Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Needing some help here


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

I was having a discussion with a friend of mine about homosexuality and Marriage (sorry if this is a repeat) She made some interesting points and I hadn't the foggiest how to counter her arguements.

Some points here
Marriage has always been a economic transaction its never been for love, if you look back in the pass centuries marriage was usually arranged between familes usually for some economic gain.

Marriage isnt for the procration of the species...what happens to the couples whom can't have children? Are they not typically married because they can't procrate?

Our Country wasn't founded by religious zealots rather deist whom wanted to seperate God from politics.

No one gets hurt by a homosexual marriage, Two people love each other and want to spend their lives together all they want is for they union to be recognized by the legal system.

Upon that she stated if I wanted to raise my kids racist i have the right to do so and no one can tell me otherwise. Because I can do anything I want as long as it doesn't hurt anyone physcially

(I love this one)
Your trying to impose your religious views on others and thats not what this country was founded on...(something like that)

Iam kinda new with the apolgetics stuff and from this arguement I wanted to learn how to defend the faith. If anyone has any good counter arguements here that would be great...I am all ears :topsy:
Also if anyone knows of any good resources that I could use that would be great also. I tried the apolgetics resources on PM but it was kinda confusing.

In JMJ

Edited by Marieteresa
Posted (edited)
:lol: It sounds like your friend is quite anti-Catholic and does not agree with anything that we stand for. She sounds very hate-full.

A lot of these arguments are easy, as they are simply common sense. Why would you go out of your way to treat someone badly when you do it with out even knowing?

So here it goes Im just going to shoot off the hip some initial thoughts here, so everyone else please correct me if I am wrong.

[quote]Marriage has always been a economic transaction its never been for love, if you look back in the pass centuries marriage was usually arranged between familes usually for some economic gain.[/quote]
I would ask how your friend stands on the idea of polygamy, If marriage is simply for money only why is polygamy socially unexectable? Marriage is of mutual respect for each member it is to be pure, both giving and taking.

Perhaps your friend should have a look at what happens to peoples marriages who base it on money... They get divorced.

The sacrament of marriage is the revalation of the un-dying love of a man and a women for each other. In the has always been the Jewish tradition of 1 man and 1 women. Marriage is the expressions of God's love in the Trinity. It is an image of God him self. The two becomes one and with the birth of child, the three become one as in the Trinity. This is part of God's devine plan.

[quote]Marriage isnt for the procration of the species...what happens to the couples whom can't have children? Are they not typically married because they can't procrate?[/quote]
As stated above, procreation of the species is secondary part of marriage and not essential to be married. The love of the man and woman is paramount. However the couple should be open to having children.

[quote]Our Country wasn't founded by religious zealots rather deist whom wanted to seperate God from politics.[/quote]
This could be the case, however, God's laws are higher than the laws of man. Look at all major religions in the world, they all hold marriage as the most high essteem.

[quote]No one gets hurt by a homosexual marriage, Two people love each other and want to spend their lives together all they want is for they union to be recognized by the legal system. [/quote]
I love my male friends, my father, my brother, and my uncles and cousins... This doesnt mean I should have sex with them a become married. Again this falls into the true definition of marriage and thus the first commandment of God in Genesis..."God created them male and female".... "Be furtile and multiply and subdue the earth". Gay people can not be fertile and multiply and subdue the earth. It is agaisnt pro-creation. They are taking their-selves out of the gene pool. When ever a species does this the effects are deadly. Our earthly population would cease to exist if everyone was homosexual. We are not to allow our sexuality control our lives. Rather it is something that we are. You are either Male or Female thats it. A man is made for a woman, a woman is made for a man... they fit together :lol: Thats how we were created. We are made for one another.

[quote]Upon that she stated if I wanted to raise my kids racist i have the right to do so and no one can tell me otherwise. Because I can do anything I want as long as it doesn't hurt anyone physcially [/quote]
The nazi's stated they had that same right... look how that ended up, this thought will surely lead to self distruction. We have a social responsiblity to at least attempt to better our selfs and our culture. All people deserve to be respected because of thier human dignity. These rifts of raising kids like this would hurt far more than physical harm!

[quote]Your trying to impose your religious views on others and thats not what this country was founded on[/quote]
It is justified when people are leading their self and the entire world to utter distruction... What is so wrong with Jesus. Love your neighbour, do good to those who perscute you. If you are struck on the cheek, offer the other also. Ever human being can live by these commandments. It is the only way that will lead to a culture of life, and true lasting peace in the world. Its easy.... BE NICE to people. Do on to other as you would have them do onto yourself.

