Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Orthodox Answers Needed on Order of Authority


Recommended Posts

Posted

So I read that the most authoritive teachings of the Church are "Constitutions". Are Lumen Gentium (sp?) and Dei Verbum (sp?) the only Constitutions that have the preface of "Dogmatic" in their titles? Does this mean they are the most authoritative documents of the Church? Does it mean that every line of them is dogma? If not, why are they uniquely titled "Dogmatic"?

A follow up question: in the order of authority in Church documents, where does the Catechism fall? What about the Code of Canon Law? And if one must give obedience and assent to all such documents anyway (regardless of what category they may fall into), why even bother with catagories? What's the difference?

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Ziggamafu' date='Jan 29 2006, 07:01 PM']So I read that the most authoritive teachings of the Church are "Constitutions". Are Lumen Gentium (sp?) and Dei Verbum (sp?) the only Constitutions that have the preface of "Dogmatic" in their titles? Does this mean they are the most authoritative documents of the Church? Does it mean that every line of them is dogma? If not, why are they uniquely titled "Dogmatic"?

A follow up question: in the order of authority in Church documents, where does the Catechism fall? What about the Code of Canon Law? And if one must give obedience and assent to all such documents anyway (regardless of what category they may fall into), why even bother with catagories? What's the difference?
[right][snapback]869644[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
It depends on what you mean by "authoritative". Not all Church documents have authority in the same sense; or you might say they don't all have the same jurisdiction. It is really more organic than this however.
Maybe I'll put it this way: different documents of the Church have different domains in which they apply. The Code of Canon Law for example applies to canonical norms within the Roman Church and is not universally binding doctrinal material. Liturgical directives are also not universally binding since they general pertain to a specific rite.
I don't want to be confusing so maybe I'll take a different approach...

You are correct that Dei Verbum and Lumen Gentium are the only documents of Vatican II that have the word "dogmatic" in the title. Rather than thinking of this in terms of "authority" think of it in terms of application. These documents contain doctrinal content and are intended to state universally binding doctrinal formulations of the Church. There are no canons in the documents of Vatican II, but there are what might be considered decrees. But many of the documents of Vatican II pertain simply to Church policy, liturgical directives, discipline, etc. This is why some l ike to label Vatican II a "pastoral council". All of the documents of Vatican II are authoritative in that they are concilliar, universally directed (generally) and authenticated by the highest authority of the Church. But not all of the documents apply to the same domain. An aspect of Canon Law, or a document outlining the Church's ecumenical policy can be perfectly authoritative and binding, but this does not mean that it exists within the domain of doctrine and can be called dogmatic.
The Catechism too has a intent and domain which is not the same as the dogmatic canons of an ecumenical council. To treat it as such would be to err. But this does not mean that it is not important or "authoritative". But the authority of such a document ought to be understood within its proper sphere, namely catechetics. When the Catechism was released a document was promulgated which described the intent of the Catechism; from this one can get a sense of the nature of this text and the domain in which it applies.
Things such as canon law, church policy (including the ecumenical movement), liturgical directives, etc. can be changed and do change, but things such as dogmatically defined doctrines do not change. We are bound to obedience to the Church, so for practical purposes such questions are of little concern. The question to ask is whether or not something is putting forth a formulation of a revealed truth of faith or a truth of the moral law. If the answer is yes one can begin to enquire as to the level of official "authority" of the formulation. The Catechism was universally directed and confirmed by the highest authority in the Church, but it is still not a vast dogmatic formulation of doctrine. It is a guide for teachers of the Faith that is authorized by the Church and endorsed as faithfully articulating the Faith.

I have to go and I won't be around until next weekend, but I hope this helps.. I have a great deal more to say. :(

God bless.

Posted

[quote name='Laudate_Dominum Today' date=' 06:10 AM ']These documents contain doctrinal content and are intended to state universally binding doctrinal formulations of the Church. There are no canons in the documents of Vatican II, but there are what might be considered decrees.[/quote]

I totally agree with this statement, however, I would add dogmatic to it. These documents contain doctrinal AND DOGMATIC content and are intended to state universally binding doctrinal AND DOGMATIC formulations of the Church......

What do I mean by this? As L_D points out, many docs simply pertain to discipline, however there are some things which are unchagable. When L_D says:

[quote]Things such as canon law, church policy (including the ecumenical movement), liturgical directives, etc. can be changed and do change, but things such as dogmatically defined doctrines do not change. We are bound to obedience to the Church, so for practical purposes such questions are of little concern.[/quote]

He is most certainly correct, but I would add that [u]our understanding[/u] of dogma and doctrine (in this capacity) can and does change (not the dogma itself). This is partially the reason that I include the addedendum to L_D's statement above. For example, we know the dogma of the Trinity and this knowledge doesn't change, however, our understanding of it has grown since It's definition. The same can most certainly be said about any dogma that you choose to list. This is the reason why certain docs of Vatican Council II are considered dogmatic.

[quote name='L_D']The question to ask is whether or not something is putting forth a formulation of a revealed truth of faith or a truth of the moral law. If the answer is yes one can begin to enquire as to the level of official "authority" of the formulation.[/quote]

Ding, ding, ding.......this gets at what I am trying to show. It is the inquiry that people, orthodox and heterodox, get hung up on. This is where the controversy is created.

When you speak of authority, look at it from this point of view, not from a "heavy-handed" and "authoritarian" point of view, but rather from an unchangable beginning which can be expanded, but not changed. The authority lies in that, not in notion that every word is dogma.

