Dave Posted February 5, 2006 Posted February 5, 2006 (edited) How would y'all go about responding to what this rad-trad acquaintance told me? [quote]I was a "conservative" for a long time so I know what you are going through. Drop the mental gymnastics. Deep in the heart of every "conservative" is the fear that the Church has failed. It has not. If you look closely, you will see that it has never officially proclaimed error. However, a large section of our bishops have failed. Pope JP II failed. They are human beings, and they sin. Cardinal Law allowed little boys to be raped [color=red][b][edit][/b][/color] and knew all about it. JP II knew about it and transferred Law to one of the most cushiest positions in the Church. This is one small example of bishops and Popes showing that they are not impeccible. And the Lord did not promise us that they would be. If you don't see any problems with the present Church, then go to the N.O. Mass. If you find that the TLM is better, then become a Traditionalist. Don't sit the fence. You remind me of the 1960's generation ladies who come to our Mass with their hacked off hair refusing to wear the veil [b](note from Dave -- at my parish, where this guy used to attend, it's NOT mandatory for women to cover their head but nevertheless highly encouraged)[/b]. Yet they come to our Mass. They ruined their own Mass and now they scandalize our children. [/quote] Edited February 5, 2006 by phatcatholic
photosynthesis Posted February 5, 2006 Posted February 5, 2006 Well, you can look at what this guy says from another angle... You have these ultra liberal "Catholics" who are pro-abortion and want women priests, and they justify their ideas by saying that Popes throughout the ages have sinned and thus they have no real authority to deem what is true and what is not. I would argue that "deep in the heart of every conservative" is FAITH that the gates of Hell will never prevail against Christ's Church, and that He accomplishes this through the working of the Holy Spirit through apostolic succession. Nobody's perfect, but God is so powerful he can use even the weakest people for the glory of His church.
ironmonk Posted February 5, 2006 Posted February 5, 2006 My reply... The greatest thing that I find troubling in what you say is that one would think that a "traditionalist" would have a reverence for the priesthood that matched the reverence that Catholic Faithful had before Vatican II. Because of what you just said about priests, a Cardinal, and the Pope, you show a lack of reverence for the priesthood. If you have a concern about them, you should take it up with the Father (in Heaven) and no one else. The scandal of a few can cause the loss of faith of many because they might be weak. Do you want to be the cause of someone's apostasy? The "reasoning" you are using reminds me of a recent homily where the priest mentions a few verses from Genesis where Satan tempted Eve. You do not know the reasons why Cardinal Law or Pope John Paul II did what they did. Who are you to cast judgement on men who gave up their lives for Christ? Are you wiser than the Church established by Christ in 33 AD? If the Pope has approved a Mass, the Mass is valid. [b]The Way 66 [/b] A Priest — whoever he may be — is always another Christ. [b]The Way 68 [/b] Presbyter — Priest — means, literally, an elderly man. If old age deserves veneration, think how much more you ought to venerate the Priesthood. [b]The Way 67[/b] Though you well know it, I shall remind you again that a Priest is 'another Christ'. And that the holy Spirit has said: 'Nolite tangere Christos meos — do not touch my Christs'. [b]The Way 69 [/b] It shows very little refinement — and great lack of respect — to make fun of a Priest, whoever he is, and whatever the pretext! [b]The Way 70 [/b] I repeat: to make fun of a Priest — no matter what the circumstances — is always, at best, a sign of coarseness and poor taste. [b]The Way 73 [/b] It cut you to the heart to hear people say that you had spoken badly of those Priests. And I am glad that it hurt: for now I am sure you have the right spirit! [b]The Way 74 [/b] To love God and not venerate his Priests... is not possible. [b]The Way 75 [/b] Like the good sons of Noah, throw the mantle of charity over the defects you see in your father, the Priest. [b]The Way 528[/b] A very important characteristic of the apostolic man is his love for the Mass. [b]1 Corinthians 9:19 [/b] Although I am free in regard to all, I have made myself a slave to all so as to win over as many as possible. [b]20 [/b]To the Jews I became like a Jew to win over Jews; to those under the law I became like one under the law--though I myself am not under the law--to win over those under the law. [b]21 [/b]To those outside the law I became like one outside the law--though I am not outside God's law but within the law of Christ--to win over those outside the law. [b]22 [/b]To the weak I became weak, to win over the weak. I have become all things to all, to save