Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Delicate Dance for Bush in Depicting Spy Program as Asset

by ADAM NAGOURNEY
Published: January 23, 2006

WASHINGTON, Jan. 22 - With a campaign of high-profile national security events set for the next three days, following Karl Rove's blistering speech to Republicans on Friday, the White House has effectively declared that it views its controversial secret surveillance program not as a political liability but as an asset, a way to attack Democrats and re-establish President Bush's standing after a difficult year.

Whether the White House can succeed depends very much, members of both parties say, on its success in framing a complicated debate when the country is torn between its historic aversion to governmental intrusion and its recent fear of terrorist attacks at home.

Polls suggest that Americans are divided over whether Mr. Bush has the authority to order the searches without warrants that critics say violate the law and that the president says are legal and critical to the nation's security.

But as the White House and Democrats are well aware, the issue can draw very different reactions depending on how it is presented. These next few days could prove critical, as both Mr. Bush and Congressional Democrats move aggressively to define what is at stake.

Americans may be willing to support extraordinary measures - perhaps extralegal ones - if they are posed in the starkest terms of protecting the nation from another calamitous attack. They are less likely to be supportive, members of both parties say, if the question is presented as a president breaking the law to spy on the nation's own citizens.

Viewed from the perspective of the battles over the Homeland Security Act or the USA Patriot Act, this White House holds a tactical edge; it has repeatedly proved highly effective in defining complicated debates against the Democratic Party. Applying the campaign lessons of simplicity and repetition, Mr. Bush and Mr. Rove, his chief political adviser, have systematically presented arguments in accessible if sometimes exaggerated terms, and they have regularly returned to the theme of terrorism since the attacks of Sept. 11, 2001.

Mr. Rove's speech on Friday to the Republican National Committee was a classic example. "Let me be as clear as I can be: President Bush believes if Al Qaeda is calling somebody in America, it is in our national security interest to know who they're calling and why," Mr. Rove said. "Some important Democrats clearly disagree."

Democrats - and, though Mr. Rove made no mention of this Friday, some Republicans, too - have indeed challenged the administration for eavesdropping without obtaining warrants. They argue, among other points, that the White House is bypassing legal mechanisms established in 1978 that already allow law enforcement agencies to move rapidly to monitor communications that might involve terrorists. Yet it is difficult to think of a Democrat who has actually argued that it is not "in our national security interest" to track Qaeda calls to the United States, as Mr. Rove contested; he did not offer any examples of whom he had in mind.

Beyond that tactical edge, the White House enjoys the advantage of its platform. The sheer crush of news media attention to a rare public speech by Mr. Rove could not have been lost on Democrats.

By contrast, there is no single Democrat who stands as the voice of opposition. That difference is likely to become particularly glaring this week, with a speech on Monday by Lt. Gen. Michael V. Hayden, the former head of the National Security Agency; a legal defense of the spying program on Tuesday by Attorney General Alberto R. Gonzales; and a visit by Mr. Bush to N.S.A. headquarters on Wednesday. This orchestrated campaign is the work of the same White House that initially offered a crouched, guarded response to the disclosure of the eavesdropping program last month.

Still, in many significant ways the task the White House faces now may prove more daunting than the battles it has waged on this terrain before.

A number of Republicans have joined Democrats in challenging the surveillance program, pointedly reminding the administration that precedents established today will be in place whenever a Democrat returns to power.

"A lot of Democrats?" said one prominent Republican supporter of Mr. Bush, who did not want to be identified while being critical of a White House that famously does not brook criticism. "Democrats, Karl? Republicans, too."

David A. Keene, chairman of the American Conservative Union, said: "A lot of conservatives are very skeptical about it. It is not as clean-cut a political win as the administration thinks that it is."

Senator Arlen Specter, the Pennsylvania Republican and chairman of the Judiciary Committee, is planning hearings on the surveillance program. And in an interview on Fox News on Sunday, Senator John McCain of Arizona said he did not think the president had the legal authority for this operation, adding that the White House should seek Congressional approval to alter the 1978 provisions if it thinks they are not working now.

Mr. McCain also came to the defense of Democrats in response to Mr. Rove's suggestion that they were not committed to the nation's security. "Do I think that the president's leadership has been worthy of support of our party and our leadership?" he said. "Yes. But there's too many good Democrats over there who are as concerned about national security and work just as hard as I do."

Beyond that, one Republican analyst who is skeptical about the White House strategy said Mr. Bush's position was hardly helped by the fact that his credibility numbers have dropped along with his popularity since his re-election. Mr. Bush may find that, as some Democrats have suggested, the invocations of Sept. 11 do not have the force they once had.

For their part, Democrats said they have learned from their repeated defeats by this White House. The Democratic presidential candidate of 2004, Senator John Kerry of Massachusetts, said in an interview on Sunday that Mr. Rove and the White House were willfully distorting the Democratic position.

"He's playing an old game," Mr. Kerry said. "Every time they have a problem, they play the 9/11 card."

