknow:
[right][snapback]863939[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
ditto.

I've not heard many good things about it.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Jan 23 2006, 09:58 AM']ditto.

I've not heard many good things about it.
[right][snapback]863942[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
My OT prof liked it, but always pointed out its shortcomings and how it is to be applied. He took it for what it was worth but then moved on. I believe that it has good things to offer, but one must be sure to read it in light of its limitations.

Edited by Paphnutius
Posted

[quote name='Theoketos' date='Jan 23 2006, 10:54 AM']Um, I seriously doubt that, as one of my professors is on the Commession and constantly (but I would say fairly) rails against the method. :idontknow:
[right][snapback]863939[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Jan 23 2006, 10:58 AM']ditto.

I've not heard many good things about it.
[right][snapback]863942[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
[quote name='Paphnutius' date='Jan 23 2006, 11:16 AM']My OT prof liked it, but always pointed out its shortcomings and how it is to be applied. He took it for what it was worth but then moved on. I believe that it has good things to offer, but one must be sure correctly understand it.
[right][snapback]863957[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Allow me to clarify... in the early 90s especially, the H-C method was all over in terms of literature. From the recent research I've seen, it's still very much in the spotlight. There are those who are not in favor of it (or as I often see it, against Raymond Brown <_< ). It certainly has it's limitations, as do all approaches and methods. Paphnutius hit the nail on the head: the key is a proper understanding of a method/approach and going from there accordingly.

Posted

photo.............check this out:

Hermeneutics and Exegesis
[url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/693"]http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/693[/url]

Church Documents (on Hermeneutics and Exegesis)
[url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/710"]http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/710[/url]

Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Jan 23 2006, 11:47 AM']check out "The Interpretation of Scripture in the Church" by the Pontifical Biblical Commission. I bet it will cover a lot for that seminar, and it does go over a few methods.
[right][snapback]863933[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
here's a link to the document that fides referenced:
[url="http://www.catholicculture.org/docs/doc_view.cfm?recnum=561"]http://www.catholicculture.org/docs/doc_view.cfm?recnum=561[/url]

photosynthesis
Posted

[quote name='shortnun' date='Jan 23 2006, 11:12 AM']Photo- the short answer to your question would be [i]"there are dozens of other methods!"[/i] But allow me to elaborate some.... there are [b]methods [/b]and there are [b]approaches[/b]. (If this is something your prof has already addressed, please forgive me for being redundant.)

[b]Method:[/b] A group of scientific procedures employed in order to explain texts. (i.e. Historical-Critical Method[b][i][u]s[/u][/i][/b]. I emphasize here that there is more than one way to utilize this hermeneutic. There is no universal historical-critical method.)
[b]Approach:[/b] An inquiry proceeding from a particular point of view. (i.e. feminist, mujerista, liberation, cultural-anthropological/ social-scientific (some scholars see this as a method more than an approach))
* Definitions cited as put forth in the PBC's [i]Document on the Interpretation of the Bible in the Church[/i], 21 September 1993.
I hope that's a somewhat helpful response to your question. My question for you is: what sort of books are you using/looking at this semester?
[right][snapback]863910[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
well, it's not a college course... just a bunch of people from this young adult center I go to getting together and discussing theology with a priest. We're going over the document from the Pontifical BIblical Commission right now.

He said we were going to be examining all kinds of modern approaches, like feminist, ideological, psychoanalytic, etc. along with some of the more traditional approaches. The problem is, he seems to know a lot more about modern methods of bible study than traditional ones.... how did people interpret scripture before the historical-critical method?

Posted

The Holy Father (no stranger to Scripture scholarship) gave an excellent talk entitled "Biblical Interpretation in Crisis":

[url="http://www.catholicculture.org/docs/doc_view.cfm?recnum=5989"]http://www.catholicculture.org/docs/doc_view.cfm?recnum=5989[/url]

[quote]There should be no particular need to demonstrate that on the one hand it is useless to take refuge in an allegedly pure, literal understanding of the Bible. On the other hand, a merely positivistic and rigid ecclesiasticism would not do either. Just to challenge individual theories, especially the more daring and dubious ones, is likewise insufficient. Likewise dissatisfying is the middle-ground position of trying to pick out in each case as soon as possible the answers from modern exegesis which are more in keeping with tradition. Such foresight may sometimes prove profitable, but it does not grasp the problem at its root and in fact remains somewhat arbitrary if it cannot make its own arguments intelligible. In order to arrive at a real solution, we must get beyond disputes over details and press on to the foundations. What we need might be called a criticism of criticism. By this I mean not some exterior analysis, but a criticism based on the inherent potential of all critical thought to analyze itself.[/quote]