at least some. [b]23 [/b]All this I do for the sake of the gospel, so that I too may have a share in it. In light of the ignorance of most non-Catholic Christians and the attacks of the anti-Catholics, the New Mass is needed so it can win over as many as possible. To win non-Catholics we must become like them. [b]St. Matt 16:19 [/b] [color=red]I will give you the keys to the kingdom of heaven. [u][b]Whatever [/b][/u]you bind on earth shall be bound in heaven; and [u][b]whatever [/b][/u]you loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven[/color]." The New Mass is completely valid, "whatever" covers "whatever". The Pope can unloose what disciplines have been bound by a previous Pope. The Church will never be overcome. Believe this wholeheartedly and accept the faith as taught by the Pope and Magisterium like a child. If you disagree, then realize that you must have a misunderstanding and accept the teaching... the faith... the Mass. Otherwise you risk falling into the same instance of sin that Eve fell into wanting to be like God... ego and pride... instead, be humble like a child. .... my two cents. God Bless! ironmonk
peacenluvbaby Posted February 5, 2006 Posted February 5, 2006 OMG.....SCANDAL.... it's the invasion of the non-veil wearing women with hair that doesn't reach their waists.... What is this world coming too???? Quick grab a burka... grab a burka... : Actually, you could point out that there are hyper-conservative N.O. places like Thomas Aquinas College in CA, or other places like that where skirts and veils are ubiquitous though not "mandatory" and the hair is ridiculously long, and the N.O. is latin with gregorian chant and stuff... You could also point out that the Mass of the so-called "Traditionalists" is only a few hundred years old....not 2000 years - he could also always go Maronite or another of the 7 branches of the official Church where Mass is in Arabic/Aramaic and the "tradition" outdates the western Latin version.... Peace out!
qfnol31 Posted February 5, 2006 Posted February 5, 2006 I think you could say two things here. 1) He has concluded that the abuses in people come from the Novus Ordo...I don't think that's true at all. People's actions cannot necessarily be equated with the Mass. Some of the scandals happened many, many years ago, before the change in Masses or even Vatican II. Does that mean we need to go back to a pre-Tridentine Mass? Well, we do that and we'll run into the Medici Popes and such... 2) If he thinks you cannot associate yourself with the Novus Ordo, he needs to break off. He would be in association by just calling himself Catholic. The Orthodox are in schism for that reason...he should probably do the same that he did if he's going to claim the Mass is not any good..... (N.B. I think you know my feelings on the Tridentine Mass versus the Novus Ordo; I'm just responding to this guy.)
photosynthesis Posted February 5, 2006 Posted February 5, 2006 [quote name='peacenluvbaby' date='Feb 5 2006, 05:26 AM']OMG.....SCANDAL.... it's the invasion of the non-veil wearing women with hair that doesn't reach their waists.... What is this world coming too???? Quick grab a burka... grab a burka... : Actually, you could point out that there are hyper-conservative N.O. places like Thomas Aquinas College in CA, or other places like that where skirts and veils are ubiquitous though not "mandatory" and the hair is ridiculously long, and the N.O. is latin with gregorian chant and stuff... You could also point out that the Mass of the so-called "Traditionalists" is only a few hundred years old....not 2000 years - he could also always go Maronite or another of the 7 branches of the official Church where Mass is in Arabic/Aramaic and the "tradition" outdates the western Latin version.... Peace out! [right][snapback]876154[/snapback][/right] [/quote] You didn't even spell "burqa" right. If a woman wants to wear the veil and have hair down to her knees, who are you to criticize her? It is a sign of her purity and reverence for God... Obviously women who wear veils and have long hair do this because they love God and don't care about what others think. I have hair down to my waist and I wear the veil. I think that women who have short hair and don't wear veils are missing out on a holy tradition of the Church, but I don't really have a problem with them.
avemaria40 Posted February 5, 2006 Posted February 5, 2006 I'm all for long hair and veils. i plan on growing my hair long and buying a veil, however I do want to give at least ten inches of hair to Locks of Love. I think if you're donating your hair, or short hair works better for you and helps you serve God better, go for it. Sometimes you need short hair to serve God (nuns traditionally have their hair cut, St. Joan of Arc had to cut off her hair to go into battle, etc.) I believe that women should wear hair coverings to Mass, it's just more reverent, but the length of your hair is your choice.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now