However everyone has the choice, you are not imposing things on her. They have the choice not to accept them. Imposing them would mean forcing them to accept it... much as the Nazi's did, communism etc. We do not do that, before you make a life decision isnt it wise to hear all the arrguments first? Edited by Church Punk
Posted

[quote name='Marieteresa' date='Jan 25 2006, 09:24 AM']I was having a discussion with a friend of mine about homosexuality and Marriage (sorry if this is a repeat) She made some interesting points and I hadn't the foggiest how to counter her arguements.[/quote]
i'll take a crack at it :thumbsup:


[quote]Some points here
Marriage has always been a economic transaction its never been for love, if you look back in the pass centuries marriage was usually arranged between familes usually for some economic gain.[/quote]
notice how she goes from an absolute statement ("always" been an economic transation) to a qualified statement ("usually" for some economic gain). She knows how rash it is to state such a thing, and you should emphasize that point.

the fact is that marriage was [i][b]not[/b][/i] always entered into for economic gain. in prehistoric times, man chose women b/c she was appealing to his senses and fit to nurture his seed. in other times, man married woman to unite two families that were at war with each other, or b/c women depended on men to thrive, or man paid a dowery to the woman's family or father, or did some kind of work for him. in some ancient tribes, the man actually went and seized the woman he was going to marry from another tribe. so, you can't say that it was "always" about economic gain, and you certainly can't say that it was "never" about love. what an audacious claim!! surely marriages from time immemorial have been entered into b/c the man and woman truly loved each other.

secondly, note that she is implicitly saying that we must approach marriage like this now b/c that's how people did it back then. however, just b/c ancient societies approached marriage for this reason, that does not mean that they were approaching marriages the right way or that we should necessarily adopt their approach. in ancient times, many "marriages" were in fact polygamous. does that mean that men nowadays should have the right to run around collecting as many wives as they can? furthermore, altho it was not always lived in the history of man, the Church's approach towards marriage is one of the most ancient approaches of all, at least since the first century AD. why then, under her logic, does she not embrace this approach to marriage?

all you have to do to win the argument is point out the gaping holes in her logic and draw her statements out to their final implications.


[quote]Marriage isnt for the procreation of the species...what happens to the couples whom can't have children?  Are they not typically married because they can't procrate?[/quote]
this is simply an ahistorical statement, totally devoid of any knowledge of the inception and development of marriage from the time that man came to be. when God created man and woman, and gave each one to the other, he commanded them to be fruitful and multiply. the first 11 chapters of Genesis show the obedience of man to this command. of course, if she does not respect what the bible has to say (and i suspect this to be the case) then you will have to use a different line of argumentation.

how is mankind to further itself if man and woman do not engage in marriage? sure, i suppose i could run around having one-night stands and hope that the unsuspecting woman will both decide to keep the child (instead of aborting it) and actually be his mother and raise him (instead of leaving him to fend for hisself). but, that's not really the most effective way to further mankind. would she suggest homosexuality as the proper way? that is simply an anatomical absurdity.

the fact is that marriage is meant, at least in part, for procreation b/c it is the best scenario in which to raise a child. sociological and psychological studies ABOUND that prove this to be the case.


[quote]Our Country wasn't founded by religious zealots rather deist whom wanted to seperate God from politics.[/quote]
there are actually three statements here:
1. our country wasn't founded by religious zealots
2. the founding fathers of our contry were deists.
3. the founding fathers wanted to separate Church from State

now, you could dismiss the whole thing as off-topic (i'm not really sure how these statements refute what you believe or affirm what she believes) or you can actually confront each one. since this is a can of worms, i'll just say something briefly about each point.

regarding #1, i actually agree. the founders were not zealous. woopty-freakin-doo. regarding #2, the founding fathers were certainly NOT deists (or, at the very least, you can't make this claim about ALL of them). for example, they invoke God often, in their works and in their speeches, to bless this country. why would they even do this if, as deists, they believed that God created the universe and then wanted nothing to do with us? finally, regarding #3, it is highly debatable, and i believe erroneous, to assert that they believed in the "separation of church and state" as our society currently defines it. again, their writings and speeches show that the Christian God and our Christian morals should be involved in how this nation is to thrive, and protect the rights of man, and govern itself. the Constitution itself determines how things "ought to be", and this is a very [i][b]moral [/b][/i]principle.

now, it could be that she is making these statements b/c she sees you as a "zealot," so by asserting that the founding fathers weren't "zealots" and that they didn't intend the country to adopt a "zealous" doctrine, that you are wrong taking your particular stance. if this is the case, then you would rebut this by showing that there is nothing zealous about any of this. for one, the word "zealot" connotes extremism, and by a group that is on the fringe of society. BUT, the US is a predominantly christian nation, and the majority of its citizens believe that marriage should be between one man and one woman. many polls as well as the results of state-by-state voting to institute a ban on gay marriage shows this. of course, this does not prove in and of itself that your position is right, but it does show that you are not a "zealot" for believing as you do.