Posted

Era, what a great quote from the Holy Father! Thanks for quoting it! :)

[quote name='photosynthesis' date='Jan 23 2006, 03:04 PM']how did people interpret scripture before the historical-critical method?
[right][snapback]864152[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
A method of interpretation that predates Christianity, but was utilized by the Church beyond even the Reformation is that of the [b]Fourfold Sense[/b] (in Latin, [i]quadriga[/i]). Four different dimensions of the text are examined:
[u]Literal/Historical:[/u]what do the words say in the context of their nearest possible reference?
[u]Allegorical:[/u] what the words mean in the context of the larger story (here, the larger story of God)? What is the morality presented as it relates to us?
[u]Tropological:[/u] what do the words teach us regarding how to live our lives--what is the effect on the greater community (ecclesial community and political community)?
[u]Anagogical:[/u] what do the words show us regarding the ultimate end of history--the [i]eschatos[/i]?

Another interpretation of scripture that is still used today is [b]typology[/b]. For Christians, this is particularly noticable when events of the Hebrew Scriptures are "types" of events of the life and teachings of Christ. Often times the intent is to show unity within all the diversity (many different authors, books of the bible, etc) of the books of the Bible. People can also be examined typologically. For example, Christ is the new Adam. Christ is the new Moses. Christ is the new Melchizedek.

The history of the historical-critical method began in the 17th century, and came into the spotlight in the 19th century where the goal of many biblical scholars was to erradicate dependency on ecclesial tradition ([i]sola scriptura[/i], etc). In the late 20th century, some scholars have argued that it is impossible to study the Bible in a post-modern era. [I am not particuarly well-equipped at this moment to delve into a discussion about postmodernity and it's numerous definitions. I will just acknowedge postmodernity as the time in history after WW2, where constant change (in terms of globalization of knowledge, the world market, etc) has become the [i]status quo[/i].] The argument of these scholars being: our own way of understanding ancient texts is too influenced by contemporary thought, and the texts aren't helpful enough in describing the events that they're describing for us to ever reach true objectivity.

Whew, I feel like I'm being way toooo long-winded. Hope some of it's helpful. :)

Posted

very helpful shortnun :thumbsup:

photosynthesis
Posted

thanks! Most of what I learned about Bible Study came out of my experience as a leader with my college's chapter of InterVarsity Christian Fellowship, an evangelical campus ministry. I rediscovered Christ in their group Bible studies and it was like a stepping stone for me in my journey home to the Catholic Church. The method they often use is [i]manuscripting.[/i]] Is anyone else familiar with this? Basically, it goes like this. You look at a piece of Scripture, and:

O - Observe everything that's going on in the story.
I - Interpret what the story means
A - Apply it to your life.

It's very basic, and meant for group study. But I've never been part of a Catholic Bible study group because most parishes don't have them and I have no real catechesis, and so I've never learned any systematic approaches to reading the Bible that are throroughly Catholic.

Posted

[quote name='photosynthesis' date='Jan 23 2006, 10:42 PM']It's very basic, and meant for group study.  But I've never been part of a Catholic Bible study group because most parishes don't have them and I have no real catechesis, and so I've never learned any systematic approaches to reading the Bible that are throroughly Catholic.
[right][snapback]864398[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Photo, it all sounds wonderful. What a gift this class appears to be for you right now. Please keep us posted on what you find interesting in your class. :cool:

photosynthesis
Posted

i'll see how it goes... a lot of people at the young adult center think the priest is heterodox because he often doesn't wear his clerics and he has a lot of liberal beliefs regarding politics and stuff.

Theologian in Training
Posted

Actually, before the historical-critical method, a very popular method of intepreting Scriptures was in light of the Fathers of the Church, given the fact that they were not only interpreting Scripture, but doing so, in a pastoral way, since most of the Fathers were pastors of parishes somewhere.

