Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

US must accept the International Court of Justice!


Recommended Posts

Solve et Coagula
Posted

For the sake of International Human rights, the US and all other countries must accept the International Court of Justice... otherwise there is no guarantee that torture and other acts against humanity will be stopped!!!

What do you think?

best wishes from Switzerland

Posted

I don't think that's such a good idea. Individual countries should not give up portions of their sovereignty to an international un-checked organization. At any point the court could attempt to pursue its own political agenda and attempt to impose it upon anyone involved in it. At one point, if I recall, the court was even threatening posible action against the pope because of "abortion rights" and "homosexual rights"

this would give way too much power over our country to an elite and select few who do not even live in our country. really bad idea.

Posted

[quote name='Solve et Coagula' date='Jan 27 2006, 10:08 AM']For the sake of International Human rights, the US and all other countries must accept the International Court of Justice... otherwise there is no guarantee that torture and other acts against humanity will be stopped!!!

What do you think?

best wishes from Switzerland
[right][snapback]867438[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


No way.

Aloysius is right.

They were threatening the Pope. The international court is an enemy of freedom of religion and speech.

[url="http://www.lifesite.net/ldn/2002/feb/02021201.html"]http://www.lifesite.net/ldn/2002/feb/02021201.html[/url]
[url="http://www.lhla.org/globalwatch/gwstoppingtheicc.htm"]http://www.lhla.org/globalwatch/gwstoppingtheicc.htm[/url]

Down with the "international court" joke. It's just a way for a small group of people to try to rule the world. Down with them and the UN.

God Bless :)
ironmonk
[url="http://www.CatholicSwag.com"]http://www.CatholicSwag.com[/url] <- Shirts laying the international theological smack down

Posted (edited)

This is something I hope the Church will expand on, that is, the nature of international authority. It seems that the Bishops hold the authority of an international body like the UN rather high, and it's unclear to me whether this is a matter of doctrinal principle, or temporal consideration. For example, Cardinal Ratzinger is quoted vis a vis the Iraq war:

[quote]The United Nations is the [institution] that should make the final decision. It is necessary that the community of nations makes the decision, not a particular power.[/quote]

Regarding torture, I don't think the international court is immune to corruption. Perhaps in general it is better for the common good, but let's not canonize international bodies just because they're not the United States. They can be biased as well.

Edited by Era Might
1337 k4th0l1x0r
Posted

I remember in high school a teacher was talking about this court and I asked how the court would enforce their decisions. The teacher told me that if a ruling was made against the United States then we'd have no choice but to accept it. I asked him "what if we choose to ignore this court. Where does their authority come from?" The teacher didn't have an answer for me. I knew then that either the court would be meaningless or we'd have to hand over something very precious to them in order for it to be meaningful. We need to keep our sovereignty to ourselves. After all, we already have one pretty meaningless international organization that can't enforce any of its decisions.

Posted

[quote name='Era Might' date='Jan 27 2006, 10:47 AM']This is something I hope the Church will expand on, that is, the nature of international authority. It seems that the Bishops hold the authority of an international body like the UN rather high, and it's unclear to me whether this is a matter of doctrinal principle, or temporal consideration. For example, Cardinal Ratzinger is quoted vis a vis the Iraq war:
Regarding torture, I don't think the international court is immune to corruption. Perhaps in general it is better for the common good, but let's not canonize international bodies just because they're not the United States. They can be biased as well.
[right][snapback]867460[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


He is not infallible on that topic. The Church is fighting an uphill battle in the UN, they are a member of it and are trying to change it but it is only getting worse.

The UN is not elected, they are appointed. The only pro-life voices in the UN are the Church and a few Islamic countries.

The UN makes it a point to kill babies in the third world without regard to women.

The UN fails to really help. They make empty threats against people like Saddam... "Let us search or we'll get mad and send you more letters telling you to let us see"

What about the Suddan? The UN allows genocide...

The UN is worthless.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='1337 k4th0l1x0r' date='Jan 27 2006, 11:44 AM']After all, we already have one pretty meaningless international organization that can't enforce any of its decisions.
[right][snapback]867510[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
:lol:

Too true.

Yeah, the international court is just a really bad idea. The UN is basically a world-wide legislative system, the world court is trying to become a world-wide judicial...one more branch and you'd have the potential for the most corrupt, wicked, evil, pro-death, genocidal, anti-Christ-like organization on earth.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Solve et Coagula' date='Jan 27 2006, 09:08 AM']For the sake of International Human rights, the US and all other countries must accept the International Court of Justice... otherwise there is no guarantee that torture and other acts against humanity will be stopped!!!

What do you think?

best wishes from Switzerland
[right][snapback]867438[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Never happen.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='ironmonk' date='Jan 27 2006, 11:46 AM']He is not infallible on that topic. The Church is fighting an uphill battle in the UN, they are a member of it and are trying to change it but it is only getting worse.
[right][snapback]867515[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I didn't say he was. He wasn't even Pope when he spoke those words.