[quote]No one gets hurt by a homosexual marriage, Two people love each other and want to spend their lives together all they want is for they union to be recognized by the legal system.[/quote]
this one actually made me laugh at loud in the computer lab, when i was reading this. its hysterically typical :sweat: and it shows just how staunchly individualistic our society has become. "you can do whatever the hell you want, and i'll do whatever the hell i want, and as long as we don't do anything to each other, what we are doing is 'okay' ". its just ridiculous on its face, but i suppose it will be necessary for you to explain to her why that is.

for one, the rightness or wrongness of an action does not depend on the effect it has on other persons. an example: lets say i work on the stock crew at Walmart and one day i decide to steal a candy bar from the shelf. no one sees me do it. i am not taking it from any one person. the loss of profit from one candybar has such a nominal effect on the overall profit from the store that the management, or the owners of the store, or the stockholders, or anyone who is effect by the money that the store makes would never even notice the loss. basically, i have acted alone and effected no one. would this mean that i was right to steal? her logic would say yes, but just our basic sense of "rightness" and "wrongness" tells us, and would likely tell her, that this act is still wrong (btw, i wonder where she thinks this sense comes from.......).

also, show her that we are hardly as disconnected from other people as she would like us to think. note, she said that "no one gets hurt" by a homosexual marriage. but, as her friend, you would be hurt if she were to marry another woman b/c you love her and want whats best for her. her family would be hurt too, if they didn't condone it. it hurts society b/c it provides yet another example of society shooting itself in the foot and not furthering its own growth and prosperity (how do homosexuals procreate?) most importantly, you hurt the person you marry, and you hurt yourself. studies show that homosexual partnerships are even less likely to last than heterosexual ones, are less "healty" (regarding how much emotional and interpersonal conflict that is involved), and are more likely to spread veneral disease

from a christian standpoint, every sin, even those done in total isolation, negatively effect the entire world, and sins committed by one child of God effect the entire Body of Christ ([url="http://bible1.crosswalk.com/OnlineStudyBible/bible.cgi?word=1co+12:26&version=csb&st=1&sd=1&new=1&showtools=1"][b]1 Cor 12:16[/b])[/url]. also, salvation history shows time and time again what happens to man when he strays from the purpose that the Lord intended for him: moral decay, chaos, and destruction.


[quote]Upon that she stated if I wanted to raise my kids racist i have the right to do so and no one can tell me otherwise.  Because I can do anything I want as long as it doesn't hurt anyone physcially [/quote]
racism has no impact on others? apparently she's never been the brunt of racism. how fortunate.....


[quote](I love this one)
Your trying to impose your religious views on others and thats not what this country was founded on...(something like that)[/quote]
yea, that one is rather amusing, huh :unsure: ANYway, just b/c you have an opinion different from hers and you are defending it, that does not mean you are trying to impose it on her. you are not forcing her to do anything. you are simply using your own gifts of persuasion to show her a better way. persuasion and coercion are two very different things.

now, if this topic concerns a constitutional ban on homosexual marriage, then i would at the very least understand why she is posing that argument. but, it is still wrong :thumbsup: if it can be proven that homosexuality is harmful for all the persons involved and detrimental to the prosperity of society (which i believe it can be proven) then it would be the right and obligation of government to not allow this action. it is perfectly within the scope and purpose of government to do such a thing, just as it does when it asserts that murder and rape are unlawful. so, no one would be overstepping their bounds or their authority. society would simply be running as it should.