"We all support surveillance - that's where they are playing word games again," Mr. Kerry said. "You can protect the safety of the American people and you can protect the Constitution."

The political complexity of the issue was reflected in remarks by Governor Mitt Romney of Massachusetts, a Republican, who, like Mr. Kerry, is considering a run for president. Speaking by telephone on a trip to Iowa, Mr. Romney at first offered full support for the president's surveillance program.

"The eavesdropping is a big matter on the coasts for people who are inclined to dislike the president," Mr. Romney said. "The great majority of Americans think it is the president's first responsibility to protect the lives of the American citizens in an urgent setting where there is a threat of terrorism."

But Mr. Romney called back a few moments later to make clear that he would have a different view if the program were found to be unlawful.

"I would never suggest that the president should break the law," he said. "My guess is, my assumption is, he did not break the law. The president has a responsibility to follow the law, which I believe is likely to be found, but he also has a primary responsibility to protect the American people."

peacenluvbaby
Posted

Bush taking power...breaking laws....an asset???? Maybe if this was the USSR... :annoyed:

Pig of Intrigue
Posted (edited)

As long as you have nothing to hide, what is the problem? The only people that will say its illegal are the ones who are trying to do something naughty!

Edited by Pig of Intrigue
Posted

Well, your problem Pig is that you've never had any privacy to begin with. Some of us like hiding our dirty little secrets rather than wallowing about in them for all to see, as you do.

Pig of Intrigue
Posted

Hey, at least I'm honest about who I am. Everyone's shinobi stinks. Much better to have it out there so we know what we're dealing with than festering in some closet somewhere.

Posted

When one argues that one's protection from illegal search (as outlined and guaranteed by the US Constitution) is done simply "because they are hiding something" one is echoing the same falsehoods that every other dictatorial, totalitarian and genocidal regime in world history has argued. Mao, Hitler, Pol Pot, Ataturk, Nicolae Ceausescu, Slobodan Milosevic, Stalin, Nero and Timur the Lame all argued that the innocent need not fear.

The truth is that if some of our rights (even those of the guilty) are no longer guaranteed then the rights of the innocent will similarly be brushed aside. No one has the right to put aside the Bill of Rights. That's why they are there in the first place.

The worst thing about this debate is the presumption of the Catholicity of the participants. Pope John Paul II, a man I feel assured to the very core of my being is a saint, was a great advocate of human rights. It's inconceivable that people living in what had been touted as the world's greatest democracy can applaud the continual erosion of our most fundamental rights.

Please keep in mind the Lutheran minister Martin Niemöller immortal words:

[quote]In Germany they first came for the Communists,
and I didn't speak up because I wasn't a Communist.

Then they came for the Jews,
and I didn't speak up because I wasn't a Jew.

Then they came for the trade unionists,
and I didn't speak up because I wasn't a trade unionist.

Then they came for the Catholics,
and I didn't speak up because I was a Protestant.

Then they came for me —
and by that time no one was left to speak up.[/quote]

Posted

the Pig was being facetious

Pig of Intrigue
Posted

[quote name='Cow of Shame' date='Jan 24 2006, 08:03 PM']the Pig was being facetious
[right][snapback]865004[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


No I wasn't.

I am a big fan of human rights. But we have very few actual rights. (life, liberty, pursuit of blah blah blah) The rest are privileges.

I don't have the right to vote, drive, drink or write my name in the snow. Rights are things that cannot be taken away.

Posted

So, no right to privacy? Chuck the old search warrant & go to town on anyone that catches the cops' fancy?

Pig of Intrigue
Posted

[quote name='Cow of Shame' date='Jan 24 2006, 09:06 PM']So, no right to privacy?  Chuck the old search warrant & go to town on anyone that catches the cops' fancy?
[right][snapback]865146[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Privacy is not a right. Its a privilege that is in the constitution. It can be taken away legally therefore there is nothing inalienable about it.

We are a society of many privileges and you can argue that we've earned those privileges. I'm not saying anything different. But people have distorted view on what is their "right".

Posted (edited)

...yes...but the point is that you're not saying anything new or clever...many dictators have said the same...Mao, Hitler, Franco, Pol Pot, Ataturk, Nicolae Ceausescu, Slobodan Milosevic, Stalin, Nero, Caligula, Timur the Lame, Idi Amin, Samuel Doe, Muammar Gaddafi, Laurent Kabila, Haile Mariam Mengistu, Joseph Mobutu, King Mswati III, Robert Mugabe, Charles Taylor, Lee Kuan Yew, Mahathir, Ne Win, Pinochet, Suharto, Perwez Muserraf, Husnu Mubarek, Islam Karimov, Saparmurat Niyazov, Lon Nol, Shahanshah Aryamehr, Phoumi Nosavan, Ayub Khan, Yahya Khan, Zia-ul-Haq, Akhtar Abdur Rahman Khan, Ferdinand Marcos, Chiang Kai-shek, Chiang Ching-kuo, Pibul Songgram, Sanit Thanarat, Praphas Charusathien, Thanom Kittikachorn, Ngo Dinh Diem, Nguyen Khanh, Nguyen Cao Ky and Nguyen Van Thieu have all agreed as to the arbitrariness of human rights.