Nevertheless, his comments do raise an interesting question, which I would like to see clarified. Namely, the proper nature of international authority in Catholic social doctrine, and its relation to individual sovereignty.

The UN may permit evil, but so does the United States government. That alone would not rule out any possible authority over a sovereign nation. Whether it does, in fact, possess such authority from a Catholic perspective, remains to be seen, at least from my end.

Edited by Era Might
Posted

It's true that Ratzinger (now Ben. 16th) did say that he thought it should be the UN making the decision to go to war with Iraq. However, we should remember that he wasn't the pope at the time, and even if he had been, he wasn't invoking infallibility.

The other thing to be remembered is that even if an "international authority", if a real and effective one could be found, decides on something, it does not make it morally legitimate or right. Case in point, if the Iraq war was unjust, it wouldn't have made it just for the UN to say it was ok. On the other hand, if it was right (which I believe it was; the mass graves Saddam left speak for themselves) then the UN not being able to agree about it has no bearing. They can't agree on the color of grass anyway. What's right is right, and sometimes those decisions just have to be made, with or without other countries' cooperation.

Using the example of Iraq and the UN further, we can see that nations always seek their interests. France and Russia opposed the invasion because they got great oil kickbacks from the Baath gov't, which they knew they would lose once we went in. All the demonstrators in Europe chanting "no blood for oil" should have been telling their own governments- no nation, large or small, should allow a murderer to remain in power so that they can receive convenient oil contracts.

As I said, nations always seek their own interests. It's not unjust in and of itself, and it shouldn't be shocking. We elect governments so that they will look out for us and for our society. The same is true of the Swiss government, the French, the British... and who knows about Russia, but the point is that the purpose of government is to lead, protect and serve the people it represents. They are supposed to look out for our interests.

Yes, sometimes that turns into crookedness, like France and Russia opposing the war simply so they could keep oil deals. But when acted upon in the right context, a government acts for justice at home and abroad, because justice is always in the interest of a just society. And no morally upright society can shrink in the face of genocide and terrorism. Even when there's no "international authority" to help the society feel good about itself.

Posted

[quote name='amdgboomer' date='Jan 27 2006, 12:17 PM']The other thing to be remembered is that even if an "international authority", if a real and effective one could be found, decides on something, it does not make it morally legitimate or right.  [right][snapback]867551[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I agree, of course. Even an international authority can be wrong. But that does not answer the question of whether or not they have the authority in the first place to make a decision.

Ratzinger seemed to suggest that they do. Were his comments just a geopolitical commentary, or were they based on Catholic social doctrine?

I don't know. I tried searching "Pacem in Terris", but couldn't come up with anything. I'll have to look through the other social Encyclicals.

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

I can see a "world court" easily slipping into what the EU and UN have become.

crazymaine catholic
Posted

[quote name='thedude' date='Jan 27 2006, 04:25 PM']I can see a "world court" easily slipping into what the EU and UN have become.
[right][snapback]867850[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
i agree, and knowing what the eu and un do, i would be petrified to live in a country that is a part of an international court. while the supposed goal is to help people around the world, that is froma secularist viewpoint. because of that, there is no way these groups can truly help the people of the world. and the last time a society tried to build something great and fantastic for secular reasons, they were destroyed (aka babylon). i can't help feeling that the un, eu, an international court, interpol, and all those organizations, are a beginning point for another babylon.

Posted

[quote name='Era Might' date='Jan 27 2006, 12:21 PM']I agree, of course. Even an international authority can be wrong. But that does not answer the question of whether or not they have the authority in the first place to make a decision.

Ratzinger seemed to suggest that they do. Were his comments just a geopolitical commentary, or were they based on Catholic social doctrine?

I don't know. I tried searching "Pacem in Terris", but couldn't come up with anything. I'll have to look through the other social Encyclicals.
[right][snapback]867555[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

They seem to me to be geopolitical commentary. The internationalist perspective suggests that we should discourage a society from imposing its will on another, and go only by consensus. However the same people will say that the United States, the last superpower on Earth, should submit to a court made up by smaller, weaker European states. Supporters of the UN and ICC seem to overlook the contradiction. In the case of the US acting without the consent of the UN, you have a nation acting in its interests. In the case of the ICC (or in some ways the UN) expecting total compliance from the US, you have small nations seeking their interests (via weakening the stronger US).

A Christian, realist perspective shows with clarity that all nations seek their interests, and that it is reasonable for them to do so (so long as it's not at the expense of justice). And it's totally reasonable and just for the US to not wish to submit itself to the whims of weaker nations. The just, rational and moral thing for a powerful nation to do with its resources and power is to use it for good and to lead by doing so.