I hope that this helps.

Posted

I guess I'm just curious what things in the Code of Canon Law, the Catechism, and the Dogmatic Constitutions are unchangable and definitely preserved from error; i.e. can't be wrong.

For instance, in the CCC there is a line referring to Islam's God as Catholicism's God. I know many who strongly disagree. That refers to the Faith - so is it dogmatic?

Other citations from authoratative papal history that I'm curious about are those concerning Limbo and slavery. I've run into some articles that try to demonstrate some seriously pro-Limbo and pro-slavery positions held and taught by the papacy in certain portions of Church history. I posted some of the Limbo stuff I found in another thread here at Phatmass...

Posted

Is there any way to find the quote about Islam's God? I've been looking for it.

Posted

[quote]A second revival of slavery took place after the discovery of the New World by the Spaniards in 1492. To give the history of it would be to exceed the limits of this article. It will be sufficient to recall the efforts of Las Casas in behalf of the aborigines of America and the protestations of popes against the enslavement of those aborigines and the traffic in negro slaves. England, France, Portugal, and Spain, all participated in this nefarious traffic. England only made amends for its transgressions when, in 1815, it took the initiative in the suppression of the slave trade. In 1871 a writer had the temerity to assert that the Papacy had not its mind to condemn slavery" (Ernest Havet, "Le christianisme et ses origines", I, p. xxi). He forgot that, in 1462, Pius II declared slavery to be "a great crime" (magnum scelus); that, in 1537, Paul III forbade the enslavement of the Indians; that Urban VIII forbade it in 1639, and Benedict XIV in 1741; that Pius VII demanded of the Congress of Vienna, in 1815, the suppression of the slave trade and Gregory XVI condemned it in 1839; that, in the Bull of Canonization of the Jesuit Peter Claver, one of the most illustrious adversaries of slavery, Pius IX branded the "supreme villainy" (summum nefas) of the slave traders. Everyone knows of the beautiful letter which Leo XIII, in 1888, addressed to the Brazilian bishops, exhorting them to banish from their country the remnants of slavery -- a letter to which the bishops responded with their most energetic efforts, and some generous slave-owners by freeing their slaves in a body, as in the first ages of the Church.[/quote]

Posted

[quote name='qfnol31' date='Feb 6 2006, 09:43 PM']Is there any way to find the quote about Islam's God?  I've been looking for it.
[right][snapback]878084[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
[url="http://www.kofc.org/publications/cis/catechism/index.cfm"]Here is a link to a good CCC search engine[/url]

Posted

Philosophically that holds true...

Posted

[quote name='Ziggamafu' date='Feb 6 2006, 07:39 PM']I guess I'm just curious what things in the Code of Canon Law, the Catechism, and the Dogmatic Constitutions are unchangable and definitely preserved from error; i.e. can't be wrong.

For instance, in the CCC there is a line referring to Islam's God as Catholicism's God. I know many who strongly disagree. That refers to the Faith - so is it dogmatic?

Other citations from authoratative papal history that I'm curious about are those concerning Limbo and slavery. I've run into some articles that try to demonstrate some seriously pro-Limbo and pro-slavery positions held and taught by the papacy in certain portions of Church history. I posted some of the Limbo stuff I found in another thread here at Phatmass...
[right][snapback]877747[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

[url="http://jloughnan.tripod.com/dogma.htm"]Dogmas[/url] are listed here. As for the infallible teaching of the Church, there are many instances of the ordinary Magisterium that are infallible...too many to list.

However, I think that this needs to be stated about the Catechism. It is important to understand just what [url="http://www.scborromeo.org/ccc/aposcons.htm"]Fidei Depositum[/url] actually says. There are some keys to the nature of the Catechism itself.

[quote name='Fidei Depositum Introduction']The principal task entrusted to the Council by Pope John XXIII was to guard and present better the precious deposit of Christian doctrine in order to make it more accessible to the Christian faithful and to all people of good will. For this reason the Council was not first of all to condemn the errors of the time, but above all to strive calmly to show the strength and beauty of the doctrine of the faith.[/quote]

[quote name='Fidei Depositum #3']The Catechism of the Catholic Church, which I approved 25 June last and the publication of which I today order by virtue of my Apostolic Authority, is a statement of the Church's faith and of catholic doctrine, attested to or illumined by Sacred Scripture, the Apostolic Tradition and the Church's Magisterium. I declare it to be a sure norm for teaching the faith and thus a valid and legitimate instrument for ecclesial communion. May it serve the renewal to which the Holy Spirit ceaselessly calls the Church of God, the Body of Christ, on her pilgrimage to the undiminished light of the Kingdom![/quote]

[quote name='Fidei Depositum #3']It [the Catechism of the Catholic Church] is meant to encourage and assist in the writing of new local catechisms, which take into account various situations and cultures, while carefully preserving the unity of faith and fidelity to catholic doctrine.[/quote]

What we can see from these portions of the Catechism, it is a sure norm for teaching the faith, which makes it a valid and legitimate instrument. It also is a statement of the Church's faith and of catholic doctrine.

The other arms of this renewal are the promulgation of [url="http://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG1104/_INDEX.HTM"]The Code of Canon Law[/url] and [url="http://www.vatican.va/archive/hist_councils/ii_vatican_council/documents/vat-ii_const_19631204_sacrosanctum-concilium_en.html"]Sacrosanctum Concilium[/url]. The latter is the Liturgical renewal of the Church while the former is the legal adaptation. These parts are the major actions of Vatican Council II.

I hope this helps.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...