avemaria40 Posted January 23, 2006 Posted January 23, 2006 In the Gospel stories, when Jesus performed miracles, why would He ask the people He performed miracles on to not tell anyone? And what is the parable about "not putting new wine in old wineskins" about, because I don't really understand it.
Theoketos Posted January 23, 2006 Posted January 23, 2006 First, it helps to ask one question at a time in this forum to get your questions answered. Please pray for me as I am between jobs with my first child on the way! I will give the verses in question with a little bit of context and then my explanation for what it is worth: Luke 5: 12 Now there was a man full of leprosy 3 in one of the towns where he was; and when he saw Jesus, he fell prostrate, pleaded with him, and said, "Lord, if you wish, you can make me clean." 13 Jesus stretched out his hand, touched him, and said, "I do will it. Be made clean." And the leprosy left him immediately. 14 Then he ordered him not to tell anyone, but "Go, show yourself to the priest and offer for your cleansing what Moses prescribed; 4 that will be proof for them." 15 The report about him spread all the more, and great crowds assembled to listen to him and to be cured of their ailments, 16 but he would withdraw to deserted places to pray. My original thought was something along the lines of maybe Jesus did not want his people to believe in him because they expected benefit, but instead because the wanted to do the will of the Father who sent Him. So I looked up some commentaries and this is what they said. St. Ambrose in his commentary says: “He says then, [i]I will[/i], for Photinus, He commands, for Arius, He touches, for Manichaeus. But there is nothing intervening between God's work and His command, that we may see in the inclination of the healer the power of the work. Hence it follows, [i], And immediately the leprosy departed from him. [/i], But lest leprosy should become rife among us, let each avoid boasting after the example of our Lord's humility. For it follows, [i], And he commanded him that he should tell it to no one[/i],, that in truth he might teach us that our good deeds are not to be made public, but to be rather concealed, that we should abstain not only from gaining money, but even favor. Or perhaps the cause of His commanding silence was that He thought those to be preferred, who had rather believed of their own accord than from the hope of benefit”. St.Cyril says about this; “Though the leper was silent, the voice of the transaction itself was sufficient to publish it to all who acknowledged through him the power of the Curer.” Mark 2 18 12 The disciples of John and of the Pharisees were accustomed to fast. People came to him and objected, "Why do the disciples of John and the disciples of the Pharisees fast, but your disciples do not fast?" 19 Jesus answered them, "Can the wedding guests fast 13 while the bridegroom is with them? As long as they have the bridegroom with them they cannot fast. 20 But the days will come when the bridegroom is taken away from them, and then they will fast on that day. 21 No one sews a piece of unshrunken cloth on an old cloak. If he does, its fullness pulls away, the new from the old, and the tear gets worse. 22 Likewise, no one pours new wine into old wineskins. Otherwise, the wine will burst the skins, and both the wine and the skins are ruined. Rather, new wine is poured into fresh wineskins." I believe to concern the connexion between the Old Testament and the New Testament. With the arrival of the Messiah, the Jewish fasts, which were instigated to draw the One God and His people together and are represented by the old wine, are fulfilled by the Christ, who spills His blood or the new wine, for our sakes. St. Theophylact: We must also understand, that every man whose works are good is the son of the Bridegroom; he has the Bridegroom with him, even Christ, and fasts not, that is, does no works of repentance, because he does not sin: but when the Bridegroom is taken away by the man's falling into sin, then lie fasts and is penitent, that he may cure his sin. St. Bede; But in a mystical sense, it may thus be expressed; that the disciples of John and the Pharisees fast, because every man who boasts of the works of the law without faith, who follows the traditions of men, and receives the preaching of Christ with his bodily ear, and not by the faith of the heart, keeps aloof from spiritual goods, and wastes away with a fasting soul. But he who is incorporated into the members of Christ by a faithful love cannot fast, because he feasts upon His Body and Blood. It goes on, No one sews a piece of rough that is new cloth on an old garment: else the new piece that fills it up takes away from the old, and the rent is made worse. St. John Chrysostom. As if He said, because these are preachers of the New Testament, it is not possible that they should serve old laws; but you who follow old customs, fitly observe the fasts of Moses. But for these, who are about to hand down to men new and wonderful observances, it is not necessary to observe the old traditions, but to be virtuous in mind; some time or other however they will observe fasting with other Virtues. But this fasting is different from time fasting of the law, for that was one of restraint, this of goodwill; on account of the fervor of the Spirit, Whom they cannot yet receive, Wherefore it goes on, And no one puts new wine into old bottles: else the new wine does burst the bottles, and the wine is spilled, and the bottles will be marred: but new Wine must be put in new bottles. St. Bede; For He compares His disciples to old bottles, who would burst at spiritual precepts, rather than be held in restraint by them. But they will be new bottles, when after the ascension of the Lord, they are renewed by desiring His consolation, and then new wine will come to the new bottles, that is, the fervor of the Holy Ghost will fill the hearts of spiritual