I'm not trying at all to negate questions of Catholic social teaching (although I don't think you'll find international authority under anyone except Christ in there), I'm just saying that we as Catholic Americans don't need to feel guilty that we're a powerful nation, or feel that we need to submit to weaker nations for any reason. And recognizing the ICC, and relegating all choices to the UN would be doing just that.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='amdgboomer' date='Jan 27 2006, 06:05 PM']They seem to me to be geopolitical commentary.  The internationalist perspective suggests that we should discourage a society from imposing its will on another, and go only by consensus.
[right][snapback]867973[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Correct. And there is some validity here. The world is no longer isolated, as it was through most of the second millenia. With the nature of war having changed, and its potential for destruction greatly exacerbated, the collabortion of an international body is vital.


[quote name='amdgboomer' date='Jan 27 2006, 06:05 PM']I'm not trying at all to negate questions of Catholic social teaching (although I don't think you'll find international authority under anyone except Christ in there), I'm just saying that we as Catholic Americans don't need to feel guilty that we're a powerful nation, or feel that we need to submit to weaker nations for any reason.  And recognizing the ICC, and relegating all choices to the UN would be doing just that.[right][snapback]867973[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

This is not a question of "submission". Again, it's not about political ego. It's about war and peace, life and death. We cannot divorce American interests from the global community, as Pope John XXIII emphasizes in "Pacem in Terris":

[quote]From this it is clear that no State can fittingly pursue its own interests in isolation from the rest, nor, under such circumstances, can it develop itself as it should. The prosperity and progress of any State is in part consequence, and in part cause, of the prosperity and progress of all other States.[/quote]

He does, however, go on to address in particular the nature of international authority:

[quote]But it is no part of the duty of universal authority to limit the sphere of action of the public authority of individual States, or to arrogate any of their functions to itself. On the contrary, its essential purpose is to create world conditions in which the public authorities of each nation, its citizens and intermediate groups, can carry out their tasks, fullfill their duties and claim their rights with greater security.[/quote]

So I guess that would answer the question. On the one hand, the Church actively encourages the fruitful collaboration of sovereign nations, but without usurping that sovereignty. Clearly, though, an attitude of paranoia and intransigence toward the universal community is unacceptable.

Edited by Era Might
Posted

[quote name='Era Might' date='Jan 27 2006, 06:28 PM']So I guess that would answer the question. On the one hand, the Church actively encourages the fruitful collaboration of sovereign nations, but without usurping that sovereignty. Clearly, though, an attitude of paranoia and intransigence toward the universal community is unacceptable.
[right][snapback]868001[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

The realist perspective is not one of paranoia or intransigence. It is, just as it's name suggests, realistic. And a realistic, Christian mindset recognizes that while societies ought to cooperate with eachother for justice (as you said, without usurping sovereignty), that the world hardly lives up to ideals. All nations, whether justly or unjustly, seek their own interests, period.

That being said, the Christian knows that we live in a fallen world. While man does not always choose evil/injustice, he does so very, very frequently. The same is true of groups of men (ie societies). Yes, that means the US is capable of doing wrong. But it also means that other nations can, and lo and behold, do infringe on the rights of other nations while seeking their own interests.

The ICC would very easily be used to usurp the authority of the US judicial system and of the US as a whole. Knowing that realistically, it would be imprudent for our leaders to submit to it. That's not paranoia, that's proper leadership.

Posted

[quote name='amdgboomer' date='Jan 27 2006, 08:04 PM']The ICC would very easily be used to usurp the authority of the US judicial system and of the US as a whole.  Knowing that realistically, it would be imprudent for our leaders to submit to it.  That's not paranoia, that's proper leadership.
[right][snapback]868083[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I don't think this can be generalized. It should be taken on an individual basis. Of course, an international authority can err, and a sovereign nation would have to correct it. But, I think we need to be open to a real collaboration in each individual case. Recognizing, as you say, that this cannot be a blind submission, but it also can't be a prideful appeal to sovereigny.

Posted

[quote name='Solve et Coagula' date='Jan 27 2006, 08:08 AM']For the sake of International Human rights, the US and all other countries must accept the International Court of Justice... otherwise there is no guarantee that torture and other acts against humanity will be stopped!!!

What do you think?

best wishes from Switzerland
[right][snapback]867438[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Over my dead body!!!! :maddest:

Posted

[quote name='Era Might' date='Jan 27 2006, 08:09 PM']I don't think this can be generalized. It should be taken on an individual basis. Of course, an international authority can err, and a sovereign nation would have to correct it. But, I think we need to be open to a real collaboration in each individual case. Recognizing, as you say, that this cannot be a blind submission, but it also can't be a prideful appeal to sovereigny.
[right][snapback]868084[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I'm sorry, I just don't think being staunchly defensive of sovereingty is prideful.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...