It is actually quite sad, imho, that we have bought into the historical-critical method or the Documentary Hypothesis (for the OT) so completely that it has, in many ways, become our only way to approach the Scriptures. Yes, there are a myriad of other ways to interpret Scripture, but what happened to the time when we would not just read Scripture as a historical, literal, or allegorical book, but as the written Word of God, with which we would pray, and be led to prayer?

I mean this is the Word of God and sometimes we treat it as nothing more than another book of history or literature, which it is, don't get me wrong, but all too often, imho, methods like the historical-critical or Documentary Hypothesis, remove all elements of the sacred and spiritual leaving us doing mental gymnastics with something that should go beyond our mere reason. A priest I know put it very well, he said how many people have been converted by the historical-critical method?

I am sorry for the tangent and the lament, but basically, before all of the new information we know now, and all these new methods arose, the easiest way to interpret Scripture was by the Fathers, who, in turn, would interpret Scripture in light of the Church, and, really, what more do you need than that?

God Bless

Posted

[quote name='Theologian in Training' date='Jan 24 2006, 03:11 PM']Actually, before the historical-critical method, a very popular method of intepreting Scriptures was in light of the Fathers of the Church, given the fact that they were not only interpreting Scripture, but doing so, in a pastoral way, since most of the Fathers were pastors of parishes somewhere.

It is actually quite sad, imho, that we have bought into the historical-critical method or the Documentary Hypothesis (for the OT) so completely that it has, in many ways, become our only way to approach the Scriptures. Yes, there are a myriad of other ways to interpret Scripture, but what happened to the time when we would not just read Scripture as a historical, literal, or allegorical book, but as the written Word of God, with which we would pray, and be led to prayer?

I mean this is the Word of God and sometimes we treat it as nothing more than another book of history or literature, which it is, don't get me wrong, but all too often, imho, methods like the historical-critical or Documentary Hypothesis, remove all elements of the sacred and spiritual leaving us doing mental gymnastics with something that should go beyond our mere reason. A priest I know put it very well, he said how many people have been converted by the historical-critical method?

I am sorry for the tangent and the lament, but basically, before all of the new information we know now, and all these new methods arose, the easiest way to interpret Scripture was by the Fathers, who, in turn, would interpret Scripture in light of the Church, and, really, what more do you need than that?

God Bless
[right][snapback]864581[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I share your misgivings about historical-criticism. Here at Oxford its basically all we use and I sense very much that the Catholic world has become entrenched in its. Now I'm not [i]completely[/i] against historical-criticism and indeed I find it can be a very useful means at examining a text particularly in light of certain themes we find in the Jewish cultural milieu of 1st century Palestine words, allusions, ideas in rabbinic sources blah blah blah. But it has its limits as I think LT Johnson well illustrates in books like 'living Jesus' and I often dont think those are recognised by convinced historical critics (I say convinced because they treat their historical critical conclusions as if they ARE Christianity). Moreover, its like an unsaid code of historical-criticism in many circles to ignore the patristic testiomony as to what certain texts mean. There is such an enlightenment bias in academic Biblical theology against the idea that tradition can offer anything more substantial than my own conjecture.

Theologian in Training
Posted

[quote name='Myles' date='Jan 24 2006, 11:35 AM']I share your misgivings about historical-criticism. Here at Oxford its basically all we use and I sense very much that the Catholic world has become entrenched in its. Now I'm not [i]completely[/i] against historical-criticism and indeed I find it can be a very useful means at examining a text particularly in light of certain themes we find in the Jewish cultural milieu of 1st century Palestine words, allusions, ideas in rabbinic sources blah blah blah. But it has its limits as I think LT Johnson well illustrates in books like 'living Jesus' and I often dont think those are recognised by convinced historical critics (I say convinced because they treat their historical critical conclusions as if they ARE Christianity). Moreover, its like an unsaid code of historical-criticism in many circles to ignore the patristic testiomony as to what certain texts mean. There is such an enlightenment bias in academic Biblical theology against the idea that tradition can offer anything more substantial than my own conjecture.
[right][snapback]864600[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Agreed. Very well said.

God Bless

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Since the Early Church Fathers were actually THERE, we ignor them to our detriment. Apostolic Tradition carries equal weight with Scripture.
To start on the basis that the Bible is in error or miracles don't exist or are the products of simple imaginations is folly.

I suspect most people's most cherished and defended "approach" says far more about them, than it does about Christianity. CS Lewis said to beware the "Christianity and" folks. His point about "mere" chritianity is well taken.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...