men. A teacher must also take heed not to commit the hidden things of new mysteries to a soul, hardened in old wickedness. St. Theophylact: Or else the disciples are likened to old garments on account of the infirmity of their minds, on which it was not fitting to impose the heavy command of fasting. St. Bede Neither was it fitting to sew on a new piece; that is, a portion of doctrine which teaches a general fast from all the joy of temporal delights; for if this be done, the teaching is rent, and agrees not with the old part. But by a new garment is intended good works, which are done externally, and by the new wine, is expressed the fervor of faith, hope, and charity, by which we are reformed in our minds. If you read the whole thing you deserve a high five. The following is a bunch of notes from the New American Bible, They are not so bad this time… 12 [18-22] This conflict over the question of fasting has the same pattern as Mark 2:16-17; see the notes on Matthew 9:15; 9:16-17. 13 [19] Can the wedding guests fast?: the bridal metaphor expresses a new relationship of love between God and his people in the person and mission of Jesus to his disciples. It is the inauguration of the new and joyful messianic time of fulfillment and the passing of the old. Any attempt at assimilating the Pharisaic practice of fasting, or of extending the preparatory discipline of John's disciples beyond the arrival of the bridegroom, would be as futile as sewing a piece of unshrunken cloth on an old cloak or pouring new wine into old wineskins with the resulting destruction of both cloth and wine (Mark 2:21-22). Fasting is rendered superfluous during the earthly ministry of Jesus; cf Mark 2:20. +++++++++++++ ( IMHO) I would add that it might be possible for the Jews who convert to Catholicism to still observe the law as some sort of religious devotion (similar to wearing a scapular), so long as it was made clear that the these works were done for a enculturation and not salvation…at least according to some of my professors who I talked with.
phatcatholic Posted January 25, 2006 Posted January 25, 2006 [quote name='avemaria40' date='Jan 23 2006, 11:21 AM']In the Gospel stories, when Jesus performed miracles, why would He ask the people He performed miracles on to not tell anyone?[/quote] Theoketos provided Luke 5 as an example. we find another in Luke 9, which reads: [b]Luke 9:18-22[/b] [b]18 [/b]Now it happened that as he was praying alone the disciples were with him; and he asked them, "Who do the people say that I am?" [b]19 [/b]And they answered, "John the Baptist; but others say, Eli'jah; and others, that one of the old prophets has risen." [b]20 [/b]And he said to them, "But who do you say that I am?" And Peter answered, "The Christ of God." [b]21 [/b]But he charged and commanded them to tell this to no one, [b]22 [/b]saying, "The Son of man must suffer many things, and be rejected by the elders and chief priests and scribes, and be killed, and on the third day be raised." we see that verse 22 explains, at least in this particular instance, why Jesus charged that to tell no one some thing about him: he did not want any undue glory and praise to deter him from his mission as someone who must suffer and die. like theoketos, i too shall quote from Ambrose, who says:[list]"Christ did not seek to be glorified: He chose to come without glory in order to undergo suffering; and you, who have been born without glory, do you wish to be glorified? The route you must take is the one Christ took. This means recognizing Him and it means imitating Him both in His ignominy and in His good repute; thus you will glory in the Cross, which was His path to glory. That was what Paul did, and therefore he glorified in saying, `Far be it from me to glory except in the cross of our Lord Jesus Christ' (Galatians 6:14)" (St. Ambrose, "Expositio Evangelii Sec. Lucam, in loc."). [/list]you now have at least two reasons why Jesus would charge his Apostles to not tell anyone some thing about him. [quote]And what is the parable about "not putting new wine in old wineskins" about, because I don't really understand it.[right][snapback]863919[/snapback][/right][/quote] The Navarre Commentary reads as follows:[list][b]18-22.[/b] Using a particular case, Christ's reply tells about the connection between the Old and New Testaments. In the Old Testament the Bridegroom has not yet arrived; in the New Testament He is present, in the person of Christ. With Him began the Messianic Times, a new era distinct from the previous one. The Jewish fasts, therefore, together with their system of religious observances, must be seen as a way of preparing the people for the coming of the Messiah. Christ shows the difference between the spirit He has brought and that of the Judaism of His time. This new spirit will not be something extra, added on to the old; it will bring to life the perennial teachings contained in the older Revelation. The newness of the Gospel--just like new wine--cannot fit within the molds of the Old Law. But this passage says more: to receive Christ's new teaching people must inwardly renew themselves and throw off the straight-jacket of old routines. [b]19-20.[/b] Jesus describes Himself as the Bridegroom (cf. also Luke 12:35; Matthew 25:1-13; John 3:29), thereby fulfilling what the Prophets had said about the relationship between God and His people (cf. Hosea 2:18-22; Isaiah 54:5ff). The Apostles are the guests at the wedding, invited to share in the wedding feast with the Bridegroom, in the joy of the Kingdom of Heaven (cf. Matthew 22:1-14). In verse 20 Jesus announces that the Bridegroom will be taken away from them: this is the first reference He makes to His passion and death (cf. Mark 8:31; John 2:19; 3:14). The vision of joy and sorrow we see here epitomizes our human condition during our sojourn on earth. [/list]i hope that helps pax christi, phatcatholic
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now