Our rights are GUARENTEED in a document entitled "BILL OF RIGHTS" and not merely listed in something called the "LIST OF PRIVELEGES THAT CAN BE TAKEN AWAY AT WILL."

Can we as a nation and as the leader of the Free World say that we really are these things if we say that rights are not standardized? Rights are too important to give them up to local courts, politicians and law enforcement personnel. Remember that the RIGHT that you have to express your opinion here in this forum is similarly guaranteed by the BILL OF RIGHTS. If you would care to forgo that "privilege" then please do so.

It's perfect insanity to suggest that the Jews who suffered during the Nazi regime and the Tibetans and Burmese who are currently suffering due to the insanity going on in their respective countries, don't have the "right" to avoid such treatment and instead, should submit to those in power (but not elected to such positions) who would seek to destroy them.

It seems to me that someone who would support Bush's insane claim that rights are "arbitrary" would also, bizarrely, support America's invasion of Iraq. How does anyone mentally and emotionally survive this cognitive dissonance and hypocrisy? Aren't we there to supposedly bring about democracy? But Saddam Hussein also believed in the variability of human rights as you do. By your illogic, we should have kept him in power. Certainly his variability is no better or worse than our current arbitrariness (ie. Bush's)

It's important to maintain all of our rights, so that those who do not have rights, like the pre-born and those living in despotic regimes, can ultimately share in our rights. Keep in mind Voltaire's advice about human rights:

[quote]"Those who can make you believe absurdities can make you commit atrocities." [/quote]

Don't be fooled by those who would take away our rights and make you thank them for their "generosity," "insight" and "perspicacity."

Edited by Kismet
Pig of Intrigue
Posted

Look I understand that I'm new around here. But where I come from, we usually wait for a few pages before we start making the Hitler comparisons. Whats wrong with a little dialogue? A little give and take before we go stampeding to "You're Hitler" statements?

BTW I don't know if you planned it but you listed the fanatical world leaders by height. I'm very impressed. (Technically Idi Amin and Samuel Doe are the same height but Idi usually wore heels.)


I'm a firm believer that if you can't spell guarantee, you shouldn't have your rights gauranteed. But you've listed several groups that have had their rights violated. By death and torture. The jews weren't griping about wiretaps on their phones. They were griping about how their shower massagers had two settings, pulsate and gas.

If something can be legally taken away from you, its a privilege and not a right. (With of course the exception of the death penalty.) No government can infringe upon our inaliable rights.

I stand by what I've said. We live in a privileged country. No other country claims as many "rights" as we do. But we are only guaranteed a few.

Posted

[quote name='Pig of Intrigue' date='Jan 25 2006, 08:53 AM']I'm a firm believer that if you can't spell guarantee, you shouldn't have your rights [color=red]gauranteed.  [/color]
[right][snapback]865465[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I know its a typo .... but being the grammar nazi that I am.....

Kid, I kid.

Posted

[quote name='Azriel' date='Jan 25 2006, 11:10 AM']I know its a typo .... but being the grammar nazi that I am.....

Kid, I kid.
[right][snapback]865472[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
I noticed that too.

Ironic, that. The pig is so ironic.

And I love that you're the grammar [b]nazi[/b] :lol_roll:

Posted

Sorta appropriate, no? :P:

Posted

Don't belittle yourself, Pig….you're a fine little dictator in your own right and you're in excellent company; the Republicans would be proud of you. If you don't wish to be compared to Hitler, then stop talking like him.

Posted

Now now ... lets keep this nice.

Pig of Intrigue
Posted

[quote name='Kismet' date='Jan 25 2006, 10:27 AM']Don't belittle yourself, Pig….you're a fine little dictator in your own right and you're in excellent company; the Republicans would be proud of you. If you don't wish to be compared to Hitler, then stop talking like him.
[right][snapback]865482[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Oh come on, don't you have a better response than "You talk like Hitler?" If all you can do is throw insults around, neither of us is going to get much out of the conversation.

Posted

If you offer an insult, why would balk when your target returns with an insult?

If you try to belittle an intelligent conversation with ad hominem attacks and cheap jabs at the misspelling of a single word, I can't imagine that you are actually interested in an intelligent exchange of ideas.

How about this: you don't seem to be taking this very seriously. You seem to want to only start an argument but lack the intelligence, maturity, wisdom, erudition and logic to discuss this idea in an adult manner. So let me just forgive you for your lack of abilities and end the exchange here.

Pax et Bonum

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Pig of Intrigue' date='Jan 25 2006, 03:09 PM'] (If all you can do is throw insults around,)

neither of us is going to get much out of the conversation.
[/quote]

[b]I[/b] certainly will.

Of course, it doesn't take much to accuse someone that the Jews consider to be 'unclean' as being anti-semitic....

Edited by Cow of Shame

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...