[quote]Iam kinda new with the apolgetics stuff and from this arguement I wanted to learn how to defend the faith.  If anyone has any good counter arguements here that would be great...I am all ears  :topsy:
Also if anyone knows of any good resources that I could use that would be great also.  I tried the apolgetics resources on PM but it was kinda confusing.[right][snapback]865433[/snapback][/right][/quote]
i hope i helped. if you read it all, you get a lolly-pop :thumbsup: i didn't mean to write a novel, it just kinda came out that way. here are some links to articles that may help as well:

Marriage Is Sacred
[url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/592"]http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/592[/url]

Marriage and the Family
[url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/593"]http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/593[/url]

Same-Sex Marriages
[url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/601"]http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/601[/url]

Homosexuality
[url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/414"]http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/414[/url]


here are some individual articles to read as well:
[b]--[url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/09693a.htm"]History of Marriage[/url]
--[url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/09703b.htm"]Ritual of Marriage[/url]
--[url="http://www.lumenverum.org/apologetics/Family&humanLife/page.html"]The Family and Human Life[/url][/b]

pax christi,
phatcatholic

Posted

i wanted to thank you guys for helping me out here....I am still digesting everything and really thinking about what her counterarguments to the answers given would be. ( Sorry I like chess) Does anyone know of a good starter book or resource for beginning apoligetics thats not confusing or made for scholarly individuals?


Thanks
Marieteresa

Posted

[quote name='Marieteresa' date='Jan 26 2006, 06:37 PM']i wanted to thank you guys for helping me out here....I am still digesting everything and really thinking about what her counterarguments to the answers given would be.  ( Sorry I like chess)  Does anyone know of a good starter book or resource for beginning apoligetics thats not confusing or made for scholarly individuals?
Thanks
Marieteresa
[right][snapback]866928[/snapback][/right][/quote]
the best thing to do is go to catholic.com and just start reading the tracts under "Library" on the left-hand side of the page. there's nothing better for beginning apologetics. or you can get Keating's book "Catholicism and Fundamentalism" which is basically those tracts in print form, with some background info on Fundamentalism.

Posted

Thanks for the resources I am just wondering do you guys ever get discouraged by protestants whom really know their faith and have awesome apologetic skills. What would you guys do if in that situation? Because I am alittle afraid of that

Posted

[quote name='Marieteresa' date='Jan 26 2006, 06:53 PM']Thanks for the resources I am just wondering do you guys ever get discouraged by protestants whom really know their faith and have awesome apologetic skills.  What would you guys do if in that situation?  Because I am alittle afraid of that
[right][snapback]866943[/snapback][/right][/quote]
what do i do? go find the answer. that is CRUCIAL. don't just admit defeat and then go on about your merry way. find the catholic response to protestant assertions that stump you. find the answers to the questions of theirs that you did not know how to address. use these protestants with their awesome apologetic skills to learn more about your own faith. that way, even when you lose a debate, you really win b/c you know now what you need to learn more about. when i first got interested in my faith, i would get eaten alive all the time in debate...........but then i would go find catholic resources on the subjects that i was weak on and equip myself better for the next time. above all else, DO NOT BE DISCOURAGED. you have been given the gift that is the fullness of truth. nothing that could ever be said negatively about your faith has not already been said before..........and answered by the Church a million times over. there is truly nothing new under the sun.

if you ever need help, you know where to go :thumbsup:

Pax Christi,
phatcatholic

missionseeker
Posted

i find it handy to carry a Catechism with if I know I'm going to be asked. Like to (secular) youth conferences and things. Lots of times I'm the only Catholic in a group of anywhere as large as 64 kids and this being the Bible belt, they all try to convert you as soon as they find out that you are Catholic. (I'm in Alabama)

Posted

a bible never hurts either :thumbsup:

missionseeker
Posted

That too.

But normally, they have PLENTY that I can use. lol they don't tend to listen to anything not in THEIR Bible.

Posted

[quote name='Marieteresa' date='Jan 26 2006, 06:53 PM']Thanks for the resources I am just wondering do you guys ever get discouraged by protestants whom really know their faith and have awesome apologetic skills.  What would you guys do if in that situation?  Because I am alittle afraid of that
[right][snapback]866943[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

well for about 6 years my next door neighbour was a 7th day adventist minister, he also was the minister at a baptist church. Great guy and I am very good friends with his son.

We would have a lot of discussions, it started as finding common ground and gradually moved to just stating what we believe in. Most of it was before I even knew I was actually practicing apologetics. I would always state what the Catholic Church believed and if I didnt know I would look it up, or ask my priest.

Since then I have been been trying to rep the Church where ever I go engaging in discussions. A lot of times people dont want to hear the official Churchs stance on things, so I just use moral examples to reveal what the Chruch actually believes.

Try not to get over whlemed. One thing I find really encouragin is that we as Catholics know we have 2000 years of history backing our argument. No protestant can say that.

Well keep at it and remember dont be afraid to say I DONT KNOW. Its better than making somthing up that is false!.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...